Interdenominational Relationships

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeBaptsitGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have a lot in common with this girl, and frankly with us catholics, BaptistGuy.

According to Catholic teaching on bioethics, it is not sinful to treat a disease, even if it leads to sterility as an unintended or “secondary” consequence. Are you interested in bioethical issues, BaptistGuy? I mean contraception, abortion, euthanasia, in vitro fertilization, organ donation, the use of cell lines from aborted babies, etc. Here’s a document from the Vatican (Vatican = the Pope and the leadership of the CC, in Vatican city), entitled Dignitas Personae, if you are interested in such issues: vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20081208_dignitas-personae_en.html

Here are some basics about how the Catholic Church understands the organization and the authority of the Church, or ecclesiology. (Ecclesia means Church in Latin)

Christ gave a special authority to Peter, and the other 11 Apostles, to “bind and lose” (see Matthew Chapter 16:15-19; Matthew 18:18). Peter’s successor today is the Pope, and the Apostles’ successors are the Bishops. Peter, and the Apostles (today the Pope, and the Bishops in communion with him) received the gift of the Holy Spirit to teach infallibly (without error) in matters of faith and morals. Thus, if I, a layperson, am confused about whether contraception, in vitro fertilization, or homosexual practice are sins or not, I have one place where I can receive an error-free answer - that place being the teaching authority (Magisterium) of the Catholic Church, i.e. the teachings of the Pope, the Bishops in communion with the Pope, and the Ecumenical Councils approved by the Pope. The reason why I need to listen to the Pope and Bishops is this: they received the charism (gift from the Holy Spirit) to discern and teach infallibly on matters of faith and morals. I never received that charism. I could err in my judgment, but they are protected from error through the gift of the Holy Spirit.
 
Hello everyone, I recently found this forum while looking on the internet for some relationship questions.

I personally am a Southern Baptist. I came here because a girl I have spoken to quite a few times is Catholic, and appears quite devout. (I have not even taken her on a date yet, I am asking early. It will also give me the chance to learn about Catholicism.)

What thoughts/concerns/pitfalls/what have you should I keep in mind should I carry a relationship forward?

Is there a good way to learn general details about the Catholic faith? I certainly know that what I saw portrayed on TV as a child is less than likely to be entirely accurate.

If this is the wrong forum, my apologies, just point me in the right direction.
Welcome to the forum! I think this is a fine place for you to be. This forum is pretty massive though, so I am going to subscribe to your thread. That way I can come back to it from time to time. This may be a way for some of us Catholics to get to know our Baptist brothers and sisters better also.

I don’t think there are pitfalls exactly, but there will be differences in some of your religious traditions. Both of our churches are biblically based (a surprise to some Evangelicals I have known), but Catholicism also relies on the teaching magisterium of the Church. The tradition of the magisterium influences how we interpret the Bible. I also think our bible contains more books than the typical bible of other Christian churches.

We are also a sacramental church, believing that in the seven sacraments of the church we receive special graces = Reconciliation to be able to resist sinning, Marriage to seal our relationship to each other, Baptism and Confirmation seal us to God and Confirmation stengthens us into our adult Catholicism. In Holy Eucharist we do believe in the real presence of Christ in the Bread and Wine. The other two are Holy Orders and Sacrament of the Sick. Holy Orders is when priests are ordained. Sacrament of the sick is for the spiritual and indeed, physical strengthening of the ill. We used to reserve this for the dying, but is really beneficial for others. I had to have non-life threatening surgery a few years ago and asked to receive the sacrament.

Well that is a bit about Catholicism - a lot really! You may want more depth so just ask.

I commend you for seeking information before you jump into a relationship. My best to you both.
 
