Is it a sin to say a priest is wrong?

  • Thread starter Thread starter strugglingalong
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

strugglingalong

Guest
Hi,

Question. Is it a sin to tell a priest he is wrong? I had a recent situation where I basically told a priest that I thought the way he spoke to me was too harsh and that perhaps a little gentleness and love could help too. Do you think that is wrong, a sin, or anything?

I guess I know we need to respect and love our priests, and I do. But I think if we see a problem in anyone we should be able to tell them, out of love for them, and without any sort of vengefulness or anger or anything, but out of love.

Just wondered what you guys think…

Or should we never say anything to a priest about what may be something wrong or an imperfection or something?

Christ’s peace to you all!
 
Hi,

Question. Is it a sin to tell a priest he is wrong? I had a recent situation where I basically told a priest that I thought the way he spoke to me was too harsh and that perhaps a little gentleness and love could help too. Do you think that is wrong, a sin, or anything?

I guess I know we need to respect and love our priests, and I do. But I think if we see a problem in anyone we should be able to tell them, out of love for them, and without any sort of vengefulness or anger or anything, but out of love.

Just wondered what you guys think…

Or should we never say anything to a priest about what may be something wrong or an imperfection or something?

Christ’s peace to you all!
CRITICISM OF PRIESTS
Our Lord’s revelations to Mutter Vogel

“One should NEVER attack a priest, even when he’s in error, rather one should pray and do penance that I’ll grant him My grace again. He alone fully represents Me, even when he doesn’t live after My example!” (page 29, Mutter Vogel’s Worldwide Love, St. Grignion Publishing House, Altoting, South Germany (29. 6. 1929)).

When a Priest falls we should extend him a helping hand THROUGH PRAYER AND NOT THROUGH ATTACKS! “I myself will be his judge, NO ONE BUT I!” “Whoever voices judgment over a priest has voiced it over Me; child, never let a Priest be attacked, take up his defense.” (Feast of Christ the King 1937) "Child, Never judge your confessor, rather pray much for him and offer every Thursday, through the hands of My blessed Mother, Holy Communion (for Him) (18.6. 1939)&nsp; “Never again accept an out-of-the-way word about a Priest, and speak no unkind word (about them) EVEN IF IT WERE TRUE! Every Priest is My Vicar and My heart will be sickened and insulted because of it! If you hear a judgment (against a Priest) pray a Hail Mary.” (28. 6. 1939)

“If you see a Priest who celebrates the Holy Mass unworthily then say nothing about him, rather tell it to Me alone! I stand beside him on the altar!” “Oh pray much for My priests, that they’ll love purity above all, that they’ll celebrate the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass with pure hands and heart. Certainly the Holy Sacrifice is one and the same even when it is celebrated by an unworthy priest, but the graces called down upon the people is not the same!” (28. 2. 1938)

Mary. Queen of the Clergy, pray for them.

angelfire.com/ca3/rafaelmarie/ThePieta/zkpriest.html
 
Uh…the OP didn’t say he attacked the priest for crying out loud. He said he told him he thought he was wrong. Priests a human beings -fallible just like the rest of us.

I don’t know the details to make a judgement one way or another in this particular case but the post about not attacking priests is way over the top and honestly a little scary. If one followed those instructions literally it is easy to see why child molesting priest were able to hide for so long.

I would say it depends on the tone of the correction and the seriousness of matter. I think if it was done with gentleness and charity that would be fine.
 
I don’t think it’s a sin to say a priest is wrong, but you had better have an exact understanding that the two of you are talking about the same thing and you can backup your case.

Far, far too many people on this website are much too eager to claim a priest is wrong when the priest and the lay person have two different things in minds. The lay person had best make sure both are on the same page and he has facts and documents to back up his case.

The many years a priest studies Catholicism shouldn’t be taken lightly.
 
