Interesting New Book on Creation

  • Thread starter Thread starter hildegaard
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Please don’t take your kids if you have them. They have a bad tendency to drop religion completely when they grow up and learn the truth. Teaching kids untruths has very bad results and of course you don’t wish to drive people from the Church do you?
This is your field of expertise no doubt?
 
Two popes accept the basics of evolution. You wouldn’t be opposing Church teaching now would you? I’m told that means you are calling Jesus a liar. Apparently he likes evolution just fine and finds it quite compatible with Himself.
You need to be careful with this since “evolution” is a broad term.

The church does NOT accept the brand of evolution which does not involve the hand of God, or which seeks to deny the existence of God, or which attributes evolution strictly to blind chance. From this article: firstthings.com/article.php3?id_article=71

From Cardinal Schoenborn, author of the CCC:

• The Church “proclaims that by the light of reason the human intellect can readily and clearly discern purpose and design in the natural world, including the world of living things.”

• “Any system of thought that denies or seeks to explain away the overwhelming evidence for design in biology is ideology, not science.”

• Quoting our late Holy Father John Paul II: “The evolution of living beings, of which science seeks to determine the stages and to discern the mechanism, presents an internal finality which arouses admiration. This finality, which directs beings in a direction for which they are not responsible or in charge, obliges one to suppose a Mind which is its inventor, its creator.”

• Again quoting John Paul II: “To all these indications of the existence of God the Creator, some oppose the power of chance or of the proper mechanisms of matter. To speak of chance for a universe which presents such a complex organization in its elements and such marvelous finality in its life would be equivalent to giving up the search for an explanation of the world as it appears to us. In fact, this would be equivalent to admitting effects without a cause. It would be to abdicate human intelligence, which would thus refuse to think and to seek a solution for its problems.”

• Quoting the Catechism: “Human intelligence is surely already capable of finding a response to the question of origins. The existence of God the Creator can be known with certainty through his works, by the light of human reason. . . . We believe that God created the world according to his wisdom. It is not the product of any necessity whatever, nor of blind fate or chance.”
 
It is very comical, but what do you expect from a bunch of New York liberals.
:banghead:

Please, please tell me this is a joke.
For instance methods of radio dating are observable and repeatable when we know what the initial mass of the specimen is. Since they often don’t know the initial mass of very old items they assume an initial mass based upon where they found it in the ground. So the whole premise of what the age is depends upon the assumed age at that location in the ground is. I call this circular logic or cooking the books. This type of faulty science is used throughout evolutionary theory because it is an impossible theory to prove.
Just pretend for a moment that 99.7% of scientists out there aren’t complete idiots. Just pretend that they might have the slightest inkling of how to design a proper test. Now imagine that, at least occasionally, they check their figures. Can you imagine that results are gone over, tests are repeated, and ideas are questioned?

If you can wrap your head around that concept, then maybe this will make sense. Scientists check dating methods against each other all the time. They don’t just pick figures out of the air, because other scientists will attack those assumptions.

Put it this way: What time is it? How do you know? Springs in watches can be defective, some run fast, some slow. Batteries run dry, and people can miscalculate the position of the sun in the sky. We know what time it is because we are able to cross check the information. Why would you assume that scientists are utterly incompetent to do that over longer periods of time.
 
The Doctrines of Genesis 1-11: A Compendium and Defense of Traditional Catholic Theology on Origins
By Fr Victor Warkulwiz

$6 for the e-edition.

*Today the Catholic Church has well-developed theologies of redemption and sanctification but no well-developed theology of creation. That is because so many of her influential thinkers have abandoned the sound creation theology of the Fathers and Doctors of the Church and have embraced instead the false principles of evolutionism. The purpose of this book is to help restore traditional Catholic theology on origins to its rightful place in the belief of Catholics. The traditional teaching of the Church on Creation, the Fall, and the Great Flood and its aftermath is clearly presented in the form of sixteen doctrines abstracted from the text of Genesis 1-11. The doctrines are defended on theological, philosophical and scientific grounds from assaults made on them from the sectors of biblical criticism and scientism. The author attempts to present a story of origins that evokes true and vivid images of the creation of the world and the primal history of the human species. Accurate, thorough and readable answers are given to many questions about origins that perplex the modern Catholic. The exposition is kept as non-technical as possible so that the book will be accessible to everyone. Not everyone will be able to understand everything that is presented, but every reader will find enough to set his thinking straight and to nourish his Catholic faith.
**
The problem stems from the fact that the book of Genesis is NOT a scientific treatise on creation. It presents a cosmology of how the earth and universe were created and later how man came into being. Regardless as to whether or not evolution, in the final analysis, is either accepted or rejected, nevertheless, Genesis reveals that, through whatever process God has used in His creation, everything came from the creativity of God, and that humankind is a special creation as we have been given a spark of immortality which is the soul.**
 
A denial of God’s ability to Create in seven days is a denial of God.
An assertion that God created in six days (he rested on the seventh, remember?) is a denial of God’s ability to create in six picoseconds. Is that also a denial of God?

