Intercession of the Saints

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cruxis117
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Cruxis117

Guest
I’ve been having a discussion with my Lutheran friend. Although we’ve been able to see eye to eye in speaking about our faith, and understanding our brotherhood (if wounded by the Reformation) in Christ, he still has some issues with certain doctrines, such as Intercession of the Saints, as well as the Immaculate Conception.

What he asked me was:
  • If you’re in heaven, why would you need to pray to God anymore? You’re with God now.
  • Why would Mary be kept from sin? If God was able to do that with Mary, why not with anyone else? Why the need for Jesus at all?
His analogy was that prayer was like using a cell phone, and that you didn’t need to use a cell phone when you’re in the room with God. Do you know how I can respond to this? I’ve been doing some reading, but I’m interested in what you think.
 
  1. They pray for us, not themselves. Your friend is right they don’t need prayers for themselves anymore. But that’s not intercessory prayer. :o
  2. Man was created like Mary the first time around and fell. That’s why we need Jesus. Mary as the NT type of Eve (as Jesus was the NT type of Adam) was created without original sin also. Mary did not make the free decision to sin, however.
As to the “why” God did this, we can speculate. First you should tell a person “Whether or not we know ‘why’ God did this, Mary’s sinlessness is revealed in divine revelation regardless. So whether or not I can unlock God’s mind on this does not affect that truth.”

But if you want to give what I think are sound theological reasons, you can say because Mary is the figure of the Church as the Church will be in the final order—presented spotless and blameless before God. Her life also exhibits the pilgrim life of the Church. Both she and the Church “ponder these things of God in Her heart.” Both she and the Church are “brides” of God—Mary to the Spirit and the Church to Christ. As well, we can see that she was the “dwelling place” of God. In Scripture, sin is always off-limits to God’s dwelling place. As soon as Adam and Eve sinned, they were vanquished from the Garden which was God’s dwelling place. The high priest had to purify himself from sin before entering the temple where was the ark–another dwelling place of God. Mary was of course another dwelling place of God and therefore sin was off-limits to that domain. Protestants often have difficulty grasping the typological nature of so much of God’s revelation in this way and thus miss out and do not see the truth revealed in Scripture right in front of them because they don’t see the typological connections.
 
An ancient custom of the Catholic Church, invoking the saints and commending oneself to their intercession with God. The Cathars, the Waldensians, Wicliffe, Luther and more recently modernists attacked the legitimacy of that usage, rejecting it as idolatrous, as derogatory to the worship due Christ (the one Mediator, according to St. Paul, between man and God), and as a sign of little confidence in God’s mercy.

The Council of Trent, outlining the reasons of the ancient custom, defends its legitimacy and utility and reproves the contrary teaching as impious: “The Holy Synod orders all bishops, and all the others having the duty and charge of teaching, that - according to the usage of the Catholic and Apostolic Church, in force since the first times of the Christian religion, and according to the consensus of the Holy Fathers of the Church and the decrees of the Councils - they instruct accurately the faithful especially about the intercession and invocation of the saints . . . teaching them that the saints, ruling together with Christ, offer their prayers for men to God, and that it is good and useful to invoke them supplicantly and to have recourse to their prayers and to their powerful help in obtaining benefits from God through Jesus Christ, His Son our Lord, who is our only Redeemer and Saviour. Those who do not admit that the saints, blessed in heaven, should be invoked, or who say that the saints do not pray for men, or that . . . their invocation is idolatry, or . . . is contrary to the dignity of the one Mediator between God and men, Jesus Christ, or that it is stupid to supplicate with voice or thought those who reign in heaven: all these do think impiously.” In this decree, is found the solution of all aspects of the question.

1.) The saints can intercede for us in imitation of Jesus Christ, who (as Man) is always alive to intercede for us with the Father (Hebrews 7:25).

2.) The prayer we address to God is an act of latreutic cult because we believe that the omnipotent God can fulfill all our desires. The prayer made to the saints, on the other hand, is an act of mere dulia, because we expect the fulfillment of our desires not from their power, but from their intercession with God, who can grant us grace directly in view of their prayers and their merits, or can also work a miracle through means of them.

3.) The saints see in the beatific vision our conditions and our supplications.

4.) The intercession of the saints is directed to Christ the Mediator, through whom all heavenly favors descend upon us.

5.) God sees our needs and could provide directly, but it pleases the divine Wisdom to communicate His gifts through intermediaries. After Jesus, Mediator between God and men, Mary, the Mediatrix of all graces, excels over the angels and the saints, and so the Church addresses supplications to her in a special way.
 
