Infallible versus non-infallible

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Succintly is a word I did not know. Maybe you could write simplier words, so we do not have to look them up on bing to understand what they mean? I am always to the point and have been accused of being too brief in my answers, by many here.

I was agreeing with Brian.* I believe that* we are all Christ’s church regardless where we go. f one does not have Christ in ones heart it doesn’t matter cause the name on the door will not mean a thing.
**Your first mistake was *"***I believe that . . ."

**Doesn’t really matter what Tweetymom **believes. The truth is all that matters.
 
The Catholic Church did not compile the canon of Scripture and it is not error free. The Roman Catholic Church was still in its infancy by the time the canon was complete. The only thing the RCC did was close the canon at Carthage in 397.

If your magisterium insists that the canon of Scripture is inerrant, ask them to explain the genealogy in Luke’s Gospel.
 
**Your first mistake was *"***I believe that . . ."

**Doesn’t really matter what Tweetymom **believes. The truth is all that matters.
The first mistake is being rude, but then you always are so nothing new.God Bless you :thumbsup:anyway
 
The first mistake is being rude, but then you always are so nothing new.God Bless you :thumbsup:anyway
Nope.
Just a faithful Catholic admonishing an unruly one (1 Thess. 5:14).

**It’s a chief corporal work of mercy. **
Ummm . . . you should know that if you’re teaching RCIA . . .
 
The Catholic Church did not compile the canon of Scripture and it is not error free. The Roman Catholic Church was still in its infancy by the time the canon was complete. The only thing the RCC did was close the canon at Carthage in 397.

If your magisterium insists that the canon of Scripture is inerrant, ask them to explain the genealogy in Luke’s Gospel.
What difference does it make that the Church was still in it’s infancy at the time the canon was complete?? Of course it was. It was only about 360 years old.

Ummm . . . if the Catholic Church did not** compile the Canon of Scripture with the guidance of the Holy Spirit – who did? I eagerly await tour reply.
This ought to be
good
. :rolleyes:


As for your other point - the difference between Matthew’s and Luke genealogies does not invalidate the canon.
If inconsistencies invalidated the voracity of Scripture – you could spend all day picking the Bible apart for its alleged contradictions. However, this is a sophomoric approach – and an
** ignorant**** one.**

**There are ****several **theories going back to Augustine for the apparent differences in the two genealogies. Here are some of the more popular:

**One theory states that Joseph had two fathers—one who sired him and the other, a *****legal *****father due to levirate marriage involving uterine brothers. **

Another theory is that Matthew’s genealogy leaves out some names.

This brings us to the second theory that one of the genealogies is traced by using the legal line.

**Another popular theory is that ****Luke’s **genealogy is traced through Mary’s ancestry and not Joseph’s.

Similarly, the next theory leads us to the possibility that Matthew’s genealogy is traced using Mary’s ancestry.


ALL** of this is just further evidence that Sola Scriptura is a**** false**** doctrine because of Scripture’s apparent inconsistencies.

Lastly - why did you dodge my questions? Here they are again:
1. Tell me - why do you accept the man-made tradition of excluding the Deuterocanonicals?

  1. Secondly - if they were part of the Scriptures that Jesus studied and quoted from - by whose authority were they removed?
Since you expect a direct answer to all of your questions – pay the same courtesy by answering mine.
 
What difference does it make that the Church was still in it’s infancy at the time the canon was complete?? Of course it was. It was only about 360 years old.
The Roman Catholic Church didn’t exist prior to the Great Persecution, by then the canon was almost complete.
Ummm . . . if the Catholic Church did notcompile the Canon of Scripture with the guidance of the Holy Spirit – who did? I eagerly await tour reply.
This ought to be good.
The universal church – that’s the church Christ established, not the RCC.

What do you mean by “the guidance of the Holy Spirit”? Are you somehow able to show evidence that the Holy Spirit guided the formation of the canon?
As for your other point - the difference between Matthew’s and Luke genealogies does not invalidate the canon.
I didn’t say anything about the differences between those tow genealogies. Why did you assume I did?
If inconsistencies invalidated the voracity of Scripture – you could spend all day picking the Bible apart for its alleged contradictions. However, this is a sophomoric approach – and an ignorant one.
Then you should have no trouble explaining this.

