Ireland says no

  • Thread starter Thread starter hawkeye
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I am delighted that Ireland voted ‘no’ to Lisbon… I’m just curious, since you (and others) have mentioned about the EU trying to force abortion on us, did you not accept the Bishop’s Conference statement in which they assured Catholics that the Treaty would not force Ireland to change its laws on abortion and euthanasia?
There are other issues, my main one is losing our veto, Ireland has lost enough power to Brussels, enough is enough.

And so much for a democratic vote, already the dictators over-there are saying the treaty is not dead, when it has to be ratified by all member states, Ireland rejected it, but we don’t count ?

Plus the other countries that did ratify the treaty their people weren’t given a choice, what kind of democracy is that ?

This is why I hate Europe because even after we say no, they still insist on yes.

Anyway if you’ve read the Alive magazine then they give their perspective on it.
Loss of rights.
EU court supreme
• Lisbon would make the dangerous EU Charter of Fundamental Rights legally binding. This would place the EU Court of Justice above our Supreme Court, and give it the power to decide our rights as EU citizens, which we would really become for the first time (Art.6 TEU).
• The areas that could be affected by this include the right to life of the unborn, the nature of marriage, the rights of parents to protect their children, the right to strike, trial by jury, religious freedom, labour law, censorship and, indeed, all areas of rights.
Laughingly those looking for a yes vote may have shot themselves in the foot, they didn’t provide detailed info.

This left many bewildered, so in doubt, they voted no.

And as the song says, " what part of no don’t they understand " ?
 
And as the song says, " what part of no don’t they understand " ?
Indeed, and I’m sure many is the person who has asked that question today… The arrogance shown by many on the yes side continues even after the election, though this is not surprising. One well known politician in Ireland today warned that those who voted no and those who ‘tricked’ them into voting this way will have to come up with the new and better plan. The no campaigners are getting the blame because the majority of people actually chose to listen to them! The insult of making such a remark is threefold (at least) - it implies that the majority of Irish people are completely gullible and unintelligent because they ignored their politicians and listened to the ‘lies’ of the ‘no’ campaign. It also denies the blatant failing of the ‘yes’ side to give us compelling arguments to support their campaign. Finally, they insult us by showing continued contempt for the no side - the majority -we were the only country to show true democracy in action on this issue, but evidently some politicians cannot even begin to comprehend the meaning of the word. Maybe people will remember such politicians at the elections next year…
 
I agree with this and the other comments made about Parnell and others in Irish history. What I don’t think people realize is the situation in Ireland was as much about class and oppression of the less priviledged which was masked by the Protestant/Catholic, Nationalist/Loyalist arguement but then that’s what politicians wanted. Politicians have always convieniently thrown religion into the equation to split the working classes so they could continue to be oppressed and exploited for those who want power and wealth for themselves. There is any amount of historical evidence that Presbyterians fought alongside Catholics in the 1798 rebellion which was a revolt of peasants against oppressive landlords. Before anyone accuses me of being a communist, which I have been accused of, fighting for the rights of the less priviledged in society is very much in line with the Catholic ethos of social justice and many Protestants embraced this because of their sense of social justice. There are many aspects of socialism that are compatible with Catholicism because of the Catholic Churches view of social justice. I believe things went very wrong when the fight for social justice became Godless. It’s the Godlessness of socialism that is not compatible with Catholicism but not the principles. To me, setting Protestants off against Catholics plays right into the hands of corrupt people who want nothing more than wealth and power to remain in their hands and have no concern for the well being, spiritual or otherwise, of those they claim to serve.
Wolfe Tone was a Protestant, wasn’t he? I agree that the religion issue is often used as a wedge to separate folks who have common interests and concerns. This was done in the US, particulalry in the South, during Jim Crow in an attempt to keep poor whites and blacks from joining forces and fighting to reform (and it worked). However, I don’t find that all Socialism or socialistic ideals are always Godless, though they have generally been instituted in a Godless fashion as have those of Communism (which I don’t support). Greed seems to be the downfall of most economic systems, whatever their ideals.
 