The privilege of Mary’s sinlessness is implicit in the text of Genesis 3:15, where the triumph of the Woman and of her Offspring (Christ) over Satan is prophesied. Moreover, Mary, before the Incarnation, is greeted by the angel as “full of grace” (permanently full of divine grace), and expression in which the Fathers recognize perfect sanctity, without limit of time. The parallelism Adam-Eve (slaves of Satan and ruin of mankind) and Christ-Mary (victors over Satan and salvation of men) is familiar to the Fathers (Justin, Irenaeus, Tertullian, etc.) Ephraem has a vivid expressions on the incontaminated purity of Mary. St. Augustine, notwithstanding his fight against the Pelagians, does not dare to mention Mary when it is a question of sin

Theological reason: It is repugnant that the Mother of Christ, victor of Satan and of sin, should have been subject to one and the other, even for one instant.
 
I’ve been having a discussion with my Lutheran friend…
I’ll take a stab at your friend’s two questions:

"If you’re in heaven, why would you need to pray to God anymore? You’re with God now."

The saints in heaven are aware of what is happening to people on earth, and they ask God to intercede accordingly. A clear Scripture passage demonstrating this is Revelation 6:9-11. Herein John witnessed the martyrs in heaven imploring God to enact his justice upon the wicked that had slain them. This shows that they are aware that God has not already done this, and they are asking God to intercede in the lives of people on earth. In this case, the saints in heaven are motivated out of a sense of justice for God to deal with the wicked on earth. Is it not reasonable, then, to believe that saints in heaven would be motivated by a sense of charity to ask God to intercede in the lives of people on earth who are in need?

"Why would Mary be kept from sin? If God was able to do that with Mary, why not with anyone else? Why the need for Jesus at all?"

If Mary had sinned then that would mean that her human nature was at least at some point held in bondage to Satan. Her human nature is the source of Jesus’ human nature. It was his will to experience everything we experience except sin. Like all humans, he took his human nature from his mother, and in light of all this his human nature had to be completely free from sin. The miracle of the Immaculate Conception allowed for this.

Moreover, your friend seems to think that because Mary was kept free from sin that she did not need Jesus as her Savior. This is not Catholic teaching. The grace of the Immaculate Conception was bestowed upon Mary in anticipation of Jesus’ sacrifice. So she needed Jesus, because without the Cross of Christ there would not be an Immaculate Conception. A human may be troubled by this explanation because it is chronologically out of order. But God is not dependent upon time. He is the Creator of time and the master of time, and can manifest his power in our world in whatever way he desires.

To put this another way, although Jesus’ sacrifice on Calvary was a historical event (it happened in a specific time and place on earth), it is also a divine event, and therefore the grace it provides transcends time and space. Otherwise, it would not have the power to save the entire human race throughout all the ages. So just as it had the power to forgive all the sins that happened prior to and after Calvary, it likewise had the power to prevent sins concerning Mary prior to and after Calvary.

Finally, if someone examines all that I have stated and still asks why God did it this way and not some other way, then it suffices to say that God could do lots of things in different ways. The way he chooses is the way he chooses. We can ask why God chose to make grass green rather than red, but if grass were red we would be asking, “Why not green?”
 
If you’re in heaven, why would you need to pray to God anymore? You’re with God now.
His analogy was that prayer was like using a cell phone, and that you didn’t need to use a cell phone when you’re in the room with God.
Poor analogy. Payer is asking, making petition and talking things over with God.
Just because you are in the same room as a friend and don’t need a cell phone, doesn’t mean you don’t talk to him.
The saints intercede for us with God and their prayers/petitions have great poser for two interrelated reasons. First is the fac that tehy are in God’s very presence and Second is that they are completely purified andin union with God. For these two reasons, they cannot pray in any way that is Contrary to God’s will and thus we can be assured taht if we ask a saint to intercede for us, it will be for the Will of God and not for our will.
Why would Mary be kept from sin? If God was able to do that with Mary, why not with anyone else? Why the need for Jesus at all?
I’ll leave others to answer this one.

Peace
James
 
prayer is the language between man and God, not the phone.

Jesus came for me, and went to prepare a place for me. Our Father prepared a place for Jesus before time began.

peace
 
To offer a confessional Lutheran approach, to your Lutheran dialogue, I would direct your friend back to the Book of Concord, which are the collection of Lutheran Confessions.

