Inquisition: How to respond

  • Thread starter Thread starter NolePaul2009
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
How does one respond to the attacks from protestants or other non-Catholics when referring to the Spanish Inquisition?
Had to be done to protect Catholicism at the time. Yes, there were excesses, but then again, nearly everything Man did at that point in his history was subject to tremendous abuse, compared to modern standards.
 
I wouldnt, actually I would say “What religion has a flawless history. Every religion has had radicals who did things in the name of GOD…that doesn’t make it ok, nor does OUR church condone it. It was a mistake that a pompous, arrogant king that in the end, brought down his country into bankruptcy”
 
Had to be done to protect Catholicism at the time. Yes, there were excesses, but then again, nearly everything Man did at that point in his history was subject to tremendous abuse, compared to modern standards.
Agree with you as long as the implication that modern standards are worse than any other time in history. The USA has performed atrocious fratricide on over 50 million innocent and defenseless babies in my lifetime. That is more than the entire population of Canada and more than existed in all of Europe at the times of the Inquisitions.

On the matter of the Inquisitions people are looking at it completely backwards. We should judge the inquisitions on how many were saved through the mercy of The Church and how many were exposed to less inhumane punishments and tortures. Before the Catholic Inquisitional courts were put in place there was NO standard of justice. It was pretty much mob rule or if the king or the local Marshall did not like you - your throat was cut.

The Catholic Church started reeling in the Monarchs and secular leaders barbarity and limiting first of all who could be tried and to put limits on the forms of punishment and torture for those who were found guilty in a real court of law with real standards of evidence and testimony. History will bear out that very very few were executed or tortured under the Church Inquisitional courts and the overwhelming majority (90% at least) were spared and given the opportunity to recant heresies and plead for leniency. Had these same numbers been given over to secular courts the kings and rulers would have equated rumors of heresy or disobedience to order as direct attacks and treason on the King and the monarchy and would have killed them, taken their property (often permitting officers and in turn their subordinates rape the women as a royal right of possession) and sold their children into slavery to swell the crown treasury.

There were of course abuses where The Church was not always directly involved since the case load was so enormous that some never got to be tried and mobs or officials took the church law into their own hands before they got a fair hearing.

The Church was interested in gaining souls for Christ and growing The Church. It was not interested in killing anyone.

James
 
“The catholics are no worse or better for it than any of the others. They just have the unfortunate positions of still being an organised religion today. This would be the same as blaming a german for the holocost.”

Unfounded and unreasonable.

The problem with this specious argument is that current day Germans have rejected the ideology of Naziism and, in fact, have condemned and made criminal the practice of Hitlerian Nationalism and prosecutes anyone who adheres to any of its tenets…tenets and beliefs which fostered the mindset that engendered the horrors of the Holocaust. Today’s Catholics, however, still adhere to the beliefs and tenets which engendered the Inquisition! Something to think about.

Your Brother in Spirit,
Grampswayne
 
Hello there! Usually, before I go to any discussion about the Inquisition with my non-Catholic friends (and also “non-friends” sometimes), I do the following:
  1. I ask them whether they really researched the issue thoroughly and objectively. If they said “yes” (and they always does), then…
2.I give them a 50 item multiple choice test about the Inquisition based on general reference books (ex. encyclopedia).😉

Its very funny when Protestants–especially the former Catholic anti-Catholic–claim that they “knew it all” about the inquisition yet end up getting a score of 25 below in my “Inquisition exam”.:cool:

Try doing the same. It makes them open to FAIR TALK about the issue.
What a great idea! do you have a copy of the questions and answers you use?

Life in God
 
I’m interested too! Could we have a copy of the test questions and answers?

Thanks!
 
You beat me to it. I want the test too!

Something that may really help you is to read a book (more like a pamphlet) called “Why apologize for the Inquisition”, or something like that. I have a copy, but can’t get to it right now to give you a proper title. I’m sure someone here will give the title. It dispells a lot of myths about the Inquisition, such as many accused would intentionally blaspheme in order to be moved to the Inquisitor’s court which was considered very fair. This was also the foreshadowing of the U.S. trial law system which exists today.
 