**Sinn Fein President Gerry Adams, who canvassed in Dublin on the last
day of the campaign, pointed out that there were “tens of millions of
people across the EU who have been denied a vote and who oppose this
treaty”.

And he said the Dublin government had been “unable to explain how the
loss of vetoes, opening of health and education to competition and
undermining of workers’ pay and conditions could be a good thing”** (quote from my email sub to Irish Republican News, sorry no link).

I think Mr. Adams raised a going point in that Ireland was in many ways voting for those who had no chance to vote. I’m glad so many folks were able to see the faults with the treaty. The thing needs renegotiation big time - and that will take time. Though it is possible that many issues will be disguised in later versions, the fact that folks were able to read between the lines of such a confusing document as the Lisbon Treaty suggests they won’t be easily duped in the future either.
 
It’s fantastic to se that the Irish were able to voice their opinion one way or another in regards to the treaty, if only the rest of us could live in a democracy that did likewise
 
Its a great day for the Irish.
I’d rather look at it as a good day, not a great day. 53% “no” is too narrow of a margin. I pray the Irish pro-lifers don’t get complacent thinking that they can relax now. The tide is still moving towards legalization I would presume. I would feel much better about this if the “no” returns were in the 70+% range.
 
I was actually in favour of gay marriage in the North of Ireland. Why? Because I couldn’t wait for the first divorce!:rotfl: The first gay couple to marry in the North of Ireland divorced within a few weeks, claiming media pressure split them up. They found that obtaining a divorce was not quite so easy as getting married. They wanted equality? Well, they got it! Equality has it’s down side. As the saying goes, be careful what you ask for, you might just get it. A lot of gay couples in Britain are now holding back from a civil partnership because they’ve realised what ‘committment’ can entail. So much for love.:crying:
 
The tide is still moving towards legalization I would presume. I would feel much better about this if the “no” returns were in the 70+% range.
If I recall correctly there was a poll carried out recently here in Ireland which suggested that the majority still do not favour the legalisation of abortion. Of course if 100% of people were against, that would be great, but I found the result of the poll to be quite encouraging given the secular society we now live in where few people will openly admit to heeding the directions of the Catholic Church… Also encouraging in Northern Ireland is the uniting of politicians from different faiths and political communities to oppose the introduction of abortion to the North.

In relation to the ‘no’ vote reaching 70+% range, this was never a possibility - nor was it ever possible that the ‘yes’ side could have achieved such a majority. For one thing, the treaty itself is incomprehensible - it was even too much trouble for most of our prominent politicians to trawl through it! Neither side put forward particularly compelling arguments - as I said in my OP, it was actually the ‘yes’ side which convinced me to vote ‘no’. Both campaigns frequently used scare-tactics, and I know of several people who were concerned about voting ‘no’ simply because they would then be aligning themselves with Sinn Fein. Many voters interviewed on the news said they only decided when they were in the polling-booth by a ‘lucky dip’ because they had been so uninformed. I just don’t understand how anyone who had no idea whatsoever about the treaty and its implications could have even contemplated voting ‘yes’, and I’ve no doubt that this happened right across the country. Anyway a majority is a majority, and actually, given that all the main political parties, the Irish Farmers Association, and many major unions were calling for a yes vote, the ‘no’ result speaks volumes.
 
I admit I sometimes put off reading my IRN as I often lose my temper within 5 minutes. I was lucky enough to meet Mr. Adams last year about this time on a very rare trip of his to Southern California (I went to a Sinn Fein fundraiser, less than 100 folks, got to shake his hand 🙂 ). You are right that the attempts to villify him are ongoing and irrational, though irrational arguments often find many followers.
😦 The other irrational argument you mention is that Ireland “owes” the EU - it’s that old beggars (Ireland) can’t be choosers, with Ireland always cast as the beggar - as if the woes have been of their own making and not imposed from abroad just as the EU treaty terms would have been.
 
Yes economic is enough, when they start to impose their laws on another sovereign nation, then they’ve went a step too far.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top