Christ gave a special authority to Peter, and the other 11 Apostles, to “bind and lose” (see Matthew Chapter 16:15-19; Matthew 18:18). Peter’s successor today is the Pope, and the Apostles’ successors are the Bishops. Peter, and the Apostles (today the Pope, and the Bishops in communion with him) received the gift of the Holy Spirit to teach infallibly (without error) in matters of faith and morals. Thus, if I, a layperson, am confused about whether contraception, in vitro fertilization, or homosexual practice are sins or not, I have one place where I can receive an error-free answer - that place being the teaching authority (Magisterium) of the Catholic Church, i.e. the teachings of the Pope, the Bishops in communion with the Pope, and the Ecumenical Councils approved by the Pope. The reason why I need to listen to the Pope and Bishops is this: they received the charism (gift from the Holy Spirit) to discern and teach infallibly on matters of faith and morals. I never received that charism. I could err in my judgment, but they are protected from error through the gift of the Holy Spirit.
This is one of the things about the Catholic Church I have issues with. I do not believe in the infallability of the Pope. As far as I am concerned, he is just another guy, while he may be well educated, and with an opinion worth listening to, I would not give him any more deference than I give my own minister (whom I have grilled when I questioned what he had preached, to his credit he always had a good answer, which is why he is still my minister.) I firmly believe ANY individual can read, pray, and be granted understanding. In Catholic words, I would say anyone could receive charism, if God so willed it. I share this not to be rude or question your beliefs, just to acknowledge where I stand. (I almost did not post this as my purpose here is to learn, but another poster wanted to learn about us Baptists, so I hope I do not step on your toes.)

As for bioethical issues, I keep myself up to date on them, though not from a religious source as you gave me. Sadly, my experience has shown them to be less about ethics and more about whatever they want to be about. I remember reading one Harvard bioethicist speak about how abortion should be allowed, even after childbirth (until age 2 if I recall.)

Ohana, the sacraments! A good thing you brought them up. I remember a coworker talked about one of them once, and we quizzed her, but it has been a while.

I asked this of fermat earlier, and would welcome answers. (The quote is from fermat, earlier in the thread).
Catholics also hold that bible alone is not the sole rule of faith for a Christian. Is probably the biggest difference you will see.
What else is the Catholic faith based on that is equal to the Bible?
 
BaptistGuy, I’m a cradle Catholic, yet I admit I was puzzled by the whole claim of Papal infallibility, and why does the Catholic Church believe God uses this strange mechanism, i.e. granting this gift to one single person, that he can’t err when teaching on matters of faith and morals.

To give you an answer, I will have to start with the Old Testament, and how God used Moses as a single leader of Israel. Then, why I believe a careful reading of Matthew 16:15-19 supports exactly that claim, that God will protect the Church built on Peter from the gates of hell ever prevailing against it. Next, we would need to go over the Early Church Fathers, and the Primitive Church of the first century and beyond, and how they all interpreted Christ’s promise as giving this special authority to Peter and his successor the Pope, to settle disputed issues whenever there was internal disagreement in the Church on matters of faith and morals.

I won’t go into the details, but we hash and rehash these issues over and over again in the Non-Catholic Religions section of CAF. You will see there many threads entitled “Papal authority”, “Papal infallibility”, “Peter and the Keys”, and so on. Take your time, listen to our arguments at your leisure, and decide later on whether our arguments hold water. I was at a cross-roads some 7 years ago, between Catholicism which believes the claims of Papal infallibility, and Eastern Orthodoxy which rejects these claims (and yes my motivation came from meeting an Eastern Orthodox woman :D).

I spent an awful lot of time researching the beliefs of the Primitive Church and the Early Church Fathers, and of course reading and re-reading the relevant passages in the Bible on which the Catholic Church bases the claim that the Pope is infallible when teaching in matters of faith and morals. This is not going to be something you can decide on quickly, if my own experience is any relevant.

Take your time. Educate yourself at your own pace and make up your mind at your leisure, whether the claims of the Catholic Church are trustworthy or not, in view of the biblical texts, and in view of the understanding of the Early Church. The Early Church is important because they were the first generations, the generations of the Apostles and those directly succeeding them.
 
Hi BG.

I would only add a couple of things to this thread.

You’ve asked what else is there besides the bible and you’ve expressed dissatisfaction with the idea of papal infallibility. Both very common objections. In reality, they have the same root issue: Authority. Did Jesus leave us a shepherd to feed and tend His sheep (John 21:15-17)? Will that shepherd be protected from error (Isiah 22:21-24, Matthew 16:18)?

It may surprise you to learn that when you proclaim the bible to to be the infallible word of God, you are implicitly accepting papal authority. The canon of scripture was defined a group of Catholic bishops in the late 4th century and approved by Pope St. Damasus. I would like to recommend the book, Where We Got the Bible: Out Debt to the Catholic Church (active hyperlink).

