Intersexed People

  • Thread starter Thread starter LoyalViews
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Galileo tried to use tides to prove motion of the Earth. Bellarmine was rather ambivalent about the theory.
Yes, I’m aware his hypotheses were far from perfect, and that terracentrism with epicycles even had higher predictive power, if I remember correctly. There are many sides to this story.

But still, the facts remain: He was not sentenced for bad science, but for heresy. And the condemnations do not even mention the bad parts of his science, but the correct ones - namely that the earth is in motion and revolves around the sun, and is not the center of the universe. Those are the positions that were condemned and deemed contrary to Scripture and Tradition, and those were the positions that so greatly challenged everything we thought we knew about the universe.

It is of course tempting to make the Galileo event into simply a product of politics, pride and errors in his science. But yet, I believe it doesn’t serve us well - we have to acknowledge that the servants of the Church stepped wrong, and went outside of their domain of knowledge. And we have to keep it in mind, so it doesn’t happen again. It’s too embarrassing.

That said, I dont always follow my own advice. If I talk to a non-Catholic, and the person starts with Galileo to prove the “conflict” between the Church and science, it is tempting to play it down. But generally, I’ve realized that the best strategy is to acknowkedge the mistake, while pointing out that the myths about his punishment are wrong, and not least that the event was an exception from the rule - generally, the Church has been in favor of or at worst neutral to science.
As to Ockham’s Razor: For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong. The lex parsimoniae is rather badly misunderstood by large swaths of society.
True. If a more complex theory has greater predictive power, you of course choose the more complex one - or, if it makes sense, try to isolate the mistakes in the simpler one. The latter would have been the correct route at Galileo’s time, since terracentrism with epicycles not only was horribly complex, but severely burdened by ad-hoc hypotheses to adjust it to observations.
Oh, and check out Oresme on the heliocentric theory.
Interesting, I’ve heard him mentioned before, but never looked into it. This proves how different the atmospheres were in their respectice centuries, and how that can affect how the Church acts.

But even so, the point remains: Heliocentrism did fundamentally challenge the Church’s view of the world at the time of Galileo, and the condemnations are crystal clear. It can’t be denied.

And again, I think the current changes in what we know about gender is comparable, in that it shakes very central parts of how we see the world. But this time, the Church seems to wait with the response - perhaps exactly to avoid another mistake of the same kind.
 
Yes, I’m aware his hypotheses were far from perfect, and that terracentrism with epicycles even had higher predictive power, if I remember correctly. There are many sides to this story.

But still, the facts remain: He was not sentenced for bad science, but for heresy. And the condemnations do not even mention the bad parts of his science, but the correct ones - namely that the earth is in motion and revolves around the sun, and is not the center of the universe. Those are the positions that were condemned and deemed contrary to Scripture and Tradition, and those were the positions that so greatly challenged everything we thought we knew about the universe.

It is of course tempting to make the Galileo event into simply a product of politics, pride and errors in his science. But yet, I believe it doesn’t serve us well - we have to acknowledge that the servants of the Church stepped wrong, and went outside of their domain of knowledge. And we have to keep it in mind, so it doesn’t happen again. It’s too embarrassing.

That said, I dont always follow my own advice. If I talk to a non-Catholic, and the person starts with Galileo to prove the “conflict” between the Church and science, it is tempting to play it down. But generally, I’ve realized that the best strategy is to acknowkedge the mistake, while pointing out that the myths about his punishment are wrong, and not least that the event was an exception from the rule - generally, the Church has been in favor of or at worst neutral to science.

True. If a more complex theory has greater predictive power, you of course choose the more complex one - or, if it makes sense, try to isolate the mistakes in the simpler one. The latter would have been the correct route at Galileo’s time, since terracentrism with epicycles not only was horribly complex, but severely burdened by ad-hoc hypotheses to adjust it to observations.

Interesting, I’ve heard him mentioned before, but never looked into it. This proves how different the atmospheres were in their respectice centuries, and how that can affect how the Church acts.

But even so, the point remains: Heliocentrism did fundamentally challenge the Church’s view of the world at the time of Galileo, and the condemnations are crystal clear. It can’t be denied.