**There is a discrepancy between the genealogy Luke recorded and the genealogy in the Hebrew record. It appears as though Luke used the Septuagint to gather information regarding the ancient genealogy, which does not agree with the genealogy in the Hebrew Old Testament. Since Bibles approved by the Catholic Church contain the Hebrew Old Testament, how do you explain this discrepancy in light of the claim that the Scriptures are free of error? **
Lastly - why did you dodge my questions? Here they are again:
  1. Tell me - why do you accept the man-made tradition of excluding the Deuterocanonicals?
  1. Secondly - if they were part of the Scriptures that Jesus studied and quoted from - by whose authority were they removed?
Since you expect a direct answer to all of your questions – pay the same courtesy by answering mine.
Why, you did not answer my question before? I asked you which VIRSION of the Bible is the inerrant one. You responded with, which CANON is the inerrant one. Nice try!

As far as your questions go, I don’t care what you include in your canon. I do not recognize any authority that put the deuterocanonical books in nor do I recognize any authority that took them back out. I do not care if they are there or not.
 
The Roman Catholic Church didn’t exist prior to the Great Persecution, by then the canon was almost complete.
This shows your ignorance of history.
All you need to do is read the Letter of Ignatius to the Smyrnaens to find the term Catholic church – an already established name being used for the body of Christ at the end of the 1st Century. Toss in some of the other Ante Nicene Fathers and you get what we have today - the Catholic Church:
The Martyrdom of Polycarp
“When finally he concluded his prayer, after remembering all who had at any time come his way – small folk and great folk, distinguished and undistinguished, and the whole Catholic Church throughout the world …”


Irenaeus
“The Catholic Church possesses one and the same faith throughout the whole world, as we have already said” (Against Heresies 1:10 A.D. 189]).


Tertullian
“… they at first were believers in the doctrine of the Catholic Church, in the church of Rome under the episcopate of the blessed Eleutherus (13th Pope), until on account of their ever restless curiosity, with which they even infected the brethren, they were more than once expelled” (On the Prescription Against Heretics 22,30 A.D.200])


Cyprian
“He who does not hold this unity, does not hold the law of God, does not hold the faith of the Father and the Son, does not hold life and salvation” (On the Unity of the Catholic Church 6) A.D. 251]).

The universal church – that’s the church Christ established, not the RCC.
Read the information above. Sorry, pal – your ignorance has been exposed by the Fathers.
What do you mean by “the guidance of the Holy Spirit”? Are you somehow able to show evidence that the Holy Spirit guided the formation of the canon?
Absolutely**. Jesus told the Apostles that the Holy Spirit would guide the Church to ALL truth about the things that were coming. Read John 16:12-15.**

For you to disagree with the fact that the canon was declared with the guidance of the Holy Spirit is to disagree with the likes of Protestant theologians such as R.C. Sproul, Norman Geisler, John Mac Arthur – and many other non-Catholic and anti-Catholic theologians. But, I guess YOU know better than they . . .
I didn’t say anything about the differences between those tow genealogies. Why did you assume I did?
You don’t read very closely, do you?
I posted no less than five popular theories as to why there are discrepancies to Matthew’s and Luke versions of the genealogy of Jesus. Maybe you should read it again . . .

Then you should have no trouble explaining this.There is a discrepancy between the genealogy Luke recorded and the genealogy in the Hebrew record. It appears as though Luke used the Septuagint to gather information regarding the ancient genealogy, which does not agree with the genealogy in the Hebrew Old Testament. Since Bibles approved by the Catholic Church contain the Hebrew Old Testament, how do you explain this discrepancy in light of the claim that the Scriptures are free of error?
As far as your questions go, I don’t care what you include in your canon. I do not recognize any authority that put the deuterocanonical books in nor do I recognize any authority that took them back out. I do not care if they are there or not.
Hmmm . . . a Lone Ranger Christian. Well – THAT’S also rejected by Scripture.
The Body of Christ has many parts but Lone Rangers aren‘t part of that Body.
Yet another tragedy of the Protestant Revolt – every man – and his interpretations/beliefs - for himself . . .
 
How could anyone possibly know that a teaching is infallible? You can believe it by an act of faith, but you can never know for sure. Even the people who claim to teach infallible doctrine cannot truly say those teachings are infallible.
As I understand it

If you apply the following formula with regards to faith and morals for the Church

(Emphasis mine)
:

"we declare and define that"…

the verb “define” has come to be used as a trigger word for infallible papal statements.
(This is not the only way in which he can do this, but it is the standard way.)
outside of that, the pope can make all sorts of statements that aren’t infallible.

