Incredibly Difficult Passage to Explain for Catholics

  • Thread starter Thread starter jinc1019
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why not? None of the Holy Orders confers the power to do miracles (well, excepting the Eucharistic of course) and signs. These are given to individuals by God based on His criteria (unknown to us). There is no teaching in the Church that a deacon, or even a lay person for that matter, could not be given these powers by God.
I think my point is being lost in all of this, at my own fault. Let me try to bring this down to one simple issue at a time…Why does the Church teach that what Peter and John are doing is confirmation?
 
I think my point is being lost in all of this, at my own fault. Let me try to bring this down to one simple issue at a time…Why does the Church teach that what Peter and John are doing is confirmation?
Confirmation is a sacrament, and therefore is governed by “matter and form” in order to be valid. This includes designating who is considered the minister of the sacraments. In the case of confirmation, the minister is a bishop or, depending on the circumstances, a priest. It is not a matter of personal holiness, but rather a matter of what one’s office allows one to do. Keep in mind that Christ is the High Priest over all the sacraments, so it is his righteousness, and not the righteousness of the bishop/priest, that matters.

I am on a road trip and, therefore, away from my catechetical material (i.e., I can’t provide exact quotes at the moment), but you will commonly see Acts 8 cited in Catholic catechisms (and other reference books) when the topic of Confirmation is discussed. In terms of online resources, consider Catholic Answer’s own tract concerning Confirmation.
What does the Church teach on this? That deacons in the early Church were significantly more powerful than deacons today?
The ability to perform miracles is not a matter concerning sacraments, but rather a special charism given by the Holy Spirit to certain people. This was especially important in the ancient Church for Christianity to establish credibility and spread. My parish has a deacon and, to the best of my knowledge, never did the sort of miraculous things ascribed to Philip and Stephen, but our deacon’s baptisms are just as valid as those done by the deacons described in the New Testament.
That priests today have more authority than Philip and Stephen, both of whom could commit miracles?
Yes, priests have more authority than deacons, even deacons such as Philip and Stephen. Authority is a matter of office, not sanctity and the ability to do miracles. Moreover, every time a priest celebrates Mass, he not only works in conjunction with the Holy Spirit to do a miracle, but the greatest miracle of all, the Eucharist. Despite the marvelous things they did, Philip and Stephen were not empowered to be channels of the Holy Spirit for allowing bread and wine to become the Real Presence of the eternal, living God.

The miracles done by Philip and Stephen were meant to be signs so that people would believe in the fledgling Church. After all, if these deacons did heavenly works in the name of Jesus, then this demonstrates that Jesus is the Messiah, and people ought to belong to his Church. Simply put, they had an essential role in the 1st Century evangelizing mission of the Church. But the role of a priest is to (among other things) provide spiritual nourishment, administer the sacraments, and reconcile sinners with God.
 
My point is, I don’t think Stephen and Philip are just deacons in the modern sense, if they were, they wouldn’t be given the power to do all of these miracles and signs.
Yes they were deacons. The reality of the various signs etc given in the first steps of the Church first century …were particular to those first days.

Of course miracles still happen (and God can give such a charism to any) …but those first days were special.

Yes he was a deacon.
 
Right.

The disciples went out while Jesus was still alive and performed miracles. They had not been ordained nor received any sacraments at that time.

Miracles are a gift, a charism.
👍
 
Under ordinary circumstances, confirmation is conferred by the bishops. It still is normally done that way today. Previous posters have mentioned that there are exceptions to that rule, that in certain circumstances a priest can confer the sacrament of confirmation. The priest does this, as he does everything, through the power of the bishop, which the bishop allows him to use.

The ordinary minister of baptism is a priest or a deacon. A lay person can baptize in a case of emergency, but it is not normally something he can do.

Miracles and prophecy are some of the gifts (charisms) of the Holy Spirit. People caan receive these gifts regardless of their status.

Even today we teach that while the Holy Spirit is received in baptism,the sacrament of baptism is completed in confirmation. In baptism the person receives the Holy Spirit, sanctifying grace, as original sin is removed from his soul. His parents and godparents make promises for him that he will believe all that the Catholic Church teaches, and that he will follow her guidelines. In confirmation the individual renews these baptismal promises himself and receives the gifts and fruits of the Holy Spirit so that he is capable of sharing this grace with others as the aposles did after they received the Holy Spirit at the first Pentecost.

A deacon can not minister confirmation today and he couldn’t do so in the early Churc because that power was given to the apostles and those appointed to follow them, the bishops.
 
