D
DavidJoseph
Guest
What does one say to a Catholic who refuses to believe canonizations are infallible despite having heard quotes from Ludwig Ott, St. Alphonsus Liguori, and similar sources? He’s like, “Church teachings are only infallible if they’ve been taught from the beginning. Even the Catholic Encyclopedia only says that most theologians believe canonizations are infallible, not that the Church explicitly teaches it” (at least that’s his argument in a nutshell).
Just for the record, this guy claims the Church was wrong to beatify Bl. John Paul II (I won’t go into why he believes that) and says that should His Holiness be canonized, he will continue to be “charitable” and pray FOR His Holiness.
Just for the record, this guy claims the Church was wrong to beatify Bl. John Paul II (I won’t go into why he believes that) and says that should His Holiness be canonized, he will continue to be “charitable” and pray FOR His Holiness.