R
Rin
Guest
Yes, I’m aware his hypotheses were far from perfect, and that terracentrism with epicycles even had higher predictive power, if I remember correctly. There are many sides to this story.Galileo tried to use tides to prove motion of the Earth. Bellarmine was rather ambivalent about the theory.
But still, the facts remain: He was not sentenced for bad science, but for heresy. And the condemnations do not even mention the bad parts of his science, but the correct ones - namely that the earth is in motion and revolves around the sun, and is not the center of the universe. Those are the positions that were condemned and deemed contrary to Scripture and Tradition, and those were the positions that so greatly challenged everything we thought we knew about the universe.
It is of course tempting to make the Galileo event into simply a product of politics, pride and errors in his science. But yet, I believe it doesn’t serve us well - we have to acknowledge that the servants of the Church stepped wrong, and went outside of their domain of knowledge. And we have to keep it in mind, so it doesn’t happen again. It’s too embarrassing.
That said, I dont always follow my own advice. If I talk to a non-Catholic, and the person starts with Galileo to prove the “conflict” between the Church and science, it is tempting to play it down. But generally, I’ve realized that the best strategy is to acknowkedge the mistake, while pointing out that the myths about his punishment are wrong, and not least that the event was an exception from the rule - generally, the Church has been in favor of or at worst neutral to science.
True. If a more complex theory has greater predictive power, you of course choose the more complex one - or, if it makes sense, try to isolate the mistakes in the simpler one. The latter would have been the correct route at Galileo’s time, since terracentrism with epicycles not only was horribly complex, but severely burdened by ad-hoc hypotheses to adjust it to observations.As to Ockham’s Razor: For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong. The lex parsimoniae is rather badly misunderstood by large swaths of society.
Interesting, I’ve heard him mentioned before, but never looked into it. This proves how different the atmospheres were in their respectice centuries, and how that can affect how the Church acts.Oh, and check out Oresme on the heliocentric theory.
But even so, the point remains: Heliocentrism did fundamentally challenge the Church’s view of the world at the time of Galileo, and the condemnations are crystal clear. It can’t be denied.
And again, I think the current changes in what we know about gender is comparable, in that it shakes very central parts of how we see the world. But this time, the Church seems to wait with the response - perhaps exactly to avoid another mistake of the same kind.