This is all important because while we as Catholics firmly believe in the authority of scripture, the infallible of scripture and the absolute necessity of scripture, we do not believe that the bible by itself contains everything that Jesus wanted us to know and believe. There was a church for hundreds of years before there was a formal bible. That church learned by word of mouth and by letter. We formalized (guided by the spirit of course) the letter part. Understanding that will make talking to you lady friend a little easier.

God bless!
 
I may have missed it, but our bishop’s website has a copy of the Catechism on it usccb.org/beliefs-and-teachings/what-we-believe/catechism/catechism-of-the-catholic-church/
There is also many other valuable things. All of it starting points. The depths of the words open up to you as you go deeper and open up more to the Holy Spirit.

As fat as the Cathechism is, it is still only the tip of the iceberg…there are also papal writings, that help explain catechesis more specifically, and then there are the church fathers. You may be able to find them online.

Scott Hahn has a book…“Rome Sweet Home” and Patric Madrid “Surprised by Truth”. where they address many of the things you might struggle to understand, as the philosophy and concept is from a different perspective than the one you were raised in.

One of the things that you might end up finding difficult, is that you as the father and husband in a Catholic home, could be very frustrating as many of your beliefs would not be affirmed as much as you would like them to be. Many are nearly the same.

Of course, many times people who are both Catholic would have worse problems that a baptist guy as at least you take your faith seriously. Just being Catholic in name alone does not make you equally yoked.

Marriage is supposed to be a communion of becoming one with Christ. It is a prayer. Conflict is a big deal in many ways in a marriage. Spiritual conflict can tear you up as marriage is a prayer of human love meeting with divine. If you are not on the same page spiritually (or at least foundationally) then it is quite a cross to bear.

I think with your open mind, and curiosity you could grow in understanding and it won’t be a stumbling block eventually. Mary, the staints, Eucharist, the Church, etc…there is a pretty standard list of differences, but if you read for understanding with an openness to the Holy Spirit, you will find you “get” it.
 
BG, I would like to address the issue of “am I, average Joe, able to discern what’s right and what’s wrong?” “Do I even need someone else (Pope and Bishops) to tell me what’s right and what’s wrong, when I can read the Bible and decide for myself?”

Some years ago I made friends with a number of devoutly religious people. One of them was a Nazarene, and he believed we should never take arms to defend our country or ourselves, based on the Bible’s commandment to turn the other cheek if someone hits you. I also met a Jehovah’s Witness, a guy who was very dedicated to things of God, and spent hours and hours studying the Bible almost every day - he also believed it was sinful to take arms. That experience was the beginning of my troubles of discernment, because I did serve in the army, and I did take arms to protect innocent civilians, women and children, and the Catholic Church said it was not sinful what I did. Essentially, here we had two camps of devout Christians, both camps prayerfully considering the teachings of the Bible, and they couldn’t even agree on something as simple as “am I allowed to take arms to defend my country, and to protect innocent civilians?”.

And I felt, we are in trouble here. We Christians disagree, so is there an objective right and wrong, and why didn’t God provide a mechanism for us to know what’s right and what’s wrong?

Then, I met the conundrum of artificial birth control (ABC). The Catholic Church reads the story of Onan in the OT, who spilled his semen on the floor, and the CC concludes that all forms of ABC are sinful - coitus interruptus, condoms, birth control pills. But the mainline Protestant Churches disagree. They believe ABC is not sinful, when done by husband and wife in a marriage.

Again, who’s right and who’s wrong? Is ABC sinful or not?

Next, there came the issue of “committed homosexual relationships”. The Catholic Church (and I think the Southern Baptist Church) say it’s sinful to practice homosexuality, however the Episcopalian Church says such couples should be allowed to “marry” each other, and that it’s anti-gay bigotry to oppose their “marriage”.

Now, if I side with the Catholics, the Episcopalians say I’m a bigot. If I side with the Episcopalians, the Catholics will say I condone a grave sin, a sin for which God destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah. So, who’s right and who’s wrong? :banghead: And why can’t Christians of various denominations agree on whether homosexual practice is sinful or not, when these Christian denominations are reading the same Bible, taking their clues from the same Bible? :o

Another more modern bioethical issue is IVF (in vitro fertilization). Thousands of Protestant couples conceived babies in a test tube, and the practice is not considered sinful by mainline Protestant Churches. But the Catholic Church teaches that the “unitive” and “procreative” aspects of the marital act should never be separated. Engaging in the marital act while using a barrier (i.e. condoms) to block procreation is a sin because the couple intends to unite without procreating. And it’s also sinful (according to Catholic teaching) to procreate without uniting, i.e. to conceive a baby in a test tube rather than through the marital embrace which unites the spouses.

