Is it a sin to follow my dream?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sling_Shot
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sling_Shot

Guest
Hello, thank you all at Catholic Answers Forums for your prayers and support.

I have written about quitting my job back in February forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=946089

SUMMARY: To make a long story short, three weeks ago I began applying to other places, last week I put in my two-weeks’ notice, now I have an opportunity to pursue my dream to work with my art, but I feel bad. (Feel free to skip down to the conclusion at this point.)

Details:

The job was providing respite care for adult brothers with severe developmental delays, a field I have been in professionally for over ten years. I gave notice in part because of a violent incident detailed below, in part because of becoming burned out, and in part due to frustrations with the lack of communication and negative atmosphere.

I have studied art, and recently did well in an illustration contest. I use most of my spare time each week to work on commissions and my portfolio. I am relatively young and newly married, and I want to give my dream a shot while the opportunity is here. But I feel bad. Why?

Examples of administrative frustrations:

-Behavioral incidents were not reported; I had to specifically ask my coworkers when I arrived for my shift if anything happened. When I heard of alarming behavior, I asked if they had emailed a report to the supervisor. No, they hadn’t. Once I experienced such an incident first-hand, I immediately wrote a report to the super.

-A meeting was called, which I was only able to attend over the phone – teleconference. I re-arranged my day to be available for that phone call, and never heard anything. After the meeting, there were no notes, and what one co-worker told me was contradicted by another.

-Incident charts were then made available, (after I asked for a way to communicate/record behavior among staff) but after a few weeks, I am now the only one who uses them. Again, I would arrive at work and hear of the same alarming behavior, but there was nothing written down. I even witnessed some very alarming incidents, and the staff involved said, “Oh, I mentioned it to the super.” But that leaves nothing for other staff, so I wrote a report for her.

-Two weeks ago, my client became uncharacteristically violent towards me.* I had not altered my friendly and personal treatment that I had with him since beginning there eight months ago. This incident was so intense that I had to sneak out of the house by a different door. I was so exhausted, I was barely able to complete my next shift (a child with autism). *Because of the disordered nature of the behavior, I suspect biochemical, rather than behavioral, issues.

Examples of negative atmosphere:

-My coworkers continually complain about other staff members. When one staff was unable to make it to work due to his car battery, another staff said outright, “no it’s not, he’s lying!”

-Another time when he was late due to traffic, a different coworker, disbelieving, vocally looked up traffic patterns on her phone, apparently to catch him lying.

-The most senior staff member, and the only one besides myself who is really trained for this work, arrives a half-hour late every day, and does not notify me when he (frequently) takes a day off, something I have specifically asked him to do several times.

-When I took time off for Christmas/New Year’s, my supervisor said, “Ok, if you take all that time off, someone is going to have to cover for you.” (I think I took maybe six days off) They are very understaffed, vacation policy is unclear, and because of being understaffed, some of my coworkers take on tons of extra time (overtime is unpaid) and… complain about it to me, but will not mention it to the super, as I suggest each time they bring up their hours.

CONCLUSION: (Finally! Whew!)

Now that I have put in my notice, my supervisor has offered me a raise if I stay, and even the option to work one day a week. I still have my evening shift, but it does not generate a lot of income. My husband is very supportive of my leaving; he very much wants me to pursue my art. I feel like I am leaving a “Christ-serving, healing” line of work (I like the work, not the workplace) to pursue something “selfish” that I really really want.

My art would involve me working from home (my sky-in-the-pie dream is to create intelligent and beautiful children’s books), which I could hopefully adjust to compliment motherhood, God willing. (I would quit away-from-home work for the babies, anyway.) But I would do my art anyway, even if no one was paying me for it. (Getting paid is nice, though, ha-ha)

Any advice is appreciated! In the meantime, I will continue to pray. Thank you all who take time to share their wisdom.

God bless,
-SlingShot
 
The kind of caring you have been doing is very intense, both physically and mentally. If you do that sort of work, you need to be employed by a well-organised and supportive organisation, or you will soon get burnt-out. Unfortunately, all too often you have to struggle with staff shortages and other challenges, as staff tend not to stay forever - it’s not physically possible, IMO. I have personal experience of these working environments, by the way.

