Is it a vow or is it bargaining?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Beachcomber
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Beachcomber

Guest
I would like some opinions on this: I realize that one isn’t supposed to ‘bargain’ with God over a prayer request; but I know that people will make a vow to do a specific thing if their prayers are answered.

Is that a form of bargaining with God? Or should I make a vow? And I’m not really sure what kind of vow I would make.

The reason I’m asking is that I’m dealing with something right now, giving it a lot of prayer. It’s not a decision, per se, but rather an ‘outcome’ of something in progress.

Any thoughts and opinions are appreciated.
 
I would like some opinions on this: I realize that one isn’t supposed to ‘bargain’ with God over a prayer request; but I know that people will make a vow to do a specific thing if their prayers are answered.

Is that a form of bargaining with God? Or should I make a vow? And I’m not really sure what kind of vow I would make.

The reason I’m asking is that I’m dealing with something right now, giving it a lot of prayer. It’s not a decision, per se, but rather an ‘outcome’ of something in progress.

Any thoughts and opinions are appreciated.
My dear friend

You should not make a vow just to try and get a prayer answered. You certainly should talk to your priest and ask his advice before making any vows too. If you deliberately break any vows it’s a mortal sin you know.

If in doubt consult a good priest.

God bless you:thumbsup:🙂

John
 
My dear friend

You should not make a vow just to try and get a prayer answered. You certainly should talk to your priest and ask his advice before making any vows too. If you deliberately break any vows it’s a mortal sin you know.

If in doubt consult a good priest.

God bless you:thumbsup:🙂

John
Thanks for your reply. I hadn’t thought of the mortal sin issue.

It was exactly what you said: making a vow to get an answer. That’s what I thought was more like bargaining. I think what was going through my mind, however imperfectly, was that I wanted an answer so much that, in gratitude for an answer, I would do “X,” whatever “X” would be.

I do believe I’ll make an appointment with our parish priest. He’s a very approachable, kind man, full of good sense and spirituality. I feel very lucky to have him at the parish.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top