For full context
jimmyakin.org/2004/06/two_instances_o.html
 
You don’t read very closely, do you?
I posted no less than five popular theories as to why there are discrepancies to Matthew’s and Luke versions of the genealogy of Jesus. Maybe you should read it again . . .
There was nothing ambiguous about my challenge; I made it perfectly clear I was not talking about the differences between the two genealogies. Let me state again what I said. This time I will emphasize the key phrases.

There is a discrepancy between the genealogy Luke recorded and the genealogy in the Hebrew record. It appears as though Luke used the Septuagint to gather information regarding the ancient genealogy, which does not agree with the genealogy in the Hebrew Old Testament. Since Bibles approved by the Catholic Church contain the Hebrew Old Testament, how do you explain this discrepancy in light of the claim that the Scriptures are free of error?
 
There was nothing ambiguous about my challenge; I made it perfectly clear I was not talking about the differences between the two genealogies. Let me state again what I said. This time I will emphasize the key phrases.

There is a discrepancy between the genealogy Luke recorded and the genealogy in the Hebrew record. It appears as though Luke used the Septuagint to gather information regarding the ancient genealogy, which does not agree with the genealogy in the Hebrew Old Testament. Since Bibles approved by the Catholic Church contain the Hebrew Old Testament, how do you explain this discrepancy in light of the claim that the Scriptures are free of error?
Again - one of the theories I presented was that the genealogy in Luke’s Gospel has many more names it it than Matthew’s, who seems to leave some out. This, coupled with the First popular theory I presented **regarding the possibility that Joseph had two fathers—one who sired him and the other, a legal father due to levirate marriage involving uterine brothers makes my point.

Does that finally register?
 
Again - one of the theories I presented was that the genealogy in Luke’s Gospel has many more names it it than Matthew’s, who seems to leave some out. This, coupled with the First popular theory I presented regarding the possibility that Joseph had two fathers—one who sired him and the other, a *legal *father due to levirate marriage involving uterine brothers makes my point.

Does that finally register?
Okay, as I suspected you have no clue what I am talking about so I will spell it out for you so that maybe you can understand.

From Luke’s genealogy:

… Eber, the son of Shelah the son of Cainan, the son of Arphaxad, the son of Shem, the son of Noah, the son of Lamech, (Luke 3:35-36)

From Genesis 10:24:

“And Arpachshad begat Shelah; and Shelah begat Eber.” (Hebrew Gen. 10:24)

Luke states that Shelea is the son of Cainan, who is the son of Arphaxad. But the Hebrew Old Testament says Shelea is the son of Arphaxad with no mentian of Cainan.

Both records cannot be correct, which proves your magisterium is not infallible when they say they are. Your magisterium is not telling you the truth.
 
Okay, as I suspected you have no clue what I am talking about so I will spell it out for you so that maybe you can understand.

From Luke’s genealogy:
… Eber, the son of Shelah the son of Cainan, the son of Arphaxad, the son of Shem, the son of Noah, the son of Lamech, (Luke 3:35-36)
From Genesis 10:24:
“And Arpachshad begat Shelah; and Shelah begat Eber.” (Hebrew Gen. 10:24)
Luke states that Shelea is the son of Cainan, who is the son of Arphaxad. But the Hebrew Old Testament says Shelea is the son of Arphaxad with no mentian of Cainan.

Both records cannot be correct, which proves your magisterium is not infallible when they say they are. Your magisterium is not telling you the truth.
This doesn’t nullify the inerrance of Scripture - it just intruduces a few possibilities.

**For example, in Gen. 14:14, Lot is called Abraham’s “brother”, even though he was the son of Haran, Abraham’s brother (Gen. 11:26–28). **
Were they siblings or Uncle and Nephew?

In Gen. 29:15, Jacob is referred to as the “brother” of his uncle Laban.

**Were they siblings or Uncle and Nephew?

****In 1 Chron. 23:21–22 Brothers Kish and Eleazar were the sons of Mahli. Kish had sons of his own, but Eleazar’s daughters married their “brethren,” the sons of Kish - who were actually their cousins. Were they cousins or siblings?

The answer to these 3 examples is the Aramaic word Ach, which means kinsman, brother or even neighbor and fellow countryman - but to the uneducated they are merely contradictions.

****Some of the accounts of the crucifixion show the mother of James and Joseph to be the wife of Clopas. In other verses of Scripture, the father of James and Joseph is Alphaeus. Which verse is wrong and which is right?