I think my point is being lost in all of this, at my own fault. Let me try to bring this down to one simple issue at a time…Why does the Church teach that what Peter and John are doing is confirmation?
Well, the form and matter of confirmation is the laying on the hands by a Bishop in order to pass on the gifts of the Holy Spirit. Since that is exactly what the passage in question describes, what else could the Church teach? I hate to sound trite, but when a scriptural passage is that clear, it interprets itself.
 
I do not believe I am way off base here…This doesn’t make sense. You say that Philip and Stephen are just deacons and don’t have the power to do something as simple as confirmation, something the average priest can do today, but Philip and Stephen can actually make miracles and are tasked with going out into foreign lands and converting Jews? How does that make any sense? How can men given miraculous powers not have the power to do what a common priest can do today?
The average priest today can not do something “as simple as confirmation” Only Bishops can give the sacrament of Confirmation.

There is no science behind whether someone can do miracles or not. It is all up to the Will of God. Neither is there a scientific explanation for why Bishops can perform Confirmation and others can not. That is just the way God ordered it. The Church did not make anything up, it is just following the example made by Jesus.
 
Confirmation is a sacrament, and therefore is governed by “matter and form” in order to be valid. This includes designating who is considered the minister of the sacraments. In the case of confirmation, the minister is a bishop or, depending on the circumstances, a priest. It is not a matter of personal holiness, but rather a matter of what one’s office allows one to do. Keep in mind that Christ is the High Priest over all the sacraments, so it is his righteousness, and not the righteousness of the bishop/priest, that matters.

The ability to perform miracles is not a matter concerning sacraments, but rather a special charism given by the Holy Spirit to certain people. This was especially important in the ancient Church for Christianity to establish credibility and spread. My parish has a deacon and, to the best of my knowledge, never did the sort of miraculous things ascribed to Philip and Stephen, but our deacon’s baptisms are just as valid as those done by the deacons described in the New Testament.

Yes, priests have more authority than deacons, even deacons such as Philip and Stephen. Authority is a matter of office, not sanctity and the ability to do miracles. Moreover, every time a priest celebrates Mass, he not only works in conjunction with the Holy Spirit to do a miracle, but the greatest miracle of all, the Eucharist. Despite the marvelous things they did, Philip and Stephen were not empowered to be channels of the Holy Spirit for allowing bread and wine to become the Real Presence of the eternal, living God.

The miracles done by Philip and Stephen were meant to be signs so that people would believe in the fledgling Church. After all, if these deacons did heavenly works in the name of Jesus, then this demonstrates that Jesus is the Messiah, and people ought to belong to his Church. Simply put, they had an essential role in the 1st Century evangelizing mission of the Church. But the role of a priest is to (among other things) provide spiritual nourishment, administer the sacraments, and reconcile sinners with God.
I appreciate your detailed response…I guess what doesn’t make sense to me is the term “Holy Spirit,” which seems to get thrown around a lot in a lot of different contexts. In Mathew 16 and Mathew 18, it seems that the Holy Spirit guides people in truth and is the reason the Church claims to be infallible. But in Acts 2, when Peter is addressing the masses, he says that all those who are baptized will receive the Holy Spirit, but all of those people belonging to the laity are not protected with infallibility. Then in Acts 6, it says that Stephen is blessed with the Holy Spirit before being made a deacon, but in Acts 8, the Holy Spirit only comes down to the people of Samaria when Peter and John lay their hands upon the people.

In all of these stories, the Holy Spirit is doing different things, applying to different groups of people, and is given in different capacities. In one instance, it makes the Church infallible and is given by Jesus, in another, it doesn’t make the laity infallible and is given by Peter. In another instance it allows Philip and Stephen to make miracles, but in other instances it doesn’t give the power of miracles. In Acts 6, it is given to Stephen without laying on of hands, but in Acts 8, it can only be given through the laying on of hands. It just seems inconsistent to me. Apparently no one else thinks so, and I do appreciate everyone’s efforts.
 
Huh …I thought Philip was an Apostle, would have sworn we recently heard his name mentioned in a reading.

I also sympathize with the OP because often I’m scratching my head while reading scripture. Can you imagine the chaos there’ed be on ‘interpretations’ without the Church? Thank God for the clergy.
 
With all due respect, I am not sure this makes any sense. If Philip is a deacon who is not to engage in the prayer and ministry, as it says in Acts 6, why is he going around Samaria making miracles, baptizing, and preaching the word of God?
It is in no way true - then or now, according to the Bible or Catholic teaching - that deacons are not to “engage in the prayer and ministry.” On the contrary, deacons are ordained clergymen, and they have a responsibility as Catholic clerics to preach, teach, etc. That’s why they proclaim the Gospel at Mass, are allowed to give homilies, witness weddings for the Church and conduct funerals, and are ordinary - not extraordinary - ministers of Holy Communion.

