Intelligent Design, most scientific

  • Thread starter Thread starter dcdurel
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Demoting God to a “designer” is, of course a major sin. But the fact that we can’t find evidence for design in nature is much more damning from a scientific POV.
Alright, then let’s take a look at this…
Exodus 20:11:
For in six days the LORD made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that is in them, but he rested on the seventh day. Therefore the LORD blessed the Sabbath day and made it holy.
Here we see God apparently designed a pattern right into the framework of his creation, one that follows a seven day rhthym according to God’s own word (which is repeated several times within the Scriptures too).

Now some take passages like this very literally, insisting that God indeed created the heavens and the earth in seven literal days, something which I personally don’t agree with.

However, having said this, I would agree that there is a rhthym within nature itself which does follow this pattern which God himself “supernaturally” designed within creation, a “literal” pattern that our termporal seven day week actually harmonizes very well with.

I would also suggest that cellular chronobiology has now actually demonstrated this “heptad nature” which God “hard-wired” into the fabric of his creation too, because this rhthym simply does not correspond to any “naturally known” rhythm that currently exists today.

For example, we may casually assume that our week is really a division of the moon cycle. But if that is our assumption, we forget that the lunar cycle is not a twenty-eight-day cycle, but approximately twenty-nine days, twelve hours, forty-four minutes and three seconds – or 29.5306 days between new moons.

A precise quarter of the lunar cycle amounts to the uneven figure of 7.38625 days. So any week using that true length would begin at different times of the day every time the cycle started. There is just no way to neatly divide the lunar cycle into weekly blocks of complete days.

The same thing could be assumed regarding the solar cycle I suppose. But, as Ken Westby points out, the cycle of seven does not actually relate to the center of our solar system either. The 7-day week also works independently from the annual solar cycle of 365 1/4 days too. In other words, a “year” of 52 weeks would have just 364 whole days.

Nor is the week in harmonic sympathy with the star year of 366 1/4 days. Star days or “sidereal days” are about four minutes shorter than solar days (an observer will see a particular star at the same position four minutes earlier on successive nights).

In short, there appears to be no known external rhythms in nature that could explain the near universal existence of the seven day social week.

Why is this mysterious seven-day beat working independently from the environmental factors which apparently morphed our biological makeup-- such as the cycles of sun, moon and stars for example?
 
Many people have seen all sorts of things, when their faith demands that those things exist.
But what happens when science “accidentally” finds something that faith has been claiming all along?

More importantly, what happens when those scientists who were exploring from the vantage point of their particular scientific field find something they were not expecting to find it in the first place?

Remember my previously quoted source?
These circaseptan, or about weekly, rhythms are one of the major surprises turned up by modern chronobiology. Fifteen years ago, few scientists would have expected that seven-day biological cycles would prove to be so widespread and so long established in the living world.
Here’s a link for further information.

I personally don’t agree with some of the concusions that this article has reached. But I think they raise some very good questions which directly pertain to the question of whether God directly interacts on a more mundane level with nature of not.
Science can’t evaluate religious beliefs, because they are untestable.
And yet the science behind this chronobiological research can be tested and verified, resulting in tangible consequences to our physical lives– so it’s not just something which strictly applies solely to purely metaphysical questions.
Interesting things, apparently (at least in algae) medated by something in the nucleus. The only thing remotely fitted to this, would be the multiplicity of spring and neap tides, suggesting that it evolved in the oceans a long time ago.
I suppose that one could suggest that it evolved naturally.

Or one could also suggest that God supernaturally designed this pattern into his creation as the Scriptures seem to attest.

Again, I will note that this rhythm appears to be the only major rhythm of human activity that is oblivious to external nature, resting on mathematical regularity alone as far as we can tell-- judging from a purely scientific perspective.
Still not resolved. All sciences have unresolved things to study.
No doubt.

But at what point do we draw the line for seeking a natural explanation for something which may indeed have a supernatural origin?

More imortantly, what if we are searching for a “natural explanation” for something that might not actually have a “natural explanation” to begin with?

At what point do we stop searching for hard evidence and start believing what we simply perceive to be true?
 
continued
More imortantly, what if we are searching for a “natural explanation” for something that might not actually have a “natural explanation” to begin with?

