Intersex People

  • Thread starter Thread starter BornInMarch
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
… I can’t see gender transitioning being allowed even for intersex people, except at birth where the parents would have to decide which gender to raise their child as. For example, if a person had reproductive organs for both male and female, I don’t think that would give them permission when they turned 18 to, for example, transition from male to female. The Church would expect them to remain with the gender their parents raised them. …
On what do you base this? If (and that’s a big IF) the objective sex at birth is in fact unclear - what makes you think the decision made at birth by the parents is “binding” on the child?
 
Intersex People are people who are born with genitals and physical features from both genders, often do to a birth defect. In some cases, such as in Klinefelter’s Syndrome/XXY Syndrome, Intersex People are born with defective sex chromosomes as well.

What is The Church’s stance on these people?
There are some 30 identified Intersex conditions. I believe these are all “biological” conditions - that is, the biological process determining our sex go awry.

Katie Baratz has XY chromosomes but - on any reasonable basis - is a girl (affected by androgen insensitivity syndrome- AIS). She developed testes which did not descend (and did not develop other internal female organs), but the AIS prevented the testosterone produced by the testes from “masculinising” her.

An Oprah interview of a number of Intersex people. The first is Katie.
youtube.com/watch?v=I9a1rXOpIuc
 
On what do you base this? If (and that’s a big IF) the objective sex at birth is in fact unclear - what makes you think the decision made at birth by the parents is “binding” on the child?
The Bible said God created us male and female. Because of disease or disorder it might not be clear what God intended, but he certainly intended each person to be either male or female. Not male part of their life and female later on. Because of this, gender transitioning should only be used to bring a person as close to the way God intended them to be as possible. When it is unclear what God intended, a choice needs to be made and it should be final. Just like I as a male can’t decide to become female later. An intersex person raised as one gender should not suddenly switch to the other gender unless there was a mistake with the original decision. Maybe parents thought it was a girl but later found out the child had XY (boy) chromosomes, transitioning would probably be allowed to more align the person’s outward appearance with the gender God intended them to have.
 
The Bible said God created us male and female. Because of disease or disorder it might not be clear what God intended, but he certainly intended each person to be either male or female. Not male part of their life and female later on.
How the person “is” is not determined by the decision of parents and / or doctors made at birth.
Because of this, gender transitioning should only be used to bring a person as close to the way God intended them to be as possible. When it is unclear what God intended, a choice needs to be made and it should be final.
I don’t know what you mean by ‘gender transitioning’, but as far as I can tell, these 2 sentences are contradictory. What if the “choice” made at birth appears - with the benefit of time, development of the individual, and hindsight - to have been a very poor one?
Just like I as a male can’t decide to become female later.
Presumably you cannot, because your sex is in no doubt by any objective measure.
An intersex person raised as one gender should not suddenly switch to the other gender unless there was a mistake with the original decision.
Earlier, you said the choice made at birth should be final! Now you say different.
Maybe parents thought it was a girl but later found out the child had XY (boy) chromosomes, transitioning would probably be allowed to more align the person’s outward appearance with the gender God intended them to have.
I suggest the “right” outcome is not always so easily determined. I refer you to the case of Katie referenced in my earlier post. She has XY (“boy”) chromosomes, but is by all reasonable assessment - a girl. As far as I am aware, her circumstances are as follows:
  • outwardly female appearance and assigned female at birth;
  • undescended testes discovered at age 6. Diagnosed with AIS;
  • no ovaries, uterus or fallopian tubes but normal appearing female external genitalia;
  • she took Estrogen from age 14 so that she externally developed as a female;
  • testes removed at age 18.
Now - AIS is caused by a genetic fault usually passed from the mother (on the X chromosome). So at the time of conception (in Katie’s case), we have XY chromosomes but with a genetic fault that will ensure a “normal” boy does not develop. How do you propose to make a call on “what God intended” based simply on those facts.
 
Typically, one sex is much more dominant in these cases, but the sinfulness of them identifying more with the other gender later on might be debatable.
 
Intersex People are people who are born with genitals and physical features from both genders, often do to a birth defect. In some cases, such as in Klinefelter’s Syndrome/XXY Syndrome, Intersex People are born with defective sex chromosomes as well.

What is The Church’s stance on these people?
Excellent question. 👍
 
I find it a bit disturbing how many people answer with “there aren’t enough of them to care” or “just don’t think about it”. Avoiding a question is not an answer.
I am also disturbed by this.