So deacons are supposed to “engage in the prayer and ministry.”
Additionally, I don’t buy your argument because all those being “confirmed,” according to your statements, are being given the power of the Holy Spirit. If that is true, then the Holy Spirit is being given to the laity here…which seems to conflict with Catholic teaching also.
Not at all. 🙂 Remember that any Christian who receives the Sacrament of Confirmation receives the Holy Spirit in a deeper way. It’s not true that only the ordained have the Holy Spirit… the grace of the Spirit is for all of us.
I do not believe I am way off base here…This doesn’t make sense. You say that Philip and Stephen are just deacons and don’t have the power to do something as simple as confirmation, something the average priest can do today, but Philip and Stephen can actually make miracles and are tasked with going out into foreign lands and converting Jews? How does that make any sense? How can men given miraculous powers not have the power to do what a common priest can do today?
Why does it not make sense? Performing miracles in no way depends upon or reflects one’s clerical status. Nothing prevents God from empowering a layperson to perform a miracle if He so wishes.

Offering the Sacraments, however, does depend on one’s clerical status. Thus only priests can celebrate the Eucharistic sacrifice, bestow Sacramental absolution, Confirm (in communion with the local bishop), and Anoint. And only bishops can ordain (Holy Orders).

None of that has anything to do with miracles. God can and does work wonders through unexpected people… humbling the haughty and lifting up the lowly. Is it not astounding that a young boy was chosen to take down Goliath? That a man with a speech impediment was chosen to lead the Israelites from Egypt? That a bunch of quasi-ignorant Palestinian peasants were chosen to be the Lord’s Holy Apostles in the first place? That an inconspicuous peasant girl in a backwoods, redneck province of the Roman Empire would be chosen to be the Mother of God and, eventually, the Queen of the Universe?

Compared to these, I don’t understand how it strains credulity for a deacon to perform miracles.
 
It just seems inconsistent to me. Apparently no one else thinks so, and I do appreciate everyone’s efforts.
You’re correct: the Holy Spirit does many different things, and all His acts are not interchangeable. Why should they be? He’s a divine Person and as such does many different things for us. 🙂
 
In all of these stories, the Holy Spirit is doing different things, applying to different groups of people, and is given in different capacities.
Yes, exactly. The Holy Spirit acts in many different ways and contexts.
 
It is in no way true - then or now, according to the Bible or Catholic teaching - that deacons are not to “engage in the prayer and ministry.” On the contrary, deacons are ordained clergymen, and they have a responsibility as Catholic clerics to preach, teach, etc. That’s why they proclaim the Gospel at Mass, are allowed to give homilies, witness weddings for the Church and conduct funerals, and are ordinary - not extraordinary - ministers of Holy Communion.

So deacons are supposed to “engage in the prayer and ministry.”

Not at all. 🙂 Remember that any Christian who receives the Sacrament of Confirmation receives the Holy Spirit in a deeper way. It’s not true that only the ordained have the Holy Spirit… the grace of the Spirit is for all of us.

Why does it not make sense? Performing miracles in no way depends upon or reflects one’s clerical status. Nothing prevents God from empowering a layperson to perform a miracle if He so wishes.

Offering the Sacraments, however, does depend on one’s clerical status. Thus only priests can celebrate the Eucharistic sacrifice, bestow Sacramental absolution, Confirm (in communion with the local bishop), and Anoint. And only bishops can ordain (Holy Orders).

None of that has anything to do with miracles. God can and does work wonders through unexpected people… humbling the haughty and lifting up the lowly. Is it not astounding that a young boy was chosen to take down Goliath? That a man with a speech impediment was chosen to lead the Israelites from Egypt? That a bunch of quasi-ignorant Palestinian peasants were chosen to be the Lord’s Holy Apostles in the first place? That an inconspicuous peasant girl in a backwoods, redneck province of the Roman Empire would be chosen to be the Mother of God and, eventually, the Queen of the Universe?

Compared to these, I don’t understand how it strains credulity for a deacon to perform miracles.
As I mentioned earlier, I think my primary problem is understanding how the Holy Spirit functions in so many different ways. I always felt the Holy Spirit=authority since the Church claims its authority based on the idea that the Holy Spirit is protecting them. But according to what is being said here, the Holy Spirit is not why the Church has authority and has nothing to do with authority…which is confusing to me…especially because I thought this was the basis for apostolic succession.
 
