Is blue okay for Advent?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cathyt
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Man, oh man. (sigh)

(…)

Any suggestions about a way to address this. (I also work at the parish. Leaving isn’t an option and i’d like to be at least a little diplomatic.)

Thanks for the replies.
Or you could do what a certain priest I know did - whenever he knew the bishop was coming to the parish he would pull out the blue vestments and hang them out in full view in the sacristy.

Or course this works only if your bishop leans toward orthodoxy.
 
Or you could do what a certain priest I know did - whenever he knew the bishop was coming to the parish he would pull out the blue vestments and hang them out in full view in the sacristy.

Or course this works only if your bishop leans toward orthodoxy.
I just have to say, I like this approach in addition to probably talking it over with the pastor. It kind of cracks me up and of course, it also sounds like something that could work!

Thanks.
 
The issue of priests in the USA wearing blue vestments during Advent is an issue that was brought before Rome and rejected. Priests in the USA are not to wear blue vestments period.

If the Holy See should ever change its mind on this issue, then fine, wear blue, but until then, we must stick with violet.

And that’s the way it is.

MT
 
But the proper color of the candles are three Violet and one Rose. Any other colors and it’s not an Advent wreath.
For my home Advent wreath I’ve occasionally had to use white candles with violet and rose ribbons when I’ve not been able to find violet and rose candles. It used to be that stores would sell a box containing a set of Advent tapers, but those are harder to find nowadays (unless I can get to a Catholic store, which isn’t often).

'thann
 
For my home Advent wreath I’ve occasionally had to use white candles with violet and rose ribbons when I’ve not been able to find violet and rose candles. It used to be that stores would sell a box containing a set of Advent tapers, but those are harder to find nowadays (unless I can get to a Catholic store, which isn’t often).

'thann
Thann,
have you tried ordering them online from Autom or Leaflet Missal or a similar web site?
 
For my home Advent wreath I’ve occasionally had to use white candles with violet and rose ribbons when I’ve not been able to find violet and rose candles. It used to be that stores would sell a box containing a set of Advent tapers, but those are harder to find nowadays (unless I can get to a Catholic store, which isn’t often).

'thann
My point is that we should not use RED and GREEN candles. White (no color) with Violet and Rose ribbons would seem fine. (careful, don’t catch the ribbon on fire)
 
The issue of priests in the USA wearing blue vestments during Advent is an issue that was brought before Rome and rejected. Priests in the USA are not to wear blue vestments period.

If the Holy See should ever change its mind on this issue, then fine, wear blue, but until then, we must stick with violet.

And that’s the way it is.

MT
There are minor exceptions to this. Where I live the Spanish Privledge was brought over and retained. My direct knowledge of it being in force is vague but as it has the force of being a long standing tradition of over 450 years I would submit that it would stand as a valid liturgical tradition and not something made-up like many “traditions” we hear about from place to place in the US.
 
There are minor exceptions to this. Where I live the Spanish Privledge was brought over and retained. My direct knowledge of it being in force is vague but as it has the force of being a long standing tradition of over 450 years I would submit that it would stand as a valid liturgical tradition and not something made-up like many “traditions” we hear about from place to place in the US.
Ceremonies of the Modern Rite, 132: “Violet” is used for Lent and Advent and may be chosen for All Souls Day, funerals, and requiem Masses. The classical Roman tradition is to use a “reddish rather than the purple with a blue tone which is widely seen today. This acknowledges that the blue tone reddish” purple for violet, is widely use today, although not desired.
 
Ceremonies of the Modern Rite, 132: “Violet” is used for Lent and Advent and may be chosen for All Souls Day, funerals, and requiem Masses. The classical Roman tradition is to use a "reddish rather than the purple with a blue tone which is widely seen today. This acknowledges that the blue tone reddish
" purple for violet, is widely use today, although not desired.

“White is worn for solemnities of the feasts of Our Lord and Our Lady, in festive seasons and on days specified. In practice, ivory, cream or a similar shade may replace white, but surely not grey, which has no festive association. Cloth if gold or silver may also replace white. Except where the Spanish privilege is permitted, blue is not used for Our Lady. but it may be customary to use white vestments adorned with blue for her feasts.” (Ceremonies of the Modern Roman Rite. 2nd Ed. Elliott, p 47 emphasis added)
 
The proper color for advent is a violet there being no distinction between the color for lent or advent. This is supposed to help us understand the unity between Advent and Lent.
This is correct – there is no distinction between the shade of violet used for Lent and that for Advent. This differentiation was brought about by the usual dissenting types that are always trying to change something, and seems to be a way of easing a parish into the use of full blue vestments. I am by no means an interior designer, but to my eye the juxtaposition of dark blue and rose pink is unattractive. As was mentioned elsewhere, the actual Biblical “purple” was more of a magenta or ruby-red color with less blue than purple has today. In fact, the magenta-red zucchetto worn by bishops is called “Roman purple,” as opposed to the orange-red “scarlet” color worn by a cardinal.
 
I often wear blue during Advent, and sometimes even red and green.

Priests and deacons during liturgical celebrations, however, should be in violet or rose.
 
Purple is the correct Liturgical color for Advent. Blue is from Anglican tradition, hence it is wrong for use in the Catholic Church.
 
I often wear blue during Advent, and sometimes even red and green.

Priests and deacons during liturgical celebrations, however, should be in violet or rose.
😃 I prefer wearing black, because it goes with everything and always looks cleaner than it usually is. I entered the seminary so that I could wear it all the time without people thinking I’m a goth. Just kidding!
 
When I was church yesterday for our Generations of Faith (GOF) catechism lesson, my DRE said that a group of liturgist who are working to change the Advent colors from purple to blue. The thought is that most people associate purple with reconciliation and penance, not royalty. I converted to the RCC a couple of years ago and I never made that conncection. To me, Advent purple stands for the royalty of Christ, proclaiming His diety.

Is this plan of action true?? How can they change it?

Pax
 
This talk has gone on for thirty years, and nothing has ever come of it. 🤓
 
Traditionally, Advent IS a penetential season though not to the degree that Lent is. The Church used to always have fasts as a way of preparation for major feasts. The current instructions say that a different shade of purple can be used for Advent but not blue. Blue in the Church is associated with Marian feasts but even then not as a vestment color.

If there was a time to emphasize the Royalty of Jesus it would be during the Christmas season, not during Advent anyway.
 
I fear this is starting us on a path to no good place. This DRE is becoming more liberal than I care for. Should I say or do anything?

Pax
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top