Indulgences

  • Thread starter Thread starter nick347
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nick347

Guest
I’m confused about the explanation of indulgences, and purgatory. I thought that Jesus died to save us from the punishment of sin (obviously, we have to confess it and be sorry for it). I’ve heard Protestants and others say that this belief takes away from what Jesus did for us on the cross. Could anyone help me with this?
 
From what I’ve read, it’s that God’s Justice demands payment for our sins, even while in His Mercy He forgives us- kind of like how you can break your neighbor’s window with a ball and they may forgive you but they still expect you to pay for a new window. And also that we must be completely purged of our sinful nature before we can come before God. In the protestant view, they believe that upon death we are purged of that sinful nature and thus can go before God at that time. In the Catholic view, saints go straight to Heaven but the rest of us need some time in Purgatory before we are ready. There are verses in the Bible which back up this view, and honestly it makes more sense to me.

Others will chime in, I’m sure, with a better way of explaining it.
 
I’m confused about the explanation of indulgences, and purgatory. I thought that Jesus died to save us from the punishment of sin (obviously, we have to confess it and be sorry for it). I’ve heard Protestants and others say that this belief takes away from what Jesus did for us on the cross. Could anyone help me with this?
Jesus’ death on the cross merited for us the means to have our sins forgiven, the punishment for sin taken away, eternal life on high with God, and he opened heaven for us. Jesus instituted the seven sacraments by which the fruits of Christ’s redemptive death are applied to us. For example, Jesus said "No one can enter the kingdom of God without being born through water and the Spirit. " Baptism is one of the sacraments which Jesus wants us to partake in and by which the fruits and merits of his death and suffering on the cross are applied to us. In baptism, all our sins and the punishment due to our sins are all taken away so that if we died immediately after being baptized, we would go straight to heaven.

Again, Jesus said “unless you eat my flesh and drink my blood, you will have no life within you.” This refers to partaking in the eucharist and communion. So, Jesus’ death on the cross doesn’t automatically save us unless we do what he wants us to do such as partake in the sacraments of the Church and belong to His Church. Again, Jesus applies the merit and fruit of his death on the cross through the sacraments of the Church which give grace.

Confession is also one of the sacraments Jesus instituted for us. For we sin all the time and the sacrament of confession is a remedy for our sins. Here again, it is through this sacrament that Jesus applies the merit and fruit of his death of the cross. Our sins are forgiven in confession only because of Jesus’ redemptive and sacrificial death on the cross. We partake in Jesus’ death on the cross through the sacraments of the Church which Jesus instituted for us.

Now, there are three parts to the sacrament of penance, namely, contrition or sorrow for our sins, confession of our sins to the priest, and satisfaction or doing the penance the priest gives us to perform after we leave the confessional. The satisfaction or penance the priest gives us to perform, for example, saying an Our Father or a few Hail Mary’s, is to atone for the temporal punishment that is a consequence of our sins. For every sin carries with it either an eternal punishment which is the consequence of mortal sin, or temporal punishment which is the consequence of venial sin.

Indulgences atone for the temporal punishment of sins of which the guilt has already been forgiven such as we confess in confession. A plenary indulgence atones for all the temporal punishment we may accrue due to our sins while a partial indulgence atones for part of the temporal punishment due to our sins. Indulgences are a beautiful doctrine of the mercy of Jesus and God. We can gain a plenary indulgence by spending a half hour in prayer in front of the blessed sacrament and fulfilling the other prescribed conditions for plenary indulgences. Just by spending a half hour in prayer before the Blessed Sacrament, we can atone and satisfy for all the temporal punishment still lingering on our souls (we need to fulfill the other prescribed conditions for plenary indulgences too). Again, the Church’s granting of indulgences is the application of the fruit and merit of Christ’s death on the cross.

The Enchiridion of Indulgences, Norms and Grants is the official publication of the Catholic Church on indulgences. It can be found online here basilica.org/pages/ebooks/Sacred%20Apostolic%20Penitentiary-The%20Enchiridion%20of%20Indulgences.pdf

You might especially want to read toward the back of this publication the Apostolic Constitution “The Doctrine of Indulgences” issued by Pope Paul VI in 1967 when the Church revised the practice of gaining indulgences. This Apostolic Constitution explains the doctrine of indulgences in the Church. You can also read about indulgences in the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
 
Jesus’ death on the cross merited for us the means to have our sins forgiven, the punishment for sin taken away, eternal life on high with God, and he opened heaven for us. Jesus instituted the seven sacraments by which the fruits of Christ’s redemptive death are applied to us. For example, Jesus said "No one can enter the kingdom of God without being born through water and the Spirit. " Baptism is one of the sacraments which Jesus wants us to partake in and by which the fruits and merits of his death and suffering on the cross are applied to us. In baptism, all our sins and the punishment due to our sins are all taken away so that if we died immediately after being baptized, we would go straight to heaven.

Again, Jesus said “unless you eat my flesh and drink my blood, you will have no life within you.” This refers to partaking in the eucharist and communion. So, Jesus’ death on the cross doesn’t automatically save us unless we do what he wants us to do such as partake in the sacraments of the Church and belong to His Church. Again, Jesus applies the merit and fruit of his death on the cross through the sacraments of the Church which give grace.

Confession is also one of the sacraments Jesus instituted for us. For we sin all the time and the sacrament of confession is a remedy for our sins. Here again, it is through this sacrament that Jesus applies the merit and fruit of his death of the cross. Our sins are forgiven in confession only because of Jesus’ redemptive and sacrificial death on the cross. We partake in Jesus’ death on the cross through the sacraments of the Church which Jesus instituted for us.