As I mentioned earlier, I think my primary problem is understanding how the Holy Spirit functions in so many different ways.
Perhaps reading the Catechism section on the Holy Spirit would be helpful to you.
I always felt the Holy Spirit=authority
The Holy Spirit = third person of the Trinity
since the Church claims its authority based on the idea that the Holy Spirit is protecting them.
Continue reading in the Catechism on the Church, which immediately follows the paragraphs on the Holy Spirit.

Christ is the source of authority, the Holy Spirit the protector of it. The Church doesn’t claim authority based on the idea that the Holy Spirit is protecting it. The Holy Spirit protects the Church because of her authority.
But according to what is being said here, the Holy Spirit is not why the Church has authority and has nothing to do with authority…which is confusing to me…especially because I thought this was the basis for apostolic succession.
Again, I suggest reading the entire section of the Catechism on the Holy Spirit and the Church.
 
As I mentioned earlier, I think my primary problem is understanding how the Holy Spirit functions in so many different ways. I always felt the Holy Spirit=authority since the Church claims its authority based on the idea that the Holy Spirit is protecting them. But according to what is being said here, the Holy Spirit is not why the Church has authority and has nothing to do with authority…which is confusing to me…especially because I thought this was the basis for apostolic succession.
What was written that implies the Holy Spirt has nothing to do with authority? Jesus sent the Holy Spirit to the Church to protect it from error. So the Holy Spirit is one of the reasons the Church has authority, although I agree with the previous poster, the source of the authority is Christ.
But I do not see why you see this as in conflict of these passages or of the responses you are being given. There are many gifts of the Holy Spirit. Of these, we all receive (in varying degrees) the traditionally defined Seven Gifts of the Holy Spirit ( Wisdom, Understanding, Counsel, Fortitude, Fortitude, Piety, and Fear of the Lord) at the time of confirmation. And then there are charisms (special favors, in Greek) of the Holy Spirit, which God chooses to bestow on individuals according to His will. An example of this would be healing power.
 
Perhaps reading the Catechism section on the Holy Spirit would be helpful to you.

The Holy Spirit = third person of the Trinity

Continue reading in the Catechism on the Church, which immediately follows the paragraphs on the Holy Spirit.

Christ is the source of authority, the Holy Spirit the protector of it. The Church doesn’t claim authority based on the idea that the Holy Spirit is protecting it. The Holy Spirit protects the Church because of her authority.

Again, I suggest reading the entire section of the Catechism on the Holy Spirit and the Church.
I have read it. The Church does claim authority based on the Holy Spirit because it bases its current authority on the idea of infallibility, which is completely based on the idea that the Holy Spirit is protecting it. If the Holy Spirit was not protecting the Church, the Church would still have authority to do certain things, but it would not be infallible. You cannot separate infallibility from authority in my opinion,
 
What was written that implies the Holy Spirt has nothing to do with authority? Jesus sent the Holy Spirit to the Church to protect it from error. So the Holy Spirit is why the Church has authority.
But I do not see why you see this as in conflict of these passages or of the responses you are being given. There are many gifts of the Holy Spirit. Of these, we all receive (in varying degrees) the traditionally defined Seven Gifts of the Holy Spirit ( Wisdom, Understanding, Counsel, Fortitude, Fortitude, Piety, and Fear of the Lord) at the time of confirmation. And then there are charisms (special favors, in Greek) of the Holy Spirit, which God chooses to bestow on individuals according to His will. An example of this would be healing power.
The reason I am having trouble with it is because the Church teaches it is infallible because of the Holy Spirit, but the Holy Spirit is given to numerous people who the Church says cannot claim infallibility…I agree with your point about authority and infallibility, as I mentioned above.
 
As I mentioned earlier, I think my primary problem is understanding how the Holy Spirit functions in so many different ways. I always felt the Holy Spirit=authority since the Church claims its authority based on the idea that the Holy Spirit is protecting them. But according to what is being said here, the Holy Spirit is not why the Church has authority and has nothing to do with authority…which is confusing to me…especially because I thought this was the basis for apostolic succession.
All of us receive the Holy Spirit in Baptism and Confirmation…etc etc.

The Church is made up of various members and offices. Some of particular authority for the sake of the Church.

Authority, the Sacraments etc is all by the Holy Spirit.

Simply being “by the Holy Spirit” does not mean that what is “by the Holy Spirit” is the same as what is “by the Holy Spirit” in other cases.

If a person is healed …it happens “by the Holy Spirit” because the Holy Spirit has given the particular person the power to do so. Has worked in that way.

But that person can not then turn around and say “well now I am a successor of the Apostles” for what I did was “by the Holy Spirit”.

Even in the beginning of Acts – no one dared to join the Twelve.

The Holy Spirit works in many various ways.

