Is heaven or hell awaiting me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mpjw2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
hi all,

I am curious as to what catholics believe about my eternal destination.

Is it possible that God will accept me into heaven should I die right now as a non catholic?

To give you a little about me, I invite you to read through my “common beliefs” thread.

I believe in Jesus our Savior and Lord, born of a virgin Mary.

As an adult, He was crucufied, died, rose and ascended into heaven.

I believe Jesus when He said “no one comes to the Father except through me.

I confess my sins directly to God in prayer.

I have not been before a priest in confession in a very long time.

I love Jesus

Any opinions???

be honest

no offense will be taken or given
God bless
Your going to Jahannam mate 😃 just kidding.
 
Catholics believe this too. Where the hair-splitting arises is in discussing whether a person’s rejection of Jesus Christ is a knowing one, or one based on what people more intelligent than I refer to as invincible ignorance. This is hard to say regarding a man who is raised and lives his whole life in Dehli, India - in a community that generally denies the Gospel message. What the Church teaches is that it depends entirely upon the grace God gives that person, and that person’s response to that grace. If a Hindu responds to the grace God has given Him and tries His best to do God’s will - without rejecting what has been given, then that person may ultimately be saved through the merits of Christ (apart from any Hindu beliefs or practices).

I understand exactly what you are saying you believe

Such a person, it is understood, would not have rejected Jesus Christ if given the opportunity to truly understand and accept the Gospel message.

An assumption…probably a correct one.
God only knows

So, I would say that we are essentially in agreement here

not quite Robert.

Paul writes in Romans …
For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen
 
Not our places to determine, we have no business in telling God how to share his mercy and love with us, question though, what do you think is your destination and why?
thank you for asking 1edyson

I will happily answer.

First let me say I ***DO NOT ***believe in OSAS

Having said that, I do believe that if I die right now, I will go to heaven. I am 100% sure of it.

I do not say that to be arrogant, but I say that to let other believers know that I believe they can have the same assurance as I do.

I also believe that ***all the catholic faithful ***are destined for heaven.

On November 14, 1999, I made a decision, by faith, to accept God’s gift of salvation offered to me through the sacraficial blood shed by Jesus Christ and trust in Him as my Lord and Savior.

Thank you Jesus 🙂

It was on that day I was introduced to the simple news of the Gospel.

As a catholic in my youth years, I felt obligated to do the things I had to do to be in favor with God so that someday He will let me in heaven.

Had to…

go to mass
go to confession
receive communion at Easter
fast
abstain

to name a few

works vs faith.

an issue mentioned a lot in this community

In short, I do not believe there is anything I can do to earn God’s favor so that He will let me into heaven when I die.

God already made the way to heaven.

The only thing I believe we have to do is quite simply choose to go that way…by accepting the gift of salvation He offers us and trusting by faith in His promise to us.

With possesion of the gift comes great responsibilities.

Yes, I believe that once one has His gift they can loose it, if they choose at some point in the future to reject Christ to the moment of their death.

Why anyone would reject Christ after having believed and trusting in Him I can’t answer.

They will not be happy they rejected the gift when they get to the other side of eternity 😦

My catholic sisters and brothers in Christ, I understand all you are saying and believing about the one catholic church Jesus founded and built on a rock…Peter.

Here is one area the debate starts …was Peter the rock Jesus was referring, or was it Jesus Himself.

Only God know the absolute truth. One of us is correct. The other has a false belief.
This I am 100% sure we can agree on

Quite frankly, I believe that whoever is wrong is not going to prevent that person from entering heaven.

The simple truth is that I believe that you and all the catholic faithful believe that Jesus’s blood cleanses all of us from our sins when we confess and repent to Him.

You confess to a priest as an intercessor I do not.
here I am not sure if you believe that god totally forgives me because I do not go to a priest…I repent and confess to God in prayer and ask for forgiveness.

again only God knows the absolute truth.

I can quote many scriptures.

Reading through this site, it is obvious to me that there is not one scripture that I can refer too that this community has not heard and/or gave the catholic teaching of.

