Infallible versus non-infallible

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
then post it
Go for it. I’ll tell you if you got it right. 👍
You’ve attacked infallibility on this forum for 5 years.
It is apparent that papal supremacy/infallibility has been a tragic error for at least 140 years. 😃
when did infallibility end?
Or maybe you think infallibility never existed.
Okay, since you will not clarify. I will answer to the best of my ability. The idea of papal supremacy/infallibility did not exist at the time of the apostles. It did not exist during the first millennium of the undivided Church. It did not exist for most of the second millennium for the Orthodox or the schismatic Latin Church. It exist now only for the schismatic Latin Church and some of those in communion with Her.

There ya go Stevie! 👍
 
I suggest you begin studying the Church Fathers more seriously.
I have studied them extensively and I continue to study them…in context. 😉
I’ve taken nothing out of context.
You’ve taken everything out of context.
What I posted above is just a drop in the bucket,
Indeed! 👍
It was at the Ecumenical Councils where the pontiff presided and exercised the charism of infallibilty
Nope. No such thing as a supreme/infallible Pontiff during the great Councils.
You can’t be sure unless you subscribe to the doctrine of infallibilty.
Silly wabbit. It was not a Pope that codified the canon.
Anyway, this doctrine or belief isn’t a post- schismatic invention of the West.
Yes it is.
 
I suggest you begin studying the Church Fathers more seriously. I’ve taken nothing out of context. What I posted above is just a drop in the bucket, but nevertheless shows that the early Church acknowledged the primacy of the church at Rome and the bishop of Rome (in temporal and spiritual matters] who succeeded St. Peter there.
The first bishop of Rome to try to flex his muscle was Victor, and he was “rebuked by the entire Church,” as Eusebius shows us (and no, Nicea did not endorse Rome’s calculation, but Alexandria’s).
It was at the Ecumenical Councils where the pontiff presided
The Pope never presided at an Ecumenical Council.
and exercised the charism of infallibilty in union with the college of bishops when defining dogmas in refutation against heresies. On these occasions the pope confirmed the brethren in the faith.
Like Honorius? The Sixth Council (and Popes Agatho and Leo II, and their successors who took the oath acccording to the Liber Diuris) had something to say about that:

ANATHEMA!!!
Perhaps you think Pope Damasus and the bishops could have been mistaken in establishing the canon of Scripture. Is there any chance the Book of Revelation or St. Paul’s Letter to the Hebrews is apochryphal? You can’t be sure unless you subscribe to the doctrine of infallibilty.
The first time we find the NT canon as we have it is in Pope Athanasius (of ALEXANDRIA)'s Paschal message of 367AD.

The story of Pope Damasus in the Pseudo-Gelesius Decretal, and its OT canon doesn’t match that of Trent. Rome was rejecting Hebrews.
Anyway, this doctrine or belief isn’t a post- schismatic invention of the West.
It’s a post reformation invention of the West. The Hiberno-English Catechism of 1870 which said Infallibility was Protestant slander, and Hefele up to 1870 denied it: they had to change their story quickly.
 