To some are given authority…to some miracles etc…but to all are given the Holy Spirit.
 
I appreciate your detailed response…I guess what doesn’t make sense to me is the term “Holy Spirit,” which seems to get thrown around a lot in a lot of different contexts. In Mathew 16 and Mathew 18, it seems that the Holy Spirit guides people in truth and is the reason the Church claims to be infallible. But in Acts 2, when Peter is addressing the masses, he says that all those who are baptized will receive the Holy Spirit, but all of those people belonging to the laity are not protected with infallibility. Then in Acts 6, it says that Stephen is blessed with the Holy Spirit before being made a deacon, but in Acts 8, the Holy Spirit only comes down to the people of Samaria when Peter and John lay their hands upon the people.

In all of these stories, the Holy Spirit is doing different things, applying to different groups of people, and is given in different capacities. In one instance, it makes the Church infallible and is given by Jesus, in another, it doesn’t make the laity infallible and is given by Peter. In another instance it allows Philip and Stephen to make miracles, but in other instances it doesn’t give the power of miracles. In Acts 6, it is given to Stephen without laying on of hands, but in Acts 8, it can only be given through the laying on of hands. It just seems inconsistent to me. Apparently no one else thinks so, and I do appreciate everyone’s efforts.
I can certainly understand how all this can be confusing. I am about to leave for a 4-hour drive so I hope my following statements will prove to be helpful, as it will be quite awhile before I can do any follow-up commentary.

The Holy Spirit, in his love and mercy, makes himself available to people in a variety of ways. These ways can be divided into two categories: sacramental and non-sacramental. When we talk about miracles, the yearning of people to know God (and seek baptism), and many experiences in our daily prayer life, we are describing what the Holy Spirit does in a non-sacramental capacity (and I’m speaking generally here).

The work of the Holy Spirit in the sacraments, however, provides a special grace, “sacramental grace”. This grace is “fine tuned” to do what the sacrament is designed to do. For example, the “ordinary means” that God absolves us from mortal sin is the Sacrament of Reconciliation. God can (and does) absolve us from mortal sin through what is called “perfect contrition”, but this is not sacramental absolution, but rather an “extraordinary means” for dealing with post-baptismal sin (and here, “extraordinary” simply means, “outside the norm”, not “incredibly good”). The benefit of going to confession over relying on perfect contrition is that it is hard for us to gauge whether or not we truly have perfect contrition to begin with. But in order to receive absolution in the Sacrament of Reconciliation, we simply have to be at least somewhat sorry for our sins, properly confess them, have a firm purpose of amendment and do our penance. Objectively speaking, I can know whether or not I made what is called a “good confession”, but I usually cannot know if I have perfect contrition. But perfect contrition, fortunately, is not a requirement for making a good confession in the context of the Sacrament of Reconciliation (all we need is “some” contrition, not “perfect” contrition).

I know that this thread is focusing on Confirmation, so the only reason why I brought up Confession is because I think it helps to understand the difference between sacramental grace and non-sacramental grace. We have certain assurances with the sacraments.

As I stated earlier, each sacrament is regulated by “matter” (the material utilized) and “form” (the words spoken). These are the parameters for a sacrament to be valid. For example, the matter for baptism is water, not sand, so if a person goes to get baptized and the minister pours sand over his head instead of water, it is not a valid baptism. It could be argued that the person received “baptism by desire” (i.e., an extraordinary means of obtaining God’s grace) but not a valid sacramental baptism (i.e., an ordinary means). Generally speaking, when we speak of “extraordinary means” we are often theorizing how God does things, but we have the assurance of God’s revelation concerning his “ordinary means.”

The Church’s teachings concerning the matter and form of a sacrament are doctrinal, and therefore we believe that such information is part of God’s revelation. The matter and form for the sacraments includes designating the “ordinary” minister for each one. This is the person empowered by God to administer the sacrament in question. A baptism does not require a member of the clergy for the purposes of sacramental validity. But Confirmation requires a bishop or (in certain circumstances) a priest. This is what has been known and understood within the Church since the beginning, and if someone wonders why this is a rule, the simplest answer is because it is the way God revealed it to us. It is considered part of the apostolic ministry (to which deacons are able to participate in but only to a certain degree).

The sacrament of baptism is the ordinary means by which God initially absolves us of sin and confers upon us the gifts of the Holy Spirit. Confirmation is the ordinary means by which God strengths (or “confirms”) these gifts that we previously received in baptism. God can absolve, confer gifts and strengthen these gifts in extraordinary means as well, but when such actions are done in the ordinary, sacramental capacity, they are to involve those properly designated as the ministers, because these ministers are empowered by God to do so.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top