Question. Is it a sin to tell a priest he is wrong? I had a recent situation where I basically told a priest that I thought the way he spoke to me was too harsh and that perhaps a little gentleness and love could help too. Do you think that is wrong, a sin, or anything?
Do you agree that what he said was correct, but the tone was too harsh? Or do you think that he was both wrong in what he said and in the way that he said it?
 
I agree with rayne89-- priests are fallible just like the rest of us. Their vocation is pastoral, so you would hope they have a natural inclination to be kind and understanding, and that they would have a gift for putting things in a way that makes them easier to understand.
That said life is about learning by mistakes. I think it’s important that you tell someone if what they say hurts you. God gives us other people as mirrors- this way we can see what we do that upsets others and how we would like to be treated ourselves. Hopefully this priest will learn from his experience and try to include more charity the next time he has to say something difficult to someone.
 
Do you agree that what he said was correct, but the tone was too harsh? Or do you think that he was both wrong in what he said and in the way that he said it?
I agreed with the content just not with the way it was presented.

Christ’s peace to you.
 
CRITICISM OF PRIESTS
Our Lord’s revelations to Mutter Vogel

“One should NEVER attack a priest, even when he’s in error, rather one should pray and do penance that I’ll grant him My grace again. He alone fully represents Me, even when he doesn’t live after My example!” (page 29, Mutter Vogel’s Worldwide Love, St. Grignion Publishing House, Altoting, South Germany (29. 6. 1929)).
I have no idea who Mutter Vogel is and why I should take what you copied and pasted as fact and truth. I am not saying it is false but revelations qua revelations aren’t always trustworthy.

Christ’s peace to you.
 
Hi,

Question. Is it a sin to tell a priest he is wrong? I had a recent situation where I basically told a priest that I thought the way he spoke to me was too harsh and that perhaps a little gentleness and love could help too. Do you think that is wrong, a sin, or anything?

I guess I know we need to respect and love our priests, and I do. But I think if we see a problem in anyone we should be able to tell them, out of love for them, and without any sort of vengefulness or anger or anything, but out of love.

Just wondered what you guys think…

Or should we never say anything to a priest about what may be something wrong or an imperfection or something?

Christ’s peace to you all!
depends on what you mean by “being wrong.” If you mean is interpersonal skills leave something to be desired or worse, may have put him in a bad situation, a gentle reminder the same way you would give it to someone else may be in order. The most effective way to express your displeasure with how someone has treated you or spoken to you is by using I statements rather than you statements. “I felt very hurt when you told me such and so, Father,” not “Father, you were very cruel in your remarks to me yesterday.”

If you mean he is teaching false doctrine from the pulpit or elsewhere, or allowing liturgical abuses, that is another matter. There is a protocol for how to address such situations, it has been mentioned here before and is on the cuf.org site.

If you mean he is guilty of moral offenses or misbehaviors that could give scandal or pose danger to others you should speak to his bishop or write him a brief, specific letter with dates, times and places and sign it, send it and ask for proof of delivery receipt.
 
I have a lot of anger or animosity towards our new priest at times. I disagree with his theology and ways of doing things on numerous occasions. I am not afraid to argue with him or speak my mind about him. Even though I think I am right, sometimes they way I act or the way I go about it might be sinful. I have confessed this to another priest and was told this is probably not good for my spirtuality but I don’t think he told me it was sinful as long as I am more careful and respectful about the way I deal with the situation. I am loyal to my parish so I won’t leave until I move.
 
Again the definition of Right and Wrong is relative to each of us who was in the position of an observer. For me, we have to see when the action took place. If it was during the holy mass, we should not “attack” of even “object” such priest. (But, logically the situation described would be quite impossible to occur during a holy mass anyway). The Priest during the holy mass (or equivalent of a minister who presides during any christian services) is regarded as the bridge between God and us. So, whoever in the position of the representative of God or the one who is being used by God in a valid occation (such as a holy mass) should be in the position of infallible. Otherwise, there is no point for us to listen to let alone to follow him, right? On the other hand, however, if a Priest is NOT in a HOLY MASS celebration, he is not in the position of infallible. Therefore, he is fallible. So, if we believe that a priest is making a mistake not in the context of holy mass celebration, we have a duty to remind him and pray for him that he would realize his mistake. In the case presented, I believe the occurence was not in a holy mass celebration. I have never seen nor heard in my life, whereever I go, that a priest would talk to somebody in such an “unusual” way during a mass celebration.
 
