Interspecies marriage

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jack_Bauer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Heaven forbid…
Whose gonna pay for the long distance phone calls, the flower delivery costs and the petrol money for dates. :eek:
Nah, Stargate SG-1 had the whole worm hole thing going so it was easier.

If men are from Mars and women are from Venus then isn’t that extra terrestrial/alien marraiges already?
 
Assuming a million other variables fall into place; if there is no chance, ever, for procreation, then probably not. Kind of like gay “marraige”. If there is, then maybe. :confused:
That’s my read as well. Years ago I came up with an idea for a sci-fi novel about this, but as with most of my ideas, I haven’t done much with it! The idea is that there are two sentient alien species: one of them is generally attractive to humans, and the other isn’t. But humans can reproduce “naturally” with the latter and not the former (because the latter are an “artificial” race anyway and their “natural” mode of reproduction involves test tubes, etc., therefore in my fictional world the Vatican rules that “artificial” means of reproduction aren’t artificial in the case of these genetically engineered beings). Many Catholics naturally dislike this ruling, and the novel (if I ever write it as planned) focuses on a papal emissary who is sent out from Earth to investigate the dissent over this issue found on a particular planet where the three species live together. The situation is complicated by the facts that many humans are prejudiced against all aliens and see the Vatican’s ruling as supporting their hatred, and that the alien race with whom humans aren’t allowed to intermarry are experiencing a revival of their traditional “pagan” religion.

There’s perhaps a bit too much of Orson Scott Card in this idea (I came up with it when I was reading a lot of his work), but someday I want to have a serious go at writing it down!

Edwin
 
That’s my read as well. Years ago I came up with an idea for a sci-fi novel … someday I want to have a serious go at writing it down!

Edwin
Well, tomorrow is the start of the rest of your life.

You’d better get cracking.
 
That’s my read as well. Years ago I came up with an idea for a sci-fi novel about this . . .snip
Interesting idea; I’d like to see it worked out.

In contrast, I had an idea for a novel in which human - alien unions were not fertile, but offspring could be “engineered” using those parts human and alien DNA that would work with each other. Those parts would be assembled by a computer like stringing beads, making a child that would be part one and part the other. This was not a major part of the story, but was a device to explain a character’s having non-human abilities. I was not a Catholic when I came up with this idea, so the Vatican’s concerns didn’t enter into the story. I think this will actually be doable (for human parents) in a couple hundred years.
 
Interesting idea; I’d like to see it worked out.

In contrast, I had an idea for a novel in which human - alien unions were not fertile, but offspring could be “engineered” using those parts human and alien DNA that would work with each other. Those parts would be assembled by a computer like stringing beads, making a child that would be part one and part the other. This was not a major part of the story, but was a device to explain a character’s having non-human abilities. I was not a Catholic when I came up with this idea, so the Vatican’s concerns didn’t enter into the story. I think this will actually be doable (for human parents) in a couple hundred years.
What section of the CCC deals with alien reproduction?
 
That’s my read as well. Years ago I came up with an idea for a sci-fi novel about this, but as with most of my ideas, I haven’t done much with it! The idea is that there are two sentient alien species: one of them is generally attractive to humans, and the other isn’t. But humans can reproduce “naturally” with the latter and not the former (because the latter are an “artificial” race anyway and their “natural” mode of reproduction involves test tubes, etc., therefore in my fictional world the Vatican rules that “artificial” means of reproduction aren’t artificial in the case of these genetically engineered beings). Many Catholics naturally dislike this ruling, and the novel (if I ever write it as planned) focuses on a papal emissary who is sent out from Earth to investigate the dissent over this issue found on a particular planet where the three species live together. The situation is complicated by the facts that many humans are prejudiced against all aliens and see the Vatican’s ruling as supporting their hatred, and that the alien race with whom humans aren’t allowed to intermarry are experiencing a revival of their traditional “pagan” religion.

There’s perhaps a bit too much of Orson Scott Card in this idea (I came up with it when I was reading a lot of his work), but someday I want to have a serious go at writing it down!

