If you watch the “Oprah” segment mention they clearly explain that the person in question is undeniably a deformed male with micro penis and undescended testes. The feminine facial features and voice occurred after castration and female hormone usage.
He is a male eunuch; case closed.
You seem to be confused as to a well reasoned basis for defining sex.
You seem to be start out that chromosomes are the absolute basis for deciding this and so ignore other equally valid indicators including some actual organs such as a perfectly functioning vagina and related plumbing.
Noone denies that non functioning testes were also present.
Re Katie you suggest she did not have a clitoris but a penis. I did not pick that up from the video. Can you give me the time stamp for that bit?
You omit the AIS chromosomal abnormality that led to androgen hormone insensitivity in the womb and the formation of a vagina and also meant her brain likely did not form along male lines at a critical time.
Now from all this it seems to me that sex is about having a number of different ducks all lined up in a row if it is going to work and be functional. It’s not just chromosomes as you assume. And even at the chromosomal level we can still find defects here in the sex related genes even if the basic XY pattern is still presenting.
So no, castrated male hardly does justice to Katie’s difficult situation.
Though it sure makes your intellectual prejudices simpler to live with!
Would it be immoral for Katie to marry a guy or have reassignment surgery and marry a girl?
I think both options are validly open to her. However she is a stable and we’ll socialised girl thanks to her parents and local community so the latter won’t be happening.
If only our Catholic communities could be as supportive of our own intersex or even homosexually oriented children.