*“by the judgment of God and of Christ, by the testimony of almost all the clergy, by the vote of the people then present, by the consent of aged priests and of good men, at a time when no one had been made before him, when the place of Fabian [Bishop of Rome], that is the place of Peter, and the step of the sacerdotal chair were vacant.” *
Cyprian, Bishop of Carthage
St. Cyprian also translated and published the letter Firmilian sent to him when St.Cyprian sought aid against Stephen of Rome.
  1. And in this respect I am justly indignant at this so open and manifest folly of Stephen, that he who so boasts of the place of his episcopate, and contends that he holds the succession from Peter, whom the foundations of the Church were laid, should introduce many other rocks and establish new buildings of many churches; maintaining that there is baptism in them by his authority. For they who are baptized, doubtless, fill up the number of the Church. But he who approves their baptism maintains, of those baptized, that the Church is also with them. Nor does he understand that the truth of the Christian Rock is overshadowed, and in some measure abolished, by him when he thus betrays and deserts unity…
  2. Consider with what want of judgment you dare to blame those who strive for the truth against falsehood. For who ought more justly to be indignant against the other?—whether he who supports God’s enemies, or he who, in opposition to him who supports God’s enemies, unites with us on behalf of the truth of the Church?—except that it is plain that the ignorant are also excited and angry, because by the want of counsel and discourse they are easily turned to wrath; so that of none more than of you does divine Scripture say, “A wrathful man stirreth up strifes, and a furious man heapeth up sins.”For what strifes and dissensions have you stirred up throughout the churches of the whole world! Moreover, how great sin have you heaped up for yourself, when you cut yourself off from so many flocks! For it is yourself that you have cut off. Do not deceive yourself, since he is really the schismatic who has made himself an apostate from the communion of ecclesiastical unity. For while you think that all may be excommunicated by you, you have excommunicated yourself alone from all; and not even the precepts of an apostle have been able to mould you to the rule of truth and peace, although he warned, and said, “I therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, beseech you that ye walk worthy of the vocation wherewith ye are called, with all lowliness and meekness, with long-suffering, forbearing one another in love; endeavouring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. There is one body and one Spirit, even as ye are called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism; one God and Father of all, who is above all, and through all, and in us all.”
    ccel.org/ccel/schaff/anf05.iv.iv.lxxiv.html
 
Go for it. I’ll tell you if you got it right. 👍
It is apparent that papal supremacy/infallibility has been a tragic error for at least 140 years. 😃
Okay, since you will not clarify. I will answer to the best of my ability. The idea of papal supremacy/infallibility did not exist at the time of the apostles.
That is a false unsubstantiated assertion I would expect from a fundie. It is a blatant flat out LIE.
It did not exist during the first millennium of the undivided Church. It did not exist for most of the second millennium for the Orthodox or the schismatic Latin Church. It exist now only for the schismatic Latin Church and some of those in communion with Her.
That is double LIE. If you can make remarks with no proof then so can I. Your statements are lies, but the difference between you and me is is that I can prove what I say, you just make mindless, erroneous assertions.
 
That is a false unsubstantiated assertion I would expect from a fundie.
Careful with that beam in your eye.
40.png
kepha1:
I can prove what I sayYou have proved nothing.
It is a historical fact that papal supremacy/infallibility is an innovation that was set forth and defined in 1870 by Pius IX and the ultramonatanists. You cannot prove otherwise. 🤷
 
Careful with that beam in your eye.
You have proved nothing.
It is a historical fact that papal supremacy/infallibility is an innovation that was set forth and defined in 1870 by Pius IX and the ultramonatanists. You cannot prove otherwise. 🤷
Proving your ignorance of Vatican 1 isn’t hard. But you evade defining your own premise and refuse to clarify your position. You refuse to say if infallibility ever existed, and if it did, when did it end? Be clear for a change. It’s not the Latin Church that places limits on the prolongation of the Incarnation. Dialoguing with a brick wall is a waste of time.
 
Go for it. I’ll tell you if you got it right. 👍
It is apparent that papal supremacy/infallibility has been a tragic error for at least 140 years. 😃
Okay, since you will not clarify. I will answer to the best of my ability. The idea of papal supremacy/infallibility did not exist at the time of the apostles. It did not exist during the first millennium of the undivided Church. It did not exist for most of the second millennium for the Orthodox or the schismatic Latin Church. It exist now only for the schismatic Latin Church and some of those in communion with Her.

There ya go Stevie! 👍
:extrahappy:FINALLY!!! After all my prodding, you finally answer!!! It’s not a correct answer but at least you answered.

Phew!!!