Intersex people are of no less worth because they are a minority. They are infinitely loved by their Creator, Who died for them on the cross, and they deserve our respect and love as a result. They deserve to know the truth about God’s will for their lives and what impact their bodies have on their vocation. I have heard approximately 1% of the population is intersex, but even if only a single person was, the Church still needs to consider the theology/philosophy of this reality. Yes for the intersex individuals, but also as it pertains to other areas. For example, I believe the existence of intersex persons teaches us something about Bible passages such as “God created them male and female”, and allows us to apply that correct interpretation to other realities, such as that of transgender persons. (Just because Adam and Eve were created male and female, doesn’t mean every person after them is created strictly male or female, physically and psychologically.)

I am not aware of the Church having spoken officially any doctrine regarding intersex persons yet, but she needs to.
 
…I am not aware of the Church having spoken officially any doctrine regarding intersex persons yet, but she needs to.
It should not be assumed that an absence of a specific statement on that topic implies something is being withheld.

What specifically do you believe needs to be said?
 
It should not be assumed that an absence of a specific statement on that topic implies something is being withheld.

What specifically do you believe needs to be said?
In my humble opinion, I think the Church needs to acknowledge that not everyone is strictly male or female. She needs to acknowledge intersex persons have dignity and deserve our respect. She needs to tell intersex people how they fit into the body of Christ, what vocations God might be calling them to, whether they are able to marry or join religious orders specifically for men or women. She needs to make a statement about whether it is acceptable for parents to choose a gender for their intersex children and surgically remove/alter the organs of intersex infants without their consent. I would hope that she would provide more support and more love for individuals and the families of intersex and transgender persons.
 
In my humble opinion, I think the Church needs to acknowledge that not everyone is strictly male or female.
As to biological characteristics, I don’t think this is in dispute. Is there a specific position of the Church you object to, or is this an area where people makes assumptions that you believe needs to be respond to?
She needs to acknowledge intersex persons have dignity and deserve our respect.
Is such in any doubt for any person with a bodily or biological abnormality?
She needs to tell intersex people how they fit into the body of Christ
I’m not sure I understand what this means – unless it refers to the following points you raise. Does this question arise for persons with other kinds of abnormalities?
… what vocations God might be calling them to, whether they are able to marry or join religious orders specifically for men or women.
Is it your view that there is a straightforward and evident answer, universally applicable for all Intersex conditions? I doubt it. The Church does address the prerequisites for marriage “in general” - the ability to consummate the marriage. This at least establishes biological requirements.
She needs to make a statement about whether it is acceptable for parents to choose a gender for their intersex children
Is it your view that there is a straightforward and evident answer, universally applicable for all Intersex conditions? I doubt it. It seems evident that for many intersex examples, the sex can be chosen, because there is little to no doubt.
…and surgically remove/alter the organs of intersex infants without their consent.
Medical wisdom has evolved on this point (to being less inclined to surgery), as understanding of the reality of the condition and the manner of sexual development has evolved. I don’t think this is solely a moral question - and may not be a moral question at all.

Note that there is a wide range of intersex conditions, with varying degrees of ambiguity. Circumstances vary widely.
I would hope that she would provide more support and more love for individuals and the families of intersex and transgender persons.
The duty to love is not restricted to the church leadership. It is primarily ours.
 
Whether or not someone with a form of intersexuality would be able to marry would depend upon the bodily condition; as with all anomalies and birth defects, there is no standard answer.

As to choosing a gender for such a child at birth, that is even more an issue for the secular society than the Church.

ICXC NIKA
 
I don’t see why they couldn’t marry.
I don’t really see how surgery could fix anything if your talking about actual genitalia. You would most likely end up committing either female genital mutilation or castration, both of which are forbidden.
 
The situation is very rare, and people with it are unfairly burdened with the alternate-sexual agenda, which is something entirely different (people with genetically unflawed bodies who **want **to live out another sexuality).

Strictly, it is a biomedical issue and not a Church one. The world is full of birth defects: Siamese twins, extra or missing limbs, microcephaly, etc. Why should sexuality alone be expected to be perfect?

Those having the condition are required to exercise self control in the same manner as everybody else.

ICXC NIKA
Could an intersex person be a priest? That’s a Church issue.
 
If you watch the “Oprah” segment mention they clearly explain that the person in question is undeniably a deformed male with micro penis and undescended testes. The feminine facial features and voice occurred after castration and female hormone usage.
He is a male eunuch; case closed.
 
Could an intersex person be a priest? That’s a Church issue.
That would be a Church issue, but, given my average-sinner understanding, most likely a closed one.

Men are routinely rejected from ordination for any manner of “body deformation.” I’d guess that intersexuality falls into that category.

