Impossible situation, now separation

  • Thread starter Thread starter over_whelmed
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

over_whelmed

Guest
I will throw this out there to see if there is ANYone else in our situation as ours is a very unique set of circumstances that has led us to temporarily separate.

My husband and I have been married 20 years. We have seven children which I have homeschooled up until this past fall. Now five of the seven are in school. I have had very difficult pregnancies and many c-sections. I was hospitalized a long time with our last child because they (my OB and other high risk specialists) assumed I would rupture so I was put in the hospital “just in case” I did so they could get to the baby and me in time to save us both. I was told several children ago NOT to have any more children. I went to my husband and asked him if he would be agreeable to NFP and in a nutshell he said I lacked faith in God, for which he has now realized he was wrong in saying that. Nevertheless, now we have seven and medically we are not advised to have any more as my life and that of my unborn baby would be in serious jepordy.

Before the birth of the last child we went to our parish priest and asked him if an “elective” hysterectomy would be allowed by the church since I was so high risk. He said he needed to consult a canon lawyer and he did (this canon lawyer studied in Rome). We were told that no, we cannot elect for a hysterectomy unless my life was in peril ON THE OPERATING table.

The surgeons were able to save my uterus after a four hour surgery/birth. So here I am still fertile, unable to practice ABC, too frightened to use NFP (we tried using it in the past but I still managed to get pregnant). Our priest said we needed to abstain until I reach menopause.

My husband was less than agreeable and I “caved” and would allow two times per month when I knew my cycle was just about to start, even though an NFP expert told me that was still dangerous as I near perimenopause and my cycles could be longer than I think. The pressure has built up SO much because my husband has a hypersexual appetite. I just want to be left alone for my body, mind, soul and spirit to heal.

This has clearly become an impossible situation in our life. I know my husband is committing sin outside the “safe days” and he goes to frequent confession for it (not adultery if you know what I mean). He is cranky, moody and we fight all the time. I feel like I gave the last 15 years of myself unselfishly to the marital debt and he cannot do the same for me. We HAVE tried marriage counseling, but it didn’t seem to help.

I recently found out he has watched porn on “several occasions” as well. I feel betrayed and sickened over this even though I am told it’s NOT really that big of a deal; that he talked to a priest about these issues already. Everything seems to be minimized at the end of the day. Some days I feel like I am going crazy because my feelings are rarely if ever validated.

I asked for a separation because I just cannot take anymore sexual pressure. There are clearly other issues going on besides, but this is the main issue.

Does it come down to which is the greater sin? ABC or marital separation? We both are willing to try counseling separately, but I am really at the point where I feel like I am just done. It makes me sad, but that’s how I feel.
 
Obviously I don’t know the whole story nor should I. but from what you have said I would welcome your husband back home. During this time of abstinence learn nfp (it can be done) like your life depends on it. It’s the easiest time to learn any way. Even if you stay separated still learn it. You have nothing to lose by learning it. Ask a 2nd priest. My mother was in your similar medical situation and she got one (hysterectomy) several months after I (#8) was born. Every medical condition will get a different option from each doctors. some make things seem more serious than others .who’s right well that’s a matter of option too. What I’m saying is find a doctor that understand how serious this medical condition is to you and shares your same option. this may help a prist understand (doctor rec) You may find encouragement by reading some of the saints lives. My two favorites are St Monica and St Rita.
 