And again, I think the current changes in what we know about gender is comparable, in that it shakes very central parts of how we see the world. But this time, the Church seems to wait with the response - perhaps exactly to avoid another mistake of the same kind.
He wasn’t convicted for his science being heresy, but rather that he was trying to lecture to theologians when he lacked any credentials.

There wasn’t really a difference, the Church was quite open to scientific discussion and even facilitated it. The difference between Galileo and Oresme is that Galileo ran up and down claiming everyone disagreed with him was wrong even if it were on theology which he had no training and the other person had a doctorate, Oresme on the other hand rather fairly laid out the evidence for and against the heliocentric theory
 
He wasn’t convicted for his science being heresy, but rather that he was trying to lecture to theologians when he lacked any credentials.
Then why does the papal condemnation say explicitly that is science was heresy, and that this (together with his refusal to abjure his theories) was the reason for the condemnation?
There wasn’t really a difference, the Church was quite open to scientific discussion and even facilitated it. The difference between Galileo and Oresme is that Galileo ran up and down claiming everyone disagreed with him was wrong even if it were on theology which he had no training and the other person had a doctorate, Oresme on the other hand rather fairly laid out the evidence for and against the heliocentric theory
Yes, I know the Church was open to scientific discussion, at least in general. I know Galileo did mistakes. Yet, why do the trial texts say what they say, if that’s not really what happened? Has the Church falsified history in its own disfavor? 😉

Edit, so I don’t have to create another post:

Another reason I think downplaying how fundamentally heliocentrism challenged the Church is a bad idea, is the fact that not only Galileo was put under censure, but so were books from other scientists promoting heliocentrism:
General Congregation of the Index:
…And whereas it has also come to the knowledge of the said Congregation that the Pythagorean doctrine—which is false and altogether opposed to the Holy Scripture—of the motion of the Earth, and the immobility of the Sun, which is also taught by Nicolaus Copernicus in De revolutionibus orbium coelestium, and by Diego de Zuniga [in his book] on Job, is not being spread abroad and accepted by many—as may be seen from a certain letter of a Carmelite Father, entitled Letter of the Rev. Father Paolo Antonio Foscarini, Carmelite, on the Opinion of the Pythagoreans and of Copernicus concerning the Motion of the Earth, and the Stability of the Sun, and the New Pythagorean System of the World, at Naples, Printed by Lazzaro Scoriggio, 1615: wherein the said Father attempts to show that the aforesaid doctrine of the immobility of the sun in the centre of the world, and of the Earth’s motion, is consonant with truth and is not opposed to Holy Scripture. Therefore, in order that this opinion may not insinuate itself any further to the prejudice of Catholic truth, the Holy Congregation has decreed that the said Nicolaus Copernicus, De revolutionibus orbium, and Diego de Zuniga, On Job, be suspended until they be corrected; but that the book of the Carmelite Father, Paolo Antonio Foscarini, be altogether prohibited and condemned, and that all other works likewise, in which the same is taught, be prohibited, as by this present decree it prohibits, condemns, and suspends them all respectively. In witness whereof the present decree has been signed and sealed with the hands and with the seal of the most eminent and Reverend Lord Cardinal of St. Cecilia, Bishop of Albano, on the fifth day of March, 1616.
( law2.umkc.edu/faculty/projects/ftrials/galileo/admonition.html )
 
Then why does the papal condemnation say explicitly that is science was heresy, and that this (together with his refusal to abjure his theories) was the reason for the condemnation?

Yes, I know the Church was open to scientific discussion, at least in general. I know Galileo did mistakes. Yet, why do the trial texts say what they say, if that’s not really what happened? Has the Church falsified history in its own disfavor? 😉
He attempted to claim the heliocentric theory was theological sound and on theological grounds it was found wrong. How things worked then can be rather alien to how people think now. Which doesn’t make it illogical just proceeding from different axioms.
 
He attempted to claim the heliocentric theory was theological sound and on theological grounds it was found wrong. How things worked then can be rather alien to how people think now. Which doesn’t make it illogical just proceeding from different axioms.
To that, I agree. However, how does that contradict my claim about heliocentrism shaking the very fundament of the Church’s world view at the time? Doesn’t it rather confirm it?

(Sorry for editing the previous post while you posted, by the way - I would have posted separately if I foresaw a reply before I was done…)
 
To that, I agree. However, how does that contradict my claim about heliocentrism shaking the very fundament of the Church’s world view at the time? Doesn’t it rather confirm it?