By asserting any particular duration you are denying God’s ability to use all the other possible durations.

rossum
 
Barbarian asks:
Would it surprise you to know that some things in the Bible are literally true, and other things are allegories?
If you were God I would have to would agree with you, but since you weren’t there I’ll take God’s word for it.
Where did God tell you that any particular part of Scripture is literal? The idea that Genesis is literal is man’s invention, not God’s word.
He can speak alagorically and literally at the same time.
You’re essentially saying that God can even produce a logical contradiction. Maybe so, but it seems doubtful that He would do it in a book to instruct us.
Your view of Him seems to be very limited.
I don’t see how taking Him at his word is limiting Him.
 
For instance methods of radio dating are observable and repeatable when we know what the initial mass of the specimen is.
Fortunately, isochrons can tell us what that was, even for very old specimens. Here’s a place to learn how it works:

sciencecourseware.org/VirtualDating/files/1.0_ClocksInRocks.html

It’s quite simple, and you can play with the different factors to see how it works.

You’ve been badly misled about how they figure these things. For example, the lab doesn’t know the strata from which the rock came. Remarkably, they are still able to give accurate answers. Recently, Argon/Argon testing was able to produce an accurate estimate of the date of the eruption that buried Pompeii.
I call this circular logic or cooking the books. This type of faulty science is used throughout evolutionary theory because it is an impossible theory to prove.
As you see, scientists aren’t really as dumb as you were told they are. There’s a lot of things you were misled about. Check the virtual dating site, and then we’ll talk.
 
Spiritmeadow writes:
Please don’t take your kids if you have them. They have a bad tendency to drop religion completely when they grow up and learn the truth. Teaching kids untruths has very bad results and of course you don’t wish to drive people from the Church do you?
This is your field of expertise no doubt?
If you’re smart, you’ll listen. YE creationism is a highly effective atheist-maker. Many young people have come to me, their faith shaken, because they were taught creationism was a Christian doctrine, and then they found out that it couldn’ t possibly be true. YE will have much to answer for, at Judgement.
 
The church does NOT accept the brand of evolution which does not involve the hand of God, or which seeks to deny the existence of God, or which attributes evolution strictly to blind chance.
Yes, that is why the Pope has no problem with evolutionary theory. It does not (and cannot) deny God or His providence, and of course it was Darwin’s discovery that evolution is not by blind chance.
 
As Cardinal, he signed off on a document his commission prepared, saying that common descent of all life on Earth was virtually certain. He has pointed out that contingency can also be used by God to His purposes.

And he objects to the same thing scientists object to: trying to abuse science by using it to make theological points.
 
As Cardinal, he signed off on a document his commission prepared, saying that common descent of all life on Earth was virtually certain. He has pointed out that contingency can also be used by God to His purposes.
“common descent of all life on earth…” is not equivalent to “evolution.”

And of course I think we all agree that God can use contingency for his purposes.

I’m sorry. I see no “proof” here for your statement: “…the Pope has no problem with evolutionary theory.”
 
Because a pope accepts evolution does not make it Church teachings
Agreed. What would you point be? The Vatican is never going to endorse creationism and everyone knows that for obvious reasons. Just because it’s not official doesn’t mean its not essentially what the Church believes. I hear the same stuff from those who are still supporting the war…“The vatican hasnt called it unjust!”…No, but they have done everything but call it that and even neo-cons on the Relgiious right aren’t confused that the Vatican opposes the war. This is just playing games to suggest that the Church hasn’t made evolution church teaching yet. Its merely formulating the connection between theology and science is all.

Although this is about the Big Bang it applies equally to evolution. The Church has no official teaching on evolution. I could not paste the entire answer as it was copyrighted but it does support the theory as being in tuned with our faith. BUT it is not officially taught and can be disagreed with without fear that you are calling Jesus a liar. Don’t over state your case there is NO official teaching and one should not claim there is.

link

I realize that. But anyone who is so out there as to still claim a protestant definition of creationism as the true model is simply not at all in step with where the Church is and they know it. The problem is the same folks tend to claim any Church document as stating Church teaching when it suits their theological desires too. You can’t have it both ways, and that was mostly my point.
 
This is your field of expertise no doubt?
Do you have any idea how many people here and elsewhere lament the loss of their children to atheism when they leave home and go to colleges and universities?. To tell outright lies to children and then expect them to separate the truth from the lies doesn;t work. Fundamentalists when they come to, tend to become atheists or at best agnostics. That is tragic. To pursue creationism in the face of the objective truth that some reasonable form of this theory is indeed true, is to work against Catholicism and to drive people away from both the Church and faith.
 
