Is it bad that I have no religious tolerance?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AndrewJMason
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AndrewJMason

Guest
I guess it’s not as bad as I put it there. I don’t HATE or Dislike the people of the religion. I just strongly dislike other religions. Well, their belief system. I respect non-christian religions. But the hardest thing for me is Protestantarinism I can’t stand their beliefs. They make no sense, and they’re false. They are not supported at all by scripture, and it’s hard. Is this bad?
 
I guess it’s not as bad as I put it there. I don’t HATE or Dislike the people of the religion. I just strongly dislike other religions. Well, their belief system. I respect non-christian religions. But the hardest thing for me is Protestantarinism I can’t stand their beliefs. They make no sense, and they’re false. They are not supported at all by scripture, and it’s hard. Is this bad?
Couple of things. I actually believe that is true of many Catholic beliefs where Protestants and Catholics are divided: But let’s not get into that debate:

This is what the Catechism of the CC says:

838 "The Church knows that she is joined in many ways to the baptized who are honored by the name of Christian, but do not profess the Catholic faith in its entirety or have not preserved unity or communion under the successor of Peter."322 Those "who believe in Christ and have been properly baptized are put in a certain, although imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church."323 With the Orthodox Churches, this communion is so profound "that it lacks little to attain the fullness that would permit a common celebration of the Lord’s Eucharist."324

The Catholic church recognizes Orthodox and Protestants as Christians, but does not seem them as possessing the fullness of the Catholic faith. Catholics are called to accept non Catholics as fellow Christians while hoping for them to become fully unified with the Catholic church.

Hated has no place in the church. Rather, you should pray for your seperated brothers and sisters that any falsehoods we have adopted should would be revealed to us. Pray for the unity of Christ’s body.
 
I have come to ask the same question for myself. I have been brought up as a Jehovahs Witness and it angers me how they twist scriptures to make it fit their viewpoints. Since I have left the group a number of years ago I started reading into Catholicism, and through much prayer and study im now Catholic and beleive what they teach about God and everything else. I did alot of research on a protestant denomonations, and they are all just a branch off what was the true Church for the many centuries before. I lost family and many friends over what I have come to beleive is true. I do feel your frusteration when it comes to other religions. The thing im learning now is that we have to stand firm in our faith and have that intimate relationship with God. That’s between you and God, nobody else. If people want to preach another Gospel other then the one Jesus Christ teached, they will have to answer to God for it.

God bless
 
But the hardest thing for me is Protestantarinism I can’t stand their beliefs. They make no sense, and they’re false. They are not supported at all by scripture
The basic beliefs of Protestantism is basic Christianity. It would be inaccurate to say they’re supported by nothing but Scripture, but anything else is at best second in authority to that. So there’s some factual inaccuracy to what you say, and it’s not really surprising that you have some things to work through as you convert from one thing to another. Try to do so in a way that’s generally positive rather than negative.

You are converting from some form of Protestantism, yes? If so, make sure you don’t burn too many bridges on your way across the Tiber. You might need them in the long term for one reason or another.
 
Hi AndrewJ!

My suggestion, as a non-Catholic, is to pray for us the way we pray for you as a fellow Christian.

It’s also true that people tend to hate or fear that which they do not understand. It would potentially benefit you, and help control your feelings of distaste and anger, if you perhaps learned more about Protestant or non-Catholic religions. (NOT trying to convert you). It’s easier for me, as an Episcopalian, to love and accept all of my Christian brothers and sisters by learning as much as I can about how we are similar, why we may differ, and why it’s OK to have differing views on some things - as long as we all come together in Christ.

God bless.
 
Well, we should not hate people of other beliefs but neither accept what they believe. I suppose liking Protestants is different to liking what they believe. I have friends who are Protestants and non - Christians and I like them a lot. But what they believe? Not at all. I think it is important to distinguish between the two.
 
Well, we should not hate people of other beliefs but neither accept what they believe. I suppose liking Protestants is different to liking what they believe. I have friends who are Protestants and non - Christians and I like them a lot. But what they believe? Not at all. I think it is important to distinguish between the two.
I feel so much better after reading this quote.

But on topic, being as though I came up with a Protestant following due to my family. I am now branching out and searching for myself the origin of Christianity and that’s Catholicism. As I draw more deeper into this Truth I look back and for some reason I began developing a hatred for Protestants also. Don’t know why but I think what upsets me is when they use Sacred Scripture for personal interpetation. My mother and grandmother do this so it’s probably why I frown upon them now. So to some extent I was in the same boat as OP but feel better now after reading the above quote 🙂

Bruce
 
I used to feel the same way. I understand what you are saying. I actually just signed up to CAF to write a post. It is so obvious to us that the Catholic Church is the one holy and apostolic church. We are not trying to be so judgmental, it is just hard to look at Protestantism and not feel upset at their teachings. Recently, I have been talking/debating with an Evangelical pastor who is trying to “show me in Scripture where the Catholic Church teaches opposite to the Bible”, and convert me. I am very strong in my faith in the Catholic Church, so I decided to hear what he had to say. Maybe I will help him understand our teachings more accurately, thus leading him to the truth.( of course, the HOly Spirit is responsible for wisdom and understanding!) Anyway, in doing so, I have a much better understanding of Protestant teachings and am more respectful to all Christians. It is easy to see why so many people don’t understand the full truth when you know how they are being taught… The way they piece things together, does make for an understandable case. This pastor also told me that he doesn’t feel as though anyone broke away from the Catholic church, rather they reformed the Church. Of course, we don’t agree, but when you look at it from his side, you can be a little more tolerant. I am so happy that I have had these conversations with him because know I am a kinder, gentler Catholic…who ultimately is even more strong in my belief that the Catholic church is where we all need to be!
 