Edwin
Edwin,

Let me know when you get around to finishing it, because it sounds really interesting!👍
 
Depending on the distances involved, you’d need multiple generations just to organise the first date. 😃
Didn’t you watch the original Planet of the Apes? All you need is hibernation.😉

Read Allen Steele’s Coyote, and you’ll see how easy it is!
 
What section of the CCC deals with alien reproduction?
It should have been fairly clear that I was talking about conditions as of the time of the story, but to make things perfectly clear, perhaps I should have said, “I was not a Catholic when I came up with this idea, so the Vatican’s possible future concerns didn’t enter into the story.”
 
It should have been fairly clear that I was talking about conditions as of the time of the story, but to make things perfectly clear, perhaps I should have said, “I was not a Catholic when I came up with this idea, so the Vatican’s possible future concerns didn’t enter into the story.”
I realized that you were not Catholic. Truth is that I was struggling with figuring out why in vetro fertilization bothered me so much when so many Protestants don’t seem to think twice about it.
 
I realized that you were not Catholic. Truth is that I was struggling with figuring out why in vetro fertilization bothered me so much when so many Protestants don’t seem to think twice about it.
I don’t think many Protestants realize that human souls are created and then destroyed during the IVF process. In the story line I mentioned above, the creation of the offspring was done within the alien culture; human sensitivities would not have applied. I also have another story line in my head that uses IFV, but in that case the technology is so advanced that no human beings are wasted.
 
Trying to find a marriagable non-human from some far distant galaxy is too fraught with problems. We don’t have any known worm holes to facilitate dating over vast distances and I reckon the fuel bill would kill the average household budget. However, If, in principle, it is OK to marry a species that is alien, that is, not human, then it’s OK for me to marry my dog. To say otherwise is discriminatory. One -] eminent /-] high profile philosopher termed it ‘speceism’.
 
Assuming intelligent life exists on other planets, would God allow marriage between the species?
I believe only with another “human” species…a typoid human for lack of a better word…very interesting thought!

Intelligent life can denote a dolphin…but we wouldn’t marry.
 
I believe only with another “human” species…a typoid human for lack of a better word…very interesting thought!

Intelligent life can denote a dolphin…but we wouldn’t marry.
Funny. I talked about this with my wife and my son. We’re watching all the Star Trek series on Netflix. I compared marrying another bipedal huminoid from another planet equivalent to marrying a whale of dolphin. I think it’s fairly obvious that it would never happen for scientific reasons. After some time passes and I get approval, I’d like to open a dialogue dealing with a more realistic problem developing in our world today. Had I not been in the wrong place at the wrong time I would have never believed it. It’s not a topic allowed to be discussed on CAF.
 
no because for a valid marriage the partners must be one man and one woman, human, and must be able to complete the marriage act. Since aliens by definition are not human, although they might be intelligent, no valid marriage would be possible.
Sorry, Lois. You can never marry your Superman. 😛
 
Sorry, Lois. You can never marry your Superman. 😛
:rotfl:
I’m watching Star Trek with my sons and the youngest didn’t understand me when I explained that the Doctor and Seven of Nine could never be married.
 
Yeah, but 7/9 used to be human,…
And I don’t know of any means by which a human can, due to infection, injury, or bodily modification, become non-human. A person who has lost a leg is clearly still a human who can marry. The same thing applies to a person with an artificial heart, or a pacemaker, or who is otherwise a cyborg.

Some SF universes, such as Star Trek, have other life forms that can fully interbreed with humans. There was an episode, iirc, where they established that humans, Klingons, and other such life actually had a common origin in an ancient civilization.

In the Stargate universe, many of the people encountered elsewhere in the universe are actually human, that is, homo sapiens. In that universe, humanity was spread across the galaxy and possibly beyond during ancient times. So, in that universe, the humans on other worlds from the perspective of Earthlings were sort of equivalent to Aztecs and Cherokee as viewed from the perspective of European explorers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top