****The answer here may be twofold: Alphaeus may have had a Greek name change to clopas - similar to the Paul’s name change from Saul.

****So, if Luke was going by the Septuagint, there may have also been a Greek name change in the lineage that was rendered a certain way.

****What of the accounts of the death of Judas?
****In Matthew’s Gospel, it says he hanged himself. **In Acts, we read that he fell headlong and his insides burst open. Which version is a lie?
Answer: NEITHER. Many cases of hanging involve the head detaching from the body and the body falling to the ground. If Judas hung himself near a cliff or ravine - it may have happened exactly this way.
 
This doesn’t nullify the inerrance of Scripture - it just intruduces a few possibilities.

For example, in Gen. 14:14
, Lot is called Abraham’s “brother”, even though he was the son of Haran, Abraham’s brother (Gen. 11:26–28).
Were they siblings or Uncle and Nephew?

In Gen. 29:15
, Jacob is referred to as the “brother” of his uncle Laban.
**Were they siblings or Uncle and Nephew?

In 1 Chron. 23:21–22 Brothers Kish and Eleazar were the sons of Mahli. Kish had sons of his own, but Eleazar’s daughters married their “brethren,” the sons of Kish - who were actually their cousins. Were they cousins or siblings?
**
The answer to these 3 examples is the Aramaic word Ach
, which means kinsman, brother or even neighbor and fellow countryman - but to the uneducated they are merely contradictions.

Some of the accounts of the crucifixion show the mother of James and Joseph to be the wife of Clopas. In other verses of Scripture, the father of James and Joseph is Alphaeus. Which verse is wrong and which is right?

The answer here may be twofold: Alphaeus may have had a Greek name change to clopas - similar to the Paul’s name change from Saul.

So, if Luke was going by the Septuagint, there may have also been a Greek name change in the lineage that was rendered a certain way.

**What of the accounts of the death of Judas?
****In Matthew’s Gospel, it says he hanged **himself. In Acts, we read that he fell headlong and his insides burst open. Which version is a lie?
Answer: NEITHER. Many cases of hanging involve the head detaching from the body and the body falling to the ground. If Judas hung himself near a cliff or ravine - it may have happened exactly this way.
You are not going to explain away this discrepancy. The error is minor, but an error nonetheless. Nobody knows why, but the seventy translators of the Septuagint inserted Cainan into the genealogy. Your magisterium claims that the authors of the New Testament were guided in their writing by the Holy Spirit; and that may be true to a certain extent, it is not true to the extent of everything they wrote, such as Luke including the genealogy.

It is unreasonable to say Luke wrote the genealogy by divine revelation when it conflicts with the carefully guarded Hebrew Scriptures. But since we know that Luke’s genealogy agrees with the Greek Old Testament, we can confidently conclude that he copied the ancient portion of it from the Greek Scriptures (Septuagint).

So Luke copied the genealogy from records he could get his hands on, so what’s the big deal? Well, it’s no big deal until somebody, who claims to speak by divine revelation, tells you that he wrote it by divine revelation. Luke was proclaiming the gospel of Jesus Christ; where did he say his account was given by divine revelation?

“Since many have undertaken to compile a narrative of the events that have been fulfilled among us, just as those who were eyewitnesses from the beginning and ministers of the word have handed them down to us, I too have decided, after investigating everything accurately anew, to write it down in an orderly sequence for you, most excellent Theophilus, so that you may realize the certainty of the teachings you have received.” (Luke 1:1-4, NAB)
 
You are not going to explain away this discrepancy. The error is minor, but an error nonetheless. Nobody knows why, but the seventy translators of the Septuagint inserted Cainan into the genealogy. Your magisterium claims that the authors of the New Testament were guided in their writing by the Holy Spirit; and that may be true to a certain extent, it is not true to the extent of everything they wrote, such as Luke including the genealogy.

It is unreasonable to say Luke wrote the genealogy by divine revelation when it conflicts with the carefully guarded Hebrew Scriptures. But since we know that Luke’s genealogy agrees with the Greek Old Testament, we can confidently conclude that he copied the ancient portion of it from the Greek Scriptures (Septuagint).

So Luke copied the genealogy from records he could get his hands on, so what’s the big deal? Well, it’s no big deal until somebody, who claims to speak by divine revelation, tells you that he wrote it by divine revelation. Luke was proclaiming the gospel of Jesus Christ; where did he say his account was given by divine revelation?