Again, who’s right and who’s wrong? Am I a coldhearted person, denying infertile couples the opportunity to conceive children through IVF, if I side with the Catholic Church? Or, do I show “empathy” to such couples and end up condoning what the CC calls a sin, namely conceiving a child through IVF?

As far as I’m concerned, disagreements such as these convinced me that there’s a problem of “discernment”, or problem of “authority” in Christendom. If the Bible and our private consciences are the sole mechanisms that God provided us for discerning right from wrong, the system clearly doesn’t work. We have groups of Christians on both sides of the issues, Christians who prayerfully read the Bible and try to discern right from wrong, very sincere and dedicated Christians, and yet they come to fundamentally different and conflicting conclusions all the time! :eek:

Jesus says in Matthew 16:18, “on this Rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it”. Now, let’s take gay marriage. If God truly wants us to have gay marriage, as the Episcopalians (and also certain Lutherans) believe, the gates of hell already prevailed against that part of the Church which, behaving as bigots, opposes gay marriage. Conversely, if “gay marriage” is still a grave sin like it was at Sodom and Gomorrah, than the gates of hell prevailed against those Christians (Episcopalians and others) who teach that it’s OK to have gay marriage.

Now, the Catholic understanding of Matthew 16:18 is that Jesus is saying, the gates of hell will not prevail against the community (Ecclesia = Church = community) built on Peter the head of the Apostles, the Church or community that stays in communion with Peter. Of course, the successors of Peter are called the Popes. Thus, the admittedly rather outrageous claim of the Catholic Church is this: if you want to know whether you can take arms to defend your country and to defend unarmed civilians against would-be criminals, if you want to know whether gay marriage, artificial birth control, in vitro fertilization, etc are sinful or not, listen to Peter and the community (Church) built on Peter. Peter received that authority and that gift to discern right from wrong, and thus the Church built on Peter will never fall to the attacks of Satan (gates of hell). However, the rest of us received no such guarantee, and thus we may end up like we did recently with gay marriage, where we have two groups of committed Christians who both read the Bible, who both pray and try to discern, and who still disagree in the end.
 
BaptistGuy,

I am jumping into this thread after 27 other posts, but agree with this early one:
(Important note: This is much, much better than the similarly titled “Idiot’s Guide”)

Asking questions here will give you only a sampling of your friend’s faith. This book is inexpensive, interesting and orthodox. Learn what the largest Christian community (1.2 BILLION) across the planet believes! If you read it, you are likely to still have questions and the forum will be great at answering them.
 
I just wanted to add a technical detail about mixed marriages between Catholic and non-Catholic Christians. Such marriages are not approved “by default” by the Catholic Bishop of the Catholic party, but a dispensation is given to the Catholic party, allowing him/her to marry the non-Catholic Christian, if the Parish Priest of the Catholic party determines that the Catholic party will not be hindered in his/her free exercise of his/her own Catholic religion.

Regarding the offspring, it used to be that both the Catholic and non-Catholic parties were requested by the Catholic Church to promise to baptize and raise the children in the Catholic Church, but this is no longer the case. Since a few (several?) years ago, the Catholic Church asks the Catholic party to promise to do his/her best to have the children baptized and raised as Catholics. The non-Catholic party is not requested anymore to make such promise. However, the Catholic Church informs the non-Catholic party that the Catholic party made this particular promise. The Catholic Church will not give the go-ahead to the marriage unless the non-Catholic party understands, and does not object to the fact that the Catholic party made this promise.

Of course life is a lot simpler and easier when both spouses belong to the same Church and worship together, but for those who can’t come to an agreement on which one Church to belong to, and if they are still willing to take the leap of faith and marry each other, what I posted above is the actual present policy of the Catholic Church according to the best of my knowledge.
 
Hello everyone, I recently found this forum while looking on the internet for some relationship questions.

I personally am a Southern Baptist. I came here because a girl I have spoken to quite a few times is Catholic, and appears quite devout. (I have not even taken her on a date yet, I am asking early. It will also give me the chance to learn about Catholicism.)