For example, someone can suggest, as you have, that these chronobiological patterns within these organisms might be the result of natural processes which mirrored the multiplicity of spring and neap tides-- suggesting that it evolved in the oceans a long time ago.

But then one has to wonder exactly how this happened if the earth was spinning faster a long time ago. For example, consider Professor John W. Wells research into Coral Growth and Geochronology which tackles questions regarding the length of days in the ancient past.
Astronomers seem to be generally agreed that while the period of the Earth’s revolution around the Sun has been constant, its period of rotation on its polar axis, at present 24 h, has not been constant throughout Earth’s history, and that there has been a deceleration attributable to the dissipation of rotational energy by tidal forces on the surface and in the interior, a slow-down of about 2 sec per 100,000 years according to the most recent estimates. It thus appears that the length of the day has been increasing throughout geological time and that the number of days in the year has been decreasing. At, the beginning of the Cambrian the length of the day would have been 21 h (ref. 1).
A torque between the earth and the moon acts to decelerate the earth’s rotation and increase the moon’s angular momentum. This results in a slight increase in day length estimated to be about 2 milliseconds (two thousandths of a second) per day every 100 years.

This means that 100 million years ago (when the dinosaurs were trotting about) a day would have been roughly half an hour shorter than today - so a day would have lasted 23.5 hours (0.002 sec/day/century x 1,000,000 centuries = 2,000,000 msec (2000 seconds) = 0.55 hours. A year at this time would have lasted 374 days.

Looking further back in time, 600 million years ago the day would have been 3.3 hours shorter, giving 424 days/year.

In other words, if the multiplicity of spring and neap tides suggest that it evolved in the oceans a long time ago, then at which point in earth’s history does this “seven day pattern” which evolved naturally actually mirror a “time-frame” which existed back then?

At which time in earth’s ancient history did God “set the clock” that the chonobiological sciences have found themselves wound up in biological life today?

Does it correspond to the appearance of humanity on earth?

Is man the measure by which God judges his own creation?
Psalm 8:3-5:
When I consider your heavens,
the work of your fingers,
the moon and the stars,
which you have set in place,
what is man that you are mindful of him,
the son of man that you care for him?

You made him a little lower than the heavenly beings
and crowned him with glory and honor.
 
BTW, I see some have taken issue with your observation that Einstein was a Spinozan pantheist. Here’s a site, they might want to visit:
einsteinandreligion.com/spinoza2.html

You may be already aware of these statements, but others might want to see them.
Thank you for pointing that out.

Yes, I was already aware of this, but it is good to point this out for others in the thread.

Admittedly, I do have much respect for Einstein even if he was a pantheist in the spirit of Spinoza. Then again, I have a lot of respect for Spinoza too, even if I don’t agree with all things Spinoza said.

There was one thing in the article that you linked to that caught my attention…
But there was one religious concept, Einstein went on to say, that science could not accept: a deity who could meddle at whim in the events of his creation. “The main source of the present-day conflicts between the spheres of religion and of science lies in this concept of a personal God,” he argued. Scientists aim to uncover the immutable laws that govern reality, and in doing so they must reject the notion that divine will, or for that matter human will, plays a role that would violate this cosmic causality.
His belief in causal determinism was incompatible with the concept of human free will. Jewish as well as Christian theologians have generally believed that people are responsible for their actions. They are even free to choose, as happens in the Bible, to disobey God’s commandments, despite the fact that this seems to conflict with a belief that God is all knowing and all powerful.
Einstein, on the other hand, believed–as did Spinoza–that a person’s actions were just as determined as that of a billiard ball, planet or star. “Human beings in their thinking, feeling and acting are not free but are as causally bound as the stars in their motions,” Einstein declared in a statement to a Spinoza Society in 1932. It was a concept he drew also from his reading of Schopenhauer. “Everybody acts not only under external compulsion but also in accordance with inner necessity,” he wrote in his famous credo. “Schopenhauer’s saying, ‘A man can do as he wills, but not will as he wills,’ has been a real inspiration to me since my youth; it has been a continual consolation in the face of life’s hardships, my own and others’, and an unfailing wellspring of tolerance.”
This reminds me of a previous poster’s thoughts (I think in this very thread, though I can’t remember for sure), a view which Collins likewise seemed to speak of in his book Language of God.