During this time of abstinence learn nfp (it can be done) like your life depends on it.
My life actually DOES depend on it. One of my closest friends is an NFP instructor and certified to the highest levels. It was SHE who said I am still “rolling the dice” even in a small window of 2 times per month because my cycles can and will change as perimenopause goes on. As an aside, I do know NFP. Some cannot use it as effectively as others. For instance I have chronic insomnia so taking my temp first thing in the morning will not be reliable because I am awake half the night.
Every medical condition will get a different option from each doctors. some make things seem more serious than others
I had three different OB/GYN’s for FOUR different births tell me I should not be having any more children with the state of my uterus. FOUR medical doctors and that is not including the high risk team, which was comprised of seven different doctors. I was told I was a “ticking time bomb” with my last pregnancy. It’s safe to say that I can be confident in the decision to never, ever get pregnant again. I have no other medical reason to remove my uterus. My “window of opportunity” has come and gone when I wanted it done with the traumatic birth of my last child, but “ethically” my OB could not just take it out if it could be saved. My OB - actually telephoned my priest to tell him the severity of the situation. My OB is JEWISH - that says something right there of how strongly she feels. Even if the situation weren’t as serious as it is - I refuse to “roll the dice” and leave the rest of my children without a mother.

I pray there will someday be some kind of solution, but as of right now we are not looking too good and frankly, I am breathing for the first time in a LONG time. I read that link someone posted. There was another person on here with a similar story as mine. I could so relate to everything she was saying. I now am beginning to see how very objectified I was all those years.
 
I have chronic insomnia. For that reason, when we used NFP we never used the STM.

Creighton and Billings do not use temp.
 
I realize you don’t want to roll the dice. My mother had a similar story and I taking the same path vbac 5th kid. I’m not in your situation yet but one day I could be and I too would not leave my children without a mother. But hear me out, If you not having sex what do you have to lose you just learning about your cycles. you won’t regret it. And save your marriage too.
 
A few weeks ago, the sermon at my church was about the sanctity of life. We were told that we should not support assisted suicide because life is sacred. Perhaps you should speak to ANOTHER priest. Your life, dear woman, is sacred.

Heavenly Father, in faith, I thank You for helping this dear woman and her husband during this difficult time. Amen.
 
I am sorry he is so upset and frustrated all the time, I wish he would take some time to reconsider. It also sounds like he is constantly gas lighting you and your feelings psychologytoday.com/blog/power-in-relationships/200905/are-you-being-gaslighted. I don’t feel any of that is your fault. From what you have said it is honestly either sex or your very life. You would think he would be more understanding considering how very blessed he is in life with a loving wife and many children and you are already in pre menopause.
 
Before the birth of the last child we went to our parish priest and asked him if an “elective” hysterectomy would be allowed by the church since I was so high risk. He said he needed to consult a canon lawyer and he did (this canon lawyer studied in Rome). We were told that no, we cannot elect for a hysterectomy unless my life was in peril ON THE OPERATING table.
This doesn’t sound right. A canon lawyer studies Canon Law which are the regulations of the Church. It is different from the moral law. Morever the answer is wrong. You cannot get a hesterectomy if your purpose is contraceptive. However we do have the principal of double effect and there are definitely medical situations besides being on the operating table that would fall under this category. Whoever advised this may have been ignorant of the medical issues. This is where you end up with a huge divide between those with the medical knowledge to fully understand the situation completely and those with the thorough moral ethics background to rightfully discern the correct path. This divide means that even if you ask a medical expert or a moral expert, there is still a margin of error especially if they’re going to be absolutist about their answer.

Anyway, a friend of mine is 28 years old and just had a total hysterectomy. My understanding is that she needed the hystectomy so badly because had she been allowed to have another period, she would have needed a blood transfusion to save her life. She certainly was not on the operating table and her situation definitely fit within the boundaries of the principal of double effect.

Here’s my best recommendation for you. Start praying a rosary novena for your marriage and for your complicated moral situation. Ask God for guidence, understanding and to do any changes in your heart that need to be made. Ask for moral clarity. Maybe He’ll bring the right spiritual director in your life. Try praying for that. Unforunately I’ve always had difficulty finding spiritual directors. Everyone I’ve asked has just said “Here are the characterics you want to look for in someone.” They utterly pretend I’m not asking them. But anyway. Maybe He’ll open your eyes another way. Get a copy of Humanae Vitae and read it front to back meditatively maybe even in front of the blessed Sacrament. Keep a spiritual journal with you and jot down your moral principal questions. Does this mean that? What does this principal mean? Also I’d say keep your bible and your catechism handy in case you feel the urge to open it. Often when I’ve been in this mode of prayer I’ve felt some sort of compulsion to read a specific passage of the bible or the Catechism. If you’re feeling lost in how to pray this way, try paging through the psalms, find something that hits you and pray it with as much of your heart as you can.