If you had said I don’t know how the Catholic Church defines it, I would have gladly posted the Vat 1 documents
papalencyclicals.net/Councils/ecum20.htm Session 4 covers primacy, Ch 4 in that session covers papal infallibility

Re: the definition according to the Church of papal infallibility.
:
we teach and define as a divinely revealed dogma that
  • when the Roman pontiff speaks EX CATHEDRA,
  • that is, when,
    1. **in the exercise of his office as shepherd and teacher of all Christians,
    2. in virtue of his supreme apostolic authority,
    3. he defines a doctrine concerning faith or morals to be held by the whole church,**

    • he possesses, by the divine assistance promised to him in blessed Peter,
    • that infallibility which the divine Redeemer willed his church to enjoy in defining doctrine concerning faith or morals.
    • Therefore, such definitions of the Roman pontiff are of themselves, and not by the consent of the church, irreformable.
    Honorius, who you like to use to oppose papal infallibility, didn’t meet the criteria, within that definition.
    • Honorius didn’t teach, define, declare as divinely revealed dogma, ANYTHING he and Sergius were talking about.
    • He didn’t bind the entire Church to any belief he and Sergius were talking about.
    • Finally, Honorius kept quiet about what he and Sergius talked about.
    Therefore, papal infallibility was not even an issue in the matter…BY DEFINITION
 
:extrahappy:FINALLY!!! After all my prodding, you finally answer!!! It’s not a correct answer but at least you answered.

Phew!!!

If you had said I don’t know how the Catholic Church defines it, I would have gladly posted the Vat 1 documents
papalencyclicals.net/Councils/ecum20.htm Session 4 covers primacy, Ch 4 in that session covers papal infallibility

Re: the definition according to the Church of papal infallibility.

Honorius, who you like to use to oppose papal infallibility, didn’t meet the criteria, within that definition.
  • Honorius didn’t teach, define, declare as divinely revealed dogma, ANYTHING he and Sergius were talking about.
  • He didn’t bind the entire Church to any belief he and Sergius were talking about.
  • Finally, Honorius kept quiet about what he and Sergius talked about.
Therefore, papal infallibility was not even an issue in the matter…BY DEFINITION
Orthodox, Sede Vacant Heads, and Fundamentalists use the same LIE about Pope Honorius that Mickey uses.
St. Robert Bellarmine ended the sixth chapter of his fourth book about the spiritual power of the popes (Controversiarum De Summo Pontifice, Liber Quartus, De Potestate Spirituali, Caput VI) by noting
“…that up to now no supreme Pontiff has ever been an haeretic, since it certainly cannot be proven of any of them that he was an haeretic: therefore it is a sign (from Heaven) that such a thing cannot happen”.

To give the most convincing practical proof of this, he studied all the cases of all the popes who allegedly had succumbed to errors, beginning with St. Peter and ending with Innocent VIII, the fortieth slandered pope (whom the enemies of the Church accused of allowing the Norwegians to celebrate the Eucharist without using any wine at all)…

… St. Robert… gives all the details he has found true, and they fill seven large in-quarto pages. To make our summary clearer, we will divide his answers between those concerning the substance of Honorius’ letters, and those concerning the proofs of numberless falsifications and forgeries that caused many people, especially during the Middle Ages, to believe that Honorius had been solemnly condemned by the Church.

As St. Robert reports, all the scandalous stories started with the Sixth Synod of Constantinople (681-682), e.g. “That synod has condemned Honorius as an heretic (act. 13) and has *burnt *his letters”.

Then started the endless publications of these conciliar “actions” by following councils, scrupulously repeated by a host of other writers, and even by popes throughout Christendom, even to our present day.
The burning of Honorius’ correspondence with Sergius, the Patriarch of Constantinople who triggered the affair, is significant. I personally find it extremely suspicious that the “judges” should have decided to burn “pieces of evidence”, [which were,] in fact, the only direct physical ones that were in existence. St. Robert is thus obliged to comment upon only two fragments; the rescued parts of the letters that had escaped combustion. He writes the following analysis:
  • In these letters there are not any errors*. Honorius confesses, as far as this affair is concerned that there were in Jesus two will-powers that operated distinctly. He merely forbids anyone to use the phrases “only one will-power” or “two will-powers”, which had never been heard of before that time. But his confessing the real existence of both powers is conspicuous in his second letter (which is totally Catholic): ewtn.com/library/COUNCILS/V1.HTM
 
Pope Honorius never taught error. He lived as a solid churchman and died with his reputation intact. He was buried with honors in St. Peter’s basillica. It was not until 20 years after his death that his letters to Sergius became an issue. By that time, Pope Honorius’ attempt to prevent schism and keep the Monothelites in the Church was seen to have failed. His leniency had to be condemned. Show me one single Magisterial document in which the Catholic Church officially taught error in this case. There are none.