Because we all believe in Jesus, I believe we all have a sincere want to live our lives that is pleasing to God, so that others through our actions and words may see the love we have for Jesus, but more important I believe we hope that they see and/or feel the love Jesus has for them.

God bless you and may God’s peace be with you all

mpjw
 
thank you for asking 1edyson

I will happily answer.

First let me say I ***DO NOT ***believe in OSAS

Having said that, I do believe that if I die right now, I will go to heaven. I am 100% sure of it.

I do not say that to be arrogant, but I say that to let other believers know that I believe they can have the same assurance as I do.

I also believe that ***all the catholic faithful ***are destined for heaven.

On November 14, 1999, I made a decision, by faith, to accept God’s gift of salvation offered to me through the sacraficial blood shed by Jesus Christ and trust in Him as my Lord and Savior.

Thank you Jesus 🙂

It was on that day I was introduced to the simple news of the Gospel.

As a catholic in my youth years, I felt obligated to do the things I had to do to be in favor with God so that someday He will let me in heaven.

Had to…

go to mass
go to confession
receive communion at Easter
fast
abstain

to name a few

works vs faith.

an issue mentioned a lot in this community

In short, I do not believe there is anything I can do to earn God’s favor so that He will let me into heaven when I die.

God already made the way to heaven.

The only thing I believe we have to do is quite simply choose to go that way…by accepting the gift of salvation He offers us and trusting by faith in His promise to us.

With possesion of the gift comes great responsibilities.

Yes, I believe that once one has His gift they can loose it, if they choose at some point in the future to reject Christ to the moment of their death.

Why anyone would reject Christ after having believed and trusting in Him I can’t answer.

They will not be happy they rejected the gift when they get to the other side of eternity 😦

My catholic sisters and brothers in Christ, I understand all you are saying and believing about the one catholic church Jesus founded and built on a rock…Peter.

Here is one area the debate starts …was Peter the rock Jesus was referring, or was it Jesus Himself.

Only God know the absolute truth. One of us is correct. The other has a false belief.
This I am 100% sure we can agree on

Quite frankly, I believe that whoever is wrong is not going to prevent that person from entering heaven.

The simple truth is that I believe that you and all the catholic faithful believe that Jesus’s blood cleanses all of us from our sins when we confess and repent to Him.

You confess to a priest as an intercessor I do not.
here I am not sure if you believe that god totally forgives me because I do not go to a priest…I repent and confess to God in prayer and ask for forgiveness.

again only God knows the absolute truth.

I can quote many scriptures.

Reading through this site, it is obvious to me that there is not one scripture that I can refer too that this community has not heard and/or gave the catholic teaching of.

Because we all believe in Jesus, I believe we all have a sincere want to live our lives that is pleasing to God, so that others through our actions and words may see the love we have for Jesus, but more important I believe we hope that they see and/or feel the love Jesus has for them.

God bless you and may God’s peace be with you all

mpjw
Actually I think it boils down to one question.

Will we obey Christ by remaining united in one church under one shepherd, founded on the one Rock He Himself appointed? Yes or no?
 
thank you all for you honesty.

just in case you are wondering about my inquiry, as a catholic in my youth, I believed catholicism was the one and only way to heaven.

Stinky thinking huh?

some of your responses however did bring to light some differences in our beliefs on how to get to heaven and/or who God will accept into His kingdom.

God bless
Catholics believe that Christ is the way, the truth, and the life, but Catholics also believe that Christ is the Church as well. You see Catholics take literally what is said in Acts of the Apostles. Paul (when he was Saul) was persecuting the Church, but when Christ appeared to him Christ asked him why he (Saul) was persecuting him (Christ). To Catholics this means that Christ and the Catholic Church are the same. This is why when people come on these Boards and attacks the Catholic Church Catholics become defensive because they see it as a direct attack on Christ. Christ calls sinners not the righteous, so you will find a lot of sinners in the Catholic Church. However Catholics see this as no reflection on the Church for it is no reflection on Christ because Christ and the Catholic Church are seen as one. You see to a Catholic all truth is Christ, so all truth is a Catholic truth. So to Catholics there is only the Catholic Faith and salvation through it because there is only Christ whether you know him by name or by grace in your life. This does not mean that everyone who calls themselves Catholic are saved by default, but if you live the best you can according to what you understand of the way, the truth, the life then you are Catholic to some degree. (Keep in mind that Catholics are Sacramental Christians, so Catholics see the Sacraments as a Physical manifestation of God’s Grace in the world.) I’m no scholar, so this is simply a humble understanding from lurking on these boards. God Bless.
 