You need to be careful with this since “evolution” is a broad term.
Yes and everyone here is most aware of what I believe. I stated it on at least 8 threads in probably 300 or more posts. You don’t believe in creationism so what is the issue? We both believe that God is the Creator of all that exists and that if evolution is the model he chose to advance life throughout the universe, that was his business. You and i differ on whether ID is properly a science or still theology.
The church does NOT accept the brand of evolution which does not involve the hand of God, or which seeks to deny the existence of God, or which attributes evolution strictly to blind chance. From this article: firstthings.com/article.php3?id_article=71
Why would you think I need either to be told that or to be cited to something on that? You know I believe it. You’ve PM"d me several times and we’ve conversed about just this issue. ? What exactly is your purpose now?
From Cardinal Schoenborn, author of the CCC:
• The Church “proclaims that by the light of reason the human intellect can readily and clearly discern purpose and design in the natural world, including the world of living things.”
• “Any system of thought that denies or seeks to explain away the overwhelming evidence for design in biology is ideology, not science.”
• Quoting our late Holy Father John Paul II: “The evolution of living beings, of which science seeks to determine the stages and to discern the mechanism, presents an internal finality which arouses admiration. This finality, which directs beings in a direction for which they are not responsible or in charge, obliges one to suppose a Mind which is its inventor, its creator.”
And you know as well that Schoenborn has been reined in on his remarks regarding ID
• Again quoting John Paul II: “To all these indications of the existence of God the Creator, some oppose the power of chance or of the proper mechanisms of matter. To speak of chance for a universe which presents such a complex organization in its elements and such marvelous finality in its life would be equivalent to giving up the search for an explanation of the world as it appears to us. In fact, this would be equivalent to admitting effects without a cause. It would be to abdicate human intelligence, which would thus refuse to think and to seek a solution for its problems.”
• Quoting the Catechism: “Human intelligence is surely already capable of finding a response to the question of origins. The existence of God the Creator can be known with certainty through his works, by the light of human reason. . . . We believe that God created the world according to his wisdom. It is not the product of any necessity whatever, nor of blind fate or chance.”
Yes these refer to theological arguments for the existence of God, through reason. They restate the obvious, that we do not believe in totally natural causes for the universe.
 
Agreed. What would you point be? The Vatican is never going to endorse creationism and everyone knows that for obvious reasons. .

Although this is about the Big Bang it applies equally to evolution. The Church has no official teaching on evolution. I could not paste the entire answer as it was copyrighted but it does support the theory as being in tuned with our faith. BUT it is not officially taught and can be disagreed with without fear that you are calling Jesus a liar. Don’t over state your case there is NO official teaching and one should not claim there is.

link
My point is you state that evolution is Church teaching. It is not. The Church will never endorse any theory. It is interesting that Pope John Paul II made a point to say there were more than one theory.

We can have whatever belief we want as long as The first causer is God. If you believe in Creationism you are with the belief of the Church. This is true of any theory as long as God is first cause. The Church does not have the position that you say it does.
I realize that. But anyone who is so out there as to still claim a protestant definition of creationism as the true model is simply not at all in step with where the Church is and they know it. The problem is the same folks tend to claim any Church document as stating Church teaching when it suits their theological desires too. You can’t have it both ways, and that was mostly my point.
Again you try to speak for the Church. The Church has no position so it is not possible to be out of step. You may think it is foolish. You may be right but others think you are foolish they may be right. To say that it does not have an official position is correct. You may not go beyond that. You may wish the Church had one but don’t do a end run around it by saying that is what the Church really believes.

I was interested in your take about children leaving the faith because they were taught this. Do you have any study evidence or is it personnel opinion? I have not seen this to be the case with families that I know. With my own children this did not come up when raising them. I must admit I was quite surprised to hear my grown son’s argument against evolution. His opinion was formed at school because as I have said we never discussed it at home and my opinion would not be the same.
 
Do you have any idea how many people here and elsewhere lament the loss of their children to atheism when they leave home and go to colleges and universities?. To tell outright lies to children and then expect them to separate the truth from the lies doesn;t work. Fundamentalists when they come to, tend to become atheists or at best agnostics. That is tragic. To pursue creationism in the face of the objective truth that some reasonable form of this theory is indeed true, is to work against Catholicism and to drive people away from both the Church and faith.
Do you have any idea how many people here and elsewhere tell the truth to their children and have them become atheists?

Do you have any idea how many people are not fundamentalists and still have their children become atheists?

Do you have any idea how many people on this forum have been labeled creationists (meaning, 6 day creationists) who are not really creationists?

You seem to believe that there are only 2 points of view - 6 day creationism, and unguided / undesigned / undirected evolution.
The church does indeed allow belief in “some reasonable form of this theory” (evolution). But that is the guided kind, not the unguided kind which it seems you prefer. If I’m wrong about that, I apologize.
 
You truly can’t be serious? You know I know better. Why are you doing this?
Doing what? My comment was to a comment somebody else made.

:confused:

Late Edit: I just got to your next post. I was posting the Schoenborn article for the benefit of the new people on the thread who had not see it before.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top