Interested conservative/"ultra" conservative dress

  • Thread starter Thread starter Miguelita
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’ve personally never seen a Catholic dress like this, but if that’s what you want to do, then go for it!

With that being said, in all honesty, if I saw someone dressed like that I’d immediately think they were a member of some fundamentalist protestant faith, and not Catholic. But who cares? If you like dressing like that and if it makes you feel closer to the faith while not hurting anyone else, then why not?

Let people think what they want! 👍
😃

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
To paraphrase your question: Is there a way to dress like a Mennonite without being mistaken for a Mennonite in Mennonite country?

The short answer is: no. If you don’t want to be mistaken for a Mennonite, then you will probably have to find a new look. May I suggest retro-chic. You can find retro-chic dresses and skirts that are classy, modest, feminine, flowy, and even flowery and fun, if that’s what suits your fancy. I LOVE the retro dresses on shabby apple. Some are a little pricey, but they are gorgeous! Here’s a few lovely pieces for inspiration:

Dresses:
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1331_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1530_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/907_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1523_2_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1098_2_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1570_1_.jpg

Skirts:
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1502_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1415_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1296_1_.jpg

Aprons and accessories:
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/666_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/p-1517-dusty-rose-headband.aspx
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1432_1_.jpg
 
I like the very flared classic fifties ones, but the rest aren’t too my taste. I don’t like skirts above the knee, or skirts that are fitted or tight. The dress with the little Peter Pan collar is nice though, and I do especially think those aprons are adorable! I’m afraid I can’t wear fitted dresses though, not with buttons. I’m very very thin around the waist and very…not…on top. Which is why I don’t buy clothes online. I wonder if I could find a similar pattern, lengthen the skirt and sleeves and take in the waist. thank you for the links.
 
I like things like this

cattlekate.com/store/womans-western-wear/1800s-period-attire-western-dresses/prairie-dancer-dress

And I don’t see what’s wrong with that. 🤷 I posted this thread to share my view, bring up the concerns I DID have (which are not the concerns brought up by posters here, which I find a non issue) and to see if anyone else shared my view.
That’s because there IS nothing wrong with that. I’m still not sure what the fuss is about. 🤷

Only thing is, I hope you live somewhere cold! You wouldn’t be able to get away with wearing that where I live, unless you wanted to have a heat stroke. 👍
 
That’s because there IS nothing wrong with that. I’m still not sure what the fuss is about. 🤷

Only thing is, I hope you live somewhere cold! You wouldn’t be able to get away with wearing that where I live, unless you wanted to have a heat stroke. 👍
What I like to do is buy all cotton, and if the dress has longer sleeves, I widen them out so they’re airy, and wear lighter colors. It does get very hot where I live, but it doesn’t bother me, unless I’m layering, or I’m wearing something synthetic, like a nylon slip. It’s AMAZING how hot it gets with just a little bit of polyester 0.0
 
What I like to do is buy all cotton, and if the dress has longer sleeves, I widen them out so they’re airy, and wear lighter colors. It does get very hot where I live, but it doesn’t bother me, unless I’m layering, or I’m wearing something synthetic, like a nylon slip. It’s AMAZING how hot it gets with just a little bit of polyester 0.0
I see now you’re from the Midwest. Pretty chilly up there. :winter:

I’m sure you’ll be fine.
 
I see now you’re from the Midwest. Pretty chilly up there. :winter:

I’m sure you’ll be fine.
Oh MY no! I’m from sourthern Kansas, actually. We call it the midwest, but maybe you’re thinking upwards of the Dakotas? Like I said, Kansas, where it can get to well over 100! but the wind is strong here, and I’ve found a long cotton skirt and elbow sleeves aren’t any hotter than capris and a t shirt 🙂
 
I like things like this

cattlekate.com/store/womans-western-wear/1800s-period-attire-western-dresses/prairie-dancer-dress

And I don’t see what’s wrong with that. 🤷 I posted this thread to share my view, bring up the concerns I DID have (which are not the concerns brought up by posters here, which I find a non issue) and to see if anyone else shared my view.
This looks like period dress, just something you’d choose because you like it and don’t care that it is on the costume-y end. People might think you’re a bit eccentric, but unless you add the little cap typical of the sect, I don’t think they’d think you’re a Mennonite. I’d be more concerned that they’ll think you write cowboy poetry, if I cared at all what they think. It isn’t that costume-y, particularly if you don’t live in a very fashion-forward city.