Hi,

I can’t say where you will go, because that is only God’s decision, and only He knows 🙂

in my own opinion, I think that God is merciful to those who call upon Him…and knows your heart… but He also knows that the Protestants are not fully united to the Church and so Protestants might have to first go to purgatory for this (and so do many Catholics, for other reasons :))

also, I think the Church teaches that if someone knowingly rejects the Church, that can affect their salvation, though we don’t know for sure. Because teh Church is Christ’s Body. (like how Saul persecuted Christ by persecuting the Church…) the Church is the Catholic Church…

but there is salvation for non Catholics through invinsible ignorance. Even if a non Christian just never heard of Jesus, but would have accepted Him if he knew, and if he responded to whatever grace was given him in life, he can perhaps be saved (through Christ still)

Salvation isn’t faith alone… James 2 says, we’re not justified by “faith alone”. It doesn’t mean we’re saved by our works. It means that our faith is dead unless we have works, and this faith can’t save us.

You said that when you were a Catholic, you had to do all this stuff like to go to confession, fast, etc, and that’s what you believed would get you to heaven. Now, you believe you’re going to heaven because you accepted Christ’s sacrifice. But I’d say that all the Sacraments - confession, Communion, etc, - those are not “works”, those are works of God which give us grace…which transfer grace to our souls. And we need grace for salvation. This grace also comes through faith, but there is more of it in the Church because of the Sacraments. The Sacraments are like “tools” that God gave us to come to His grace. The fasting, etc, that isn’t for salvation, that’s just to prepare us for receiving the Sacraments, and for our spiritual growth…
simply “accepting Christ”, it’s a good thing, but what Catholics believe is that it’s not like His sacrifice “covers” all our sins…rather, our sins get entirely washed away. We get transformed. That’s why we don’t consider salvation a one step thing, just saying a prayer. Because we have to get transformed, and that’s as process, it’s a journey, involving not only faith but also cooperation with grace (works). To get to heaven, we need to be in a state of grace…but the reason purgatory exists is because a person might still not be perfect when they die, and so the perfection (sanctification) process is completed there.

God bless 🙂
 
:extrahappy:
Hi,

I can’t say where you will go, because that is only God’s decision, and only He knows 🙂

in my own opinion, I think that God is merciful to those who call upon Him…and knows your heart… but He also knows that the Protestants are not fully united to the Church and so Protestants might have to first go to purgatory for this (and so do many Catholics, for other reasons :))

also, I think the Church teaches that if someone knowingly rejects the Church, that can affect their salvation, though we don’t know for sure. Because teh Church is Christ’s Body. (like how Saul persecuted Christ by persecuting the Church…) the Church is the Catholic Church…

but there is salvation for non Catholics through invinsible ignorance. Even if a non Christian just never heard of Jesus, but would have accepted Him if he knew, and if he responded to whatever grace was given him in life, he can perhaps be saved (through Christ still)

Salvation isn’t faith alone… James 2 says, we’re not justified by “faith alone”. It doesn’t mean we’re saved by our works. It means that our faith is dead unless we have works, and this faith can’t save us.

You said that when you were a Catholic, you had to do all this stuff like to go to confession, fast, etc, and that’s what you believed would get you to heaven. Now, you believe you’re going to heaven because you accepted Christ’s sacrifice. But I’d say that all the Sacraments - confession, Communion, etc, - those are not “works”, those are works of God which give us grace…which transfer grace to our souls. And we need grace for salvation. This grace also comes through faith, but there is more of it in the Church because of the Sacraments. The Sacraments are like “tools” that God gave us to come to His grace. The fasting, etc, that isn’t for salvation, that’s just to prepare us for receiving the Sacraments, and for our spiritual growth…
simply “accepting Christ”, it’s a good thing, but what Catholics believe is that it’s not like His sacrifice “covers” all our sins…rather, our sins get entirely washed away. We get transformed. That’s why we don’t consider salvation a one step thing, just saying a prayer. Because we have to get transformed, and that’s as process, it’s a journey, involving not only faith but also cooperation with grace (works). To get to heaven, we need to be in a state of grace…but the reason purgatory exists is because a person might still not be perfect when they die, and so the perfection (sanctification) process is completed there.