Overall I personally think you need to be the one educating your conscience on the principals rather than relying for someone with incomplete knowledge of the entire medical situation to make rash judgments based on his own more complete education in moral theology. Make yourself the expert and then trust your judgment. Don’t get all anxious about your judgment being in error. As long as you’ve responsibly sought after a deeper understanding of the truth and have had a willingness to accept a spiritual director in your life if God puts such a person in your proximity, in the end your decision has to be made. Make no mistake, even if a priest tells you one thing, it doesn’t mean that he can’t misguide you and that a mistake can’t be made. Mistakes are always possible. We aren’t responsible for invisible ignorance.
 
Our priest said we needed to abstain until I reach menopause.
Could you go back to your priest and ask him if it’s sinful at all to ask for separation, since your life depends on staying abstinent and your DH refuses to cooperate?

I would sincerely hope that your priest will tell you you are not committing a sin at all, because your life is on the line and you are trying to protect your life for the sake of your seven children who need you to take care of them.
 
Anyway, a friend of mine is 28 years old and just had a total hysterectomy. My understanding is that she needed the hystectomy so badly because had she been allowed to have another period, she would have needed a blood transfusion to save her life. She certainly was not on the operating table and her situation definitely fit within the boundaries of the principal of double effect.
Twoangels, the situation of the OP does sound different from your friend who got the hysterectomy at age 28. The OP doesn’t need her uterus removed in order to cure some disease or to have her life saved. She will be safe and sound as long as she stays abstinent - and this is exactly what her husband needs to understand. It’s time for her husband to show some sacrificial love, in the form of refraining from sexual activity until his wife reaches menopause. This way, his wife can avoid an unnecessary operation, and still stay safe from a life-threatening pregnancy.
 
Could you go back to your priest and ask him if it’s sinful at all to ask for separation, since your life depends on staying abstinent and your DH refuses to cooperate?

I would sincerely hope that your priest will tell you you are not committing a sin at all, because your life is on the line and you are trying to protect your life for the sake of your seven children who need you to take care of them.
I agree she would not be committing a sin if she separated. Nonetheless, she has SEVEN children with this man. Separation may not be a sin, but would it be wise? Would it be good for the children??

I recommend fighting for your marriage. And also, try talking to another priest… and make sure he thoroughly understands the medical situation.
 
I will throw this out there to see if there is ANYone else in our situation as ours is a very unique set of circumstances that has led us to temporarily separate.

My husband and I have been married 20 years. We have seven children which I have homeschooled up until this past fall. Now five of the seven are in school. I have had very difficult pregnancies and many c-sections. I was hospitalized a long time with our last child because they (my OB and other high risk specialists) assumed I would rupture so I was put in the hospital “just in case” I did so they could get to the baby and me in time to save us both. I was told several children ago NOT to have any more children. I went to my husband and asked him if he would be agreeable to NFP and in a nutshell he said I lacked faith in God, for which he has now realized he was wrong in saying that. Nevertheless, now we have seven and medically we are not advised to have any more as my life and that of my unborn baby would be in serious jepordy.

Before the birth of the last child we went to our parish priest and asked him if an “elective” hysterectomy would be allowed by the church since I was so high risk. He said he needed to consult a canon lawyer and he did (this canon lawyer studied in Rome). We were told that no, we cannot elect for a hysterectomy unless my life was in peril ON THE OPERATING table.