Now, there are three parts to the sacrament of penance, namely, contrition or sorrow for our sins, confession of our sins to the priest, and satisfaction or doing the penance the priest gives us to perform after we leave the confessional. The satisfaction or penance the priest gives us to perform, for example, saying an Our Father or a few Hail Mary’s, is to atone for the temporal punishment that is a consequence of our sins. For every sin carries with it either an eternal punishment which is the consequence of mortal sin, or temporal punishment which is the consequence of venial sin.

Indulgences atone for the temporal punishment of sins of which the guilt has already been forgiven such as we confess in confession. A plenary indulgence atones for all the temporal punishment we may accrue due to our sins while a partial indulgence atones for part of the temporal punishment due to our sins. Indulgences are a beautiful doctrine of the mercy of Jesus and God. We can gain a plenary indulgence by spending a half hour in prayer in front of the blessed sacrament and fulfilling the other prescribed conditions for plenary indulgences. Just by spending a half hour in prayer before the Blessed Sacrament, we can atone and satisfy for all the temporal punishment still lingering on our souls (we need to fulfill the other prescribed conditions for plenary indulgences too). Again, the Church’s granting of indulgences is the application of the fruit and merit of Christ’s death on the cross.

The Enchiridion of Indulgences, Norms and Grants is the official publication of the Catholic Church on indulgences. It can be found online here basilica.org/pages/ebooks/Sacred%20Apostolic%20Penitentiary-The%20Enchiridion%20of%20Indulgences.pdf

You might especially want to read toward the back of this publication the Apostolic Constitution “The Doctrine of Indulgences” issued by Pope Paul VI in 1967 when the Church revised the practice of gaining indulgences. This Apostolic Constitution explains the doctrine of indulgences in the Church. You can also read about indulgences in the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
Well stated and informative, thank you. 👍
 
I’m confused about the explanation of indulgences, and purgatory. I thought that Jesus died to save us from the punishment of sin (obviously, we have to confess it and be sorry for it). I’ve heard Protestants and others say that this belief takes away from what Jesus did for us on the cross. Could anyone help me with this?
The Fourth Edition (1999) of the ‘Enchiridion Indulgentiarum’ is current and the previous versions are no longer in effect.

ewtn.com/library/CURIA/APINDULG.HTM

Christ merited justification for us, but due to our sins, attachments to sin remain (temporal punishments) that must be eliminated in this life or purgatory. We also suffer consequences as a result our sins during this life.

Catechism of the Catholic Church
617 The Council of Trent emphasizes the unique character of Christ’s sacrifice as "the source of eternal salvation"449 and teaches that "his most holy Passion on the wood of the cross merited justification for us."450 And the Church venerates his cross as she sings: "Hail, O Cross, our only hope."451
The punishments of sin 1472 To understand this doctrine and practice of the Church, it is necessary to understand that sin has a double consequence. Grave sin deprives us of communion with God and therefore makes us incapable of eternal life, the privation of which is called the “eternal punishment” of sin. On the other hand every sin, even venial, entails an unhealthy attachment to creatures, which must be purified either here on earth, or after death in the state called Purgatory. This purification frees one from what is called the “temporal punishment” of sin. These two punishments must not be conceived of as a kind of vengeance inflicted by God from without, but as following from the very nature of sin. A conversion which proceeds from a fervent charity can attain the complete purification of the sinner in such a way that no punishment would remain.83
 
I was taught that Jesus opened the gates of heaven for us, and it is up to us if we enter.

Btw-it is from the baItimore cateshism and is a simple answer-but I believe ot sums it up nicely.
 
Think of it like needing to be scrubbed clean in the heavenly mud-room before being allowed inside the house. You get allowed into the house because you repented of the foolishness that you engaged in whilst outside–but you’re still all filthy, or you didn’t take enough time to wipe down before coming in.

Stretching this analogy further (too far?), indulgences are like blankets that the Church has collected and passes out to those who think to ask for them.

I’m sure someone will shoot all kinds of holes in this analogy, but this is how I’ve always understood the doctrine.
 
I’m confused about the explanation of indulgences, and purgatory. I thought that Jesus died to save us from the punishment of sin (obviously, we have to confess it and be sorry for it). I’ve heard Protestants and others say that this belief takes away from what Jesus did for us on the cross. Could anyone help me with this?
First, it bears pointing out that there are three parts to repentance that have been defined by the Church–contrition, confession, and bringing forth fruits worthy of repentance (this last part is often called “making satisfaction.”) See Acts 26:20, Matt 3:8, Like 3:8. If we don’t bring forth sufficient fruit worthy of repentance in this life–ie if we don’t make sufficient satisfaction–we do so after death, but before entering Heaven through what we call Purgatory. Temporal Punishment is essentially the consequence of not making this satisfaction.

Indulgences are a grant from the Church of the shared fruit (the “treasury of merit”) of the whole Body of Christ to make satisfaction on behalf of the person benefiting from the indulgence. Just like in Acts where the faithful share all in common by laying it at the Apostles’ feet, and then the Apostles distribute it, so do we continue to do with our excess spiritual goods. It’s why St. Paul could rejoice that his suffering made up for what was lacking in other members of the Church (see Col. 1:24). He was making satisfaction/bringing forth fruit on behalf of others.
 
As Catholic’s we have been taught too go too confession when we feel that we did something wrong too offend God, and too put us back in the state off Grace.
Yes, Jesus did die too save us sinners but other religious place believe diffident than we do.,and I,ll leave at that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top