What thoughts/concerns/pitfalls/what have you should I keep in mind should I carry a relationship forward?

Is there a good way to learn general details about the Catholic faith? I certainly know that what I saw portrayed on TV as a child is less than likely to be entirely accurate.

If this is the wrong forum, my apologies, just point me in the right direction.
Hi SomeBG, yes there are good ways to learn and this is a good forum for questions. I would start you at the parent website of this forum www.catholic.com. There is a search engine there that will give you a world of tracts and information.

Try Newadvent.org for the Catholic Encyclopedia and Catechism.

I think you’ll find the education interesting. For a “flavor” of Catholic thought take a look at WordOnFire.org (Fr. Robert Barron) “standingonmyhead” (Fr. Dwight Longenecker) “EWTN.com” for TV shows, audio and text libraries, etc.

You will find that there is quite a bit of difference and many similarities between our religions and hope you are enriched by the reading and listening…
 
Infant baptism. Baptist granny will not be thrilled about coming to that party.

Sunday and Holy Days of Obligation (aka, no Easter Egg hunt on Good Friday or Holy Saturday and YES we go to Church on Christmas no matter what day of the week it falls on - if Christmas is on Saturday we go to Church two days in a row :eek:).

You would never be able to receive Communion with your wife. She cannot receive at the Baptist congregation and you cannot at Mass.

“Why does daddy not pray the Rosary with us”?

Either that bread at communion IS the Body of Christ or it is not. Kids are smart, they know two things cannot be opposite and true, so, which one are you going to teach them?
 
I had a response to everyone, it was long, and then it got lost because I got logged out during typing. So, here we go again…

Piper, I think you are right; this will take time to read it all. I am not changed on my view that the popes are fallible, one need only look over the Popes of the past to see obvious flaws. Benedict IX for an obvious one.

Fermat, while I may accept the Bible as divine, and will acknowledge the early Catholic church did a marvelous job in putting it together under that divine guidance, I have a hard time seeing how that means every pope will be infallible, and that I accept the authority of the pope. I do believe you to be 100% correct regarding early Church communication, still, I would say the Bible contains everything God decided we needed to follow Him.

Mama, thanks for the materials. I will note, we are not even dating. I just want to know more about her religion. Even if we never do, it will be good to know. You brought up Mary, I have a hard time seeing why she gets so much attention. She was the Mother of Jesus, and the Angel accurately noted she was blessed among women, but it seems almost as if she is deified by the Catholic Church. Am I missing something?

Piper, to be clear, I never said anything about just deciding for myself, what I said earlier was “I firmly believe ANY individual can read, pray, and be granted understanding”. That understanding comes from God. The issues you described dealing with regarding other groups comes from reading, and making their own decisions. Coincidentally, I would even say this is a major issue for society, and it became so because of the lukewarm churches that are merely putting a Christian veneer over worldly desires. An easy litmus test is to find out how these other Christians determine good. You mention quite a few issues, I will use homosexuality as our example if you please. Those who say homosexuality is acceptable, are doing so because they have decided it is good to do so. It is good for their friendships, and makes them happy. The real reason ANYTHING is good is because God says so. Why is the world, and everything in it good? In Genesis, after God created it, he said it was good. Why is homosexuality bad, regardless of whether it is a pair of guys, or beautiful women? Because God has said quite clearly it is an abomination. I would submit to you, that those groups who call us bigots because we take God’s side, have an argument with Him, and not us. (I find it slightly amusing that when pointed out this, they will refuse to touch a Bible in support of their position, but resort immediately to how it doesn’t feel right that homosexuals can’t do it. They seriously think their feelings trump God.) Because they refuse to do as God wills, and instead plan to do what “feels right”, it does not matter that you read from the same Bible.

Now, on the seed dumping (Onan, Genesis 38), I will flatly say the Catholic Church got it wrong. Onan was not killed for wasting his seed, he was killed for refusing to make his dead older brothers wife pregnant. There are quite a few reasons this was bad, one, it was his duty to continue his brothers line. Two, God had made a promise earlier, to make descendents like stars. Well, when you refuse, you are standing in the way of God. Like jumping in front of a moving semi on the highway, the results will not be good.

Luther, thanks for the seconding.

Piper, do Catholics have to obtain permission to marry?