The Augsburg Confession, Article XXI, is reacting against the worship of saints, which had become an abuse of the Middle Ages (and in some parts of the world, continues to this day.) Denouncing the worship of the saints is something that both Lutherans and Roman Catholics can agree upon.

In the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, Article XXI, the same issue is expressed in greater detail. Here it is noted, in part:

"Our Confession approves honors to the saints. For here a threefold honor is to be approved. The first is thanksgiving. For we ought to give thanks to God because He has shown examples of mercy; because He has shown that He wishes to save men; because He has given teachers or other gifts to the Church. And these gifts, as they are the greatest, should be amplified, and the saints themselves should be praised, who
have faithfully used these gifts, just as Christ praises faithful businessmen, Matt. 25, 21. 23. The second service is the strengthening of our faith; when we see the denial forgiven Peter, we also are encouraged to believe the more that grace truly superabounds over sin, Rom. 5, 20. The third honor is the imitation, first, of faith, then of the other virtues, which every one should imitate according to his calling…

"Besides, we also grant that the angels pray for us. For there is a testimony in Zech. 1, 12, where an angel prays: O Lord of hosts, how long wilt Thou not have mercy on Jerusalem? Although concerning the saints we concede that, just as, when alive, they pray for the Church universal in general, so in heaven they pray for the Church in general, albeit no testimony concerning the praying of the dead is extant in the Scriptures, except the dream taken from the Second Book of Maccabees, 15, 14.

“Moreover, even supposing that the saints pray for the Church ever so much, yet it does not follow that they are to be invoked; although our Confession affirms only this, that Scripture does not teach the invocation of the saints, or that we are to ask the saints for aid. But since neither a command, nor a promise, nor an example can be produced from the Scriptures concerning the invocation of saints, it follows that conscience can have nothing concerning this invocation that is certain. And since prayer ought to be made from faith, how do we know that God approves this invocation? Whence do we know without the testimony of Scripture that the saints perceive the prayers of each one? … Therefore the adversaries ought not to force us to an uncertain matter, because a prayer without faith is not prayer.”

From the Lutheran perspective, the crux of the matter is faith and trust in Christ. Nothing should be compelled apart from the Holy Scriptures. The Lutheran Confessions do not expressly forbid requesting the saints to pray for us, and even acknowledge the Biblical truth that they do, indeed, pray for us. On the contrary, the Lutheran Confessions forbid that we place our hope and trust in the saints, but give this worship and faith to Christ alone.

Perhaps here is fruitful ground for your continued conversation?

Peace be with you.
 
To offer a confessional Lutheran approach, to your Lutheran dialogue, I would direct your friend back to the Book of Concord, which are the collection of Lutheran Confessions…
Although your comments were directed to the OP, I would like to say that I appreciate your (name removed by moderator)ut to help us understand things from a Lutheran perspective. I would like to respond to one of your statements from a Catholic perspective…
On the contrary, the Lutheran Confessions forbid that we place our hope and trust in the saints, but give this worship and faith to Christ alone.
As you noted in your post, both Catholics and Protestants officially forbid worshiping saints. But let us examine the idea of placing hope and trust in saints. From the Catholic perspective, there is a right way of approaching the saints and a wrong way.

The wrong way would come from believing that a saint is somehow able to do something for me that God is not. A correct understanding is that whatever saints are able to do for us, they do so with God’s approval and God’s power.

Another wrong way would come from the belief that because saints are human, they are able to understand us better and sympathize with us better. Therefore, some think that the saints are more approachable than God. The First and Third Persons of the Holy Trinity are not human, and even though the Son has a human nature, he also has a divine nature, leading some to think that he is not really able to fully relate to us. A correct line of thinking is that God understands us and relates to us far greater than we, ourselves, are capable of.

The intercession of the saints (according to a proper Catholic understanding) is based upon the idea of Christian fellowship and virtuous living. If I pray to the saints for their help, I exercise the virtue of humility. If they help me with their intercessions, they exercise the virtue of charity. What goes on all the time among Christians on earth (asking others for their prayers and praying for others as well) is simply extended to include the community of saints in heaven. The Letter of James tells us to pray for one another, and states that the prayers of the righteous are powerful in their effects (James 5:16). Obviously, the saints in heaven are certainly righteous beyond our imagination. I am sure lots of 1st Century Christians asked St. James to pray for them, especially after reading his letter. Why can’t I ask St. James to pray for me as well? Sure, he has experienced earthly death, but he has also triumphed over death through the power of Christ and is living in heaven, more fully alive now than he ever was on earth. The same is true for all the saints in heaven.

