Infallible versus non-infallible

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Im’ not? I just did - along with Kepha1.

So your angle is that the Scriptures are a fraud - and, ergo, so is the Catholic Church?
Is that what you’re saying?
You’ve been all over the board on this topic and I’m trying to figure out just what you’re trying to say. God knows it isn’t easy debating with somebody who is both cryptic and ineloquent.
That is ridiculous! The preaching of the apostles was certainly inspired, but you cannot transfer that divine inspiration to every word committed to writing; Luke’s genealogy is an example of that. Luke committed to writing what was handed down to him by Paul and perhaps others. He was also an eyewitness himself to Paul’s preaching of the Gospel.

He said he investigated everything anew and then committed it to writing. If he was infallibly guided through his Gospel account by the Holy Spirit, he would not have said he investigated it anew. He committed to writing the divinely inspired testimonies of the apostles in his own words and with his own additions.

You cannot tell me that Luke received from the Holy Spirit a genealogy that differs from the Hebrew Old Testament; he copied the ancient genealogy from the Septuagint.
 
That is ridiculous! The preaching of the apostles was certainly inspired, but you cannot transfer that divine inspiration to every word committed to writing; Luke’s genealogy is an example of that. Luke committed to writing what was handed down to him by Paul and perhaps others. He was also an eyewitness himself to Paul’s preaching of the Gospel.

He said he investigated everything anew and then committed it to writing. If he was infallibly guided through his Gospel account by the Holy Spirit, he would not have said he investigated it anew. He committed to writing the divinely inspired testimonies of the apostles in his own words and with his own additions.

You cannot tell me that Luke received from the Holy Spirit a genealogy that differs from the Hebrew Old Testament; he copied the ancient genealogy from the Septuagint.
**Tell me something - I know that is a stretch because you haven’t answered or even attempted to answer one single question yet, but here goes:
Do you adhere to Sola Scriptura?

Also - what is your religious affiliation (denomination)?
 
Good** - you seem to be learning. **
To recap, we have learned that the Scriptures implicitly teach about the Holy Trinity - and the Church declares it doctrine**.**
This is precisely what I said:
canon came from the Church, led by the Holy Spirit (John 16:12-15
) and short of six few books that prideful, rebellious men threw out some 1500 years later - it is the very canon YOU adhere to.
I’ll rephrase it for you:
**You adhere to the very canon declared by the Catholic Church - *except ***for the fact that you follow a man-made tradition that removed six books of the Old Testament.
**As a matter of fact, had it not been for his contemporaries, Luther would have removed Hebrews, James, Jude, and **Revelation as well.

The Bible has 73 books. Ironically, the Deuterocanonicals, which Protestants reject, were books that were studied by Jesus and the Apostles. In short - Catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did.

**We know this because there are over 100 **NT references to these books from the Septuagint. Here are a few for you to chew on:

Matt. 2:16 - Herod’s decree of slaying innocent children was prophesied in Wis. 11:7 - slaying the holy innocents.

**Matt. 7:12 ****- Jesus’ golden rule “do unto others” is the converse of ****Tobit 4:15 ****- what you hate, do not do to others. **

**Luke 21:24 ****- Jesus’ usage of “fall by the edge of the sword” follows Sirach 28:18. **

**1 Cor. 2:16 ****- Paul’s question, “who has known the mind of the Lord?” references Wisdom 9:13. **

**1 Cor. 10:20 ****- what pagans sacrifice they offer to demons and not to God refers to Baruch 4:7. **

**Matt. 7:16,20 ****- Jesus’ statement “you will know them by their fruits” follows ****Sirach 27:6 **- the fruit discloses the cultivation.
40.png
Elvisman:
Ironically, the Deuterocanonicals, which Protestants reject, were books that were studied by Jesus and the Apostles. In short - Catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did
.

You have no basis for your claim that “Catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did”. The truth is that we do not know how many different versions of the septuagint existed in the 1st century nor do we know exactly which books were included. You have way overstated your case.

As for your list you should read the gospel of Matthew and see where Matthew and the Holy Spirit say the prophecy regarding the slaying of the innocents comes from. I’ll give you a hint…it ain’t any of the deuterocanonicals.

The fact is that there is no single quote or reference anywhere in scripture from the deutero’s that would lead one to believe that they are inspired.
 
You have no basis for your claim that “Catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did”. The truth is that we do not know how many different versions of the septuagint existed in the 1st century nor do we know exactly which books were included. You have way overstated your case.