In the analogy of the pool game, it was argued that the distinction between intelligent design and theistic evolution would be like comparing a person who shoots the balls in the hole one and at time and another person getting all the balls in the holes in one single shot.

Consequently, if God does get all the balls in the holes in on shot, how does this allow the room for freedom within human nature? Is everything merely pre-determined to the point that people have no free-will-- so much so that some of the balls on the pool table drop down into hell whereas others drop up into heaven?

You youself said here that Omniscience for God means that God never did any planing or designing. More specifically, you said that I ignored the fact that an omniscient being does not plan, does not design-- that He is merely aware of His intent and of the consequences.

But, if you’re positing this in your theodicy of God to avoid the conclusion that God can make mistakes (as Darwin himself seems to have done when introducing his theory of evolution), then does this position allow any room for humanity to actually make mistakes?

For the record, I haven’t ignored this point. I’m asking you if you believe that God has a free-will or not? I’m also wondering if you believe that people have free-will or not?
Sounds like a Christian idea to me.
That’s because it is a Christian idea.

Whereas the ID movement seems to be akin to a Watchmaker argument, and the atheistic evolutionist seems to be akin to a Blind Watchmaker argument, the theistic evolutionist seems to be arguing that God himself is the Watch.

Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?

Ezekiel 33:7 said:
“Son of man, I have made you a watchman for the house of Israel; so hear the word I speak and give them warning from me.”
 
That’s why I didn’t say you did it. But I’m wondering why you don’t just go the full Monte, and call it “creation.”
I have no problem with God’s creation.

I do have a problem, however, when people claim the Full Monte of Creation is the fact that God did not in fact design the universe because a) his omniscience precludes him from planning in the first place and b) this ultimately reduces him to nothing more that a Christian variation of the demiurge of the gnostic heretics.

I’m not sure if I can make my position any clearer than this to be honest.
The Wedge Strategy depends on peddling the soft version as a way of opening the way for a non-Christian form of ID.
And, in inverse proportion, the Wedge Strategy can be used as a way of opening the way for a Christian form of Theistic Evolution too, even if they did not intend for it to be used this way.
Yep. “Nature” is merely a place or a system that God produced for us to live out our natural lives in. It’s just a special subset of the supernatural.
Me personally, I think the “physical creation” is, metaphorically speaking, akin to a replicated cell which has, by a process similar to a spiritual cellular fission, been duplicated from God’s eternal universe ex nihilo.

I think it was something which was orignally intended to perfectly mirror God’s heavenly realm when it was “finished”. But then something went wrong prior to its completion.
Romans 8:22:
We know that the whole creation has been groaning as in the pains of childbirth right up to the present time.
In the end, however, when all is said and done, we will see this universe perflectly reflect the glory our our creator in his beautific vision-- and nothing will have gone wrong in the end.

Isaiah 65:17 said:
"Behold, I will create new heavens and a new earth. The former things will not be remembered, nor will they come to mind.
Didn’t say it was easy. But the demarcation line is convoluted, not blurry.
I think it’s blurry, like a darkened mirror…
1 Corinthians 13:8-12:
Love never fails.

But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be stilled; where there is knowledge, it will pass away.

For we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when perfection comes, the imperfect disappears.

When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put childish ways behind me.

Now we see but a poor reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face.

Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.
I’m not a theistic evolutionist. Theism has nothing to do with evolution.
And yet you believe that God used evolution to speciate life on earth, do you not?

Is this merely another semantic argument whereby we shift definitions in order to make statements that we progressively never intended to speak from the other person’s lips the first place?

In other words, perhaps you could state your position more clearly. 🙂

I liked Collins term BioLogos by the way. I like it a lot actually.
 
Barbarian observes:
That’s why I didn’t say you did it. But I’m wondering why you don’t just go the full Monte, and call it “creation.”
I have no problem with God’s creation.
Then there’s nothing but semantics in involved, and you just use “design” where Chrstians usually use “creation.”
I do have a problem, however, when people claim the Full Monte of Creation is the fact that God did not in fact design the universe because a) his omniscience precludes him from planning in the first place
This much is true. Of course, God could intentionally set aside His own omniscience, if He wanted. But why? Nothing in Christian Scripture or tradition says so.
and b) this ultimately reduces him to nothing more that a Christian variation of the demiurge of the gnostic heretics.
At least your interpretation seems no different than “creator”, which wouldn’t apply. But those who actually consider Him to have designed (in the strict sense) do that.

