Is downloading a game sinful?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PiousTemplar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PiousTemplar

Guest
I have an Idea that downloading a game from a torrent to play is sinful… because I didn’t pay for it. Its just a game from 2000 which I havn’t played in years. Should I be doing things like this?
 
You should not being doing this, be it with games, music, or anything else that is downloaded. You’re using the benefit of a product without giving the requisite payment. If as you haven’t played this game in years, or done this in a while, then simply delete the game and bring this up during your next confession.
 
If you really want to play the game, see if you can buy it from the publisher (for example Atari still sells old games) or eBay. That is what I did when I had a sudden craving to play Wing Commander IV (from 1995) a year or so back.
 
It is a sin, one you have to go for confession as well. Trust me, i have learned this the hard way by feeling guilt and shame.

Buy the game and give benefit back to the producer(s).

Peace and all good to you.
 
Well, it is a form of theft. And if you know what you are doing is wrong, and you do it anyway, it’s a mortal sin!

If the original publishers of the video game are not selling it anymore, look for secondary publishers or go onto websites such as Good Old Games and see if you can find them there. If you can find no one that is selling it, that means it’s no more in production and the publishers/developers are done with it. Usually by then, games and other digital media are in the public’s domain.
 
Hello all. Thanks for the replies. The game was downloading when I made this thread but I ended up deleting the download before it was finished.
 
Well, it is a form of theft. And if you know what you are doing is wrong, and you do it anyway, it’s a mortal sin!

If the original publishers of the video game are not selling it anymore, look for secondary publishers or go onto websites such as Good Old Games and see if you can find them there. If you can find no one that is selling it, that means it’s no more in production and the publishers/developers are done with it. Usually by then, games and other digital media are in the public’s domain.
Copyrights do not need to be renewed, nor the work stay in publication, to maintain protection. It is copyrighted until the term is up, period.
 
What’s the name of the game, PiousTemplar?
Copyrights do not need to be renewed, nor the work stay in publication, to maintain protection. It is copyrighted until the term is up, period.
I didn’t state otherwise but I didn’t make it clear either 😛
 
Theres a new game I want now, from 2002. Can’t find it in local retailers. It’s called ‘American Conquest’.
 
I have an Idea that downloading a game from a torrent to play is sinful… because I didn’t pay for it. Its just a game from 2000 which I havn’t played in years. Should I be doing things like this?
I have wondered about this myself and here is what I find interesting:

When you steal money, or a car or a loaf of bread, something is taken and the original owner no longer has access to what was stolen, so they suffer a very tangible loss (they can no longer drive their car or eat the bread which they bought, etc…)

But when you illegally download a game or a song what you are really doing is creating your own identical copy of that game or song. Its the same as making a copy of a file on your computer. The original owner will probably never know that it was copied. There is no tangible loss.

If you had the ability to build a toyota prius from scratch would that be considered stealing from Toyota? If you sold it then it would be a patent violation, but if you just made it for yourself would it really be stealing from Toyota? I say no.

Here’s another example:
Lets say you are in a furniture store and you see a chair that you really like but can’t afford it, so you go home and make an exact copy of that chair in your garage and then use it in your house. Is that stealing from the furniture store?
 
Here’s another example:
Lets say you are in a furniture store and you see a chair that you really like but can’t afford it, but you go home and make an exact copy of that chair in your garage and then use it in your house is that stealing from the furniture store?
I’m pretty sure I understand the point you’re making, and in spirit I generally agree.

That said, I once had to do some work on a 7 million dollar intellectual property contract between a company that designed equipment (Lucent Technology/Bell Labs) and one that was to provide software to convey parts of a patented design. That was a pretty convoluted situation. From a strictly legal standpoint, it wouldn’t surprise me if there is a precedent for protection for even the shape of the curves designed into the chair parts, or into the car body.

Yes, I believe it can get that tricky. Although things may have changed, I used to read articles about lawsuits protecting particular colors. One I remember was about ironing board covers. There was a company making ironing board covers that were the same color as a name brand product. They were sued for using the same color, because at first glance, people might not notice that it was not the same brand as they were used to. (Of course; that’s certainly why they chose that color.) I don’t remember which side prevailed.

Alan
 
Ah, Yes, Thankyou.

I found a couple on amazon for cheap, perhaps I might get one 🙂
 
Remember that video games are worldly pleasures and empty entertainment. The majority of them have no salutary effect on a person. Most of them often contain sentiments and missions contrary to love of neighbour. It is an excellent virtue to be able to enjoy proper rest by playing video games (especially on Sundays), but they are merely sensible consolations to pass time. Daring to download such things without paying for them both violates the seventh commandment, and shows that you are more focused on the world than on God.

Naturally, all morality is open to circumstance. Say you have a video game with a unique CD-key that you owned, but broke the CD. If the game is many years old and the key will never be used by anyone again, it seems permissible to download it. This is my opinion, and may just be casuistry. 😛
 
Remember that video games are worldly pleasures and empty entertainment. The majority of them have no salutary effect on a person. Most of them often contain sentiments and missions contrary to love of neighbour. It is an excellent virtue to be able to enjoy proper rest by playing video games (especially on Sundays), but they are merely sensible consolations to pass time. Daring to download such things without paying for them both violates the seventh commandment, and shows that you are more focused on the world than on God.

Naturally, all morality is open to circumstance. Say you have a video game with a unique CD-key that you owned, but broke the CD. If the game is many years old and the key will never be used by anyone again, it seems permissible to download it. This is my opinion, and may just be casuistry. 😛
Wow, thanks for your explanation.
 
Most of them often contain sentiments and missions contrary to love of neighbour.
Oh really? All my RPGs are generally stories promoting friendship, honor, and opposition towards a nihilistic evil. How is such games contrary to love of neighbor again? 😛
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top