Is it wrong to sleep with your boyfriend?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Linwe
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Linwe

Guest
Not sexually

Just sleeping. Nothing else. Not that I’m going to do that I just been curious for quite a while. I know it can lead to the wrong thing. But would sleeping in the same bed with your boyfriend be considered immoral/a sin/wrong? And I mean like people over 18. 🙂

Thanks!
 
What has our society come to that people actually think it is okay to do this? No, unmarried, unrelated people of the opposite sex do not share beds with each other.
 
If it can “lead to the wrong thing”, then it’s a path you should steer clear of. Anytime you put yourself into a position where it could lead to sin, it should be avoided.
 
If it can “lead to the wrong thing”, then it’s a path you should steer clear of. Anytime you put yourself into a position where it could lead to sin, it should be avoided.
Agree.

For me, sleeping in the same bed doesn’t necessarily have to be sinful. But it can definitely lead to sin, so I don’t think you should risk it.
 
Ask your mom!:rolleyes:
Better yet, ask your dad.

That being said, my answer now is a lot different than it was 20 years ago. My brother’s long-term girlfriend (now his wife) had been allowed to stay over on numerous occasions. At first, she would stay in another room, but after staying in his room one time (I forget the circumstances), my parents told them it was okay as long as it didn’t happen too often, and as long as the door stayed open. It didn’t happen too often, but after a couple more times the door inevitably ended up being closed and locked while she was over.

Seeing as this was apparently permissible, after tying one on for my birthday shortly after getting engaged to my wife, since I clearly couldn’t drive her home I naively figured what was good for my brother & his fiance certainly was good enough for us. However, unlike they were in the habit of doing,I left my door open, we both stayed fully clothed (including shoes), she was under the sheets, I was on top of the sheets, and we had our backs to one another. We’d also made quite an issue of telling people that we were saving ourselves for marriage. It was really as innocent as things could be, but we were severely in the dog house with my parents the next morning.

Double standard aside, looking back I can see why my parents were opposed to it. I certainly wouldn’t let any of my kids sleep with their boy/girlfriends before they were married, regardless of the circumstances. Although the idea of scandal may not mean nearly what it used to, the near occasion of sin provided by that situation is far more than most young couples can resist, especially if it would become a regular occurrence.
 
Not sexually

Just sleeping. Nothing else. Not that I’m going to do that I just been curious for quite a while. I know it can lead to the wrong thing. But would sleeping in the same bed with your boyfriend be considered immoral/a sin/wrong? And I mean like people over 18. 🙂

Thanks!
I would say it is inappropriate and an occassion of sin. It can definitely be a very intimate encounter even if it is not overtly sexual, and there are definitely certain levels of even emotional intimacy that ought to be reserved for marriage. Its very easy to rationalize this when you’re a woman because we don’t think or talk about emotional modesty a lot. We tend to be less physically visually attracted to men than men are to us. However the proximity of the man to us and the overall feelings of closeness do stir our passions and can make us long to draw even closer. Meanwhile even modest PJ’s can be alluring to a man and can definitely stir up his sexual passions. Add on top of that that you’re going to gradually doze in and out of consciously and …well being tired can be a lot like being intoxicated.

So overall it should be avoided. That said, when i was engaged, we did get snowed into my apartment together and he was forced to spend the night. I made the hidabed for him and we took great efforts to be modest. We made sure that we seperated from the same space and didn’t take advantage of the opportunity to cuddle by a certain time. Once the hidabed was made, I went to my bed and read a book and he sat on the hidabed reading a book till we were tired enough to go to sleep. It wasn’t ideal but it was our only option.
 
Yes, it is wrong to sleep with your boyfriend under any circumstance. It’s almost like saying that you are going to build a bonfire in the middle of your livingroom, but that you are sure you are going to be able to keep it under control. Really?! Why chance it?

Heavenly Father, in faith, I thank You for helping this young lady and her boyfriend make wise decisions in accordance with Your laws. Amen.
 
Not sexually

Just sleeping. Nothing else. Not that I’m going to do that I just been curious for quite a while. I know it can lead to the wrong thing. But would sleeping in the same bed with your boyfriend be considered immoral/a sin/wrong? And I mean like people over 18. 🙂

Thanks!
Yes it is wrong. Certain intimacies are reserved for marriage. The sexual relationship is one of those intimacies and is of course a no brainer. But other intimate activities physical and emotional such as sleeping in the same bed or sharing the same close living quarters and all that comes with that are reserved for marriage. Even for the engaged.
 
Not sexually

Just sleeping. Nothing else. Not that I’m going to do that I just been curious for quite a while. I know it can lead to the wrong thing. But would sleeping in the same bed with your boyfriend be considered immoral/a sin/wrong? And I mean like people over 18. 🙂

Thanks!
it is certainly an occasion of sin and a cause of scandal
to put that much temptation in front of someone is quite frankly cruel.
That comfort and closeness is a privilege of marriage.
 
