Is it possible to commit a mortal sin in a dream?

  • Thread starter Thread starter someone429
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

someone429

Guest
I want to know: Is it possible to commit a mortal sin in a dream?

Many people say that it is impossible, because in dreams we don’t have full control of what we “do”. But how do people know this? From their own experience (“I feel that I didn’t have full control of what I did in the dream”), or from some authoritative opinion (for example, authoritative opinion from a Pope)? At least, I have had some dream in which I was tempted to do something bad, and I resisted doing that, but eventually I chose to do that. So, I’m not sure whether it is possible to have full control of what we “do” in dreams.
 
I highly doubt it. Whether we “act responsibly” in dreams or not doesn’t have any bearing on whether or not mortal sin was committed. The fact is that we can’t fully “consent” to what we do in dreams because our consciousness is impaired (obviously).
 
If I went into the confessional and said, “Forgive me father for I have murdered a person.” And he asked what happened and I replied, “Well I was standing space without a space suit and whipped my lightsaber to try convincing Anakin not to join the dark side…” I think he’d look at me funny.

But I will say that sometimes it’s annoying. Every now and then a dream comes along a dream comes along that feels so real you feel a little guilty even though, logically, you know there was no sin. In those cases I’ve just learned to be grateful it was just a dream.
 
no, like you said we have no full control and its a dream not an action we do in reality.
 
How about if you’re ‘dreaming’ while awake, e.g. with a delusional disorder or schizophrenia?
 
No, because it is out of our control.
 
Last edited:
No, because it is out of our control.
How do you know that it is out of our control? At least, I have had some dream in which I was tempted to do something bad, and I resisted doing that, but eventually I chose to do that. If dreams are out of our control, why did I resist but eventually chose to do something in a dream?
 
Last edited:
If I dream that I can fly, does that mean that I really am able to? Dreams are not real. They are not anything we dream that we are. We cannot control what we dream about.
 
Often when we dream, it feels very real. Then when we wake up, we realize that certain things made no sense (Why was I in high school again? Why did my driving instructor ask me to sing the national anthem to pass the driving test? Why didn’t the bathroom stall have a door?) This shows that in dreams our mind doesn’t fully catch that we aren’t in reality.

So, if our mind isn’t fully reliable while we dream, then any “sin” committed was not committed with full will and consent. You resisted in the dream probably because your mind subconsciously knows that your knee jerk reaction would be to resist. I wouldn’t look too deeply into it. We are all tempted in life, it makes sense that it affects our dreams as well.
 
How do you know that it is out of our control? At least, I have had some dream in which I was tempted to do something bad, and I resisted doing that, but eventually I chose to do that. If dreams are out of our control, why did I resist but eventually chose to do something in a dream?
I too have had dreams where dream-me knows what dream-me is doing is wrong. But dream-me is not me. Otherwise I’d be walking on air right now and be a Jedi. So when dream-me does something wrong, all I do is be glad it was a dream and, if applicable, say, “Wait a sec. What? But why?”
 
Just think about the conditions that have to met for a sin to be mortal, and you’ll have your answer.
 
I have dreamed of committing certain sins -
and when I awoke, I wondered, if I should be held guilty -
because my dream self - floated along with it -

I do immediately pray, repenting, even if it was just a dream !
 
Even when lucid dreaming, you’re not fully rational or conscious. To put it in Freudian terms, the Id seems more awake than the Superego. A mortal sin requires full consent of the will, in addition to grave matter and knowledge.
 
Hmmm. Trouble is that anyone who’s breaking commandments has to be mentally ill on some level or ignorant of God’s will. Why, otherwise, would someone do something that might lead them to damnnation?
 
Being awake helps tremendously if you wish to sin. Trust the Old Colonel. He knows what he’s talking about. 😎
 
No it’s not possible, but you can mention in the Sacrament of Penance.
 
Hmmm. Trouble is that anyone who’s breaking commandments has to be mentally ill on some level or ignorant of God’s will. Why, otherwise, would someone do something that might lead them to damnnation?
Wow. What a strange comment. (shaking my head)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top