Seems to me that you have gone as far as you can at that job, at least for the foreseeable future. If you leave now, you are not shutting the door on it forever, if you wish to return at a future date (and perhaps with another employer). God gave you talents, and one of them is artistic skill. To illustrate lovely books for little children is not a selfish line of work at all! The children will read them, enjoy them, learn and read more.

In the future, you’ll be able to balance work and motherhood and your own children will benefit tremendously from that. Your husband supports you and you should definitely give yourself this chance to fulfil your dream, in my view.

I hope you are hugely successful and on the best-seller list very soon! Good luck to you and may God bless you. 🙂
 
Hello, thank you all at Catholic Answers Forums for your prayers and support.

I have written about quitting my job back in February forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=946089

SUMMARY: To make a long story short, three weeks ago I began applying to other places, last week I put in my two-weeks’ notice, now I have an opportunity to pursue my dream to work with my art, but I feel bad. (Feel free to skip down to the conclusion at this point.)

Details:

The job was providing respite care for adult brothers with severe developmental delays, a field I have been in professionally for over ten years. I gave notice in part because of a violent incident detailed below, in part because of becoming burned out, and in part due to frustrations with the lack of communication and negative atmosphere.

I have studied art, and recently did well in an illustration contest. I use most of my spare time each week to work on commissions and my portfolio. I am relatively young and newly married, and I want to give my dream a shot while the opportunity is here. But I feel bad. Why?

Examples of administrative frustrations:

-Behavioral incidents were not reported; I had to specifically ask my coworkers when I arrived for my shift if anything happened. When I heard of alarming behavior, I asked if they had emailed a report to the supervisor. No, they hadn’t. Once I experienced such an incident first-hand, I immediately wrote a report to the super.

-A meeting was called, which I was only able to attend over the phone – teleconference. I re-arranged my day to be available for that phone call, and never heard anything. After the meeting, there were no notes, and what one co-worker told me was contradicted by another.

-Incident charts were then made available, (after I asked for a way to communicate/record behavior among staff) but after a few weeks, I am now the only one who uses them. Again, I would arrive at work and hear of the same alarming behavior, but there was nothing written down. I even witnessed some very alarming incidents, and the staff involved said, “Oh, I mentioned it to the super.” But that leaves nothing for other staff, so I wrote a report for her.

-Two weeks ago, my client became uncharacteristically violent towards me.* I had not altered my friendly and personal treatment that I had with him since beginning there eight months ago. This incident was so intense that I had to sneak out of the house by a different door. I was so exhausted, I was barely able to complete my next shift (a child with autism). *Because of the disordered nature of the behavior, I suspect biochemical, rather than behavioral, issues.

Examples of negative atmosphere:

-My coworkers continually complain about other staff members. When one staff was unable to make it to work due to his car battery, another staff said outright, “no it’s not, he’s lying!”

-Another time when he was late due to traffic, a different coworker, disbelieving, vocally looked up traffic patterns on her phone, apparently to catch him lying.

-The most senior staff member, and the only one besides myself who is really trained for this work, arrives a half-hour late every day, and does not notify me when he (frequently) takes a day off, something I have specifically asked him to do several times.

-When I took time off for Christmas/New Year’s, my supervisor said, “Ok, if you take all that time off, someone is going to have to cover for you.” (I think I took maybe six days off) They are very understaffed, vacation policy is unclear, and because of being understaffed, some of my coworkers take on tons of extra time (overtime is unpaid) and… complain about it to me, but will not mention it to the super, as I suggest each time they bring up their hours.

CONCLUSION: (Finally! Whew!)

Now that I have put in my notice, my supervisor has offered me a raise if I stay, and even the option to work one day a week. I still have my evening shift, but it does not generate a lot of income. My husband is very supportive of my leaving; he very much wants me to pursue my art. I feel like I am leaving a “Christ-serving, healing” line of work (I like the work, not the workplace) to pursue something “selfish” that I really really want.

My art would involve me working from home (my sky-in-the-pie dream is to create intelligent and beautiful children’s books), which I could hopefully adjust to compliment motherhood, God willing. (I would quit away-from-home work for the babies, anyway.) But I would do my art anyway, even if no one was paying me for it. (Getting paid is nice, though, ha-ha)

Any advice is appreciated! In the meantime, I will continue to pray. Thank you all who take time to share their wisdom.