God bless 🙂
Good to see you 4EverHis. :extrahappy:
Good Post.
The fact is that some Catholics just don’t understand the Catholic Faith, and they don’t take time to explore it.
 
Hi Bob, thank you for sharing a little of your story,
This is my opinion, and like any opinion, it can be wrong.

as can mine, that is why we have this forum…to share our opinions. either you or I do not know the absolute truth about a topic…maybe we both do not have it right…

Only God knows

I used to be Protestant, Presbyterian and Wesleyan Methodist, with Baptist participation thrown in. I became catholic a bit over a decade ago.

interesting

Yet the wisest and most prophetically accurate man I’ve met was my first Protesant pastor.

really

Therefore it came as a surprise to me when he commented to me in the privacy of his office, “I sometimes wonder if Protesants get to heaven.”

Hard to believe a pastor would declare this to anyone

His argument was that he didn’t think God was as easy going about the division of HIS church as we are. We put up a lot of straw arguments eg. “We’re spiritually united”, “You’ve just gotta be born again” etc,

the biggest problem with OSAS, which I totally disagree with

while ignoring Christ’s other teachings eg. to Peter that He would found His Church on him, that no-one can belong to Him unless they drink His Blood and eat His Flesh, the authority He gave to the apostles re. forgivnig and retaining sins (the basis of confession and apostolic authority) and so on.

catholic interpretation of scripture
I will not debate here, there is enough of that. we will go in circles on who got it right

This authority preceded the Bible which in the beginning of the Church didn’t even exist.

I agree with you.
I hope you can agree with me that the bible is made up of all the books inspired by God that preceeded Christ. The books and letters God inspired to be written after Christ comfirmed what was written in the old testament…all these books together make up the bible

from personal experience, my perception of the violent division of the church (particularly during the Reformation, which was easily the most violent upheaval in Church history), and the respect I gained for the old pastor’s personal wisdom from experience,

I think if you died today, you wouldn’t go to heaven. I think you’d have to wait till the church reunified.

Thank you so much for your honesty. I guess in a way this is how I felt in my catholic youth days. This is why I started this thread…

I have to believe that you are not the only catholic who believes this. Either the ones who do have not read this thread yet or they decided not to post.

If you died as a committed Christian, whether Catholic or not, you certainly wouldn’t go to Hell.

I am glad you believe that :).

My own belief is that you’d wind up in the almost heavenly end of what might be called Upper Purgatory, but not heaven.

Upper purgatory? like a first class suite in a AAAAA rated Hotel…sorry 😦 I couldn’t resist
it is the first time i heard the term upper purgatory
In case you do not know, I do not believe in purgatory.

I believe that at the moment of our death, within the next split second, we will be in our eternal home…heaven or hell

Like the old pastor, I don’t think God is very impressed with man’s immensely violent and continued division of the church which His own Son founded on Peter, by His own words.

founded on Peter or was He refererencing Himself as the rock.

Yes, Peter was a great leader. His conversion story is an amazing one.

however a rock is 100% solid.

Peter was not…He denied Jesus 3 times
To make sure that Peter understood what it meant to love Him, Jesus had to ask Peter multiple times…“Do you love me”?

Again my belief which can be in error. I am sure you believe it is.

What decision you make on all the answers you get is up to you, and of course the consequences will depend on your decision.
consequences… hell or upper purgatory for extended time… will depend on my decision

My decision determines my eternal destination
I 100% agree with you that the decision and **choice I make right now **determines my eternal destination

As I mentioned previously I believe that it is the decision everyone on the face of this earth makes right now which determines their own eternal destination.