Seeking the intercession of the saints in heaven (in accordance with proper Catholic teaching) is not done to the exclusion of Christ, because there is one Body in Christ. The Church exists in heaven and on earth, and whereas the members of the body of the Church can pray for and assist one another, such activity is done in conjunction with the head of the Church, Jesus. By his power such communication between earth and heaven is possible, and it is his grace that responds to the prayers. Going back to my example involving St. James, the only difference between me asking for his intercession today and the people of the 1st Century who asked him, is that he is now in a different location within the Church, within the Body of Christ (because he is in heaven and I am on earth). But we still exist as members of the same Body, united within Christ (and consequently we are united in a sacramental way during the reception of the Eucharist).

To tie this all together with your above statement, it is wrong to place faith and trust in a saint if this is to the exclusion of Christ. But Christian fellowship is often a channel of his grace into our lives. So as a Catholic I place my faith and trust in Christ working through the intercession of the saints. Jesus can, and does, provide grace in a variety of ways, not just through Christian fellowship (and the intercession of saints), but Christian fellowship is a very important part of Christian living. I simply see the intercession of the saints as being part of the “big picture” of what such fellowship entails.
 
Friend,

What you write below, is not offensive to the Lutheran Confessions, and ought not be to any Lutheran who subscribes to them. Lutherans also speak of the Means of Grace, primarily the great Sacraments of Holy Baptism, Holy Eucharist, and Holy Absolution, but also through the persons whom God uses to deliver that grace (Office of the Holy Ministry in particular with her bishops and priests, and the general laity through their baptismal grace.)

What is often missed in the Lutheran Confessions, is that they argue against compulsion… that none ought be compelled to invoke the intercession of the saints. If I understand it properly, Rome does not compel anyone in our day to seek the intercession of the saints, but rather encourages, along the lines of reasoning which you aptly laid out below. I do not think this is a point of doctrine that must seperate Lutherans and Romans, despite the influence of more radical Protestantism that sometimes skewed the Lutheran Confessions and their adherents. This becomes, to my mind, a point of private piety, and one in which we have broad liberty.

Blessings be to you, this Lenten season.
To tie this all together with your above statement, it is wrong to place faith and trust in a saint if this is to the exclusion of Christ. But Christian fellowship is often a channel of his grace into our lives. So as a Catholic I place my faith and trust in Christ working through the intercession of the saints. Jesus can, and does, provide grace in a variety of ways, not just through Christian fellowship (and the intercession of saints), but Christian fellowship is a very important part of Christian living. I simply see the intercession of the saints as being part of the “big picture” of what such fellowship entails.
 
If I understand it properly, Rome does not compel anyone in our day to seek the intercession of the saints, but rather encourages, along the lines of reasoning which you aptly laid out below. I do not think this is a point of doctrine that must seperate Lutherans and Romans, despite the influence of more radical Protestantism that sometimes skewed the Lutheran Confessions and their adherents. This becomes, to my mind, a point of private piety, and one in which we have broad liberty.
Well said. And once again, I appreciate the quote you provided earlier from the Book of Concord. I agree with you that, seeing as the conversation between the OP and his friend is a conversation between a Catholic and a Lutheran, knowing the official teachings of both is the reasonable foundation for the discussion. Thanks to your post, we have the Lutheran perspective to add to the discussion. And I also believe when the time is taken for sincere dialog, one finds that Catholicism and Lutheranism is often “on the same page” on many subjects.
Blessings be to you, this Lenten season.
And to you as well!
 
Thank you all so much for these amazing posts! I’ll show them to my friend, if you don’t mind. I’m quite sure that I cannot articulate these posts properly to him. If you guys don’t mind, I’ll point him to this thread and have him read it. Thank you all very, very, much!
🙂 Peace be with you all 🙂
 
An ancient custom of the Catholic Church, invoking the saints and commending oneself to their intercession with God. The Cathars, the Waldensians, Wicliffe, Luther and more recently modernists attacked the legitimacy of that usage, rejecting it as idolatrous, as derogatory to the worship due Christ (the one Mediator, according to St. Paul, between man and God), and as a sign of little confidence in God’s mercy.