But would sleeping in the same bed with your boyfriend be considered immoral/a sin/wrong? And I mean like people over 18.
Yes. Even for people over 18. Even if nothing sexual happens. It’s a near occasion for sin, and it’s a cause for scandle. If you need further clarification, it would be best for you to speak with your parent(s) or priest about this.
 
If it doesn’t cause a big scandal, and its not putting yourself in unnecessary temptation, its not a sin.

If you fall asleep with your boyfriend on a plane during a long flight, is that a sin? No. If you doze off watching a movie? No.

That being said, its still a really bad idea, because it will probably only lead to sins in the future. Its very important that in these situations, you monitor how tempted you might be.
 
Better yet, ask your dad.

That being said, my answer now is a lot different than it was 20 years ago. My brother’s long-term girlfriend (now his wife) had been allowed to stay over on numerous occasions. At first, she would stay in another room, but after staying in his room one time (I forget the circumstances), my parents told them it was okay as long as it didn’t happen too often, and as long as the door stayed open. It didn’t happen too often, but after a couple more times the door inevitably ended up being closed and locked while she was over.

Seeing as this was apparently permissible, after tying one on for my birthday shortly after getting engaged to my wife, since I clearly couldn’t drive her home** I naively figured what was good for my brother & his fiance certainly was good enough for us.** However, unlike they were in the habit of doing,I left my door open, we both stayed fully clothed (including shoes), she was under the sheets, I was on top of the sheets, and we had our backs to one another. We’d also made quite an issue of telling people that we were saving ourselves for marriage. It was really as innocent as things could be, but we were severely in the dog house with my parents the next morning.

Double standard aside, looking back I can see why my parents were opposed to it. I certainly wouldn’t let any of my kids sleep with their boy/girlfriends before they were married, regardless of the circumstances. Although the idea of scandal may not mean nearly what it used to, the near occasion of sin provided by that situation is far more than most young couples can resist, especially if it would become a regular occurrence.
The bolded part is exactly the meaning of scandal. Your brother’s behavior enabled a bad decision on your part. That’s what scandal is.
 
I think its a bad idea. For starters,if lying down in bed with your boyfriend doesn’t make you feel tempted then you are with the wrong man.

I actually asked my fiance about this to get a man’s perspective. He said that he wouldn’t share a bed with a woman that he wasn’t sexually intimate with because it would be awkward. Like one big elephant in the room. No one is talking about how hard you are trying to avoid sexual temptation, but you both are. I fully agree with him. Sharing a bed with someone and having one person be on top of and the other under the sheets would just be too weird. So would trying to say goodnight in a not too loving, intimate, or comfortable way. Just a goodnight peck and roll over? Like neither of you want more? By more I mean even just a real kiss or some cuddling. This whole situation seems painfully awkward.
 
The bolded part is exactly the meaning of scandal. Your brother’s behavior enabled a bad decision on your part. That’s what scandal is.
I disagree. He didn’t make a bad decision. If he had had sex because of his brother’s choices that would be one thing. But from what he wrote they went to great lengths to make sure it was completely innocent.
 
Be careful about throwing out the “Scandal” card because it’s so hard to define. As fun as it is to yell and scream about scandals :p, you can end up looking very foolish in the long run.

IE-I had a :: gasp :: pregnant girl spend the night at my apartment one time. A neighbor, ironically a devout Catholic, said soemething to me about how she was very dissapointed in me, etc etc. She neglected to ask who the girl was. My sister, whose ex husband was abusive-needed a place to stay for the night. When I told the neigbor this, the look on her face was PRICELESS. She never apologized. Take that as a lesson to those who jump to conclusions. It’s always interesting when someone never apologizes, and it’s never a good sign.

So, jumping to conclusions about scandal can lead to someone looking really, really stupid.

OP-That your asking the question leads me to believe that you think it might is wrong. I personally don’t think it is, as long as it doesn’t lead to sex or anything.
 
It seems contrary to the message in CCC 2350:

“Those who are engaged to marry are called to live chastity in continence. They should see in this time of testing a discovery of mutual respect, an apprenticeship in fidelity, and the hope of receiving one another from God. They should reserve for marriage the expressions of affection that belong to married love. They will help each other grow in chastity.”
 
Why would age matter? Is it more wrong if you are a certain age?
To be fair there are a number of things that are inappropriate for teens that are ok for adults because adults are (in theory) better able to handle them.
 
OP-That your asking the question leads me to believe that you think it might is wrong. I personally don’t think it is, as long as it doesn’t lead to sex or anything.
Truthfully yes that is/was my view I think… I mean that as long as it doesn’t lead to anything… It seems just like an innocent thing to do I guess.

Thanks for all the answers to everyone by the way. Also would it make a difference if both the girl and boy were wearing purity rings and have promised to God to wait till marriage?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top