In the Inquisition people were BURNED ALIVE at the stake, some excess:confused:
 
Interesting article, but it gives no permission to BURN PEOPLE AT THE STAKE ALIVE. WICKED WICKED PRIESTS, POPE, CHURCH.
 
Interesting article, but it gives no permission to BURN PEOPLE AT THE STAKE ALIVE. WICKED WICKED PRIESTS, POPE, CHURCH.
God burns Satan and evil men for eternity. I am curious would you extend this same condemnation to God?

James
 
Hell fire is the other side of the coin of the fire of God’s love.🙂
I didn’t think you would answer my question with the same zeal of contempt that you wanted to burn The Catholic Church with.

Retract your incendiary attack or else choose your portion - Coward or Hypocrite?

James
 
I am not a theologian nor a biblical scholar, but it seems to me I remember reading in the old testament that God had commanded the Jewish army to strike a certain city in the middle east, and to kill all inhabitants (women and children?). After the invasion, God was upset because some inhabitants had been brought back as slaves (perhaps someone can help with the citation for this particular passage).

The point is that there were very harsh realities in ancient times. I agree with the gentleman who indicated that the inquisitions were held so as to provide a less harsh treatment than would have been provided by the civil courts. Apostasy was considered a very serious offense in the middle ages, and especially in the post reformation era when politics was very much a factor in a person’s belief or lack thereof.

Saul was deposed for not exterminating the Amalekites (1 Sam. 15). IOW, he was deposed for failing to commit genocide. I thought genocide was what certain political leaders of recent times got up to - not Christians :(. Did Jesus say, “Go forth, kill the nations ?” :mad:​

BTW, I doubt it made much difference to the persons being executed whether the flames burning them were kindled in Protestant London, Catholic Paris, or by the Inquisition in Spain & its dominions: the pain would not depend on the religion of the executioner or the sufferer.
 
Per the Wiki:
“In the 16th century, Pope Paul III established a system of tribunals, ruled by the “Supreme Sacred Congregation of the Universal Inquisition”, and staffed by cardinals and other Church officials. This system would later become known as the Roman Inquisition. In 1908 Saint Pope Pius X renamed the organisation: it became the “Supreme Sacred Congregation of the Holy Office”. This in its turn became the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith[5] in 1965, which name continues to this day[update].”
The first formal Catholic Church councils of official inquiry into heresy began in the 12th Century in response to the “growing problem of Catharism” and as stated above were continued with varying degrees of torture, executions, burnings and severity up to the present powers of defrocking and ex-communication. In fact, Joseph Ratzinger for 25 years prior to his nomination for Pope was the Prefect of this latest incarnation of the Inquisition…so in effect was holder of the office of Grand Inquisitor in a direct descendency from the greatest of them, and most associated and reviled (although not necessarily deservedly), Tomas de Torquemada. His greatest concern and for whom he “worrie(d) most are those who have carved out roles - and even careers - for themselves as Church ‘reformers’”. And, as Prefect he therefore was not particularly fond of the likes of Albino Luciani who had proposed massive “reforms” (unfortunately, he was unable to enact them due to his rather untimely and suspicious death) which were desperately needed, particularly in 1978 with accusations of money laundering by Marcinkus’ Vatican Bank and various ties to the P2 corruption which later brought great shame to the Church and Italian politics.

Your Brother in Spirit,
Wayne
 
Thanks to Grampswayne for bringing up the issue of catharism as it is a case in point on how to respond to the question of inquisitions. My recollection of the Cathars was that a particular area of France in the 12th century had espoused and rekindled an old heresy in the Church to the effect that certain individuals were privileged with a direct line to God, i.e. they had a special knowledge of the divine. This heresy spread to the point that the villagers were creating their own little kingdom which in turn incurred the wrath of the local duke who was set to exterminate the whole lot. However, a few franciscans had taken it upon themselves to try to save them by having them formally renounce their apostasy. Since they were unable to, the civil authority attacked the village(s), and God knows what massacre was inflicted on these people. It is contended that the Church was not complicit in these proceedings except to try to save their souls. Although not a formal inquisition, the Church had set about to interview the Cathars and to inquire as to the source of the heresy. In this particular case, the inquisition was most certainly benevolent. However, I’m sure that throughout the ages, the process of formal inquisition was abused to varying degrees.
 