As for your list you should read the gospel of Matthew and see where Matthew and the Holy Spirit say the prophecy regarding the slaying of the innocents comes from. I’ll give you a hint…it ain’t any of the deuterocanonicals.

The fact is that there is no single quote or reference anywhere in scripture from the deutero’s that would lead one to believe that they are inspired.
Gee, ummm, I have dozens more quotes that prove the validity of the Deuteros. That’s the problem with some of you guys - no matter how much proof is thrown in your face - you’ll still deny the truth.
Jesus spoke WELL of you when he said:


John 6:63-65
**“It is the spirit that gives life, while the flesh is of no avail. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life. *****But there are some of you who do not believe.*” Jesus knew from the beginning the ones who would not believe and the one who would betray him. **
**And he said, “For this reason I have told you that no one can come to me unless it is granted him by my Father.” **

"The proof is in the pudding", as they say. Well - here’s some more of the pudding, my spiritually prideful friend:
James 5:3
** - describing silver which rusts and laying up treasure follows Sirach 29:10-11. **
1 Peter 1:6-7** - Peter teaches about testing faith by purgatorial fire as described in Wisdom 3:5-6 and Sirach 2:5. **
Rev. 2:12** - reference to the two-edged sword is similar to the description of God’s Word in Wisdom 18:16. **
Rev. 5:7** - God is described as seated on His throne, and this is the same description used in Sirach 1:8. **
Rev. 8:3-4** - prayers of the saints presented to God by the hand of an angel follows Tobit 12:12,15. **
Rev. 8:7** - raining of hail and fire to the earth follows Wisdom 16:22 and Sirach 39:29. **
Rev. 9:3 - raining of locusts on the earth follows Wisdom 16:9. **
Rev. 11:19
- the vision of the ark of the covenant (Mary) in a cloud of glory was prophesied in 2 Macc. 2:7. **
Rev. 17:14** - description of God as King of kings follows 2 Macc. 13:4. **
Rev. 19:1** - the cry “Hallelujah” at the coming of the new Jerusalem follows Tobit 13:18. **
 
Gee, ummm, I have dozens more quotes that prove the validity of the Deuteros. That’s the problem with some of you guys - no matter how much proof is thrown in your face - you’ll still deny the truth.
Jesus spoke WELL of you when he said:

John 6:63-65
**“It is the spirit that gives life, while the flesh is of no avail. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life. **But there are some of you who do not believe.” Jesus knew from the beginning the ones who would not believe and the one who would betray him.
And he said, "For this reason I have told you that no one can come to me unless it is granted him by my Father."

"The proof is in the pudding", as they say. Well - here’s some more of the pudding, my spiritually prideful friend:
James 5:3** - describing silver which rusts and laying up treasure follows Sirach 29:10-11**.
1 Peter 1:6-7** - Peter teaches about testing faith by purgatorial fire as described in Wisdom 3:5-6 and Sirach 2:5**.
Rev. 2:12** - reference to the two-edged sword is similar to the description of God’s Word in Wisdom 18:16**.
Rev. 5:7** - God is described as seated on His throne, and this is the same description used in Sirach 1:8**.
Rev. 8:3-4** - prayers of the saints presented to God by the hand of an angel follows Tobit 12:12,15**.
Rev. 8:7** - raining of hail and fire to the earth follows Wisdom 16:22** and Sirach 39:29.
Rev. 9:3 - raining of locusts on the earth follows Wisdom 16:9.
Rev. 11:19** - the vision of the ark of the covenant (Mary) in a cloud of glory was prophesied in 2 Macc. 2:7**.
Rev. 17:14** - description of God as King of kings follows 2 Macc. 13:4**.
Rev. 19:1** - the cry “Hallelujah” at the coming of the new Jerusalem follows Tobit 13:18**.
Gee…ummm you didn’t even take the time to defend the “supposed” reference to Wisdom in Matthew.

You are grossly overstating your case for the deutero’s.

There is not a single quote that would lead anyone to believe the dc’s are inspired. If you disagree please provide what you believe to be the strongest quote or reference that you believe demonstrates the canonocity of the deutero’s.

Also you should retract your claim that catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did since you have no way of knowing or demonstrating that your claim is true.

While I don’t appreciate your use of scripture as a weapon to insult me it’s pretty typical of your posts.
 
