Is it necessary for a cardinal to witness a bishop's consecration or something?

  • Thread starter Thread starter YoungTradCath
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Y

YoungTradCath

Guest
In every video I’ve seen of a bishop’s consecration, there has been a cardinal present in choir dress, who does not concelebrate, but simply sits and watches while sitting in the sanctuary. Is this a requirement or something? Perhaps a prince of the Church to witness on the behalf of the Pope?
 
In every video I’ve seen of a bishop’s consecration, there has been a cardinal present in choir dress, who does not concelebrate, but simply sits and watches while sitting in the sanctuary. Is this a requirement or something? Perhaps a prince of the Church to witness on the behalf of the Pope?
No, usually they’re in choir dress because they would outrank the bishops and thus would have to be principal celebrant if they concelebrated.

There should be a prelate of some kind reading the apostolic letter, if I remember correctly. (Note: monsignori are prelates, though not bishops.)
 
In every video I’ve seen of a bishop’s consecration, there has been a cardinal present in choir dress, who does not concelebrate, but simply sits and watches while sitting in the sanctuary. Is this a requirement or something? Perhaps a prince of the Church to witness on the behalf of the Pope?
No, a cardinal does not need to be present. I think it’s probably coincidence. You’ll see it at most, if not, all episcopal consecrations in England and Wales. There’s one cardinal in England and Wales. He’s the Archbishop Emeritus of Westminster. At episcopal consecrations in England and Wales the entire hierarchy usually attend, including His Eminence. He is always present in choir dress; never vestments. But, his presence isn’t a necessity.
 
There should be a prelate of some kind reading the apostolic letter …
If my memory serves me well I think the rite calls for a deacon to read the apostolic letter. However, in England and Wales it’s usually read by the Apostolic Nuncio.
 
No, it’s not necessary that a cardinal be there. Often times, they are there, mainly because an episcopal consecration is quite a big deal.

The only reason they don’t usually concelebrate, is (as JGMendes mentioned) the issue of rank. It would be improper for a cardinal to concelebrate while a prelate of lower rank is the primary celebrant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top