Barbarian observes:
The Wedge Strategy depends on peddling the soft version as a way of opening the way for a non-Christian form of ID.

Yes, and on fundamentalist boards, ID is functioning as a sort of halfway house for recovering creationists. That is the only benefit of ID. But that requires demonstrating the logical inconsistencies in ID.

Barbarian observes:
Yep. “Nature” is merely a place or a system that God produced for us to live out our natural lives in. It’s just a special subset of the supernatural.
Me personally, I think the “physical creation” is, metaphorically speaking, akin to a replicated cell which has, by a process similar to a spiritual cellular fission, been duplicated from God’s eternal universe ex nihilo.
I think it was something which was orignally intended to perfectly mirror God’s heavenly realm when it was “finished”. But then something went wrong prior to its completion.
I suspect that nothing “went wrong.” The disaster of the Fall was an essential thing if we were to become capable of fellowship with God. We had to become moral beings if we were to share it fully with Him.

The Serpent told a half-truth in the Garden, not a complete lie. He said that we would become like God, if Eve ate from the tree. And God later confirms this to be true.

The Serpent, seeking to undermine God, only carried out his part.

Barbarian on faith and science:
Didn’t say it was easy. But the demarcation line is convoluted, not blurry.
I think it’s blurry, like a darkened mirror…
Take a closer look.

Barbarian observes:
I’m not a theistic evolutionist. Theism has nothing to do with evolution.
And yet you believe that God used evolution to speciate life on earth, do you not?
I believe He used physics to produce the world. But I’m not a “theistic physicist”, either. That is a religious belief, and is not scientific in the least. (which is fine; science can’t handle all things)

I think maybe it is just a semantic difference we have.
 
reggie M:

I accept that I am a creature of God. I accept that God directly created my soul and evolution was not involved in that action. I accept that the design which is evident in my body and in my “personhood” were created by God. I do not see sufficient evidence to accept that human beings are “evolved apes”.

**If you do not “see” sufficient evidence to accept that humans are evolved from apes then I suggest you are not looking for it. The evidence is simply overwhelming. You simply announce that you do not likely and thus look for “evidence” that you’re right. Such is not honest discourse. The vatican has spoken albeit not the most clearly but it has admitted no basic disagreement with evolution as a model. It obviously points out that God is still the ultimate creator of all that is. **

All of these things are very hard to accept for people who embrace Darwinian naturalism since that theory holds that God was not involved in the creation of human beings.
**The theory holds no such thing. Darwinism makes no claims about God whatsoever. Some people use Darwinism to pursue their own agenda of what it means, however the science itself never makes any such claim. **
 
The Catholic Church combines the science with theology to investigate the two together, not separately. It then informs the faithful based on both science and the deposit of faith. This is the whole answer, the correct answer, the complete answer.

God bless,
Ed
 
I don’t know what intelligent design is but I do know this:

As long as God is infinitely intelligent I know that the universe wasn’t created by Dumb design!

A Master Billiards player can vary the speed and English on the cue ball so he winds up being able to easily make every shot.

Couldn’t the Infinite God be able to do that with the universe?

It seems to me that whether you believe that God Started the universe and it evolved or that God started and continualy influenced it along the way–in either case you’re dealing with an Intelligent Designer–either God is smart enough to initiate it in a way to where He doesn’t have to intervene again for it to work out

Or that God starts it and continualy influences it along the way–even if that influence to us is imperceptible.

Either way you’re dealing with an Intelligent Designer.

If you believe that the universe is at its current state of being through random chaos for no point whatsoever and it still came out as beautifully ordered as it did are you really being logical?

What’s more logical–an Infinitely Intelligent Designer either way he created or a dumb design that indicates no God?

I vote for Intelligent design–either with evolution or with continuing influence!
 
I think the Cardinal made it clear that some scientists reach conclusions that are incompatible with Catholic teaching. So, yes, he said that iit was fine to observe the world and reason our way to a worldview. He merely pointed out that a certain evolutionary-Darwinist worldview is false.
…in Schoenborn’s opinion which is based on a very poor understanding of the science. His view on whether the science is right or not carries no more authority than the view of the guy at the supermarket checkout and his railing against contingency in evolutionary biology merely drags the church into disrepute.