God bless,
-SlingShot
Where does the “sin” part come in. All this seems to be is just a decision that you are struggling with. And it sounds like you have all the information organized in your head. I’m not you, but I would do what I wanted to do.
 
Slingshot

The simple fact that they offered you more pay to stay on is an admission that they have been underpaying you all this time. You owe them nothing. You’re totally free do to whatever is best for you.
 
Slingshot

The simple fact that they offered you more pay to stay on is an admission that they have been underpaying you all this time. You owe them nothing. You’re totally free do to whatever is best for you.
Exactly.
Bolt.
 
You weren’t planning on staying forever, right? So, you can leave now.

On a somewhat different topic, bear in mind that it will be more and more possible to self-publish children’s books, even lavishly illustrated ones. Color Kindles make that very feasible and convenient for families to carry around a library of picture books. I haven’t bought children’s books myself on the Kindle, but I have bought a number of inexpensive self-published ones, and I’m quite willing to take a gamble on a $3 self-published book.

You’re thinking entirely of the caring work that you won’t do if you leave to follow your art. But what about the art that you won’t do if you do the caring work?
 
Also, if you are seriously hurt on the job because of the mismanagement that you have described (and it could easily happen), what happens to you, your husband and your future children?
 
You weren’t planning on staying forever, right? So, you can leave now.

On a somewhat different topic, bear in mind that it will be more and more possible to self-publish children’s books, even lavishly illustrated ones. Color Kindles make that very feasible and convenient for families to carry around a library of picture books. I haven’t bought children’s books myself on the Kindle, but I have bought a number of inexpensive self-published ones, and I’m quite willing to take a gamble on a $3 self-published book.

You’re thinking entirely of the caring work that you won’t do if you leave to follow your art. But what about the art that you won’t do if you do the caring work?
Excellent points!
FWIW, the St. Vincent de Paul Society always needs compassionate people as case workers on a volunteer basis. Your gifts can certainly be used and much more appreciated.
Go where your heart is, and give your "extra gifts " to the needy.
 
Excellent points!
FWIW, the St. Vincent de Paul Society always needs compassionate people as case workers on a volunteer basis. Your gifts can certainly be used and much more appreciated.
Go where your heart is, and give your "extra gifts " to the needy.
Yes!

You could be very valuable to a vulnerable child or adult as a CASA or guardian ad litem. (And it could easily be a child or adult with even less resources than the individuals you are currently working with.)

Best wishes!
 
God bless you for the work you’ve done with those who have developmental delays.
What a blessing you must have been in such a position. I’m sorry the work environment had deteriorated and your client has had violent outbursts. You’ve certainly given a lot of yourself to that position.

It’s wonderful you have this opportunity to follow your dream and I agree it’s time to do so.

GO for it and best of luck on your new journey.

Mary.
 
Any advice is appreciated! In the meantime, I will continue to pray. Thank you all who take time to share their wisdom.
You have outlined more than sufficient reasons to leave the organization. The threat of violence alone is grounds for immediately leaving, let alone all of the other reasons you cited.

Pursuing your passion and talents is a better alternative. If, for whatever reason, you elect to get back into a more formal job setting, you can find a more reputable employer that will take better care of your physical safety, not to mention economic opportunity and dealing with more competent fellow employees and management.
 
I am sad that you had such bad experiences with your job, but I think that is immaterial.

You do a good job at work. You decide you want to go in a different direction. You give notice and go on your way. No harm, no foul. Even if it was a great job and you loved it, you still have the right to move along when you want to.

I think the only way leaving a position would be sinful is if you fail do carry out your duties as promised until the end, don’t follow procedure or leave a job that is needed to support your family with no other job or prospect to go to.
 
Rip that bandaid off….yes, it’s going to hurt, but you need to do it. Be free from the stress of this situation, and move on with your lovely life. You are not morally bound to this company, and as others have said, the fact they offered you a raise just proves how undervalued you were.

Good luck with your artistic endeavors!
 
I just want to thank everyone for sharing their wisdom and support. CAF has been a real blessing. Please keep me in your prayers, and you will be in mine as well!

God bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top