The surgeons were able to save my uterus after a four hour surgery/birth. So here I am still fertile, unable to practice ABC, too frightened to use NFP (we tried using it in the past but I still managed to get pregnant). Our priest said we needed to abstain until I reach menopause.

My husband was less than agreeable and I “caved” and would allow two times per month when I knew my cycle was just about to start, even though an NFP expert told me that was still dangerous as I near perimenopause and my cycles could be longer than I think. The pressure has built up SO much because my husband has a hypersexual appetite. I just want to be left alone for my body, mind, soul and spirit to heal.

This has clearly become an impossible situation in our life. I know my husband is committing sin outside the “safe days” and he goes to frequent confession for it (not adultery if you know what I mean). He is cranky, moody and we fight all the time. I feel like I gave the last 15 years of myself unselfishly to the marital debt and he cannot do the same for me. We HAVE tried marriage counseling, but it didn’t seem to help.

I recently found out he has watched porn on “several occasions” as well. I feel betrayed and sickened over this even though I am told it’s NOT really that big of a deal; that he talked to a priest about these issues already. Everything seems to be minimized at the end of the day. Some days I feel like I am going crazy because my feelings are rarely if ever validated.

I asked for a separation because I just cannot take anymore sexual pressure. There are clearly other issues going on besides, but this is the main issue.

Does it come down to which is the greater sin? ABC or marital separation? We both are willing to try counseling separately, but I am really at the point where I feel like I am just done. It makes me sad, but that’s how I feel.
I can’t tell from this post whether or not your husband is actually trying for ABC, or if he just wants to keep having “unprotected sex” while your life is at risk. If the former is true, perhaps this post from an apologist will help:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=475359&highlight=grave+reasons

Keep us updated. Good luck, and God bless.
 
Well, I think there needs to be a compromise on both parts between you and your husband. I would say, he needs to monitor his “healthy” sexual appetite. That would be a loving thing for you, as you had seven children with him.

Also, you would need to learn your body better and I’m guessing your cycles are irregular, that’s why NFP doesn’t work…

In the end, you will have to decide what to do. 1. Separate 2. Go back to him and have the potential of another baby 3. get a hysterectomy because your life is in danger 4. (my least favorite) go on birth control because you had 7 kids and your life is in danger.

I don’t really see at this point, any problem with you taking some steps to protect your body. Your husband could be a little more understanding about your health and not go straight to porn, etc. There are lots of reasons, not just childbirth, that can cause dips in sex life.
Maybe if he was willing to abstain for a while, it could help your marriage in other ways. And you can always do a hysterectomy later on.

The worst outcome would be that you would get pregnant again and it would be complicated. Still, it may be ok. I don’t know. Pray about it. <3 <3 <3 Is a hysterectomy really worse than your marriage falling apart and 7 kids displaced?

You have to decide for yourself. Pray and listen to Christ’s answer for you.

In Christ,
~Lily
 
Rita77 - I actually have worked in the medical field for 15 years and I know about my cycles and NFP, truly I do. I am not sure what your intent is that I learn more about my cycles when any intercourse could be the lone bullet that fires when playing Russian Roulette. Regarding v-bac - that was completely taken off the table after my first c-section because they cut both sides of the uterus in an extended fashion making the lower segment very weak. No OB, high risk including, would even consider it for my case.

