Infallibility of canonizations

  • Thread starter Thread starter DavidJoseph
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DavidJoseph

Guest
What does one say to a Catholic who refuses to believe canonizations are infallible despite having heard quotes from Ludwig Ott, St. Alphonsus Liguori, and similar sources? He’s like, “Church teachings are only infallible if they’ve been taught from the beginning. Even the Catholic Encyclopedia only says that most theologians believe canonizations are infallible, not that the Church explicitly teaches it” (at least that’s his argument in a nutshell).

Just for the record, this guy claims the Church was wrong to beatify Bl. John Paul II (I won’t go into why he believes that) and says that should His Holiness be canonized, he will continue to be “charitable” and pray FOR His Holiness.
 
Well, the guy is correct that the Church has never formally and dogmatically defined the infallible nature of “modern” canonizations (ie, canonizations performed using the process we have today).

Theologians believe this teaching is part of the Sacred Tradition of the Church (which is infallible, but is not as easy to quantify).

The Church has continually and universally taught that certain people are in heaven (Mary, for example), so the idea of declaring someone to be in heaven (which today we call “canonization”) goes back to the beginning of the Church. The early Church did not have a clearly defined process for canonization, as we have today, but it is the idea (not the process) that is Doctrine. And the idea is that the Church has the divine authority to declare certain people to be in heaven, and this idea is nothing new.

The particular person who is canonized is not the idea - s/he is the subject. Just as the Church can Baptize people today (with certain infallible guarantees), She can canonize people today.
 
…

Just for the record, this guy claims the Church was wrong to beatify Bl. John Paul II (I won’t go into why he believes that) and says that should His Holiness be canonized, he will continue to be “charitable” and pray FOR His Holiness.
I don’t think this is worth a quibble.

If he wants to pray, let him. We tend to think of saints as the one’ who have ‘made it’, like they have graduated or something. That is not necessarily so, it could be that there are degrees of holiness, and that people could improve even in the next life. Perhaps he could use the prayers after all. 😉
 
I don’t think this is worth a quibble.

If he wants to pray, let him. We tend to think of saints as the one’ who have ‘made it’, like they have graduated or something. That is not necessarily so, it could be that there are degrees of holiness, and that people could improve even in the next life. Perhaps he could use the prayers after all. 😉
Well, you’re correct that there will be degrees in heaven, corresponding to the degree of holiness we attained while on earth. But in heaven, whatever degree of holiness you attained while on earth is fixed. Besides, those in heaven don’t need prayers; those in purgatory do.
 
Well, you’re correct that there will be degrees in heaven, corresponding to the degree of holiness we attained while on earth. But in heaven, whatever degree of holiness you attained while on earth is fixed.
Do you have a citation which specifically addresses this idea? I am curious.
 
Well, you’re correct that there will be degrees in heaven, corresponding to the degree of holiness we attained while on earth. But in heaven, whatever degree of holiness you attained while on earth is fixed. Besides, those in heaven don’t need prayers; those in purgatory do.
That’s nonsense. What Church teaching/document supports such a claim?
 
That’s nonsense. What Church teaching/document supports such a claim?
The following passage can be found here: newadvent.org/cathen/07170a.htm
There are various degrees of beatitude in heaven corresponding to the various degrees of merit. This is a dogma of faith, defined by the Council of Florence (Denz., n. 693 — old, n. 588). The Bible teaches this truth in very many passages (e.g., wherever it speaks of eternal happiness as a reward), and the Fathers defend it against the heretical attacks of Jovinian. It is true that, according to Matthew 20:1-16, each labourer receives a penny; but by this comparison Christ merely teaches that, although the Gospel was preached to the Jews first, yet in the Kingdom of Heaven there is no distinction between Jew and Gentile, and that no one will receive a greater reward merely because of being a son of Judah. The various degrees of beatitude are not limited to the accidental blessings, but they are found first and foremost in the beatific vision itself. For, as we have already pointed out, the vision, too, admits of degrees. These essential degrees of beatitude are, as Francisco Suárez rightly observes (“De beat.”, d. xi, s. 3, n. 5), that threefold fruit Christ distinguishes when He says that the word of God bears fruit in some thirty, in some sixty, in some a hundredfold (Matthew 13:23). And it is by a mere accommodation of the text that St. Thomas (Supp:96, aa. 2 sqq.) and other theologians apply this text to the different degrees in the accidental beatitude merited by married persons, widows, and virgins.
So you see? Nothing nonsensical about that. Care for some salt or pepper with that crow? 😛
 
The following passage can be found here: newadvent.org/cathen/07170a.htm

So you see? Nothing nonsensical about that. Care for some salt or pepper with that crow? 😛
As you are directing me to The Council of Florence document as your support can you please at least direct me to the section/paragraph in the document so I can read what it says or have you not actually read it and are simply looking to an encyclopedia (not a Church document) article to support your claim.
 