Shoot, I have no problem directly telling a cardinal archbishop that he’s wrong when it’s what he needs to hear (and, discretely, I have). Yes, how you go about it is important, but there’s no reason that we shouldn’t express our concerns when they need to be. Certainly, there’s an appropriate occasion for this sort of thing at times. It’s by no means sinful to do what has to be done. Indeed, that is how the Lord works through our own lives, also.
 
Generally, I’ve had a very good relation with my Parish Priest, who is very understanding and compassionate, even when I have made considerable demands on him or dropped on him out of the blue. My confessors have also been good.

Before we judge a priest, we should do our best to forgive their weaknesses. Priests are human beings as well, like us, and have flaws, and can get tired, worn out, sad, angry, and impatient. We should also make sure we are not inflamed by pride when making a judgement on a priest.

If a priest was doing something very gravely wrong, such as soliciting a sexual act from a penitent, or abusing a child (both offences which merit latinae sentienae excommunication under canon law) one should, if knowing about this, inform an appropriate authority and let the church deal with it. One should only make it a public matter if the matter is extremely grave and keeping a lid may do more damage to the church than letting it out.

But generally most priests are well educated and formed and are also very compassionate, so one should refrain from passing judgement on a priest for anything unless there is a very good reason to do so.
 
Seems to me that I recall the story of a woman who travelled a great distance to see the Pope. When she got there, she told him off!! I don’t recall what the problem was, but I do recall that the woman is now a canonized saint of the church. And the problem over which she tasked the poor man was eventually corrected.
So, apparently it’s sometimes a good thing to criticize a priest.

Matthew
 
Seems to me that I recall the story of a woman who travelled a great distance to see the Pope. When she got there, she told him off!! I don’t recall what the problem was, but I do recall that the woman is now a canonized saint of the church. And the problem over which she tasked the poor man was eventually corrected.
So, apparently it’s sometimes a good thing to criticize a priest.

Matthew
You are talking about St. Catherine of Seinna telling the Popes to move from Avignon in France back to Rome. If you read any of her letters(There are parts of them quoted in Warren Carrol’ 3rd volume on the History of Christiandom.) she was insistent, but very polite and respectful. He was by no means a poor man. She also traveled as you said and spoke to him personally, Not a woman to give up easily.
 
No, it is not.

When, how and where are important considerations, i.e., better not to respond in the heat of the moment, it should be done with charity and gentleness, and it should not take place in a situation where he’s likely to be put on the spot and publicly embarrassed … but then, we should keep these 3 things in mind for everyone we have to correct …

Fraternal correction is part of Christian charity and a moral obligation for every Christian.

Heavy emphasis on the charity though … 🙂
 
Hi,

Question. Is it a sin to tell a priest he is wrong?
A priest is a human being, and he is also someone that we should show respect for, so while it’s not wrong to tell a priest that he is wrong (if he is) we have to go about it in much the same way that we might correct a parent or teacher - that is, focus on the facts, and ask questions to clarify your understanding (make sure you’re not the one who’s wrong).

Some things are not worth being bothered about, and it’s important to pick your battles.

When it comes to feelings, “I” messages are best, and make good use of appropriate, respectful humour as a tool for communication.
 
The tone was harsh but was the message valid. Sometimes Priest do have to get there point across. Like when Jesus was telling his disciples of things to come, and when they replied that there not going to allow it, want did Jesus say “back you satan you are thinking as men do!”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top