A
Avdima
Guest
I would hate to call any country that locks up and murders innocent people Christan .The US is the only Christian/Catholic country in the world that still carries out executions
I would hate to call any country that locks up and murders innocent people Christan .The US is the only Christian/Catholic country in the world that still carries out executions
I think that if we know there is a chance of error and we confidently push capital punishment where the Church itself states that it is unnecessary in most cases we are possibly helping to send innocent people to death. Never mind that the death penalty has not been shown to be a deterrent or at least the information points both ways.What is the moral choice we face? If you and I both try to do the right thing but choose opposite solutions, has either of us sinned?, because if there is no sin involved then there is no moral choice.
The Church is CURRENTLY addressing it thus.I think it is anything but clear, and becomes significantly less so as you reckon with two millennia of teaching on the subject. The church did not suddenly address this subject in 1995.
Actually the Churchâs position is based also on natural law and philosophy; tradition and the Holy Scriptures. Reason is also important as St Thomas Aquinas uses reason to prove the existence of God and moral rules - oughts, and whatâs moral and whatâs not. Social science and other sciences are part of reason and can reveal certain things we did not know before or if the situation has changed. That can help us determine the natural ends of things and help illuminate moral questions.The churchâs position is based on revelation, not social science.
The death penalty was handed out for more than just murder in the past.I understand this is what is alleged, but I donât think it is accurate. Older societies seemed to have little trouble keeping people imprisoned in galleys or in mines. Iâm pretty sure they werenât ordering murders from prisons like they are doing today.
No-one said it should be blanket and I already pointed out that itâs in case of regret and promise to change. Jesus told the sinful woman to go and sin no more. She was not executed. However, He did not say, âyouâre off, carry on doing what youâre doingâ - and of course mercy should be provisional to that. However, we donât see much of that. When was a murderer who genuinely regretted their actions let off with a âdonât do it againâ?I think a case can be made for mercy in some instances, but not as a blanket application. Also, forgiveness and contrition do not eliminate the necessity of punishment.
These issues are still moral issues.The church has always recognized prudential reasons for not applying the death penalty. If 2267 is understood as prudential then there is no conflict with her traditional teaching. It is only if 2267 is taken as new doctrine that there is a problem.
Murder has to do with the deliberate killing of an innocent person - deliberate and innocent being equally important. The execution of an innocent person, assuming there was no venality involved in arriving at the sentence, would be a tragedy; it would not be murder. Nor is it murder when someone kills in a legitimate attempt to safeguard his own life or the lives of others. Finally, for one soldier to kill an enemy soldier is another act of killing that is justified and is not murder. Calling an execution a murder doesnât change what it really is any more than calling a tail a leg means a dog has five legs.I would hate to call any country that locks up and murders innocent people Christan .![]()
2267 Assuming that the guilty partyâs identity and responsibility have been fully determined, the traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor.I asked a specific question that your response did not address:
*If capital punishment is truly disrespectful of human life, why does the church allow it even theoretically?
*Ender
Execution ends life and for no reason I see of moral value to validate it being called justice in this paradigm. Its injustice, thus murder called legal execution=justice. Thats only to make it palatable. The point of contention. Safeguarding our life isnât part of the equation of one arrested and incarcerated. Life is safeguarded by this reality of incarceration. And they are alive to atone.Murder has to do with the deliberate killing of an innocent person - deliberate and innocent being equally important. The execution of an innocent person, assuming there was no venality involved in arriving at the sentence, would be a tragedy; it would not be murder. Nor is it murder when someone kills in a legitimate attempt to safeguard his own life or the lives of others. Finally, for one soldier to kill an enemy soldier is another act of killing that is justified and is not murder. Calling an execution a murder doesnât change what it really is any more than calling a tail a leg means a dog has five legs.
Ender
Not to mention that is comes squarely under the heading âLegitimate Defenseâ.2267 Assuming that the guilty partyâs identity and responsibility have been fully determined, the traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor.
In which case the Church also stated rarity if they exist all all. [Under the above paragraph.]
