Is Islam responsible for 9/11?

  • Thread starter Thread starter YHWH_Christ
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
"It is reported on the authority of Abu Huraira that he heard the Messenger of Allah say:

I have been commanded to fight against people till they testify that there is no god but Allah, that Muhammad is the messenger of Allah, and they establish prayer, and pay Zakat and if they do it, their blood and property are guaranteed protection on my behalf except when justified by law, and their affairs rest with Allah." (Sahih Muslim, Book 1, Hadith 34).

Anyone can agree nor disagree that Muhammad SAW is the Messenger of Allah in United States of America.
 
Last edited:
Oh my! I can’t believe the results on this I am seeing. Imagine asking ‘Was Catholicism responsible for all the burnings/torture/deaths during the Inquisition period of Spain?’ and seeing the same result! Wouldn’t happen.
 
My brother,

Please don’t say it if you never born and raised in the Third World Islamic country. I’m really grateful to live in Austria right now.
 
Last edited:
Let’s compare and contrast:

Some months ago, I caught a re-broadcast of Mother Angelica Live and it was back when the so called artwork “Urine Christ” was exhibited. While the artist probably got some hate mail and maybe some crank phone calls, I don’t recall anything serious happening to him; in fact, he’s gone on to create more blasphemous works. Anyway, this outstanding example of Catholic rigidity and intolerance was so enraged she… said a Hail Mary of reparation.

Fast forward a few years. Some CARTOONS “disrespectful” of Muhammad are published and people are murdered, either in planned attacks or riots of outrage. A mass shooting in Texas is barely stopped by a private security team protecting Pamela Geller’s “Draw the Prophet” contest and exhibition.

It IS a small percentage of Muslims who react this way. That said, the primal, foundational texts which IN CONTEXT support and justify these activities exist, are read, and DO promote terrorism, including 9/11.
 
BTW Angelus, the Catholic Church HAS examined its actions in the Inquisitions (plural) and has expressed sorrow and regret for Catholics, including those in the heirarchy, who WAY over stepped the bounds of the Commandments in perceived extreme circumstances. Look at Islam, and the repressive intolerance, rapaciousness, sexism, and cruelty is built right in and Pope Francis is WRONG in saying otherwise.

To those who say “that’s not true Islam” or even “that’s not MY Islam” all I and others who’ve taken “the red pill” can say is the jihadists are FAR more backed by the Koran and the aHaddith than the Muslim liberals.
 
It was pure secularist movement by the Castillian, at the time, to reclaim their own neighbourhood. Whats the problem for being patriotic.
 
Simple answer: No.

Terrorists with an extremist agenda who wanted to kill a large number of innocent people were responsible for 9-11.

There are a billion Muslims in the world. Very few are terrorists.
 
Here’s the problem: There May be only a very few number of terrorists; but the Koran advocates and permits violence against infidels. Whereas Our Lord taught us to turn the other cheek.

Islamic terrorists have a clear basis they can justify themselves in all honesty in their sacred text for all sorts of nasty behavior.

We don’t.

Plus, modern Westerners may decry the Crusades As a “ brutal war of intolerant aggression by superstitious barbarians greedy for land “; but let’s look at the truth:

The Crusades were defensive campaigns waged to defend Christian Byzantium beset by Muslim aggression and to recover Christian lands lost to Muslim conquest. Plus, Muslims were harassing Christian pilgrims who just wanted to visit the Holy Land and were harassed by intolerant Muslims.

And if you look at it; most crusaders fought in the Crusades to perform an indulgenced armed pilgrimage and didn’t settle in the Holy Land after the First Crusade.
 
Last edited:
I can’t answer the poll because has three questions but only one chance to answer.
Is Islam as a religion responsible for inspiring the attacks?
No.
Or was it a gross misinterpretation of Islam by the perpetrators?
Yes.
Is Islam an inherently terroristic religion?
No.
 
Canvas,
An extemist agenda the 9/11 terrorists didn’t pull out of thin air, but from the Koran , the aHaddith, and Ijma rulings of 1500+ years.
 
King Alfonso “The Wise” X actually ask the Granada ruler at the time for peaceful pact to leave Al-Andalusian. However, it’s just disgrace that Spanish colonial messacred people of Philippines.
 
Wahabis is the real problem. They are Saudis supremacist.
 
CT,

Not. impressed, Can we say historically shallow? (So is your comment on the Spanish Inquisition, but never mind). Wahhabi began in the 18th C, but Jihad, including informal, individual expressions began in the 7th.
 
I agree with you on Spanish inquisition. It was an ignorance on my part. However, at least since the 10th century there have been attempts from Castilian to control over Al-Andalus.

Indeed the original form of Islam such as terrorism, mental slavery, and others. But the expectations of Muslims outside the Arab peninsula know nothing about “real” Islam. Therefore Wahhabi is a delicious spice so that Muslims around the world support the supremacy of the Arabs. In fact, Shia Islam, which assimilates Zoroastrian culture with Islam, is annulled by the Muslim community itself.

The document that I am informing is the most trustful document which is actually happening in the middle east right now. The Iranians are even banned for performing the “Hajj” at Mecca.
 
Last edited:
SaberBob said:
That said, the primal, foundational texts which IN CONTEXT support and justify these activities exist, are read, and DO promote terrorism, including 9/11.
Click to expand...
9/11 was wrong, and only the terrorists responsible should have been bought to justice. Instead, Afghanistan and Iraq are bombed, killing tens of thousands of innocent people who had nothing to do with 9/11.

How do you justify the killing of thousands of innocent people? How does that make America and its allies any better than Islamist terrorists?
 
We fought the Crusades for a reason, and should have the humility and courage to do so again if need be.
 
well, this thread makes for amusing reading, as there appear to be a fair number of people who know nothing of the last 60 years of history world wide.

“There is only a small number of people who are terrorists” are the type of comments passed off as having some meaning.

The U.S. Military amounts to a bit under 35 thoundths of 1% of the US population (1.3 million out of 372.2 million people - and that does not account for ex military - only active).

Y’all might as the Israelis how many militant individuals of the Islamic faith they have encountered in the last 75 years. Or do a little actual reading of what has gone one in Afghanistan in about the smae period. Or try Indonesia. Or Iraq. Or Syria.

It is said, in a thumb nail sketch, that Christianity is a religion of mercy and Islam is a religion of justice, and therein lies a truly significant difference.

Or you might ask the French police about the “no-go” zones in France, areas they dare not enter, I could go on, but I have better things to try to accomplish. It is not for no reason that the western world, and in particular the US, is called the Great Satan.
 
Eric_Hyom said:
How does that make America and its allies any better than Islamist terrorists?
Click to expand...
The World Trade Center was accidentally hit thinking it a military bunker. That’s how.

I like softball questions.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top