Gee…ummm you didn’t even take the time to defend the “supposed” reference to Wisdom in Matthew.

You are grossly overstating your case for the deutero’s.

There is not a single quote that would lead anyone to believe the dc’s are inspired. If you disagree please provide what you believe to be the strongest quote or reference that you believe demonstrates the canonocity of the deutero’s.

Also you should retract your claim that catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did since you have no way of knowing or demonstrating that your claim is true.

While I don’t appreciate your use of scripture as a weapon to insult me it’s pretty typical of your posts.
👍
 
Hey Elvisman,

Earlier you posted, and I quote,
40.png
Elvisman:
Matt. 2:16 - Herod’s decree of slaying innocent children was prophesied in Wis. 11:7 - slaying the holy innocents.
While you and some other catholic e-pologists may make this claim I think I will side with Matthew and the Holy Spirit who wrote, and I quote,
Matthew as inspired by the Holy Spirit:
16When Herod realized that he had been outwitted by the Magi, he was furious, and he gave orders to kill all the boys in Bethlehem and its vicinity who were two years old and under, in accordance with the time he had learned from the Magi. ***17Then what was said through the prophet Jeremiah was fulfilled: *** 18"A voice is heard in Ramah,
weeping and great mourning,
Rachel weeping for her children
and refusing to be comforted,
because they are no more."[g]
Jeremiah…or Wisdom???

I would guess most reasonable folks, catholic or otherwise, would give the nod to Jeremiah.

Again, you are overstating your case for the canonocity of the deutero’s.

Elvis has left the building…
 
Hey Elvisman,

Earlier you posted, and I quote,

While you and some other catholic e-pologists may make this claim I think I will side with Matthew and the Holy Spirit who wrote, and I quote,

Jeremiah…or Wisdom???

I would guess most reasonable folks, catholic or otherwise, would give the nod to Jeremiah.

Again, you are overstating your case for the canonocity of the deutero’s.

Elvis has left the building…
:clapping:
 
Hey Elvisman,

Earlier you posted, and I quote,

While you and some other catholic e-pologists may make this claim I think I will side with Matthew and the Holy Spirit who wrote, and I quote,

Jeremiah…or Wisdom???

I would guess most reasonable folks, catholic or otherwise, would give the nod to Jeremiah.

Again, you are overstating your case for the canonocity of the deutero’s.

Elvis has left the building…
Oh, Semper - so simple yet your anger only serves to complicate.

Jeremiah’s prophecy doesn’t "out-do" or nullify the Prophecy in Wisdom. If anything - it supports and cements the fact that the Wisdom prohecy is inspired as well.


**Now - please address the dozen or so OTHER cross-references that I provided you with.
I can’t wait to see what you come up with . . .🍿
 
The last Ecumenical council was in Nicea (787).
There were many dissenting bishops. 😉

Pius IX pushed it through without them.
No, Pope Pius IX did not push it through by himself. It was hotly debated, but in the end it was the majority of Bishops along with the Bishop of Rome.

And yes, we need to be careful of semantics when referring to Councils. Most Christians would agree that the first 7 Councils were ecumenical, and the Catholic Church accordingly also refers to subsequent councils also as “general” (although still from Her perspective in a sense ecumenical).
 
I always had a problem with the fact that in the 19th century, a Pope (Pius IX) decided to infallibly declare that the Pope of Rome speaks infallibly when speaking on matters of faith and morals ex-catherdra. :hmmm:
It wasn’t a teaching of the Pope by himself, and whether or not the teaching is one that’s taught infallibly is a matter of opinion.
 
The Catholic Church did not compile the canon of Scripture and it is not error free. The Roman Catholic Church was still in its infancy by the time the canon was complete. The only thing the RCC did was close the canon at Carthage in 397.

If your magisterium insists that the canon of Scripture is inerrant, ask them to explain the genealogy in Luke’s Gospel.
Fortunately, the Catholic Church doesn’t teach simply that Scripture is inerrant. If you want to know what the Catholic Church teaches about Scripture a good place to start would be the Catechism of the Catholic Church para 101-141.

\http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/p1s1c2a3.htm
 
Oh, Semper - so simple yet your anger only serves to complicate.

Jeremiah’s prophecy doesn’t "out-do" or nullify the Prophecy in Wisdom. If anything - it supports and cements the fact that the Wisdom prohecy is inspired as well.