God bless you
 
consequences… hell or upper purgatory for extended time… will depend on my decision

My decision determines my eternal destination
I 100% agree with you that the decision and **choice I make right now **determines my eternal destination

As I mentioned previously I believe that it is the decision everyone on the face of this earth makes right now which determines their own eternal destination.

God bless you
Except it’s not one decision. It’s a decision you make today, and then again tomorrow, and then again the next day and so on. It’s not a one-shot deal and anyone who thinks it is is misguided.
 
Except it’s not one decision. It’s a decision you make today, and then again tomorrow, and then again the next day and so on. It’s not a one-shot deal and anyone who thinks it is is misguided.
thank you MelanieAnne …

I am not sure if you mis understood me or just adding on to what I posted which I am in total agrement with you…100%

Tomorrow will become today right now, Next week, next year, next decade will all become…today, right now

the reason I believe I will go to heaven if I die right now is because of the decision I made today, right now to have faith and trust in Jesus Christ and the promises of the gift God has offered me. I will make the same decision tomorrow, next week, next year, next decade.

I have previously posted I do not believe in OSAS. I agree with you that anyone who believes in OSAS…one time decision and/or salvation prayer is misguided.

God bless you
 
mpjw2
Yes, Peter was a great leader. His conversion story is an amazing one.
however a rock is 100% solid.
Peter was not…He denied Jesus 3 times
To make sure that Peter understood what it meant to love Him, Jesus had to ask Peter multiple times…“Do you love me”?
Again my belief which can be in error. I am sure you believe it is.
I think you might want to take a second look at Peter:

Why Jesus asked Peter 3 times if he loved Him:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5607480&postcount=28

More info:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5552603&postcount=22

I promise you, they’re worth reading.

❤️ Love is Patient
 
hi 4everHis
Hi,

I can’t say where you will go, because that is only God’s decision, and only He knows 🙂

as you saw from my previous post, I believe it is the decision an individual makes right now. God is the only one who knows about the decision we as individuals have made.
that is why their are missionaries who travel to the “lost” nations to share the good news of the gospel and the decisions they all have made as individuals.

in my own opinion, I think that God is merciful to those who call upon Him…and knows your heart…

agree 100%

but He also knows that the Protestants are not fully united to the Church and so Protestants might have to first go to purgatory for this (and so do many Catholics, for other reasons 🙂

A catholic viewpoint which I respect…:).

also, I think the Church teaches that if someone knowingly rejects the Church, that can affect their salvation, though we don’t know for sure.

I believe if anyone rejects the church, they do not know Christ, thereby indirectly they are rejecting Christ. This will affect their salvation.

Because the Church is Christ’s Body. (like how Saul persecuted Christ by persecuting the Church.)

Agree 100%

the Church is the Catholic Church.

A Catholic interpretation I respect.

I believe Christ’s body is made up of many different parts. Each part, (the different christian churches which exist today…catholic, protestant, methodist, baptist, lutheran, pentacostal etc…) all have a very valuable part in the building of God’s kingdom.

I believe Jesus would love to see each part and/or church recognize Jesus Christ as the creator of the body which each church is part of.

but there is salvation for non Catholics through invinsible ignorance.

first time I heard of this invinsible ignorance. I guess you believe this applies to me since i am non cathoilc. Am I correct?

Even if a non Christian just never heard of Jesus, but would have accepted Him if he knew, and if he responded to whatever grace was given him in life, he can perhaps be saved (through Christ still)

Not according to Romans chapter 1…no man is without excuse

Salvation isn’t faith alone… James 2 says, we’re not justified by “faith alone”. It doesn’t mean we’re saved by our works. It means that our faith is dead unless we have works, and this faith can’t save us.

I agree with you 100%, The reason I want to do the work I do is because of the faith I first had in Jesus.

You said that when you were a Catholic, you had to do all this stuff like to go to confession, fast, etc, and that’s what you believed would get you to heaven. Now, you believe you’re going to heaven because you accepted Christ’s sacrifice.