JRRT, thanks for the suggestions. Also, if your name is a reference to Tolkien, then I must say, you sir have a good taste in authors.

Castello, are you implying that if the Bible and Catholic Church were to conflict, the Church would be right and the Bible wrong? Also, parts of the Bible actually predate the Church.

Mark, I was unaware about the post marriage part. You are psychic it would seem. Still, not an issue for me either way, though good to know.

Castello, my “Baptist granny” as you kindly refer to my Grandma, is actually the widowed wife of a Methodist pastor. She actually would be thrilled. (But I have no intentions on having any such party, nor doing the infant baptism.) Spiritually, what is the purpose of infant baptism to Catholics? Acknowledging as a parent you plan to raise this child faithfully? If so, it isn’t for the kid, it is for the parents. I have never heard the term Holy Days of Obligation, I assume that this would roughly analogous to a High Holy day in Judaism? Egg hunts won’t be an issue, I do not celebrate pagan holidays, nor will my family.

You are actually mistaken, I could receive communion with my wife (assuming I actually marry this girl) at my Baptist church. While the Catholic church would deny me (anyone want to explain that?) my church would not deny her. My church takes the original Catholic/universal view on Christianity, if you are a Christian, we would gladly commune with you.
The rosary is something I know nothing about, and will need it explained.
I actually would agree with the Catholic church, and that the bread and wine/grape juice transubstantiates into the flesh and blood of Christ, as he said it was when he had his supper. (A Catholic co-worker used that word once, and when I asked her about she explained the Catholic view to me. That is one Catholic position I know of, but agree with.)
 
BG, just a quick post addressing some issues first. This site can be notorious for crashing. I usually type my text into the reply box, and then before I hit the “preview” or “submit” button, I hit ctrl-a (highlight the whole text) and ctrl-c (copy the whole text). Then, if the website crashes on me, I just go back to the “reply to thread” screen and hit ctrl-v to paste the whole text into the box again. I lost the stuff I typed more than once, before I made this resolution never to hit the preview/submit button before backing up my text first.

The Catholic party actually needs a permission, called “dispensation”, from his/her Bishop in order to marry the non-Catholic party. This is in recognition of the fact that the CC has a special duty to ensure that the Catholic person entering the marriage is not in danger of being prohibited or hindered from exercising his/her Catholic religion.
 
Castello, my “Baptist granny” as you kindly refer to my Grandma, is actually the widowed wife of a Methodist pastor. She actually would be thrilled. (But I have no intentions on having any such party, nor doing the infant baptism.) Spiritually, what is the purpose of infant baptism to Catholics? Acknowledging as a parent you plan to raise this child faithfully? If so, it isn’t for the kid, it is for the parents. I have never heard the term Holy Days of Obligation, I assume that this would roughly analogous to a High Holy day in Judaism? Egg hunts won’t be an issue, I do not celebrate pagan holidays, nor will my family.

You are actually mistaken, I could receive communion with my wife (assuming I actually marry this girl) at my Baptist church. While the Catholic church would deny me (anyone want to explain that?) my church would not deny her. My church takes the original Catholic/universal view on Christianity, if you are a Christian, we would gladly commune with you.
The rosary is something I know nothing about, and will need it explained.
I actually would agree with the Catholic church, and that the bread and wine/grape juice transubstantiates into the flesh and blood of Christ, as he said it was when he had his supper. (A Catholic co-worker used that word once, and when I asked her about she explained the Catholic view to me. That is one Catholic position I know of, but agree with.)
My point is, a Catholic parent will desire to baptize each child shortly after birth, this wipes away original sin and marks this child as a Christian.

A Catholic is forbidden to take communion in a Baptist Church - to do so would be a grave sin.

And if you find Easter to be pagan, then, what is Christianity about without the resurrection?

My point being, to steal a line from a great film, a fish and a bird may fall in love, but, where can they make a home?

Let this Catholic woman court and marry a Catholic man. You cannot share faith, what a sad way to begin a marriage.
 
Piper, that makes sense.

Cast, Easter is pagan. While many Christians have appropriated it, and think it good because it is Christianized, I do not agree. The eggs, rabbits etc are all throwbacks and I personally have no part of it, and in my eyes Easter has no part of Christianity. I personally WILL celebrate what Christ did, that was die on the cross for my sins, and conquer death when he was resurrected.