The letters to Sergius were not magisterial documents BY DESIGN. Pope Honorius was trying to keep the matter informal to avoid open conflict and possible schism.

Mickey’s chronic argument using the holy Pope Honorius against the Doctrine of Infallibility is a fraud.

The West never condemned holy Pope St. Honorius as a heretic.
St Robert then goes on tackling other false assumptions, among which the case of Pope Hadrian’s document.

On the fourth proof which is proposed, I answer Pope Hadrian, and the Council he gathered in Rome, does not directly affirm Honorius to have been heretical. He merely reports that he has been declared heretical by the Orientals. He knew quite well that, according to the antecedent Council that had been convoked by Martin I in Rome, Honorius had never been condemned by the Western Church.
http://www.eclipseofthechurch.com/HonoriusCalumny.htm
My question to Micky: was the development of doctrine suddenly freeze dried at the end of the Seventh Ecumenical Council?
 
St. Cyprian also translated and published the letter Firmilian sent to him when St.Cyprian sought aid against Stephen of Rome.
  1. And in this respect I am justly indignant at this so open and manifest folly of Stephen, that he who so boasts of the place of his episcopate, and contends that he holds the succession from Peter, whom the foundations of the Church were laid, should introduce many other rocks and establish new buildings of many churches; maintaining that there is baptism in them by his authority. For they who are baptized, doubtless, fill up the number of the Church. But he who approves their baptism maintains, of those baptized, that the Church is also with them. Nor does he understand that the truth of the Christian Rock is overshadowed, and in some measure abolished, by him when he thus betrays and deserts unity…
  2. Consider with what want of judgment you dare to blame those who strive for the truth against falsehood. For who ought more justly to be indignant against the other?—whether he who supports God’s enemies, or he who, in opposition to him who supports God’s enemies, unites with us on behalf of the truth of the Church?—except that it is plain that the ignorant are also excited and angry, because by the want of counsel and discourse they are easily turned to wrath; so that of none more than of you does divine Scripture say, “A wrathful man stirreth up strifes, and a furious man heapeth up sins.”For what strifes and dissensions have you stirred up throughout the churches of the whole world! Moreover, how great sin have you heaped up for yourself, when you cut yourself off from so many flocks! For it is yourself that you have cut off. Do not deceive yourself, since he is really the schismatic who has made himself an apostate from the communion of ecclesiastical unity. For while you think that all may be excommunicated by you, you have excommunicated yourself alone from all
; and not even the precepts of an apostle have been able to mould you to the rule of truth and peace, although he warned, and said, “I therefore, the prisoner of the Lord, beseech you that ye walk worthy of the vocation wherewith ye are called, with all lowliness and meekness, with long-suffering, forbearing one another in love; endeavouring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. There is one body and one Spirit, even as ye are called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism; one God and Father of all, who is above all, and through all, and in us all.”
ccel.org/ccel/schaff/anf05.iv.iv.lxxiv.html

St. Cyprian was very upset at the time,since Pope Stephen wouldn’t change his ruling against the unorthodox practice of rebaptizing those who had been baptized by heretics. The bishop of Carthage contravened Church teaching by asserting that the baptism performed by heretical clergy was invalid. The pontiff threatened to excommunicate all those who performed rebaptisms. This judgment of the pope angered Cyril who apparently never seriously questioned the primacy or universal jurisdiction of the Holy See at Rome in matters of doctrine. The most he did was just rant and rave. :mad:

catholic.com/thisrock/1997/9704eaw.asp

PAX :tiphat:
 
f God is omniscient then he knows how to bring it about that there is neither evil nor suffering.
If God is omnipotent then he is able to bring it about that there is neither evil nor suffering.
If God is benevolent then he wants to bring it about that there is neither evil nor suffering.
But if God knows how to, is able to and wants to bring it about that there is neither evil nor suffering, then why does he not do so?