ICXC NIKA
 
If you watch the “Oprah” segment mention they clearly explain that the person in question is undeniably a deformed male with micro penis and undescended testes. The feminine facial features and voice occurred after castration and female hormone usage.
He is a male eunuch; case closed.
You seem to be confused as to a well reasoned basis for defining sex.
You seem to be start out that chromosomes are the absolute basis for deciding this and so ignore other equally valid indicators including some actual organs such as a perfectly functioning vagina and related plumbing.

Noone denies that non functioning testes were also present.

Re Katie you suggest she did not have a clitoris but a penis. I did not pick that up from the video. Can you give me the time stamp for that bit?

You omit the AIS chromosomal abnormality that led to androgen hormone insensitivity in the womb and the formation of a vagina and also meant her brain likely did not form along male lines at a critical time.

Now from all this it seems to me that sex is about having a number of different ducks all lined up in a row if it is going to work and be functional. It’s not just chromosomes as you assume. And even at the chromosomal level we can still find defects here in the sex related genes even if the basic XY pattern is still presenting.

So no, castrated male hardly does justice to Katie’s difficult situation.
Though it sure makes your intellectual prejudices simpler to live with!

Would it be immoral for Katie to marry a guy or have reassignment surgery and marry a girl?
I think both options are validly open to her. However she is a stable and we’ll socialised girl thanks to her parents and local community so the latter won’t be happening.
If only our Catholic communities could be as supportive of our own intersex or even homosexually oriented children.
 
You seem to be confused as to a well reasoned basis for defining sex.
You seem to be start out that chromosomes are the absolute basis for deciding this and so ignore other equally valid indicators including some actual organs such as a perfectly functioning vagina and related plumbing.

Noone denies that non functioning testes were also present.

Re Katie you suggest she did not have a clitoris but a penis. I did not pick that up from the video. Can you give me the time stamp for that bit?

You omit the AIS chromosomal abnormality that led to androgen hormone insensitivity in the womb and the formation of a vagina and also meant her brain likely did not form along male lines at a critical time.

Now from all this it seems to me that sex is about having a number of different ducks all lined up in a row if it is going to work and be functional. It’s not just chromosomes as you assume. And even at the chromosomal level we can still find defects here in the sex related genes even if the basic XY pattern is still presenting.

So no, castrated male hardly does justice to Katie’s difficult situation.
Though it sure makes your intellectual prejudices simpler to live with!

Would it be immoral for Katie to marry a guy or have reassignment surgery and marry a girl?
I think both options are validly open to her. However she is a stable and we’ll socialised girl thanks to her parents and local community so the latter won’t be happening.
If only our Catholic communities could be as supportive of our own intersex or even homosexually oriented children.
If a person is a genetic male and had testes, than I presumed that by “female outer genitalia” they mean’t a underdeveloped penis small enough to resemble a clitoris, which basically is a female penis in the same sense that men have breasts.
The idea that one could have vagina canal at the same time as testes seems strange since these form from the same material in the womb. Unless one had no scrotum, which would mean that they couldn’t descend, having nowhere to go.
 
If a person is a genetic male and had testes, than I presumed that by “female outer genitalia” they mean’t a underdeveloped penis small enough to resemble a clitoris, which basically is a female penis in the same sense that men have breasts.
The idea that one could have vagina canal at the same time as testes seems strange since these form from the same material in the womb. Unless one had no scrotum, which would mean that they couldn’t descend, having nowhere to go.
Katie said explicitly she has a vagina. From other material I’ve read in persons with this development abnormality, the vagina ends blindly, rather than connects to a uterus (which Katie does not have).

I don’t believe the testes develop from the same material as the vagina. Testes and ovaries develop from from the same material.

Katie is genetically a boy but her reality does not reflect that. The evidence is that persons with her condition manage to live successful lives, often marrying men.
 
Katie said explicitly she has a vagina. From other material I’ve read in persons with this development abnormality, the vagina ends blindly, rather than connects to a uterus (which Katie does not have).

I don’t believe the testes develop from the same material as the vagina. Testes and ovaries develop from from the same material.

Katie is genetically a boy but her reality does not reflect that. The evidence is that persons with her condition manage to live successful lives, often marrying men.
I mean the testes skin sack is from the same fetal material as the vagina mouth. If one had testes, but also a vagina, that would leave the testes with no skin sack to descend into, hence being retained inside the body cavity.
 
…He is a male eunuch; case closed.
I think that is far too simple. Katie was at one time heading for all the world to be a “boy” by virtue of the chromosomal (name removed by moderator)ut. But the anticipated maleness did not emerge. I don’t see any “wrong” in what has been done to help Katie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top