Is it moral to shoot stray cats?

  • Thread starter Thread starter melensdad
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C.S. Lewis, I believe, made the argument that perhaps pets might be “saved” by the faith of their owners, but he admitted in the essay that it was pure conjecture. There is no theological evidence for this. I have to imagine that he’s right, but I won’t be too upset if it’s not the case. I hope there are no spiders in heaven.

There was a thread on pets going to heaven a year or two ago. I don’t know whether it’s still accessible, or not.
A Catholic Cardinal claimed that there is a cat heaven. This seems a bit absurd for the Catholic hierarchy to claim such, since the teaching is that you have to be baptised in order to be saved.
 
A Catholic Cardinal claimed that there is a cat heaven. This seems a bit absurd for the Catholic hierarchy to claim such, since the teaching is that you have to be baptised in order to be saved.
My 4 year old baptized a cat.
It was the most horrible thing I have ever watched.

I couldn’t stop laughing for days.
 
My 4 year old baptized a cat.
It was the most horrible thing I have ever watched.

I couldn’t stop laughing for days.
OK help me with this, i think I’m having a bit of trouble here. What is worse (for the cat), shooting a cat to instantly put it out of its misery or having a 4 year old dunk it in a tub and baptize it 🤷
 
I was away from this forum for a while and I came upon this thread. Shooting feral cats?? Yikes! Well, I didn’t read the entire thread, but I am an a proponent of TNR - Trap/Neuter/Return. This is a good way to reduce feral cat populations.

Most ferals cannot be adopted - unless you can trap them as kittens and work to socialize them. I say most - I have 3 cats - One was rescued as a feral kitten, one as a feral teen and one as a feral adult. They all interact great with me and my husband but only the one that was rescued as a kitten will is friendly with anyone else.

There are better ways of dealing with this than shooting cats. These poor critters are the offspring of house cats that people let out or threw out of their homes. Visit Alleycat.org to see what you can do to stem the feral cat problem.

TNR works. Many communities have set these programs with a reduction in feral cat populations. The animals are trapped, neutered, vaccinated, released into their habitat where they are found and fed by volunteers on a regular schedule. There are also outdoor homes that can be put up such as made by Indyferal (these are made by prisoners in Indiania prisons!) In due time the populations will die out, the cats can not reproduce and feral cats do not live as long as indoor cats.

Anyway, my :twocents: worth.
 
IShooting feral cats?? Yikes! . . .
I am an a proponent of TNR - Trap/Neuter/Return.
. . .
TNR works. Many communities have set these programs with a reduction in feral cat populations. The animals are trapped, neutered, vaccinated, released into their habitat where they are found and fed by volunteers on a regular schedule.
I live MILES outside of any town or city.

I moved out to this land about 13 years ago, it was common to walk the property and accidently scare up a pheasant or some other wild animal. Now it is impossible to find many of these once common animals. And I really mean it is impossible to find them! The cats have been around for about 6 years and they have been on their own for about 3 years. They clearly survived and are thriving. The detriment is that the eco-system has suffered tremendously. If we were talking about native bobcats, then I would not even have started this thread. But in the wild bobcats* (which do not exist here) *are few and far between in their native habitats. They are not like these feral cats that exist in much higher numbers per acre while bobcats are measured in density per square mile.

Despite all the evidence given to show that TRAP/NEUTER/RELEASE does not work, destroys the environment and is bad stewardship and probably immoral, people cling to it as the more humane solution. TNR studies have shown that the cat populations can exist for up to 7 years after they are rereleased. That is simply not tolerable as the wildlife has already suffered enough.

I think because they think these “kitty cats” are just like “Garfield” the cartoon cat? These are wild mean nasty little cats. I’m sorry they are not in good homes being loved, but they will never exist in a home. I’m sorry they are in the situation they are in. But I didn’t create this problem and now am stuck with it.

It really is a shame that we can’t dump a load of buckshot into the behinds of the irresponsible former owners of these cats, but that is not possible either.

What we have is a bad situation and we have to figure a reasonable solution. These cat, if left unchecked, will continue to destroy the natural habitat. If captured and released, they will do the same. The morality of putting the cats back into the wild is dubious. Clearly it violates the bad stewardship beliefs of the Church.
 
Thank you to all who have participated. This thread is now closed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top