Two Angels - thank you for that post. I have to really take a better look at this situation. My OB even counseled my priest on the medical end of it and it seemed like a closed deal - no hysterectomy unless the organ itself was costing me my life AT THAT MOMENT in time. I am not sure how I could even approach an elective hysterectomy at this point if my uterus isn’t causing me trouble at the moment. Only causes trouble if I conceive. Does that make sense?
Could you go back to your priest and ask him if it’s sinful at all to ask for separation, since your life depends on staying abstinent and your DH refuses to cooperate?
He isn’t flat out refusing. After I “put my foot down” he said he would try, but I have such tremendous guilt knowing I am causing him to sin because he cannot have relations. I know it’s “on him” to take responsibility, but I can’t help but think I am causing some of the sinful things he does. It’s almost like if we separate then HE has to take full responsibilty and get a hold of his own faults and find a way to correct them. I am certain having a woman he loves lying next to him each night is not helping matters either.
I agree she would not be committing a sin if she separated. Nonetheless, she has SEVEN children with this man. Separation may not be a sin, but would it be wise? Would it be good for the children??
I questioned the same thing for quite some time before making this decision. A man is a man and has urges that we women sometimes just don’t “get.” They ARE physical creatures and very visual beings. He feels rejected and less of a man when relations are stopped and he gets frustrated and cranky not only with me, but the children as well and that’s not fair to them either. I understand his crankiness, I do. I understand how difficult this must be for him, as a man. In the short time we have been separated, I feel a true sense of peace in the house. Sure it’s crazy with seven children running around, but coming from experience of living with parents who fought 24/7 - trust me - for them to have peace will mean very much in the long-run. The scars I bear from living a life of chaos and yelling and screaming will never go away from my own childhood.
The worst outcome would be that you would get pregnant again and it would be complicated.
No, the worst outcome would be for me to become pregnant and lose my life and for my baby to lose his/her life as well. I have prayed and prayed AND PRAYED. We say a daily rosary and I am very devouted to a few saints for whom I turn when I just feel like it’s all falling apart. I just need to breathe again.

I am just not sure at this juncture whether I can REQUEST an elective hysterectomy. What reason would they have to do it? I feel strongly against ANY form of birth control because the only 100% safe way of avoiding pregnancy is abstenence.

Like I said in the title, an impossible situation.
 
I am subscribed to receiving daily St. Padre Pio quotes and this is what was in my inbox today. It’s almost as if he is speaking directly to me on this day.
Be totally resigned in the hands of our Lord, giving Him your remaining years, and begging Him always, to fill them with preparations for a life which is pleasing to Him. Don’t worry about useless promises of tranquility, enjoyment of merits, but present your hearts to your divine Spouse, totally emptying it of all other affections, except his chaste love. And beseech Him to fill it purely and simply with actions, desires and a will which pertain to his love, so that your hearts, like mother of pearl, do not conceive anything, except with the dew of Heaven, and not with the water of the world. St. Padre Pio
 
I am subscribed to receiving daily St. Padre Pio quotes and this is what was in my inbox today. It’s almost as if he is speaking directly to me on this day.
Wow, that can’t be a coincidence! Reflect on that, I believe it has you answers!

To whoever said to consider ABC I’m thinking they are forgetting that ABC has a failure rate as well. I am saying this precisely because a close friend of mine who gave birth via c_section was told by her orthodox priest that the pill is ok in her circumstance and she got pregnant 6 months later while on the pill. It is very uncharitable to offer any solution that still endangers a loved one’s life, even if it’s only 3% probability.

We all know that the loving thing is for your life to be cherished more than any " personal" or " marital" need but it seems no one wants to articulate that.

Jesus gave up His Life for you, your husband should certainly sacrifice his sexual urges for you and for your children if he were to live as Christ loves. Pray for an increase of love in his heart, be assured that you are not guilty for his sinful indulgences and don’t forget that the centre of any relationship is God, not sex!

Prolonged abstinence, for those with excessive appetite and not only, is indeed very difficult but it can also purify and heal many disorders.

God bless you!
 
I wonder, have you tried making some adjustments to live as “brother and sister” in a very literal sense? Maybe you could try that? This is what I mean: biological brothers and sisters do not sleep in one bed, do not share one bedroom, they do not see each other naked, and their form of affection in the physical sense is a non-sexual hug, a peck on the cheek, not more. If you have a biological brother, or male cousins, you will know exactly what I mean - you will never cross certain boundaries with male siblings and relatives.

The trick to success in abstinence is hidden in the details, and not putting yourselves into sexually arousing situations in the first place.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top