As you are directing me to The Council of Florence document as your support can you please at least direct me to the section/paragraph in the document so I can read what it says or have you not actually read it and are simply looking to an encyclopedia (not a Church document) article to support your claim.
#693, from Pope Eugenius IV, the Council of Florence, 1438-1445 in a decree to the Greeks, also concerning the Primacy of Peter among other points of doctrine, including Purgatory:

" . . . It is likewise defined that, if those truly penitent have departed in the love of God, before they have made satisfaction by worthy fruits of penance for sins of commission and omission, the souls of these are cleansed after death by purgatorial punishments; and so that they may be released from punishments of this kind, the suffrages of the living faithful are of advantage to them, namely, the sacrifices of Masses, prayers, and almsgiving, and other works of piety, which are customarily performed by the taithful for other faithful according to the institutions of the Church. And that the souls of those, who after the reception of Baptism have incurred no stain of sin at all, and also those, who after the contraction of the stain of sin whether in their bodies, or when released from the same bodies, as we have said before, are purged, are immediately received into Heaven, and see clearly the one and triune God Himself, just as He is, yet according to the diversity of merits, one more perfectly than another. Moreover, the souls of those who depart in actual mortal sin or in Original Sin only, descend immediately into Hell but to undergo punishments of different kinds."
 
As you are directing me to The Council of Florence document as your support can you please at least direct me to the section/paragraph in the document so I can read what it says or have you not actually read it and are simply looking to an encyclopedia (not a Church document) article to support your claim.
Methinks thou protesteth too much. New Advent is a 100% reliable source (which you’ve apparently never used). But since you want section and paragraph, I will oblige.
Council of Florence (1439): DS 1304-1306
It has likewise defined, that, if those truly penitent have departed in the love of God, before they have made satisfaction by worthy fruits of penance for sins of commission and omission, the souls of these are cleansed after death by purgatorial punishments; and so that they may be released from punishments of this kind, the suffrages of the living faithful are of advantage to them, namely, the sacrifices of Masses, prayers, and almsgiving, and other works of piety, which are customarily performed by the faithful for other faithful according to the institutions of the Church. And that the souls of those, who after the reception of baptism have incurred no stain of sin at all, and also those, who after the contraction of the stain of sin whether in their bodies, or when released from the same bodies, as we have said before, are purged, are immediately received into heaven, and see clearly the one and triune God Himself, just as He is, yet according to the diversity of merits, one more perfectly than another. Moreover, the souls of those who depart in actual mortal sin or in original sin only, descend immediately into hell but to undergo punishments of different kinds.
While I’m at it, I can’t forget the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
1053 “We believe that the multitude of those gathered around Jesus and Mary in Paradise forms the Church of heaven, where in eternal blessedness they see God as he is and where they are also, to various degrees, associated with the holy angels in the divine governance exercised by Christ in glory, by interceding for us and helping our weakness by their fraternal concern” (Paul VI, CPG § 29).
 
The Church has continually and universally taught that certain people are in heaven (Mary, for example), so the idea of declaring someone to be in heaven (which today we call “canonization”) goes back to the beginning of the Church. The early Church did not have a clearly defined process for canonization, as we have today, but it is the idea (not the process) that is Doctrine. And the idea is that the Church has the divine authority to declare certain people to be in heaven, and this idea is nothing new.

The particular person who is canonized is not the idea - s/he is the subject. Just as the Church can Baptize people today (with certain infallible guarantees), She can canonize people today.
Indeed. The “canonization process” of the ancient Church was not formally defined, but rather was an act of public acclaim (Mary, the Apostles and other notable biblical figures, as well as the Christians martyred by Imperial Rome, where proclaimed to be saints by Christians). I think this could be considered an aspect of sensus fidei and therefore, as you said, it would have certain infallible guarantees associated with it.
 
Personally, if “degrees” were important, I would not care if I were in the back row of heaven. The Beatific Vision is the Beatific Vision.
 
I don’t see anything in the citation that indicates the levels are fixed and unchanging.
Jesus said, “In my Father’s house are many mansions. If it were not so, I would not have told you.” (John 14:2)

Some interpret this passage to mean, “there’s plenty of room in heaven.” But Catholic theologians traditionally interpret it to mean that the experience of heaven will not be universally consistent for everyone. I would not characterize this as “levels” or “degrees” but different experiences.
 
Methinks thou protesteth too much. New Advent is a 100% reliable source (which you’ve apparently never used). But since you want section and paragraph, I will oblige.

While I’m at it, I can’t forget the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
That’s not what I asked. I didn’t want a copy and paste. I want to read the Council of Florence document and would like to know where to find that passage in the document.

By the way as this thread has digressed from your original post I just want to mention that canonisation is indeed an infallible declaration by the Church that the person canonised is in Heaven. Catholics are bound to believe that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top