Now - please address the dozen or so OTHER cross-references that I provided you with.
I can’t *wait *to see what you come up with . . .🍿
Well, it is simple. You went over to scripturecatholic or some other nefarious web site and pulled a list off of it a list that has been debunked, rebutted, and dissed many times on this forum. So many times that at leas some reasonable catholics have abandoned using it as an apologetics tool.

Concerning the slaying of the innocents that is supposedly prophesied in Wisdom it’s tellig that you discount what Matthew EXPLICITY writes concerning the origin of the prophecy. So, why don’t you post the text from Wisdom and explain it’s context for us. This should be easy for you to do since you apparently know more than both Matthew and the Holy Spirit and ignore, not an implicit statement but an EXPLICIT statement.

Once we put this one behind us I would like of you to post the one, single quote or allusion that makes you believe proves your point that the detuero’s are canonical.

As for the dozens of supposed references or allusions…c’mon. The first one I saw you provide (Matthew - Widsom) is stretching it why should I waste my time on a wild goose chase I alaready have engaged in before. Also, my statement is that I don’t believe there is even one quote or allusion that would lead someone to believe the canonocity of the dc’s.

Just provide the one quote or allusion which you believe best establishes the dc’s canonocity. All you need is one and we will discuss it. If you want I’ll pick one more of your so called quotes or allusions that supposedly establishes the dc’s canonocity and dispatch it if you will abandon this silly list of yours.

By the way you have yet to substantiate your claim that that you study the same OT that Jesus used.

Why don’t you either retract that claim or admit that you (or no one else) can substantiate the claim.
 
No, Pope Pius IX did not push it through by himself. It was hotly debated, but in the end it was the majority of Bishops along with the Bishop of Rome.
As early as January 1870, at the initiative of Bishops Martin and Senestre a petition was sent to the pope; it immediately received the support of the majority of the Council members and thus anticipated the decision before any discussion on the subject. The petition asked for the proclamation of the pope’s supreme and infallible authority in matters of faith. Forty-six Council members from Austria-Hungary and Germany immediately sent a counter-petition, asking not to submit this subject for discussion; they were joined by 38 French, 27 American, 17 Eastern and 7 Italian bishops.
(The Vatican dogma)


The collection of written protests against the dogma of papal infallibility shows how strong was the opposition to it. Sixty-one members wrote that the proposed dogma should be withdrawn and some gave decisive dogmatic and canonic reasons for this; fourteen said that the subject required further investigation; others regarded the proposed dogma as a self-contradictory innovation likely to lead to schism; only 56 were more or less in favour of it.
(The Vatican dogma)
 
Also, my statement is that I don’t believe there is even one quote or allusion that would lead someone to believe the canonocity of the dc’s.
The so-called Apocrypha, or Deuterocanonical, books (found in “Catholic” and “Orthodox” versions of the Bible) were a problem for Jews living after the time of Christ, since they often very clearly prophesy concerning Our Lord, and indicate His divinity.
Some of the books were also problematic for both the Jews and the Protestants because they make prophetically evident the special role of the Theotokos in the oikonomia of salvation. In fact, the Orthodox Fathers cite passages quite effectively to discuss the Church’s understanding of the role of the Theotokos.
Also, the only scriptural reference to praying for the dead is found in a Deuterocanonical Book: viz., Maccabees.
Not surprisingly, these Apocryphal/Deuterocanonical books were rejected from the “canon” of books indicated in the Jewish Scriptures. This canon was formally pronounced by a rabbinical council at Jamnia (c. 100 AD), which stated that all canonical Scripture had to have been written: in Palestine, in Hebrew (not Greek), and more then 400 years prior (300 BC) to that time.
In addition, the authorized Hebrew “translation” was at variance with the accepted Septuagint Greek versions, which had been prepared by 72 translators working in Alexandria Egypt.
This is significant, because the Apostles, who were the authors of the New Testament, as well as the early Church Fathers, frequently cite passages only found in the Septuagint (Greek) Old Testament that have significant differences in meaning from the Hebrew. Moreover, they frequently cite passages from the “Apocryphal” books of the Old Testament.
Compiled by Father Demetrios Serfes
 
Well, it is simple. You went over to scripturecatholic or some other nefarious web site and pulled a list off of it a list that has been debunked, rebutted, and dissed many times on this forum. So many times that at leas some reasonable catholics have abandoned using it as an apologetics tool.