I feel so much better after reading this quote.

But on topic, being as though I came up with a Protestant following due to my family. I am now branching out and searching for myself the origin of Christianity and that’s Catholicism. As I draw more deeper into this Truth I look back and for some reason I began developing a hatred for Protestants also. Don’t know why but I think what upsets me is when they use Sacred Scripture for personal interpetation. My mother and grandmother do this so it’s probably why I frown upon them now. So to some extent I was in the same boat as OP but feel better now after reading the above quote 🙂

Bruce
Thanks Bruce, I’m glad I helped.

You’ll probably go through all sorts of emotions on your journey. I think it is quite normal. Don’t dwell too much on that and try to see Protestants as our separathed brethren, as we call them. Learn about historic Christianity and how to refute protestant arguments. It’s not that difficult 😉
God bless.
 
When a person makes a change like this it is common to feel disdain for the place he came from. But that is the Devil trying to taint your religious convictions and turn what ought to be a change for the better into a change for the worse.

It is not alright.

Consider that you were once in their position, consider that you don’t know much about their opportunities and experiences, and consider they might be better Christians than you in practice. Do you have real cause for pride?

Also, you are very much mistaken if you think Protestantism is so very foolish, silly and clearly not true. Do you know that there are rigorous intellectual traditions in Protestantism as well? That there are very fine Protestant scholars of theology, history, and Biblical Studies? That the Pope is a fine scholar on Luther, and thinks that he is a very important theologian for Catholicism?

If you don’t realize these things, maybe you do not in fact understand Protestantism, and should refrain from judging it? You should certainly refrain from judging actual Protestants.
 
… I don’t HATE or Dislike the people of the religion. I just strongly dislike other religions. …
The instant I read this, I knew it would be taken that you hate people of other religions, and THAT’s exactly what happened.
 
Pope Benedict seems to have religious tolerance although he should be having talks with the LC-MS rather than LWF. The LC-MS and RCC have more in common than LWF and ELCA. :signofcross:

The Real Truth - Pope Stresses Unity to Lutheran Church
Code:
* Religion
Pope Stresses Unity to Lutheran Church
Code:
March 26, 2010
In a bid to promote unity between Catholics and Protestants, Pope Benedict XVI visited an evangelical Lutheran Church in a largely German-speaking community on Laetare Sunday, the fourth Sunday during Lent.

According to Zenit News Agency, the Catholic leader warned those present against being content “with the successes of the ecumenism of recent years,” regretting that Protestants and Catholics still “cannot drink of the same chalice and we cannot be together around the altar.”

“This should make us sad because it is a sinful situation, but unity cannot be created by men,” the agency reported him as saying.

“We must entrust ourselves to the Lord, because he is the only one that can give us unity,” he said, later stating, “Let us hope that he will bring us to this unity that we now await.”

During the German-language service, President of the Lutheran Community of Rome Doris Esch remarked that this was the church’s second papal visit. The first was made by Pope John Paul II in 1983.

“May you feel at home here, Your Holiness,” she said while concluding her speech (ibid.).

As Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, Benedict XVI visited the Lutheran community in 1998. He also supported the signing of the joint declaration by the Vatican and the Lutheran World Federation on spiritual justification signed on October 31, 1999, and has continued to stress unity between the two churches since assuming the papal role.
 
I guess it’s not as bad as I put it there. I don’t HATE or Dislike the people of the religion. I just strongly dislike other religions. Well, their belief system. I respect non-christian religions. But the hardest thing for me is Protestantarinism I can’t stand their beliefs. They make no sense, and they’re false. They are not supported at all by scripture, and it’s hard. Is this bad?
I think you need to be extremely careful in painting with the broad brush called Protestantism. There is such a wide variety of beliefs that we simply cannot put them into one basket. They range from Anglicans and Lutherans to Jehovah’s Witnesses and Mormons; some very close in beliefs to those who cannot even be recognized as Christian. Then you have everything in between.

What we would not consider supported by scripture are those beliefs we consider errors, but you may have 98% of what they believe that is very much supported by scripture. So I think we need to embrace all of them, while not giving in to the errors. Remember, God loves even the athiest as much as he loves the saints. If He loves them then we have no choice but to do the same. Honestly, I know many “Protestants” that live much holier lives than many Catholics that I know. So having the fullness of truth only benefits those that live that truth out in their lives. So while I love the Catholic Church with everything that I am, I know that I will enjoy heaven with many of my Protestant friends as well.
 