Correct and trust in God, by faith, of the promise He made written in John 3:16

But I’d say that all the Sacraments - confession, Communion, etc, - those are not “works”, those are works of God which give us grace. which transfer grace to our souls. And we need grace for salvation. This grace also comes through faith, but there is more of it in the Church because of the Sacraments. The Sacraments are like “tools” that God gave us to come to His grace. The fasting, etc, that isn’t for salvation, that’s just to prepare us for receiving the Sacraments, and for our spiritual growth…

Agree with you today.
In my youth years I had put a different value on communion, confession, fasting, going to church etc.
I did these things out of obligation to please God, my parents, the nuns at school.
I had never put a value on these things that I they all help me grow spritually.

simply “accepting Christ”, it’s a good thing, but what Catholics believe is that it’s not like His sacrifice “covers” all our sins…rather, our sins get entirely washed away.

interesting comment. If I understand you correctly.
Which sins do you believe His sacrifice does not cover?

We get transformed. That’s why we don’t consider salvation a one step thing, just saying a prayer.

Agree 100%. In my last post to MelanieAnne I responded…
the reason I believe I will go to heaven if I die right now is because of the decision I made today, right now to have faith and trust in Jesus Christ and the promises of the gift God has offered me. I will make the same decision tomorrow, next week, next year, next decade.
God bless you
 
hi all,

I am curious as to what catholics believe about my eternal destination.
There are two things I know.
1 - God has a plan for each of us. (He knows)
2 - I am not privy to His plans for each of us. (I don’t)

I trust that God knows infinitely more than I do about who, what, where, and especially why.

If anyone tells you they *know *that you either are or are not going to heaven, assumes too much knowledge.
Moral certitude is one thing, absolute certainty is another … and I leave that to God.

michel
 
Except it’s not one decision. It’s a decision you make today, and then again tomorrow, and then again the next day and so on. It’s not a one-shot deal and anyone who thinks it is is misguided.
I agree.
Scripture tells us to pick up our cross daily.

michel
 
You know, I think all this worrying about whether we will go to heaven, hell or purgatory is a bit misguided. In my mind, the deal is to love God with all our heart, all our souls and all our strength and to love our neighbors as ourselves. Live your life the best you can and leave it to God to judge, knowing that he will judge fairly. Our perception of ourselves is always biased and our perception of others is always incomplete. Why waste time and energy worrying about it. In my simple way of thinking, if you are worried about it, its probably because your conscience is telling you something is wrong.

Given all that, if you know that the Catholic Sacraments provide the grace that allows you to get to heaven, why would you ever forsake it?
 
you believe purgatory exist, I do not
I do understand that the prejudice against this teaching is strong.
As an individual, there is scripture that makes me think, though.
I had two issues:
1 - Is there some place other than heaven and hell.
2 - If my sins are forgiven, why the need for purgatory to pay for them?

I wondered where all those that died before Jesus went to heaven.

1 Cor 3:13-15
[13] each man’s work will become manifest; for the Day will disclose it, because it will be revealed with fire, and the fire will test what sort of work each one has done.
[14] If the work which any man has built on the foundation survives, he will receive a reward.
[15] If any man’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss, though he himself will be saved, but only as through fire.

Where is this place (or state) in which a man suffers loss, but will be saved?
Can’t be heaven. There is no suffering in heaven.
Can’t be hell. There is no being saved from hell.

These passages started my wheels turning about the teaching on purgatory.
There must be more than just heaven and hell, even if they are only temporary places.

Anyway … it’s a hard nut to crack with some. I get that.

I also realize now that there is a difference between the forgiveness of sins and the punishment for sins.

David shows us this.
2 Samuel 12:13-14
[13] David said to Nathan, “I have sinned against the LORD.” And Nathan said to David, “The LORD also has put away your sin; you shall not die.
[14] Nevertheless, because by this deed you have utterly scorned the LORD, the child that is born to you shall die.”

David’s sin was forgiven, yet he was still punished.

I think of a scenario like a neighbor’s child breaking the front window of my house. I forgive him. I hold no malice toward him and have nothing but love for him in my heart. I still want him to pay for the window, though.