I also would ask you to re-read my very first post. I am not even dating her, at this point I am considering whether to go forward there. My purpose here is to learn about Catholicism.

Why exactly is a Catholic forbidden to commune at a Baptist church?
 
Easter is the most Holy Day of Christianity. Every Sunday is a “little Easter”.

Please, learn more about Catholicism and you will find the truth and beauty of Christianity in fullness.
 
Another quick post (since you raise several good points worth addressing separately) - on papal infallibility. The Catholic understanding is that God grants the charism (gift) that the Pope is unable to teach error, in matters of faith and morals. It has a number of limitations.

First, here’s Peter whom we Catholics regard as the first Pope, the first leader of the Apostles. He was a sinful man himself, and he denied three times that he knew Jesus, when Jesus was arrested. Also, he tried to dissuade Jesus from going to die in Jerusalem. Yet, in Mathhew 16:18 Jesus called him Rock, said that he was going to build his Church on this rock, and the gates of hell will not prevail against this Church. Jesus also tells Peter, “I will give you the Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven, and whatever you bind on Earth will be bound in Heaven, whatever you loosen on Earth will be loosed in Heaven”. So, Jesus gives unprecedented power and authority to a sinful man.

There’s a similar precedent with Moses, because Moses was a killer who once killed an Egyptian soldier, a sinful man, and at a point later he doubted Israel would prevail against the enemy, for which God punished Moses so that he had to die at the threshold of the promised land; he led Israel to the threshold but he, himself had to die without being able to enter. Yet, God used this weak and sinful Moses to lead Israel, God gave him unprecedented power and authority, and Israel never got another leader instead of Moses, no matter how much they disliked Moses and no matter how much they grumbled against him.

To return to Peter - elsewhere in Luke 22:31, Jesus tells that Satan wished to sift the Apostles, but Jesus prayed for Peter (for Peter alone, not for the rest of the Apostles!) that his faith would not falter, and that he would strengthen his brethren “once he returned”. (once he returned from denying Jesus 3 times) Another indication, according to Catholic thought, that Peter was put in charge of protecting the Church, and Jesus’ efficacious prayer, which he curiously uttered for Peter and Peter alone, would protect him from faltering.

Now, with these scriptural foundations, the Catholic understanding is this: the Pope is not protected from personal sin, and he is only supernaturally protected from teaching error on faith and morals, errors that would throw the whole Church into believing and following erroneous teaching. Thus, if Pope Benedict IX was a practicing homosexual, fornicator, and murderer, that doesn’t interfere with the fact that he was protected from teaching error. He never taught that homosexuality is not sinful, or that fornication, and murder are not sinful.

The point is, Papal Infallibility as defined by the Catholic Church does not mean Papal Sinlessness. It’s a very restricted concept, it only means that the Pope cannot teach error in his official duty of teacher on matters of faith and morals. Also, since it’s restricted to matters of faith and morals, which are necessary to protect the Church from the gates of hell prevailing against it, the Catholic Church does not believe, for example, that the Pope would be infallible in making business decisions while serving as CEO of a company.

Papal infallibility, like many other Catholic concepts of theology and dogma, is not immediately self-explanatory or intuitive. We need to read the Catholic Church’s own definition of Papal Infallibility, to understand what does the Catholic Church mean by that concept.
 
Piper, that makes sense.

Cast, Easter is pagan. While many Christians have appropriated it, and think it good because it is Christianized, I do not agree. The eggs, rabbits etc are all throwbacks and I personally have no part of it, and in my eyes Easter has no part of Christianity.
and I suppose you other names for the English days of the week, given that they are named after pagan gods?

Calling Easter a pagan holiday commits the genetic fallacy: the origin of a tradition (and particularly innocuous ones such as searching for eggs hidden by a rabbit) is irrelevant to the current understanding, and ignores that truth can be found in non-Christian practices. Every religion on earth loves green growth, but that doesn’t make it buddhist or muslim to celebrate spring, it means its a catholic with a small “c” thing, universally beautiful and true, and therefore accepted by the Catholic Church.

You could take it to the extreme and say that Christians can’t use the symbolism of the cross, because it was a pagan execution method. Quite to the contrary, is there anything better than taking what was once un-Christian and then Christianizing it?
Why exactly is a Catholic forbidden to commune at a Baptist church?
Baptists do not believe in transubstantiation, among other things
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top