Alec
ww.evolutionpages.com
 
An Evolutionary-Darwinist-Only worldview is indeed false.

Its falsity lies in the worship of the “Only” part!
 
The Catholic Church combines the science with theology to investigate the two together, not separately. It then informs the faithful based on both science and the deposit of faith. This is the whole answer, the correct answer, the complete answer.
Ed
WOOOHOOO ED YA GOT IT!!! Finally and at last…congratulations!!! wee hee… :dancing: :bowdown2:
 
40.png
hecd2:
When scientists are doing science, they rightly restrict themselves to proposing only natural causes for the phenomena that they observe
It would seem unjustified then for scientists to draw theological conclusions from their scientific observations.
I would think you would be equally indignant since you’ve asserted that scientists restrict themselves to proposing natural causes.
You have a very bad habit of taking context-free snippets out of other’s arguments and addressing the extract rather than the whole argument. That is a species of misrepresentation. Do you always have this much trouble understanding or properly responding to other’s arguments?

It is true that when scientists are doing science that they rightly restrict themselves to proposing only natural causes for the phenomena that they observe. But I then went on to point that that does not and should not prevent them from using their science (and all their other knowledge and experience) to reason to a worldview which they are entitled to declare publicly whether or not that view coincides with Schoenborn’s. I also pointed out that it is based on a firmer foundation of scientific knowledge than Schoenborn’s worldview. You can find the full argument here if you are willing to read and understand more than one sentence at a time:

evolutionpages.com/Schoenborn_critique.htm

Alec
 
The Catholic Church combines the science with theology to investigate the two together, not separately. It then informs the faithful based on both science and the deposit of faith. This is the whole answer, the correct answer, the complete answer.

God bless,
Ed
That’s very well said Ed. I think this generally sums up the Catholic approach to faith and science very well. 👍
 
But, if you’re positing this in your theodicy of God to avoid the conclusion that God can make mistakes (as Darwin himself seems to have done when introducing his theory of evolution),
No, I wasn’t thinking of that at all.
then does this position allow any room for humanity to actually make mistakes?
Yes, it has to do with the nature of intelligence and self-reference. It’s a difficult question; one philosophers and cognitive psychologists alike have difficulty approaching.

Have you read Douglas Hoffstader’s “Godel, Escher, Bach”, or the follow-up “The Mind’s I?”

It is clear enough that we have “room” to go astray, but exactly how that is managed in a universe that is deterministic on the macro level is unclear. Perhaps the quantum mind theories are right. Haven’t looked at them in a rigorous way, so I can’t say.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind
 
…in Schoenborn’s opinion which is based on a very poor understanding of the science. His view on whether the science is right or not carries no more authority than the view of the guy at the supermarket checkout and his railing against contingency in evolutionary biology merely drags the church into disrepute.
Hmmm…

whether the available data support inferences of design or chance cannot be settled by theology. But it is important to note that, according to the Catholic understanding of divine causality, true contingency" – that is, dependence upon chance – "in the created order is not incompatible with a purposeful divine providence.

Report of the 2004 International Theological Commission, signed by Cardinal Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI.

I’m hoping you misunderstood what the Cardinal said. I cannot see how he would deviate that far from Catholic doctrine.
 
The Catholic Church combines the science with theology to investigate the two together, not separately. It then informs the faithful based on both science and the deposit of faith. This is the whole answer, the correct answer, the complete answer.
That is very good. To say that God was involved in the creation of the universe and then to exclude all mention of this fact in scientific research is to deny the truth about reality. This is precisely what Darwinism does.
 
using their science (and all their other knowledge and experience) to reason to a worldview
You originally conflated science and theology stating that scientists would arrive at theological conclusions basied on their studies (which are limited to naturalism).

In the above comment however, you changed “theology” to “reason a worldview”.
 
reggieM “Darwinian naturalism holds that God was not involved in the creation of human beings”

SpiritMeadow “The theory holds no such thing.”

What role does Darwinian naturalism propose for God in the creation of human beings? What role do you believe God had?
 
Between divine providence and random chance, which one makes you feel better when you look into a sunset?

Isn’t that what all this is about?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top