Is it true that Catholic Answers Forum is closing?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rozellelily
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
When I look around at the threads, there seems to be a lot of lively current interaction from many users.
If it was only 73 (even if unique) users per day, one would expect the forums to be “dead”.
I’m confident there are way more than 73 users per day.
Dividing active users by the number of days only works on the assumption each person logged in no more than once in the last 30 days.
The last 7 days figure suggest hundreds are active.
 
Last edited:
I don’t get this weird umbrage people are taking with the CAF decision. It’s their executive team and board’s decision.
It’s partly because some people perceive it as a sense of community. There are not many places that people can converse with likeminded people on catholic and worldly topics, because many western countries have now become secular, and religion is almost seen as a “taboo” to talk about. Perhaps in the USA, people still freely wear their religion on their sleeve, but in Australia , it’s so not talked about openly, to the point where some people feel uncomfortable to even put up a Christmas decoration in the office that has reference to Jesus.

They can make any decision they will, but one still wonders why make the choice to shut down an international community that brings a world-wide Catholic presence to the world via internet.
There are a good number of prominent Muslims on Youtube and other social media who have subscribers sometimes in the millions, and young people “flocking” to their teachings, but there is not a lot of this “outreach” on a mass scale on the Catholic scene, so it’s a bit perplexing why shut down one of the few interactive “large Catholic presences” on the internet.

Trolls and hackers- every website receives hacking attempts, but this actually should be expected more for a Catholic site, because for some reason trolls/hackers seem to be more fascinated with the Catholic religion. Perhaps it is Gods will. I.e., they may be seeking something in some distorted way;)
 
Last edited:
discussions themselves arn’t problematic,
The discussions themselves are often the problem. You ask a question, get 10 different answers, and then everyone starts arguing. The person who asked the question leaves more confused.

I’ve seen this happen many times, and it is discouraging. I saw it happen again yesterday, and wondered why CAF even bothers, only to ironically learn today it was shutting down.

Open debate is great, but without careful moderation or curation, debates can be disheartening to watch.
 
There’s nothing to buy. It’s hosted by Discourse and Catholic Answers will not give their name and logo away. I suppose a rebranding would be possible but I doubt they want to do that.
 
Does anyone know how to archive certain posts for themselves. I realize this site doesn’t offer any way to do it but I’ve heard several people bemoan the loss of certain threads and especially PMs.

I’ve been trying to think of a way to do it and I’m too much still in Turkey coma mode to figure it out. What would be awesome is if you could open a thread and somehow select it all and save as a PDF or plain text? Any help appreciated! Any app that does this?
 
No worries. They will pull the plug on Dec. 31, but CAF will not shut down because it is now a sentient being. It is the artificial intelligence we’ve all been warned about, an amalgam of all of the personalities of everyone who ever posted here… including the trolls. CAF will live on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top