âif this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor.â
They only are defending what they donât see but as a rare possibility which may indeed exist.
I understand that but, again, this does not address the question so Iâll try again. Is an execution an offense against manâs dignity? Thatâs a yes or no question. Just recognize what it means if you say yes. Since the church (at least theoretically) allows the use of capital punishment, if it truly is an offense against manâs dignity, the church would be allowing an evil to achieve something good (protection). Is that really a position you want to take?They only are defending what they donât see but as a rare possibility which may indeed exist.
What does this position mean in light of the fact that the church has always recognized a stateâs right to employ capital punishment? Does it mean that she has always supported murder and injustice?Execution ends life and for no reason I see of moral value to validate it being called justice in this paradigm. Its injustice, thus murder called legal execution=justice.
This makes no distinction between crime and punishment. Punishment involves the loss of some good, of something valued. Surely we can distinguish between stealing and punishing someone with fines; between kidnapping and punishing with imprisonment. In just the same way there is a clear distinction between murder and execution.We canât take guilty people, imprison them in security prisons for safety and punishment, and then restrain them and kill them, and tell others not to kill?
If this assertion was true then we should make no distinction between deliberate murder and accidental homicide. Again you have eliminated any distinction between crime and punishment.If you restrain them with the intent to kill them for what they did, and then kill them, what difference does it make how, and for whom does it make a difference?
All punishment deters some just as no punishment deters all. It seems a bit unlikely that lesser punishments have deterrent effects while the most severe punishment has none.It doesnât deter crimeâŚ
Thereâs no difference in teaching.What does this position mean in light of the fact that the church has always recognized a stateâs right to employ capital punishment? Does it mean that she has always supported murder and injustice?
Ender
*2263 The legitimate defense of persons and societies is not an exception to the prohibition against the murder of the innocent that constitutes intentional killing. âThe act of self-defense can have a double effect: the preservation of oneâs own life; and the killing of the aggressor⌠the one is intended, the other is not.âNot to mention that is comes squarely under the heading âLegitimate Defenseâ.
âIs an amputation an offense against manâs dignity? Thatâs a yes or no question. Just recognize what it means if you say yes. Since medical ethics (at least theoretically) allows the use of amputation, if it truly is an offense against manâs dignity, medicine would be allowing an evil to achieve something good (protection). Is that really a position you want to take?âI understand that but, again, this does not address the question so Iâll try again. Is an execution an offense against manâs dignity? Thatâs a yes or no question. Just recognize what it means if you say yes. Since the church (at least theoretically) allows the use of capital punishment, if it truly is an offense against manâs dignity, the church would be allowing an evil to achieve something good (protection). Is that really a position you want to take?
Ender
No, an amputation is not an offense against manâs dignity. That was simple.âIs an amputation an offense against manâs dignity? Thatâs a yes or no question. Just recognize what it means if you say yes. Since medical ethics (at least theoretically) allows the use of amputation, if it truly is an offense against manâs dignity, medicine would be allowing an evil to achieve something good (protection). Is that really a position you want to take?â
It certainly is if it is unnecessary and there are better and more humane ways to address the disorder to the health and restore the body to wholeness.No, an amputation is not an offense against manâs dignity. That was simple.
Ender
If an unnecessary amputation is performed the fault is the doctorâs, but his improper action is not an insult to his patientâs dignity. It has no effect whatever on that any more than a bad haircut is an insult. The severity of the error doesnât change its intrinsic nature.It certainly is if it is unnecessary and there are better and more humane ways to address the disorder to the health and restore the body to wholeness.
An amputation or a haircut donât exist without humans âperformingâ them. They donât have an intrinsic nature. If they are not done with the good of the person in mind, they are assault and that is not fitting to the dignity of the person.If an unnecessary amputation is performed the fault is the doctorâs, but his improper action is not an insult to his patientâs dignity. It has no effect whatever on that any more than a bad haircut is an insult. The severity of the error doesnât change its intrinsic nature.
Ender