(Sorry for editing the previous post while you posted, by the way - I would have posted separately if I foresaw a reply before I was done…)
How did this go from intersexed people to Galileo?
 
How did this go from intersexed people to Galileo?
This is “our time’s heliocentrism” - sex and gender have proved to be way less clear cut and “pretty” than we thought it was, and right now, this seems to be contrary to our Faith. But yet, “we” thought the same about heliocentrism (actually, the condemnations of it have not been cancelled by the Church - I suspect it would simply be too embarrassing to formally recognize that it is not a heresy to believe that the earth revolves around the sun at this time), and managed to find theological ways to accept it. I think the same will happen regarding gender.
 
40.png
Rin:
Actually I quite agree with your statement entirely. I just wondered when the thread would get back on the track. 🙂
 
Theologically intersex and transgender aren’t a challenge, theologians just don’t know what to make of it.

If you look at the part of the Catechism that apparently condemns transsexuals getting SRS you realize there is actually an exception that the surgery could fit into and that is about therapeutic necessity. I’ve talked to some transgendered people and it seems that for quite a few transitioning at least is therapeutically necessary for their sanity.
 
Theologically intersex and transgender aren’t a challenge, theologians just don’t know what to make of it.

If you look at the part of the Catechism that apparently condemns transsexuals getting SRS you realize there is actually an exception that the surgery could fit into and that is about therapeutic necessity. I’ve talked to some transgendered people and it seems that for quite a few transitioning at least is therapeutically necessary for their sanity.
I agree it’s not a challenge in the sense of “is SRS permissible?” - as you say, the part of the Catechism speaking about mutilation expressly allows for therapeutically necessary amputations and surgery, and the medical community agrees that SRS is therapeutically necessary.

The problem arises when we go from there to things like marriage. The current policy is simple - even though I identify as a woman, and will in a few years probably look entirely like one, to the degree of a gynaecologist being more likely to ask me when I had my hysterectomy than when I had my SRS, my baptism record won’t be changed; in the eyes of the Church I will be a castrated man, unable to marry. That’s not a huge problem for me, so this is not a complaint from my side, but it illustrates how this is a problem for the Church.

Traditionally, Matrimony and Holy Orders (and entering a religious order, but I guess that’s more a matter of discipline than theology) have been dependent on your body-sex, but currently, science is gravitating towards accepting brain-sex as the defining component. Right now, the Church can (and perhaps rightfully so, I’m divided on this) point to the “superficiality” of gender-confirming treatment (HRT+SRS), but in the future, we’ll be able to grow new internal sex organs and possibly convert the gonads, making trans people able to conceive and give birth more or less like everyone else. What then? Should the Church still go by physical birth sex, and refuse (at least many) intersex and (all) transgender people to marry, when we’re no longer technically castrated? These things are definitely a challenge, given the traditional way the Church has defined gender.
 
I agree it’s not a challenge in the sense of “is SRS permissible?” - as you say, the part of the Catechism speaking about mutilation expressly allows for therapeutically necessary amputations and surgery, and the medical community agrees that SRS is therapeutically necessary.

The problem arises when we go from there to things like marriage. The current policy is simple - even though I identify as a woman, and will in a few years probably look entirely like one, to the degree of a gynaecologist being more likely to ask me when I had my hysterectomy than when I had my SRS, my baptism record won’t be changed; in the eyes of the Church I will be a castrated man, unable to marry. That’s not a huge problem for me, so this is not a complaint from my side, but it illustrates how this is a problem for the Church.

Traditionally, Matrimony and Holy Orders (and entering a religious order, but I guess that’s more a matter of discipline than theology) have been dependent on your body-sex, but currently, science is gravitating towards accepting brain-sex as the defining component. Right now, the Church can (and perhaps rightfully so, I’m divided on this) point to the “superficiality” of gender-confirming treatment (HRT+SRS), but in the future, we’ll be able to grow new internal sex organs and possibly convert the gonads, making trans people able to conceive and give birth more or less like everyone else. What then? Should the Church still go by physical birth sex, and refuse (at least many) intersex and (all) transgender people to marry, when we’re no longer technically castrated? These things are definitely a challenge, given the traditional way the Church has defined gender.
I personally know a devout young Catholic transwoman who feels that as long as she can transition she can bear it although she thinks that loneliness might be a problem.