The Council of Trent, outlining the reasons of the ancient custom, defends its legitimacy and utility and reproves the contrary teaching as impious: “The Holy Synod orders all bishops, and all the others having the duty and charge of teaching, that - according to the usage of the Catholic and Apostolic Church, in force since the first times of the Christian religion, and according to the consensus of the Holy Fathers of the Church and the decrees of the Councils - they instruct accurately the faithful especially about the intercession and invocation of the saints . . . teaching them that the saints, ruling together with Christ, offer their prayers for men to God, and that it is good and useful to invoke them supplicantly and to have recourse to their prayers and to their powerful help in obtaining benefits from God through Jesus Christ, His Son our Lord, who is our only Redeemer and Saviour. Those who do not admit that the saints, blessed in heaven, should be invoked, or who say that the saints do not pray for men, or that . . . their invocation is idolatry, or . . . is contrary to the dignity of the one Mediator between God and men, Jesus Christ, or that it is stupid to supplicate with voice or thought those who reign in heaven: all these do think impiously.” In this decree, is found the solution of all aspects of the question.

1.) The saints can intercede for us in imitation of Jesus Christ, who (as Man) is always alive to intercede for us with the Father (Hebrews 7:25).

2.) The prayer we address to God is an act of latreutic cult because we believe that the omnipotent God can fulfill all our desires. The prayer made to the saints, on the other hand, is an act of mere dulia, because we expect the fulfillment of our desires not from their power, but from their intercession with God, who can grant us grace directly in view of their prayers and their merits, or can also work a miracle through means of them.

3.) The saints see in the beatific vision our conditions and our supplications.

4.) The intercession of the saints is directed to Christ the Mediator, through whom all heavenly favors descend upon us.

5.) God sees our needs and could provide directly, but it pleases the divine Wisdom to communicate His gifts through intermediaries. After Jesus, Mediator between God and men, Mary, the Mediatrix of all graces, excels over the angels and the saints, and so the Church addresses supplications to her in a special way.
Worker Priest,

Perhaps you might want review # 3 and how it relates to the Church’s teaching regarding Christ’s Mystical Body which is the Church.
 
To offer a confessional Lutheran approach, to your Lutheran dialogue, I would direct your friend back to the Book of Concord, which are the collection of Lutheran Confessions.

The Augsburg Confession, Article XXI, is reacting against the worship of saints, which had become an abuse of the Middle Ages (and in some parts of the world, continues to this day.) Denouncing the worship of the saints is something that both Lutherans and Roman Catholics can agree upon.

In the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, Article XXI, the same issue is expressed in greater detail. Here it is noted, in part:

"Our Confession approves honors to the saints. For here a threefold honor is to be approved. The first is thanksgiving. For we ought to give thanks to God because He has shown examples of mercy; because He has shown that He wishes to save men; because He has given teachers or other gifts to the Church. And these gifts, as they are the greatest, should be amplified, and the saints themselves should be praised, who
have faithfully used these gifts, just as Christ praises faithful businessmen, Matt. 25, 21. 23. The second service is the strengthening of our faith; when we see the denial forgiven Peter, we also are encouraged to believe the more that grace truly superabounds over sin, Rom. 5, 20. The third honor is the imitation, first, of faith, then of the other virtues, which every one should imitate according to his calling…

"Besides, we also grant that the angels pray for us. For there is a testimony in Zech. 1, 12, where an angel prays: O Lord of hosts, how long wilt Thou not have mercy on Jerusalem? Although concerning the saints we concede that, just as, when alive, they pray for the Church universal in general, so in heaven they pray for the Church in general, albeit no testimony concerning the praying of the dead is extant in the Scriptures, except the dream taken from the Second Book of Maccabees, 15, 14.

“Moreover, even supposing that the saints pray for the Church ever so much, yet it does not follow that they are to be invoked; although our Confession affirms only this, that Scripture does not teach the invocation of the saints, or that we are to ask the saints for aid. But since neither a command, nor a promise, nor an example can be produced from the Scriptures concerning the invocation of saints, it follows that conscience can have nothing concerning this invocation that is certain. And since prayer ought to be made from faith, how do we know that God approves this invocation? Whence do we know without the testimony of Scripture that the saints perceive the prayers of each one? … Therefore the adversaries ought not to force us to an uncertain matter, because a prayer without faith is not prayer.”

From the Lutheran perspective, the crux of the matter is faith and trust in Christ. Nothing should be compelled apart from the Holy Scriptures. The Lutheran Confessions do not expressly forbid requesting the saints to pray for us, and even acknowledge the Biblical truth that they do, indeed, pray for us. On the contrary, the Lutheran Confessions forbid that we place our hope and trust in the saints, but give this worship and faith to Christ alone.

Perhaps here is fruitful ground for your continued conversation?

