"Inside Mormonism" - Is this book legit?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Windfish
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

Windfish

Guest
I like to buy topical books from a Catholic perspective, and “Inside Mormonism” is a book written by a Catholic priest who became an apostate by converting to Mormonism and then later reverted. My question: is this book a fair treatment of Mormonism? All of us, I think, roll our eyes at the anti-Catholic tomes by Protestants because of their dishonesty and ineptitude. Is this book a fairer and more learned treatment of its subject than those books?
 
I’ve only read the Amazon preview so I’m not qualified to comment on it. Sorry for any dramatic buildup! 🙂
 
I’m also not familiar with the book, and read only the review on Amazon.

To me, what the Mormon church (or any church) “teaches” is what they tell the people in the pew. I think it’s silly to claim that a church “teaches” some doctrine that the members of the church have never heard of (some “secret” teaching that only the people in the “inside” really know about). Of course this absurdity sounds familiar to Catholics, who “secretly” worship Mary or pagan gods or whatever.

The problem with “secret doctrine” is that you need to let people in on the secret (or it dies out). Suppose the Catholic Church really DID worship pagan idols. What do they do - take some newly-ordained priest into a room and tell him the “truth?” What would this priest do? He surely would NOT nod his head and say, “oh yeah, good idea.” Multiply that times thousands of priests and thousands of bishops and you see how absurd it is.

Same for the mormons. And, keep in mind, unlike Catholics, the mormons have no problem with their doctrines changing. The mormons have changed their doctrine that dark skin is a curse, so while this doctrine was held (and known by) past mormons, it would not be applicable to current mormons.

If informed mormons don’t know about the teaching, then it’s not teaching. You might be able to quote some Mormon theologian or “apostle” or even Smith or Young themselves, but if mormons don’t know about it, it’s not teaching (ie, it’s not a doctrine of the mormon church).
 
I’m also not familiar with the book, and read only the review on Amazon.

To me, what the Mormon church (or any church) “teaches” is what they tell the people in the pew.
Practicing Brighamite (LDS) Mormons are very much aware that their church teaches that there is a plurality of gods. The life’s goal of any practicing Mormon is to achieve godhood through exaltation.
 
If informed mormons don’t know about the teaching, then it’s not teaching. You might be able to quote some Mormon theologian or “apostle” or even Smith or Young themselves, but if mormons don’t know about it, it’s not teaching (ie, it’s not a doctrine of the mormon church).
Why would that be the case?

The Catholic Church teaches what the Catholic Church puts forth for belief in its official documents. Catholic doctrine is not defined by whatever some Catholics in the might believe.

Supposedly 43% of “Catholics” don’t believe in the Real Presence in the Eucharist. If this number goes to 51% does that change the teaching?

I would think the same would apply to Mormons.

No?

Chuck
 
I received this book today, and began reading the history of Mormonism…

Now, I am not phased in the least about my own Catholic beliefs - however, I began to see things as an outsider. What I mean is, a lot of the historical reasons we use to support the Catholic faith are, from an outsider point of view, kind of similar to those used to support Mormonism. For example, Mormon missionaries use “eyewitness testimony” to support the existence of the golden plates of the Book of Mormon. And while this eyewitness testimony is highly suspect and inconsistent, one can also see a similar piece of evidence vis a vi the Gospels to support Catholicism. Now, this is a very simplistic comparison that probably doesn’t hold water upon closer scrutiny, but do you guys see how an outsider looking at things at a superficial level might see this?

I think this is an interesting topic, and I hope to get your guys’ thoughts on this.
 
BTW, was it Patrick Madrid who is known for studying Mormonism? This might be a good question for him.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top