I think the issue with transgendered people and marriage is something that will take a lot of time to be resolved, if ever. Might be an opportunity for reviving lay celibacy, after all celibacy is greater than marriage and also revitalizing deep friendship and our medieval rites for kinshipmaking
 
I personally know a devout young Catholic transwoman who feels that as long as she can transition she can bear it although she thinks that loneliness might be a problem.
So do I - I’d much rather transition and be alone than not transition and be married. Yet, I’ve learned to be careful with promises regarding the future - I’m human like everyone else. But I’ll deal with those problems if they arise, as they’re separate from the ones I’m facing now.
I think the issue with transgendered people and marriage is something that will take a lot of time to be resolved, if ever. Might be an opportunity for reviving lay celibacy, after all celibacy is greater than marriage and also revitalizing deep friendship and our medieval rites for kinshipmaking
It will take time indeed, which is my point - I think the Church is handling it fairly well, choosing to neither embrace nor condemn the developments. But sooner or later, when reproduction becomes possible, the current reasoning for barring transgender individuals from marriage will be obsolete. At that time, I think the Church will recognize “sex change” (I hate that term, but in this context, it sort of is the best one), but we’ll have to see. In any case, it certainly does challenge some traditional conceptions regarding gender.
 
So do I - I’d much rather transition and be alone than not transition and be married. Yet, I’ve learned to be careful with promises regarding the future - I’m human like everyone else. But I’ll deal with those problems if they arise, as they’re separate from the ones I’m facing now.
One thing I’ve realized contemplating relationships from the perspective of a lay celibate is that we don’t really need marriages or sex to truly feel intimacy and love whether it be with God or with our friends. I think Æthelred of Rievaulx’s De Spiritali Amicitia which is much forgotten today might serve as a touchstone for what is true friendship. In traditional Catholic thought the bonds of friendship are far stronger than marriage as marriage; the love of one true friend greater than that of a spouse to another and friendship being more able to aid in the salvation of souls than marriage. To them marriage was a wedding of the flesh and died at death as the flesh does whereas friendship was the wedding of the spirit and survived death.
It will take time indeed, which is my point - I think the Church is handling it fairly well, choosing to neither embrace nor condemn the developments. But sooner or later, when reproduction becomes possible, the current reasoning for barring transgender individuals from marriage will be obsolete. At that time, I think the Church will recognize “sex change” (I hate that term, but in this context, it sort of is the best one), but we’ll have to see. In any case, it certainly does challenge some traditional conceptions regarding gender.
Perhaps society will grow up one day, stop acting like horny teens about marriage and stop overhyping marriage (a tragedy of the modern age).
 
What you are saying is confusing me. Are you referring to unnaturally transgendered people? Because I am fairly sure the OP is referring to those who are born with ambiguous gender, something that DOES happen, without outside influence.
I am not sure what you mean my “unnaturally” transgendered people. Do you mean a person who identifies themselves as transgendered but have no apparent ambiguity in a physical sense? (They have genitals that are obviously just female or just male?)

Those with ambiguous gender would mean hermaphrodites to me, but they could have various degrees of outward expression of this condition. Some have genitals of both sexes, some can have a uterus with external male organs, some can have partially developed genitals with one gender more apparent than the other.

Truly transgendered people often have early expression of the gender opposite to that which others identify them as. A boy that likes to play dress-up. wear make-up and does not care about playing typical masculine games, while a girl may be all about football, never wants to play with dolls or use makeup and wants to dress as a boy.

This is of course oversimplified, but it is something that can be attested to by those who have experienced this in life. Many transgendered people will day they always felt like they were in the wrong body, or they should have been a boy versus a girl.

MY own suspicion is that there is always an outside influence or genetic mutation that results in this. It could be from something like “gene hoping”, or the person has a full XY genetic makeup with one little, tiny piece of an extra y in there as well. There could be what is called a “mosaic” expression of gender, where some of the persons cells are all XX for a girl, but 1/1000 are XY for a boy. (This happens with those who have Downs Syndrome.) A mosaic expression of Down’s Syndrome is usually what is seen in those who are less severely affected by this chromosomal abnormality versus those who have a full triple set of the 21st. chromosome.