IOW, you’re going to look like a guy would if he had a thing for pearl buttons and bolo ties. Not religious, more like you have a thing for the past…if people think about you that much, which most of them won’t. (We aren’t as interesting to the rest of the world as we tend to think.) But no, I don’t think people are going to conclude your aim is modesty.
 
It looks more western/prairie to me than Mennonite or FLDS to me. Some of it’s really cute.

Enjoy it!
 
I like things like this

cattlekate.com/store/womans-western-wear/1800s-period-attire-western-dresses/prairie-dancer-dress

And I don’t see what’s wrong with that. 🤷 I posted this thread to share my view, bring up the concerns I DID have (which are not the concerns brought up by posters here, which I find a non issue) and to see if anyone else shared my view.
I just want to say that I would love to dress like Dr. Quinn. However, my husband would be completely embarrassed, and I don’t like standing out. If we had a farm I would totally dress prairie while on the land. If you don’t mind standing out, I see absolutely nothing wrong with it.
 
Oh MY no! I’m from sourthern Kansas, actually. We call it the midwest, but maybe you’re thinking upwards of the Dakotas? Like I said, Kansas, where it can get to well over 100! but the wind is strong here, and I’ve found a long cotton skirt and elbow sleeves aren’t any hotter than capris and a t shirt 🙂
Oh haha. I guess it’s cold to my standards. I live in Florida.

When I think of the midwest, I think of snow… but I guess south Kansas is probably the warmer part of the midwest. 🙂
 
I love the long gypsy skirts, but can never seem to find a pretty blouse to wear them with!
I wear a casual yet modest top with the skirts and pants. It does take a bit of looking to find them in a plus size (that I am) but have found them mainly in thrift/charity places, consignment shops and yard sales. I also have some scarves and shawls to cover up the cleavage exposure that so many plus size designers seem to include in many tops for us larger ladies for Mass & the office.
 
Wear what you like and don’t worry about what others think. The famous Judith Martin (Miss Manners) apparently also dresses in a throwback style, preferring flowing ankle-length skirts and long ‘puff sleeve’ blouses (sort of an Anne of Green Gables look, I think). She has alluded to this several times in her columns.

Look at how she chose to be dressed for her National Gallery portrait:

washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/the-portrait-of-a-lady-judith-martin-on-sitting-for-victor-edelstein/2011/03/17/AFWmqSxC_story.html

If you’re worried about being mistaken for Amish or something like that, you could always accessorize the dress with something modern.
 
If you’re worried about being mistaken for Amish or something like that, you could always accessorize the dress with something modern.
…or something Western, or something Catholic, or don’t pouf your hair too high in the front, so as to have an FLDS look…or just wear enough jewelry of any kind -the Amish & FLDS don’t do that. 🙂
 
To paraphrase your question: Is there a way to dress like a Mennonite without being mistaken for a Mennonite in Mennonite country?

The short answer is: no. If you don’t want to be mistaken for a Mennonite, then you will probably have to find a new look. May I suggest retro-chic. You can find retro-chic dresses and skirts that are classy, modest, feminine, flowy, and even flowery and fun, if that’s what suits your fancy. I LOVE the retro dresses on shabby apple. Some are a little pricey, but they are gorgeous! Here’s a few lovely pieces for inspiration:

Dresses:
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1331_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1530_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/907_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1523_2_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1098_2_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1570_1_.jpg

Skirts:
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1502_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1415_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1296_1_.jpg

Aprons and accessories:
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/666_1_.jpg
shabbyapple.com/p-1517-dusty-rose-headband.aspx
shabbyapple.com/images/product/large/1432_1_.jpg
Thanks!👍
 
Hello, I have a question for the ladies/families here. Have any of you had a personal reform in dress after a conversion, reversion, or at any point in your spiritual life?

