Impotence and sterility

  • Thread starter Thread starter BlueEyedLady
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BlueEyedLady

Guest
I know that an impotent man cannot validly marry in the CC. What about a sterile man or an infertile woman though? Or a woman who is unable to have intercourse because of a condition that causes her vaginal muscles to tense to the point where penetration is impossible? Is that grounds for an annulment?

I seem to get different answers and opinions from every source.

Thanks in advance!
 
I know that an impotent man cannot validly marry in the CC. What about a sterile man or an infertile woman though? Or a woman who is unable to have intercourse because of a condition that causes her vaginal muscles to tense to the point where penetration is impossible? Is that grounds for an annulment?

I seem to get different answers and opinions from every source.

Thanks in advance!
My understanding is, that if they went into the marriage unaware that they had these conditions then no it would not be grounds for an annulment, but if they knew of their condition and lied about it to their partner, or withheld the information that it would be grounds for an annulment. Of course only the Church can decide such things on an individual case by case basis.

Actually I don’t think being naturally sterile is a problem as long as they can perform the marital act and are still open to life.

Canon law Can. 1084.1 , states: “Antecedent and perpetual impotence to have intercourse, whether on the part of the man or the woman, whether absolute or relative, nullifies marriage by its very nature”

while Canon Law 1084.3 states “Sterility neither prohibits nor nullifies marriage, without prejudice to the prescript of Can. 1098.”

“Canon 1098 A person contracts invalidly who enters marriage inveigled by deceit, perpetrated in order to secure consent, concerning some quality of the other party, which of its very nature can seriously disrupt the partnership of conjugal life.”
 
What about a sterile man or an infertile woman though?
Sterility is not an impediment to marriage.
Or a woman who is unable to have intercourse because of a condition that causes her vaginal muscles to tense to the point where penetration is impossible?
This would be impotence.
Is that grounds for an annulment?
Possibly. It would have to be determined that the condition is perpetual. Some things like this are treatable, others aren’t.
 
My understanding is, that if they went into the marriage unaware that they had these conditions then no it would not be grounds for an annulment
Re-read the canons. Perpetual antecedent impotence nullifies marriage by its nature. So, even if they did not *know *they were impotent, the fact of impotence nullifies the attempt at marriage once it is established without doubt.

However, in the case the OP presented paragraph 2 of Canon 1084 would apply:
  1. If the impediment of impotence is doubtful, whether by a doubt about the law or a doubt about a fact, a marriage must not be impeded nor, while the doubt remains, declared null.
 
Impotent people should not be married. It is God’s way of saying that the individual should not procreate and doesn’t deserve to be happy with a life partner.
 
I know that an impotent man cannot validly marry in the CC. What about a sterile man or an infertile woman though?!
if the latter are able to engage in sexual intercourse yes they are candidates for marriage.

however, you changed the question, a woman who cannot engage in intercourse is not the same as an infertile or sterile woman.

the issue has dozens of past discussions and on marriage and sacraments, I am sure a search would be helpful to you
 
Impotent people should not be married. It is God’s way of saying that the individual should not procreate and doesn’t deserve to be happy with a life partner.
If this is a parody, excellent.

If not, seriously? Lame.
 
Re-read the canons. Perpetual antecedent impotence nullifies marriage by its nature. So, even if they did not *know *they were impotent, the fact of impotence nullifies the attempt at marriage once it is established without doubt.

However, in the case the OP presented paragraph 2 of Canon 1084 would apply:
  1. If the impediment of impotence is doubtful, whether by a doubt about the law or a doubt about a fact, a marriage must not be impeded nor, while the doubt remains, declared null.
She said that she knew an impotent man couldn’t validly marry. I was referring to the other issue of sterility but I know my wording was poor, because I had gone to look up the Canon Laws for her and didn’t pay as much attention to my wording as I should have.
 
I know that an impotent man cannot validly marry in the CC. What about a sterile man or an infertile woman though? Or a woman who is unable to have intercourse because of a condition that causes her vaginal muscles to tense to the point where penetration is impossible? Is that grounds for an annulment?

I seem to get different answers and opinions from every source.

Thanks in advance!
Vaginismus (tensing of muscles making sexual intercourse painful) is treatable. I have never heard of a case that wasn’t. Sometimes it takes a while, but that would not be grounds for annulment, because it’s treatable.
 
Vaginismus (tensing of muscles making sexual intercourse painful) is treatable. I have never heard of a case that wasn’t. Sometimes it takes a while, but that would not be grounds for annulment, because it’s treatable.
the antecedent perpetual impotence or inability to engage in intercourse is not a bar to marriage if it is treatable or reasonable doubt exists as to its permanence.c1084 “if the presence of the impediment id soubtful, the marriage is not to be impeded nor to be declared null as long as the doubt exists.”
I I seem to get different answers and opinions from every source.

Thanks in advance!
there is only one source
it is canon law
best to inquire there and not bother with all those other sources
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top