Forgiveness is different from payment.

These are the scriptures that got me to at least being open to what scripture is teaching.

michel
 
I think you might want to take a second look at Peter:

Why Jesus asked Peter 3 times if he loved Him:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5607480&postcount=28

More info:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showpost.php?p=5552603&postcount=22

I promise you, they’re worth reading.

❤️ Love is Patient
Love is patient I read both. I know what catholics believe. I am not going to debate scripture.
Whether or not I recognize Peter who you believe He is…the rock Jesus built His church upon…I believe it does not factor whether or not God accepts me to heaven.

I will die believing that the vatican…from the pope to the cardinals, bishops and priests is a great system of catholic leadership which all the faithful of the catholic church can follow and grow in faith from their teaching.

Did God have this system in his plan when Jesus said, “upon this rock”?

Catholics believe yes …I believe no

Only God knows the absolut truth

If and I say if I am wrong and millions of non catholic christians who share the same belief as I do…

do you believe God will not accept us into heaven?

Thank you and God bless

by the way my aunt is a nun. She and I have talked about why I am no longer practicing catholicism and is in total support of my decision.
 
I believe Christ’s body is made up of many different parts. Each part, (the different christian churches which exist today…catholic, protestant, methodist, baptist, lutheran, pentacostal etc…) all have a very valuable part in the building of God’s kingdom.
What I see in scripture is one body in Christ. Unified. Being of the same mind.
Scripture is not describing the church that Jesus founded as one with so many divisions on doctrine.
Protestantism goes against the unity I see described in scripture.

1 Cor 1:10
[10] I appeal to you, brethren, by the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that all of you agree and that there be no dissensions among you, but that you be united in the same mind and the same judgment.

I think you misuse the fact that Christ’s body is made of different parts.
I see these different parts as different functions.
But the hand of Jesus’ body will not have a differing doctrine than the knee of Jesus’ body.
The hand cannot say ‘abortion is okay’ while the knee says ‘it is murder’.

Think about it.
A non-Christian comes to you and asks, “why should I believe your Christian Church as opposed to that other guy’s?”

To an outsider, they will not see the unity that Jesus says is supposed to be the reason they know we are from God.

John 17:23
[23] I in them and thou in me, that they may become perfectly one, so that the world may know that thou hast sent me and hast loved them even as thou hast loved me.

The divisions from the reformation are scandalous to the church that Jesus founded.
These divisions are a stumbling block for those that we pray become Christians.

michel
 
by the way my aunt is a nun. She and I have talked about why I am no longer practicing catholicism and is in total support of my decision.
Yes. We have many clergy from the last couple of generations (since the late 1940’s, actually) that have thoughts and comments that are not in line with the Catholic Church’s teachings.
Your aunt, as lovely and holy as she may be, is not a spokesperson for the Church.
Her approval of your religious practices (or your perception that she approves) does not make your decision correct.

As your aunt would probably tell you, continue to pray.
We all hope to continue to grow and learn.

michel
 
I will die believing that the vatican…from the pope to the cardinals, bishops and priests is a great system of catholic leadership which all the faithful of the catholic church can follow and grow in faith from their teaching.

Did God have this system in his plan when Jesus said, “upon this rock”?
What kind of system?
One that met in council to decide doctrinal issues and to teach the church?

We see this in Acts 15.

Acts 15:28
[28] For it has seemed good to the Holy Spirit and to us…

I can’t see each community receiving the decree sent after this council and someone saying, “I’ll have to decide for myself if the scripture supports what they have said before I follow this teaching.”

An issue arose.
They tried to settle it locally.
They couldn’t.
They took it to the church.
They held a council and discussed.
A decision was made and it was seen to be ‘good to the Holy Spirit and to [them]’.
That teaching was then binding on all Christians.

We see an authoritative teaching authority in the church even in Acts 15.
This is all that the magisterium really is, the teaching authority of the church that Jesus founded.

You are kind in your words.
I am glad that you seem to see the church as having the purpose of teaching and helping the church grow in faith and holiness to draw us closer to Jesus.
Others are not so kind in their view of the Catholic Church.

michel
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top