Is It Morally Acceptable To Spend Money On Plastic Surgery?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lilyofthevalley
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
tuopaolo:
Anything that wasn’t quite the way it was supposed to be. Let’s say one ear of yours is 1 milimeter larger than the other ear. Even though that’s a very tiny defect, it’s still a defect and so it’s OK to correct that (assuming one is still being generous with one’s money in helping the poor, etc.) Wouldn’t you agree?

Well let’s consider if one breast was a bit larger than the other. Just like in my ear example, it would be alright to make them equal in size. As for making both breasts larger, if the breasts were really small, one could argue that it is a defect, but I don’t know enough about biology or theology to say if it is or not 🙂 But if it were caused by some deficiency in some nutrient or hormone or something like that, then surely it could be considered a defect and thus OK to fix.

But even if it isn’t, assuming the augmentation is reasonable (i.e. not extreme) it would still be OK because it would just be like styling one’s hair or dying one’s hair different from its “natural” color. It wouldn’t be that different from working out to build up or “tone” one’s muscles for aesthetic reasons.

No I was just pointing that out as another example of something that is a result of the Fall and not part of God’s original design. So it wouldn’t be saying that “God made a mistake” to counteract the natural effects of aging by using a cream or whatever. Likewise, it’s not saying that “God made a mistake” to correct a defect through plastic surgery.
I will say something here that is liable to make a lot of people self-conscious of their bodies:o . It is verry common for many parts of the body to be slightly different in shape and size bilaterally, and by that I mean left to right. Ears commonly are not the same size, and for many people, not quite at the same level on the head. Hands and feet differ in size and shape. Almost every woman out their has a slightly different shape and size to here breasts. It is the differences, in fact that usually draw a person to someone as “beautiful” I think that some of your examples only demonstrate the self-image problems some people get into, where they see a millimeter diference in their ears as a huge thing, when quite honestly, noone else would notice something like that unless you pointed it out, and they had appropriate measuring equipment handy.

I believe that our whole culture has tried to make everyone, especially females, but even the males, feel that unless they look “perfect” they don’t have any chance at happiness.

I won’t say that occassionally I haven’t wished something on me looked different, but to me the idea of changing my appearance by plastic surgery is ridiculous, when there are so many better things I can do with my money, and my attitude is if I changed my appearance, and then met the love of my life, I could really never know whether it was changing my appearance that brought them into my life, or whether they cared for the “real” me.

I’ll break if down for people. I am a thirty-three year old man that do to a late fusion of my palate ( not quite cleft), I have a 4 millimeter gap between my two front teeth. I began to bald at about the age of 16, and now am fast approaching the “monk” haircut. My left ear is I would say two or three millimeters lower than the right ear, as evidenced by the adjustment of my glasses, and has a longer, fleshier lobe on it, making it look swollen. All things that could easily by fixed by medical proffessionals. I could get hairplugs, extensive dental work to rearange some teeth and put veneers on the front of others, my ears could be realligned and the one lobe snipped down to size. But, I look at all of those things, and ask myself why. The gap in my teeth is not causing any issuses with my teeth, my hair coming out just means less money spent on haircuts, since most of the time I just cut it to a crew cut with a pair of electric clippers. My ears function just fine.

I wear hats a little more often than I used to, not to cover my head from people seeing it, but to protect it from the sun, but other than that, i would say that nothing else makes much difference in how my life is lived. One thing I have come to know deep in my heart is that God made me like this, and when I meet my future wife, she will be the sort that will love me, not some fake teeth, surgically enhance hair and ears, or anything else like that.
 
40.png
jjwilkman:
vis a vis michael jackson. he doesn’t even look human.

i think plastic surgery would bo ok for some one that has defect that bothers their self esteem
I can’t remember the correct term for it, but I have heard of people that get excessive plastic surgery, vis-a-vis Michael Jackson, suffering from an excessive self-image problem, to the point where they become addicted to the body modifications.

If you are getting plastic surgery for self-esteem reasons, I pray heartily that you are seeking reliable psychological counseling to make sure that any the issue can be adequately addressed with the surgery, or whether you would be better addressing the issues outside of surgery, and that you aren’t getting the surgery for the wrong reasons.
 
I actually wish I had the money to treat my gynecomastia, I have had it since I was 10, I’m now 22 and I feel so out of place that I never go outside, don’t have a job or friends beause I’m afraid of what they’ll think. I figure I’ll just pray, either God will help me find strength to not care so much about my looks or I’ll die a lonely anti-social hermit, His will be done.
 