“God is incomprehensible” you respond.

Theists have often been content to say that we are unable to comprehend God, that his being transcends our mundane experiences and that our concepts, which are derived from such experiences, cannot be used to describe him. If true, then this might be thought to count in favor of agnosticism; if we cannot comprehend God, then how can we reason with any confidence concerning his existence?

Of course, I can’t expect this to make sense to any one here. The only way you could maintain such a blind faith as I see here is if you rejected anything that offended you or challenged your knowledge. At least when I am censored, you must acknowledge the truth of this last paragraph.
 
  • Honorius didn’t teach, define, declare as divinely revealed dogma, ANYTHING he and Sergius were talking about.
  • He didn’t bind the entire Church to any belief he and Sergius were talking about.
  • Finally, Honorius kept quiet about what he and Sergius talked about.
His letters were burned and called hurtful to the soul. Whose soul? Obviously, there were people who felt that since the Pope of Rome was “a confirmer of heresy” that this was a true teaching. Honorius did not have to climb on a pedestal or write an encyclical that begins with “I hereby proclaim…” He was condemned as a heretic. He was a confirmer of heresy. He was a “tool for the originator of evil”.
T
he Council says:
“We have destroyed the fort of the heretics, and slain them with anathema*…” *

*There is an imperial decree that *speaks about the “unholy priests who infected the Church and falsely governed” and includes “Honorius, the Pope of Old Rome”.

The decree goes on to say that he “strengthened the heresy.”

Pope Leo II says, “Honorius, who did not attempt to sanctify this apostolic Church with the teaching of apostolic tradition but by profane treachery tried to subvert its spotless faith".
Therefore, papal infallibility was not even an issue in the matter
I’ll give you this one. There was no such thing as papal infallibility at this time. 😉
 
Mickey’s chronic argument using the holy Pope Honorius against the Doctrine of Infallibility is a fraud. Many blessings to you during this Lenten season.
40.png
kepha1:
The West never condemned holy Pope St. Honorius as a heretic.
He was not a saint. He was condemned as a heretic.
 
The pontiff threatened to excommunicate all those who performed rebaptisms. This judgment of the pope angered Cyril who apparently never seriously questioned the primacy or universal jurisdiction of the Holy See at Rome in matters of doctrine. The most he did was just rant and rave.
St.Cyprian did more than that: he ignored Rome’s ruling, and St.Stephen dropped the issue. Btw, Eusebius shows that St. Cyprian was also practiced in Alexandria and elsewhere IIRC. And St. Cyprian quite clearly saw it as an issue of doctrine, not just practice (which the Vatican claims it has the ultimate say anyways).
 
Pope Honorius never taught error. He lived as a solid churchman and died with his reputation intact. He was buried with honors in St. Peter’s basillica. It was not until 20 years after his death that his letters to Sergius became an issue. By that time, Pope Honorius’ attempt to prevent schism and keep the Monothelites in the Church was seen to have failed. His leniency had to be condemned. Show me one single Magisterial document in which the Catholic Church officially taught error in this case. There are none.

The letters to Sergius were not magisterial documents BY DESIGN. Pope Honorius was trying to keep the matter informal to avoid open conflict and possible schism.

Mickey’s chronic argument using the holy Pope Honorius against the Doctrine of Infallibility is a fraud.

The West never condemned holy Pope St. Honorius as a heretic.

My question to Micky: was the development of doctrine suddenly freeze dried at the end of the Seventh Ecumenical Council?
Doesn’t the Catholic Church accept the teaching of the third Council of Constantinople?

piar.hu/councils/ecum06.htm
 
The first bishop of Rome to try to flex his muscle was Victor, and he was “rebuked by the entire Church,” as Eusebius shows us (and no, Nicea did not endorse Rome calculation, but Alexandria.
*From the Greek text:

The bishops assembled at Nicea, who constitute the great and holy synod, greet the church of the Alexandrians, by the grace of God holy and great, and the beloved brethren in Egypt, Lybia, and Pentapolis…

“We also send you the good news of the settlement concerning the holy pasch*, namely that in answer to your prayers this question has also been resolved. **All the brethren of the East who have hitherto followed the Jewish practice will henceforth observe the custom of the Romans **and of yourselves and all of us who from ancient times have kept Easter together with you.”
The Letter of the Synod in Nicea to the Egyptians, Council of Nicea l (325 A.D.)