Peace be with you.
Hi WP,
May I also add that, as we as Lutherans recognize the constant prayers of the Church Triumphant on our behalf, it would be a practice consistent with Lutheran teaching that way pray God to hear the prayers of His saints, just as we do in the prayer of the Church, when we pray for our fellow Christians and say, “Here our prayer”.

Jon
 
Tomster,

While I acknowledge that it is possible (even probable) that the saints see much, a Lutheran notes that surety of such things is not found in Holy Scripture, where neither a promise nor a command associated with it is found. As in many differences between our traditions, Lutherans simply stop at this point, and note that doctrine cannot be built solidly upon what is unsure in Holy Scripture, since the general revelation of Holy Scripture is sufficient for the salvation of souls.

On a personal level, I find it comforting to meditate on the closeness of the communion of the saints, and the potential for God to work through them in the world. I simply do not make of it a binding doctrine, but a pious opinion, and encourage liberty among those who desire either to contemplate it, or not.

Grace and peace to you.
Worker Priest,

Perhaps you might want review # 3 and how it relates to the Church’s teaching regarding Christ’s Mystical Body which is the Church.
 
Indeed-- well said, Jon.
Hi WP,
May I also add that, as we as Lutherans recognize the constant prayers of the Church Triumphant on our behalf, it would be a practice consistent with Lutheran teaching that way pray God to hear the prayers of His saints, just as we do in the prayer of the Church, when we pray for our fellow Christians and say, “Here our prayer”.

Jon
 
  • If you’re in heaven, why would you need to pray to God anymore? You’re with God now.
  • Why would Mary be kept from sin? If God was able to do that with Mary, why not with anyone else? Why the need for Jesus at all?
  1. Jesus says to pray always.
  2. God gives grace to who he wants. We need Jesus as an intercessor to God because we do not merit heaven
 
Tomster,

While I acknowledge that it is possible (even probable) that the saints see much, a Lutheran notes that surety of such things is not found in Holy Scripture, where neither a promise nor a command associated with it is found. As in many differences between our traditions, Lutherans simply stop at this point, and note that doctrine cannot be built solidly upon what is unsure in Holy Scripture, since the general revelation of Holy Scripture is sufficient for the salvation of souls.

On a personal level, I find it comforting to meditate on the closeness of the communion of the saints, and the potential for God to work through them in the world. I simply do not make of it a binding doctrine, but a pious opinion, and encourage liberty among those who desire either to contemplate it, or not.

Grace and peace to you.
With regard to the intercession of the Saints let it suffice to note with Aquinas that “prayer may be offered to a person in two ways, either so that he himself may grant it, or that he may obtain the favor from another. In the first way we pray only to God, because all our prayers should be directed to obtaining grace and glory, which God alone gives, according to the Psalmist (83): ‘The Lord will give grace and glory.’ But in the second way we pray to the angels and Saints, not that through them God may know our petitions, but that through their prayers and merits our petitions may be effective. Hence we read in the Apocalypse (8:4) that, ‘the smoke of the incense of the prayers of the saints ascended up before God from the hand of the Angel.’ And this is manifest also from the method which the Church uses in praying; for we ask the Trinity to have mercy upon us; but we ask the Saints to pray for us.” (Summa II, 11ae, Q. lxxxiii, art. 4.)
 
With regard to the intercession of the Saints let it suffice to note with Aquinas that “prayer may be offered to a person in two ways, either so that he himself may grant it, or that he may obtain the favor from another. In the first way we pray only to God, because all our prayers should be directed to obtaining grace and glory, which God alone gives, according to the Psalmist (83): ‘The Lord will give grace and glory.’ But in the second way we pray to the angels and Saints, not that through them God may know our petitions, but that through their prayers and merits our petitions may be effective. Hence we read in the Apocalypse (8:4) that, ‘the smoke of the incense of the prayers of the saints ascended up before God from the hand of the Angel.’ And this is manifest also from the method which the Church uses in praying; for we ask the Trinity to have mercy upon us; but we ask the Saints to pray for us.” (Summa II, 11ae, Q. lxxxiii, art. 4.)
And I as a Lutheran, and I suspect Workerpriest as well, truly undetstand the distinction made here. I have come to respect the practice of invocation of saints. I see many Catholics truly comforted by the practice. In addition, what I see in scripture, in an implicit way, gives me great pause before I would ever condemn it, most notably Luke 15:7, where Christ says: Just so, I tell you, there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents than over ninety-nine righteous persons who need no repentance.

So, while there may be no clear example, command, or promise regarding it, neither is there a rejection of it.

Jon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top