I reverted to the faith about 4 years ago, and I’ve recently decided I want to start dressing differently. I grew up in shorts and tanks and the like, and I’ve no problem with them, or pants, sleeveless shirts, etc, but ever since I was a little girl I felt that I was a lady and I wanted to dress like one, and that God wanted me to reflect the feminine ideals I held as a part of my Catholic faith. No issue, right? many women today are doing the “dresses only” thing, going for more traditional attire.

Well, I’ve always been drawn especially to old-fashioned gowns. Regency to Victorian to Edwardian, and especially to ruffled prairie dresses. In late high school, I started wearing long peasant skirts and jumpers and button up blouses and denim dresses, all of a fairly modern sense, though. But now, being away from a judgemental family, I’m feeling drawn again to show my personal sensibilities of modesty and feminine dress with the long, collared dresses I’ve always thought were so pretty. WE have a large German menonite population here, and their pretty dresses always make me more aware of my own style of dress, and my desire to follow my sense of personal dignity. I feel so joyul, feminine, and find my prayers, my religious studies and my Church attendance are much more orderly and focused when I feel like I’m dressed to reflect my beliefs.

I still feel somewhat self conscious, though. The clothes I want to wear are NOT fashionable at all; think FLDS in the nineties; wide ruffled collars, pintucks, patterns with roses and trellis flowers. I don’t want to dress in a way that suggests I’m a Menonite, or Amish, or fundamentalist mormon, bt I do find the style of clothing they wear reflects what i want to show in my Catholic devotion.

Anyway, in conclusion, what are your thoughts on Catholics following an ultra-conservative style of dress? I’ve seen sites on the PLain Catholics, but I don’t mean that simple, as I enjoy lace, patterned clothes and varied necklines. Do you think a Catholic can dress this way without being seen as a wrong religion? Do you know anyone who’s made a change to something like this?
Miguelita, my answer is influenced by the fact that I just returned to live in New Orleans again, and I noticed again that there’s no place like New Orleans. :yup: People here dress in the most outlandish ways, with striking individual styles, including dresses that make them look like they just stepped off from a movie scene in Gone With the Wind or something, and nobody bats an eye. 😃

I have to say this side of New Orleans is quite refreshing to me, after the monotonous world of shorts, miniskirts and tank tops, lacking a sense of the original or of individuality, that pervaded life in Miami Beach. Women in Miami Beach wore their unimaginative and saddening (saddening because immodest) “uniforms” of tank tops and mini skirts, but (at least some) women here in New Orleans know how to dress!!! :clapping: :extrahappy: They are feminine, beautiful, and modest at the same time.

I don’t know if this is gonna help you, dear sister, since I’m talking about New Orleans, and you live in the Midwest. :hmmm: 😛 But I wish you much fun, happiness, and may God’s blessings rest on you, while you adopt this new way of dressing that brings out the best of your own sense of modesty, fashion (in a timeless sense), individuality, and honors your dignity as a woman and a daughter of the Most High, a precious daughter of our God the Heavenly Father! 👍
 
How you dress, to a degree, is your choice. But I do not think “dress” in and of itself is “holy” or sanctifying. Religious wear, or should, garb that lets the world know they are Catholic Christians. I don’t think your dress would do that.

I have seen that many conservative Catholics adopt variations of what you describe- so you may be “known” by them. But how useful is your dress to evangelization? To what degree is your dress just serving your fashion sense? Not condemning you sense of style, just questioning how a regency dress is sign of deeper commitment to God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top