The holy fathers at the synod agreed that Easter, the Christian Pasch, should be celebrated on the Sunday following the first full moon (14 Nisan) after the vernal equinox. Thus the council endorsed that the Roman and Western custom of celebrating Easter should be embraced by all the Eastern churches.
The Pope never presided at an Ecumenical Council.
The universal primacy of the Bishop of Rome and the Chair of St. Peter were given recognition at the First Council of Nicea, although the pope did not officially preside. However, it is probable that the Emperor Constantine convoked the council in concert with Pope Sylvester l.

"The ancient customs of Egypt, Lybia, and Pentapolis shall be maintained, according to which the bishop of Alexandria has authority over all these places since a similar custom exists with reference to the bishop of Rome. Similar in Antioch and the other provinces the prerogatives of the churches shall be preserved."
Council if Nicea l, Canon 6

We see further recognition given to the primacy of the See of Rome in Constantinople, although the pope did not officially preside.The doctrinal decisions that were reached concurred with a tome that Pope Damasus and a Roman Council (c A.D. 378) had sent to the Eastern Church.
*
“The bishop of Constantinople shall have the primacy of honour after the bishop of Rome.”
Council of Constantinople 1, Canon 3 (381 A.D.)*

*In the words of Philip, legate of the Apostolic See of Rome at Ephesus:

“There is no doubt, and in fact it has been known in all ages, that the holy and most blessed Peter, prince and head of the apostles, pillar of the faith, and foundation of the Catholic Church, received the keys of the kingdom from our Lord Jesus Christ…and that to him was given the power of binding and loosing sins: who down even to today and forever both lives and judges his successors.”
Council of Ephesus, Acts, session 3 (431 A.D.)*

After Nestorius had been condemned already in a council at Rome, 11 August 430, he asked the emperor Theodosius ll to summon the council at Ephesus by an act of appeal. The emperor agreed to convoke it together with his co-emperor Valentinian lll and with the agreement of Pope Celestine l. After the two Roman legates arrived, they joined Cyril and confirmed the sentence that had been passed against him. Pope Celestine could just as well have presided there. 😉

At the Council of Chalcedon (451 A.D.) Bishop Paschasinus( a papal legate who presided together with a priest Boniface) stood in the presence of the holy fathers and said:

*“We received directions at the hands of the most blessed and apostolic bishop of the Roman city (Leo l), who is the head of all the churches, which directions say that Dioscorus is not to be allowed to sit in the present assembly, but that if he should attempt to take his seat, he is to be cast out. This instruction we must carry out.”
Acts of the Council, session 1

"After reading the foregoing epistle (The Tome of Pope St. Leo), the most reverend bishops cried out: ‘This is the faith of the fathers! This is the faith of the apostles! So we all believe! Thus the orthodox believe! Anathema to him who does not thus believe! Peter has spoken thus through Leo!’ "
Acts, session 2*

The Roman legates opposed Canon 28, and so the patriarch of Constantinople sought approval for the council from the pope, who ratified the doctrinal decrees on 21 March 453, but rejected Canon 28 since it ran counter to the canons of Nicea.

No point in going on. The pope began to physically preside, even though a legate or priest can, at the First Lateran Council in 1123 A.D… To preside I meant “to hold a position of fi authority” which is one way of defining the word. The pope’s authority was final.

To be continued.

PAX :harp:
 
If the early church didn’t practice papal infallibility and it did just come up 140 years ago, then what was the “job” of the Bishop of Rome for all the centuries after St. Peter? Did all those popes not speak Infallably on issues?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top