Is Ettore Balestrero a bishop or not?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Yarb
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

Yarb

Guest
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ettore_Balestrero

News reports say that during the last week of Benedict XVI’s papacy, Msgr. Ettore Balestrero became Titular Archbishop of Vittoriana. The page below omits to state that he was ever ordained a bishop, whereas they have that event in the list of “events” for some others. Could a person be a “titular archbishop” without being a bishop? Or could it be that he’s scheduled to get ordained a bishop soon but it just hasn’t happened yet?

catholic-hierarchy.org/bishop/bbalest.html
 
If he is a titular archbishop, then he is a bishop. He may not have been consecrated as bishop yet.
 
It sounds like he was appointed to the post of Nuncio, which is always held by an Archbishop, and thus given the titular see, but is yet to be consecrated a Bishop.

-ACEGC
 
He has been appointed to the titular see, but not yet consecrated or installed.

The problem with catholic-hierarchy.org is that the owner and custodian labors under the false impression that bishops immediately take their post upon appointment. Now, this is true for Curial appointments and posts such as nuncio, but it is not true for, e.g. diocesan bishops. For example, the Bishop of Marquette, Alexander Sample, was appointed a few weeks ago to Portland in Oregon, but he remains Bishop of Marquette until his installation in Portland. catholic-hierarchy, on the other hand, claims that +Sample is already Archbishop of Portland, and that the see of Marquette is vacant, which it is not.

I am not sure exactly how titular sees work as far as the installation, canonical possession, reading of apostolic letters, etc. But I would guess that there is less ceremony involved in taking possession than in a normal diocesan post. But someone who has not yet received episcopal consecration is not the bishop of anything yet. This man is already functioning in his position as nuncio to Colombia and does not need episcopal consecration to carry out the functions of that post.
 
OK, . . . . . . “Not yet” seems to be the tentative bottom line so far.

Thanks to everyone for replying.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top