Concerning the slaying of the innocents that is supposedly prophesied in Wisdom it’s tellig that you discount what Matthew EXPLICITY writes concerning the origin of the prophecy. So, why don’t you post the text from Wisdom and explain it’s context for us. This should be easy for you to do since you apparently know more than both Matthew and the Holy Spirit and ignore, not an implicit statement but an EXPLICIT statement.

Once we put this one behind us I would like of you to post the one, single quote or allusion that makes you believe proves your point that the detuero’s are canonical.

As for the dozens of supposed references or allusions…c’mon. The first one I saw you provide (Matthew - Widsom) is stretching it why should I waste my time on a wild goose chase I alaready have engaged in before. Also, my statement is that I don’t believe there is even one quote or allusion that would lead someone to believe the canonocity of the dc’s.

Just provide the one quote or allusion which you believe best establishes the dc’s canonocity. All you need is one and we will discuss it. If you want I’ll pick one more of your so called quotes or allusions that supposedly establishes the dc’s canonocity and dispatch it if you will abandon this silly list of yours.

By the way you have yet to substantiate your claim that that you study the same OT that Jesus used.

Why don’t you either retract that claim or admit that you (or no one else) can substantiate the claim.
Just as I thought. You won’t even*** attempt ***to disprove the list because you can’t.
If the verses have been “debunked” so many time on this form, as you say – then you should be able to debunk them for me now. I was a part of many of those threads and nothing was debunked – just dis-believed.


Remember – the simple fact that a Protestant suffers from spiritual pride and refuses to believe in the Word of God – doe NOT deem the Word of God, “debunked”.

PS –** I don’t discount anything about Matthew’s reference to Jeremiah’s prophecy - it is completely harmonious with the prophecy in Wisdom.👍**
 
Just as I thought. You won’t even*** attempt ***to disprove the list because you can’t.
If the verses have been “debunked” so many time on this form, as you say – then you should be able to debunk them for me now. I was a part of many of those threads and nothing
was debunked – just dis-believed.

Remember – the simple fact that a Protestant suffers from spiritual pride and refuses to believe in the Word of God – doe NOT deem the Word of God, “debunked”.

PS –** I don’t discount anything about Matthew’s reference to Jeremiah’s prophecy - it is completely harmonious with the prophecy in Wisdom.👍**
Please post the prophecy from Wisdom for us and explain how this is the prophecy of Matthew 2:16. I don’t see it and it would be very illuminating for all of us to see why you think that it support your position…especially since Matthew explicitly tells us where the prophecy comes from and it ain’t Wisdom.

You are right, I am not wading through a list that fails the sniff test from the get go. If you believe there is a deuterocanonical quote or allusion contained within the pages of the NT that establishes the canonocity of at least that one deutero, please post it for us to examine.

BTW, you still haven’t defended or retracted your claim that Catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did.
 
Please post the prophecy from Wisdom for us and explain how this is the prophecy of Matthew 2:16. I don’t see it and it would be very illuminating for all of us to see why you think that it support your position…especially since Matthew explicitly tells us where the prophecy comes from and it ain’t Wisdom.

You are right, I am not wading through a list that fails the sniff test from the get go. If you believe there is a deuterocanonical quote or allusion contained within the pages of the NT that establishes the canonocity of at least that one deutero, please post it for us to examine.

BTW, you still haven’t defended or retracted your claim that Catholics study from the same OT that Jesus did.
**As I’ve already stated – ad nauseam – the prophecies support one another. **

And – again – you won’t try to debunk any of the other prophecies from the Deuteros because you can’t refute them.
You SAY that they’ve been debunked but you have no evidence whatsoever to bolster your claim.

As usual – empty barrels make the most noise . . . :rolleyes:
 
As I’ve already stated – ad nauseam – the prophecies support one another.

*And – again ***– you won’t try to debunk any of the other prophecies from the Deuteros because you can’t refute them.
You SAY that they’ve been debunked but you have no evidence whatsoever to bolster your claim.

As usual – empty barrels make the most noise . . . :rolleyes:
:hmmm:
 
As I’ve already stated – ad nauseam – the prophecies support one another.

*And – again ***– you won’t try to debunk any of the other prophecies from the Deuteros because you can’t refute them.
You SAY that they’ve been debunked but you have no evidence whatsoever to bolster your claim.

As usual – empty barrels make the most noise . . . :rolleyes:
Go to the book of Wisdom and read the supposed prophecy. In context, it has NOTHING, NADA, ZERO, ZILCH to do with the slaying of the innocents.