“Since many have undertaken to compile a narrative of the events that have been fulfilled among us, just as those who were eyewitnesses from the beginning and ministers of the word have handed them down to us, I too have decided, after investigating everything accurately anew, to write it down in an orderly sequence for you, most excellent Theophilus, so that you may realize the certainty of the teachings you have received.” (Luke 1:1-4, NAB)
So are you saying the book of Luke isn’t inspired?
 
66. The father of Salah was Arphaxad Gen 11:12]
The father of Salah was Cainan Luke 3:35,36]

To me, this looks like a legitimate contradiction, although I suppose it is possible that this is the same person known by different names. After all, it is not uncommon for Biblical personages to have more than one name.
67. There were fourteen generations from Abraham to David Matt 1:17]
There were but thirteen generations from Abraham to David Matt 1:2-6]

68. There were fourteen generations from the Babylonian captivity to Christ Matt 1:17]

There were but thirteen generations from the Babylonian captivity to Christ Matt 1:12-16]

(Matt. 1:17) "This genealogy is divided into three ages:
(1) from Abraham until David, fourteen generations, the age before the establishing of the kingdom;
(2) from David until the deportation to Babylon, fourteen generations, the age of the kingdom;
(3) from the deportation to Babylon until the Christ, again fourteen generations, the age after the fall of the kingdom.

According to history, there were actually forty-five generations. By deducting from these generations the three cursed generations Matt 1:8; 1 Chron 3:11-12; 2 Kings 15:1, 13; 2 Chron. 21:5-6; 22:1-4; Exod 20:5] and the one improper generation Matt 1:11; 1 Chron 3:15-16; 2 Kings 23:34-35], and then adding one by making David two generations (one, the age before the establishing of the kingdom, and the other, the age of the kingdom), the generations total forty-two, being divided into three ages of fourteen generations each.

It’s simply a matter of how you count. In other words, you can count it as fourteen generations first by extending from Abraham to David; secondly, by extending from David to the deportation; and thirdly, by extending from Jechonias to Christ, inclusive in each case.
Now run along and scrape up some other meaningless attack gleaned from those stupid hate sites you frequent.
 
You are not going to explain away this discrepancy. The error is minor, but an error nonetheless. Nobody knows why, but the seventy translators of the Septuagint inserted Cainan into the genealogy. Your magisterium claims that the authors of the New Testament were guided in their writing by the Holy Spirit; and that may be true to a certain extent, it is not true to the extent of everything they wrote, such as Luke including the genealogy.

It is unreasonable to say Luke wrote the genealogy by divine revelation when it conflicts with the carefully guarded Hebrew Scriptures. But since we know that Luke’s genealogy agrees with the Greek Old Testament, we can confidently conclude that he copied the ancient portion of it from the Greek Scriptures (Septuagint).

So Luke copied the genealogy from records he could get his hands on, so what’s the big deal? Well, it’s no big deal until somebody, who claims to speak by divine revelation, tells you that he wrote it by divine revelation. Luke was proclaiming the gospel of Jesus Christ; where did he say his account was given by divine revelation?
“Since many have undertaken to compile a narrative of the events that have been fulfilled among us, just as those who were eyewitnesses from the beginning and ministers of the word have handed them down to us, I too have decided, after investigating everything accurately anew, to write it down in an orderly sequence for you, most excellent Theophilus, so that you may realize the certainty of the teachings you have received.” (Luke 1:1-4, NAB)
Im’ not? I just did - along with Kepha1.

So your angle is that the Scriptures are a fraud - and, ergo, so is the Catholic Church?
Is that what you’re saying?
You’ve been all over the board on this topic and I’m trying to figure out just what you’re trying to say. God knows it isn’t easy debating with somebody who is both cryptic and ineloquent.
 
Im’ not? I just did - along with Kepha1.

So your angle is that the Scriptures are a fraud - and, ergo, so is the Catholic Church?
Is that what you’re saying?
You’ve been all over the board on this topic and I’m trying to figure out just what you’re trying to say. God knows it isn’t easy debating with somebody who is both cryptic and ineloquent.
:hmmm:
 
Im’ not? I just did - along with Kepha1.

So your angle is that the Scriptures are a fraud - and, ergo, so is the Catholic Church?
Is that what you’re saying?
You’ve been all over the board on this topic and I’m trying to figure out just what you’re trying to say. God knows it isn’t easy debating with somebody who is both cryptic and ineloquent.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who thought that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top