I didn’t think you would answer my question with the same zeal of contempt that you wanted to burn The Catholic Church with.

Retract your incendiary attack or else choose your portion - Coward or Hypocrite?

James
I repent of the vigor of the attack but I cannot deny the FACTS of History. As of this time the present Roman Catholic Church is NOT wicked, nor the Pope Benedict, nor the present day Priests, But the Pope of the inquisition was sinful for allowing the burning at the stakes of the so-called heretics.
Forgive me for writing without being clear.
 
I repent of the vigor of the attack but I cannot deny the FACTS of History. As of this time the present Roman Catholic Church is NOT wicked, nor the Pope Benedict, nor the present day Priests, But the Pope of the inquisition was sinful for allowing the burning at the stakes of the so-called heretics.
Forgive me for writing without being clear.
I think you need to read some different history accounts since no pope or bishop was ever personally involved with overseeing sentencing of those who were actually found guilty of heresy or demonic possession and would not recant when given the chance.

Do you also condemn with the same rigor the Jews for stoning to death all those who violated their laws? The Inquisitional courts were a GOOD THING. People would plead to be heard in these courts (which were often run by the Dominican order) since they had a reputation for charity and mercy rather than face the king’s and secular leader’s justice - which was usually certain death or unrestrained torture. The Inquisitional courts put in place the first real standards of civility and justice. You are judging by contemporary standards - standards that are only ONLY made possible by the success of Christianity in pushing for changes in humane and fair treatment.

James
 
You really don’t have to. Many many terrible things have been done in the name of religions throughout the world and throughout human history.

The catholics are no worse or better for it than any of the others. They just have the unfortunate positions of still being an organised religion today. This would be the same as blaming a german for the holocost.

Unfounded and unreasonable.
But when you consider the churches teachings about being the true bride of Christ and their is none other, you have no witness. The infallibility argument goes out the window. In that we could presume that the Catholic church has no leadership other than any other church, it is subjective to the weakness of men, in action and works. I dont dislike the church or its members, I rather am trying to understand the faith that supports the notion that it is THE ONE AND ONLY unquestionable church.
8 But no man can tame the tongue. It is an unruly evil, full of deadly poison. 9 With it we bless our God and Father, and with it we curse men, who have been made in the similitude of God. 10 Out of the same mouth proceed blessing and cursing. My brethren, these things ought not to be so. 11 Does a spring send forth fresh water and bitter from the same opening? 12 Can a fig tree, my brethren, bear olives, or a grapevine bear figs? Thus no spring yields both salt water and fresh.**
Heavenly Versus Demonic Wisdom

13 Who is wise and understanding among you? Let him show by good conduct that his works are done in the meekness of wisdom.** 14 But if you have bitter envy and self-seeking in your hearts, do not boast and lie against the truth. 15 This wisdom does not descend from above, but is earthly, sensual, demonic. 16 For where envy and self-seeking exist, confusion and every evil thing are there. 17 But the wisdom that is from above is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, willing to yield, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality and without hypocrisy. 18 Now the fruit of righteousness is sown in peace by those who make peace.
Footnotes:
 
I think you need to read some different history accounts since no pope or bishop was ever personally involved with overseeing sentencing of those who were actually found guilty of heresy or demonic possession and would not recant when given the chance.

Do you also condemn with the same rigor the Jews for stoning to death all those who violated their laws? The Inquisitional courts were a GOOD THING. People would plead to be heard in these courts (which were often run by the Dominican order) since they had a reputation for charity and mercy rather than face the king’s and secular leader’s justice - which was usually certain death or unrestrained torture. The Inquisitional courts put in place the first real standards of civility and justice. You are judging by contemporary standards - standards that are only ONLY made possible by the success of Christianity in pushing for changes in humane and fair treatment.

James
You argument is completely absent of the teaching of Jesus and the NT. As is the action of the church in light of history.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top