Very good post, BlaineTog.
Chaz, while one may have trouble with some teachings of the Church, and they disagree with those teachings and think that the Church needs to be “less stressed on things”, ultimately one still must obey what the Church teaches. If the Church says something is a grave act, one does not get to decide otherwise, that they know better, and then go ahead and sin. It is still a grave act.
You think so? All that you mention above are generally mortal sins, so how is going ahead with one to prevent another better? The seriousness of the sin can vary depending on individual circumstances, so that is why I say “generally mortal sins”, but the individual does not decide that, his/her confessor would counsel about it, and God is the one who actually judges, but the Church teaches that most sexual sins are mortal sins. So, one must be chaste, period. That is what the Church teaches. Why do you think you know better than Holy Mother Church?
Then why have several priests told me that it was basically a venial sin? It is just hard gasping how a common habit naturally acquired during puberty has the same degree of punishment and “grave doing” as rape, murder, incest, pedophilia, adultery. Yes it is still sinful in nature but to that degree?
Logically and emotionally my conscious says no.
If it is mortal then the question comes up, why does the bible never mention it? It mentions lust yes which is a sin and the mortal sins of lust like adultery, rape, fornication, homosexuality, ect. But not M. After years of CCD it was never mentioned. If it is so grave but yet so common, it surely isn’t spoken about by the church as much as it should be.
I had to research it on my own when the question came up in my head of whether it was sinful or not.
I think it’s lack of emphasis is probably due to it’s debate on the severity of the sin because of so many circumstances.
Do I think M is a sin? : Yes I do
Do I think you should try to avoid it? : Yes because it can lead to further more serious sins.
Do I think it is mortal? : I think it depends on the situation. Many of those who do it is because it is a long developed habit and they are so to say stuck. I think in that situation it is not mortal because your willful intention is compromised. Like for me it’s been a habit for 8 years. It is comparable to a person who has been smoking for 20 years.
I have tried to stop, I have gone almost 2 months without it but it’s tough to completely break free of it especially since sex and revealing women are everywhere you turn in America. Your will and temptation for those who have fallen into it for a long time is compromised to the point where its involuntary. Next time you have an itch that is bothering, try to not scratch it. Multiply that feeling by about 5 and you have an idea.
Do I think this is an excuse to continue doing it? : No, you should try to stop if possible. But it takes a lot more time to stop doing it for someone who has been doing it 8 years not knowing it was a sin than someone who just started doing it.
Just like very few people who smoke can drop a cigarette and say “I’m done” after doing it for 20 years and never touch it again, It’s the same with M.
Given that, I think God does give mercy to those people and he only knows the heart and intention of each person.
Meanwhile I think the church needs to put that into consideration which from reading the CCC I think it does when it states what it needs to be for it to be mortal.
Compromise of the Will I think is one of them which long formed habit would compromise.
But so many people have the “No it’s mortal no matter what” attitude. In that case then 95% of men today are going to hell and some 70 to 85% of women. 50% to 60 % of both catholic and Christian men today will also be there. Statistics vary and some are higher than mine but I put a rough average after researching various statistics.
So Catholic people who have the “No it’s mortal no matter what” attitude either needs to take that into account. Or spread the word about it being a mortal sin like crazy to save people.