Context is important.

Here is the whole Wisdom chapter in question from drbo.org
40.png
Wisdom:
Other benefits of wisdom to the people of God.

1 She prospered their works in the hands of the holy prophet. 2 They went through wildernesses that were not inhabited, and in desert places they pitched their tents. 3 They stood against their enemies, and revenged themselves of their adversaries. 4 They were thirsty, and they called upon thee, and water was given them out of the high rock, and a refreshment of their thirst out of the hard stone. 5 For by what things their enemies were punished, when their drink failed them, while the children of Israel abounded therewith and rejoiced:

1 “The holy prophet”… Moses.

3 “Their enemies”… The Amalecites.

5 “By what things”… The meaning is, that God, who wrought a miracle to punish the Egyptians by thirst, when he turned all their waters into blood, (at which time the Israelites, who were exempt from those plagues, had plenty of water,) wrought another miracle in favour of his own people in their thirst, by giving them water out of the rock.

6 By the same things they in their need were benefited. 7 For instead of a fountain of an ever running river, thou gavest human blood to the unjust. 8 And whilst they were diminished for a manifest reproof of their murdering the infants, thou gavest to thine abundant water unlooked for: 9 shewing by the thirst that was then, how thou didst exalt thine, and didst kill their adversaries. 10 For when they were tried, and chastised with mercy, they knew how the wicked were judged with wrath and tormented.

11 For thou didst admonish and try them as a father: but the others, as a severe king, thou didst examine and condemn. 12 For whether absent or present, they were tormented alike. 13 For a double affliction came upon them, and a groaning for the remembrance of things past. 14 For when they heard that by their punishments the others were benefited, they remembered the Lord, wondering at the end of what was come to pass. 15 For whom they scorned before, when he was thrown out at the time of his being wickedly exposed to perish, him they admired in the end, when they saw the event: their thirsting being unlike to that of the just.

14 “By their punishments”… That is, that the Israelites had been benefited and miraculously favoured in the same kind, in which they had been punished.

16 But for the foolish devices of their iniquity, because some being deceived worshipped dumb serpents and worthless beasts, thou didst send upon them a multitude of dumb beasts for vengeance. 17 That they might know that by what things a man sinneth, by the same also he is tormented. 18 For thy almighty hand, which made the world of matter without form, was not unable to send upon them a multitude of bears, or fierce lions, 19 Or unknown beasts of a new kind, full of rage: either breathing out a fiery vapour, or sending forth a stinking smoke, or shooting horrible sparks out of their eyes: 20 Whereof not only the hurt might be able to destroy them, but also the very sight might kill them through fear.

16 “Dumb beasts”… Viz., frogs, sciniphs, flies, and locusts.

21 Yea and without these, they might have been slain with one blast, persecuted by their own deeds, and scattered by the breath of thy power: but thou hast ordered all things in measure, and number, and weight. 22 For great power always belonged to thee alone: and who shall resist the strength of thy arm? 23 For the whole world before thee is as the least grain of the balance, and as a drop of the morning dew, that falleth down upon the earth: 24 But thou hast mercy upon all, because thou canst do all things, and overlookest the sins of men for the sake of repentance. 25 For thou lovest all things that are, and hatest none of the things which thou hast made: for thou didst not appoint, or make any thing hating it.

26 And how could any thing endure, if thou wouldst not? or be preserved, if not called by thee. 27 But thou sparest all: because they are thine, O Lord, who lovest souls.
I know this is going to be hard for you to follow but when read in context this has nothing to do with the slaying of innocents. You do see that don’t you? That coupled with Matthew explicitly telling us where the slaying of the innocents was prophesied would lead most folks to concluded that it was not the book of Wisdom. But you, the Bishop of Denial insist otherwise.

Earlier you made a claim that Catholics study the same OT that Jesus used and have made no effort to back this claim up…I am guessing because you know you can’t.

I challenge the first allusion/quote that I see from you and you don’t make an effort to defend it. Again I assume it’s because you know that you can’t defend the indefensible.

Anyway, what is the one single best illustration of a NT quote/allusion of the deuterocanonical book that would lead someone to believe at least that one deutero is inspired. It surely isn’t the supposed Matthew-Wisdome slaying of the innocents is it?

Just post the best single quote/allusion that demonstrates your point. I’m sure there has to be something better than what you have posted thus far.

C’mon…I know you can do better than you have so far…or at least I hope you can.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top