Is it okay to believe that Roe v. Wade was correctly decided?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CuriousInIL
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

CuriousInIL

Guest
Is it okay for a Catholic to believe that, from a legal, constitutional perspective, that Roe v. Wade was correctly decided; in other words, to believe that the U.S. Constitution does prohibit states from banning abortion as set forth in Roe? I would add that the Catholic in question is very pro-life but believes that Roe was correct and will not be overturned without a constitutional amendment. This Catholic works toward such an amendment.
 
In a case such as you outline, your friend is making a legal argument, not a moral argument. I happen to believe he is wrong about the legal argument—and from a legal, not a moral, perspective—but Catholics are free to hold differing opinions on points of human law, so long as they do not dispute the moral law promulgated by the Church. Since your friend evidently does not dispute the moral law and is working toward a way to fix human law on an issue of grave moral import, then he is not acting contrary to his Catholic beliefs.

That said, for your friend to declare to other Catholics that he thinks Roe v. Wade was correctly decided is scandalous (i.e., it can lead Catholics to believe that a moral evil, in this case abortion, is not evil). He should be extremely discreet about his opinion on this matter, mentioning it only in private to those few individuals he knows are formed well enough in their faith, and know him well enough, not to be scandalized.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top