I think it’s natural to feel that way when you are coming out of another religion. I feel the same way. Sometimes I just can’t stand to hear anymore about sola scriptura, or the worst of all: OSAS.

But we should try to keep in mind that the Church says that every religion has some element of truth to it. Try to think about the positive things you’ve taken from protestantism. Maybe it was all part of God’s plan that you were supposed to be protestant and eventually move into the fullness of the faith. Faith is one thing I learned during my time as a protestant, now as a Catholic I am learning love. But yes… it can be hard sometimes…
 
I guess it’s not as bad as I put it there. I don’t HATE or Dislike the people of the religion. I just strongly dislike other religions. Well, their belief system. I respect non-christian religions. But the hardest thing for me is Protestantarinism I can’t stand their beliefs. They make no sense, and they’re false. They are not supported at all by scripture, and it’s hard. Is this bad?
I was raised non denominational Protestant and having converted dislike the beliefs as well. I used to have some pretty strong words about the various Protestant religions.

Then I found that it doesn’t help. If I want to draw my family and friends to the truth then I can’t call them all sorts of names. I still dislike the religion intensely - it lied to me! If you’re asked a specific question you shouldn’t compromise the truth. There’s a right and wrong way to do it though.

Look to Jesus and the Samaritan woman. Samaritanism was heresy to the Jews! He didn’t call her names or otherwise ridicule her. He set the record straight that salvation came from the Jews. The Samaritans recognized only two prophets: Moses and the coming Messiah. It was what He told her about her own life that caused her to recognize who He was. Try to find points of agreement with Protestantism and build from there. They do have elements truth, it’s just mixed in with heresy. Look for the truth and build on it.
 
The basic beliefs of Protestantism is basic Christianity. It would be inaccurate to say they’re supported by nothing but Scripture, but anything else is at best second in authority to that. So there’s some factual inaccuracy to what you say, and it’s not really surprising that you have some things to work through as you convert from one thing to another. Try to do so in a way that’s generally positive rather than negative.

You are converting from some form of Protestantism, yes? If so, make sure you don’t burn too many bridges on your way across the Tiber. You might need them in the long term for one reason or another.
What exactly might be needed in the long term?
 
I was raised non denominational Protestant and having converted dislike the beliefs as well. I used to have some pretty strong words about the various Protestant religions.

Then I found that it doesn’t help. If I want to draw my family and friends to the truth then I can’t call them all sorts of names. I still dislike the religion intensely - it lied to me! If you’re asked a specific question you shouldn’t compromise the truth. There’s a right and wrong way to do it though.

Look to Jesus and the Samaritan woman. Samaritanism was heresy to the Jews! He didn’t call her names or otherwise ridicule her. He set the record straight that salvation came from the Jews. The Samaritans recognized only two prophets: Moses and the coming Messiah. It was what He told her about her own life that caused her to recognize who He was. Try to find points of agreement with Protestantism and build from there. They do have elements truth, it’s just mixed in with heresy. Look for the truth and build on it.
Well we all carry our learned behaviors until we come to terms with them? But you have to admit that the Bible teaching is forgiveness.

You don’t you don’t have like a persons behavior, but thats no reason to dislike the person. I know thats not easy to reach, but at some point your going o understand this. Be it a family member, a close friend. Someone somewhere is just not going to March to same Drum as you. But we must still learn to love and forgive or we are condemned to this world of violence.

We can’t continue to exist as this, its impossible. Seems to me we learned so little while aquiring so much technology so fast. Its really appears to be a receipe for disaster.

Course I’m looking at the bigger picture than just Christians. But the same principle has to apply.
 
I guess it’s not as bad as I put it there. I don’t HATE or Dislike the people of the religion. I just strongly dislike other religions. Well, their belief system. I respect non-christian religions. But the hardest thing for me is Protestantarinism I can’t stand their beliefs. They make no sense, and they’re false. They are not supported at all by scripture, and it’s hard. Is this bad?
Well try not to dislike them to much because eventually it can turn into HATE. Remember they also are seeking the ultimate goal: Salvation. Now how it is achieved may differ,but we must pray for each other and not point fingers as to who is right or wrong.
 
I guess it’s not as bad as I put it there. I don’t HATE or Dislike the people of the religion. I just strongly dislike other religions. Well, their belief system. I respect non-christian religions. But the hardest thing for me is Protestantarinism I can’t stand their beliefs. They make no sense, and they’re false. They are not supported at all by scripture, and it’s hard. Is this bad?
That attitude seems fairly common here at CAF, though few will admit to it so openly.

It’s good that you’re certain of your faith. But what if you’re wrong? I mean, what if the merely Christian part is correct, but not the rest? (“It ain’t so much the things we don’t know that get us into trouble. It’s the things we know for sure that just ain’t so.”)

And whether you’re right or not, it makes it really hard to convince a Protestant because they’ll pick up on your negative attitude toward them and lose interest in listening to you. (Universal truth of human behavior: “Before people care what you know, they have to know that you care.” – Jack Kemp)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top