To have plastic surgery for “vainty only” is wrong IMO everyone is beautiful in their own special way. BUT if an accident or something caused a person to become disfigured it is more then acceptable to have reasonable reconsructive surgery. for example reconsructive breast surgery following a masetomy is a lot different then (name removed by moderator)lants. A face lift for a 50 year old who can’t face her age need conseling not surgery, but a person who’s face was disfigured in an accident plastic surgery can be a blessing.
 
40.png
Davethewave:
I actually wish I had the money to treat my gynecomastia, I have had it since I was 10, I’m now 22 and I feel so out of place that I never go outside, don’t have a job or friends beause I’m afraid of what they’ll think. I figure I’ll just pray, either God will help me find strength to not care so much about my looks or I’ll die a lonely anti-social hermit, His will be done.
I have heard that 30% of males have gynecomastia. Dave – just wear a t-shirt if it bothers you. The right girl won’t care.

Meanwhile, save up for the surgery. I was a kid with GIANT stick-out ears: my family nickname was Dumbo. People would stare at me on the street. Had 'em surgically pinned back (not made smaller) when I was 15. Changed my life. Thank you, Lord.
 
40.png
Davethewave:
I actually wish I had the money to treat my gynecomastia, I have had it since I was 10, I’m now 22 and I feel so out of place that I never go outside, don’t have a job or friends beause I’m afraid of what they’ll think. I figure I’ll just pray, either God will help me find strength to not care so much about my looks or I’ll die a lonely anti-social hermit, His will be done.
:confused:
Dave, do you think your insurance would cover the expense? Most will cover recontructive surgery, plastic surgery for burn victims, etc. If this condition is causing you mental anguish/depression perhaps you could have your doctor document that and send it to the insurance company. It’s worth a try.
 
I voted for smart (with reservation). Sometimes plastic surgery is necessary for health of mind and body. EX: a scar that creates embarrassment for the person or eye lids that impare quality of sight. I guess I have to know more about the reasons behind the surgery. The cases I have heard about prompted me to vote “smart”.
 
40.png
mercygate:
I have heard that 30% of males have gynecomastia. Dave – just wear a t-shirt if it bothers you. The right girl won’t care.
It’s not just the girls I’m worried about 😛 and I wish I could just wear a t-shirt, but the vanity/modesty which comes from my having gynecomastia causes me to need to wear many layers of shirts, which I tug at daily to make sure my family doesn’t notice. It is especially unpleasent during the summer.
40.png
mercygate:
Meanwhile, save up for the surgery. I was a kid with GIANT stick-out ears: my family nickname was Dumbo. People would stare at me on the street. Had 'em surgically pinned back (not made smaller) when I was 15. Changed my life. Thank you, Lord.
I save what I can, but having no job it isn’t much… birthday money or Christmas money. Sorry to hear about your ears, I’m glad you were able to get it fixed though.

Dave, do you think your insurance would cover the expense? Most will cover recontructive surgery, plastic surgery for burn victims, etc. If this condition is causing you mental anguish/depression perhaps you could have your doctor document that and send it to the insurance company. It’s worth a try.
[/quote]

I don’t have any type of insurance or any doctor, I wouldn’t know how to get either one. But I would appreciate any prayers from anyone reading this 🙂
 
40.png
Davethewave:
It’s not just the girls I’m worried about 😛 and I wish I could just wear a t-shirt, but the vanity/modesty which comes from my having gynecomastia causes me to need to wear many layers of shirts, which I tug at daily to make sure my family doesn’t notice. It is especially unpleasent during the summer.

I save what I can, but having no job it isn’t much… birthday money or Christmas money. Sorry to hear about your ears, I’m glad you were able to get it fixed though.

I don’t have any type of insurance or any doctor, I wouldn’t know how to get either one. But I would appreciate any prayers from anyone reading this 🙂
You’re still young? Still living at home? This can be tough. I wish your family were more involved.

Gives you incentive, though, to wear 3-piece suits. That’s cool!

With EARS there WAS no such thing as a t-shirt or 3-piece suit. They were just OUT there flappin’ in the breeze. Honest. I could almost get airborne when the wind caught those babies! Frankly, it was pretty excruciating. My ears are still huge but as long as they’re alongside my head instead of at right angles, I can live with it.

Hope you can take care of this; lots of guys really agonize over it.
 
I remember an apologist remarking that it’s okay as long as it doesn’t take out a greater good (ie sex changes…) And if we argue the money could be better spent on charity then we can argue that with houses, cars etc. I mean if it helps them get over self esteem issues I see no big problemo.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top