So, again I am not sure what you mean my unnatural.
 
I do not believe that it is chromosomes that make someone male, female, or anything else. People talk about the difference between biological sex and gender identity - but what I am referring to is the “sex” or “gender” of a person’s true “self” - of that person as a body and soul created by God.

In the past we thought we could know this for sure based on outward appearance, then we thought we could know for sure based on chromosomes, but I honestly believe that there is no completely reliable way to tell if a person’s “self” is male, female, or otherwise. I don’t see any reason why anyone “must” be either male or female. A person’s self could perhaps be somewhere on a spectrum in-between male and female, or that person could be agendered, or that person could have a gender that is completely different from male or female rather than lying on a male-female spectrum.

I don’t think norms should be defined based on the majority. Just because a certain case appears to be an exception or a minority does not mean that it should not contribute to our idea of what sex and gender is.

Just curious: has someone brought up androgen insensitivity syndrome? In some cases this can result in someone who is chromosomally xy but phenotypically female (but I do not think this person would be capable of bearing children). Can anyone other than this person be able to say what sex or gender that person is?
 
I don’t see any reason why anyone “must” be either male or female. A person’s self could perhaps be somewhere on a spectrum in-between male and female, or that person could be agendered, or that person could have a gender that is completely different from male or female rather than lying on a male-female spectrum.
It is Catholic doctrine that we are all male OR female. It is incompatible with the theology for someone to be a third gender (which doesn’t exist), not a gender (which would deny our humanity), or on a spectrum.
 
It is Catholic doctrine that we are all male OR female. It is incompatible with the theology for someone to be a third gender (which doesn’t exist), not a gender (which would deny our humanity), or on a spectrum.
Ok. So if someone has androgen insensitivity syndrome (ie, xy but the y chromosome is only partially expressed or not expressed at all) and is born with a body, including genitalia, that exhibits both male and female characteristics - is that person male or female? Does anyone have the right to decide other than that person? And if that person decides to identify as not strictly male or female, who is to say that that person is wrong?

There is a difference between being Church teaching and being part of the deposit of the faith (ie, doctrine). And it seems cruel to me to impose maleness or femaleness arbitrarily on an intersexed person - or even to force that person to choose between only two options - just so that all of our theological ducks are in a row. This is one more area where I think we are trying to define the indefinable.

Could someone refresh me on what was cited earlier in this thread defining it as Church doctrine that all bodies and souls are wholly male or wholly female to the exclusion of all other sex/gender possibilities?
 
Ok. So if someone has androgen insensitivity syndrome (ie, xy but the y chromosome is only partially expressed or not expressed at all) and is born with a body, including genitalia, that exhibits both male and female characteristics - is that person male or female? Does anyone have the right to decide other than that person? And if that person decides to identify as not strictly male or female, who is to say that that person is wrong?
This is not doctrinally stated; you are free to believe what gender you think they are based on the criteria you personally use, but they are 100% absolutely one of the two genders.
There is a difference between being Church teaching and being part of the deposit of the faith (ie, doctrine). And it seems cruel to me to impose maleness or femaleness arbitrarily on an intersexed person - or even to force that person to choose between only two options - just so that all of our theological ducks are in a row. This is one more area where I think we are trying to define the indefinable.
Us being male OR female IS part of the deposit of faith. So this is irrelevant. How we define gender in earthly bodies (chromosomes, genitalia, reproductive organs, identity) has never been definitively stated, and we are free to believe whatever we want as far as how we define it. But every single human who has ever lived has either been male or female, no exceptions.
Could someone refresh me on what was cited earlier in this thread defining it as Church doctrine that all bodies and souls are wholly male or wholly female to the exclusion of all other sex/gender possibilities?
CCC 355:
355 "God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him, male and female he created them.
 
As I said before, there is a difference between a Church teaching and something that is part of the deposit of the faith. Just because you need to assent to something does not mean that it is one of those things that you need to assent to that is infallible.

It is possible that the strict division of people into being either wholly male or wholly female is part of the deposit of the faith but just saying so in the Catechism or having a quote from Scripture that seems to say so does not make it so.

But speaking not as a Catholic and using a purely secular argument - how can you say that an intersexed person “has to be” either male or female? How is that fair for the person if that person does not identify as either?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top