Is Jesus God?

  • Thread starter Thread starter kathykiritta
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
RobGentner:
The Kind and gentle God is a Secular Humanistic influence on our society which creeps into our religion through foolish people!
Jesus Christ+ taught us Love. That is not “humanistic” or “foolish”.
“Humanism” and “foolishness” are secular attempts to describe things which are not understood by Man, while applying judgements at the same time. They may or may not be accurate, but they are, in essense, opinions.

Judge not that ye be so judged.
40.png
kathykiritta:
Try and visualise a person…upsetting tables and things strewn all over the place will mean that he meant it in a gentle and humble way??
Jesus+ also told his mother, “Woman, what have I to do with thee?” in admonishment. How do you interpret this statement in regard to His temperament?
And what makes you think that when He overturned the tables, He was angry in the same sense that YOU get angry? Can He not rebuke and admonish without being angry?
40.png
kathykiritta:
Jesus also told Peter, " Get behind me Satan" when Peter was trying to hinder His mission.
He would dare speak like this to His chosen leader of his church? He would dare infer that Peter was acting like satan?

Do you honestly feel that His examples are truly exhibitions of Man’s understanding of anger? Do you not allow that Christ+ could rebuke and admonish in terms of love? Do you really think that the God Incarnate could not understand what sort of lesson He was giving?

Such interpretations may well be representations which Man uses to try to justify his OWN emotions as godly or Christ±like.
40.png
kathykiritta:
to tell you that the sound of your reply is actually " lashing" at me. Practise what you preach!
Again you mistakenly interpret criticism or commentary in a sense of anger. Just because someone expresses an opinion different from yours, you seem to become angry. You don’t need to do that.
40.png
kathykiritta:
And by the way, I am not wrong, as it’s all from the Bible ( as I quoted )…
Yes, there are innumerable things in scripture which we can quote. But it’s up to US to quote them in context and with the true understanding of their intent… not to imply that you are quoting wrongly. When we quote from the Bible, we actually are quoting other men’s interpretations and translations (which we hope are spiritually influenced).

There are instances where Man has *managed *the interpretation of meaning (and of languages) to support what *he has done *- a justification in retrospect, if you will - or wants to do.

We just have to ensure that all men today will understand our use of the quotations. What if their understanding is different from yours? Are you to judge that it is THEY who are at fault?

“Forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us”.
 
Marc Aupiais:
There is a good point in that- there are many fools out there who will go to hell for that. For believing God is “kind” or soft, but not the most awesome Wrath, Which creates hurricane and famine, and who killed the Corinthians (I Corinthians 10, 11) for what these fools think is minor, but which is why these souls were destroyed by God, the Destroyer of men.
Awesome words, to be remembered when we think of the need for the Second Coming and what Christ+ has promised for that Coming.

Indeed, we all are going to hell, as we wait after death for that Second Coming and the Final Judgement. Even Christ+ descended into hell. I think you mean the Final Judgement’s gehenna.

But isn’t it possible that souls in hell can be judged more favorably than Man would have judged them, or that Man does judge them, or that Man has decided that they should be judged? And doesn’t that judgement belong to God alone?

Man’s judgement here on earth can implement great torment and pain, but it is not necessarily what God will pronounce on each of us at our Final Judgement. Indeed, Man’s interpretation of what God would do has led to many instances of ungodly acts during Man’s lifetime. It is akin to the Islamic tradition of thinking that it’s okay to murder someone because they don’t believe as Man does - or says to believe.

These wrong types of judgement are more dangerous to our souls than is misunderstanding of the Word. The actions speak louder than words.

Food for thought, or food for anger?
“For God so loved the world, that He gave His only-begotten Son…”
Love. God gives it. Man apparently is not so inclined.
 
There is a good point in that- there are many fools out there who will go to hell for that. For believing God is “kind” or soft, but not the most awesome Wrath, Which creates hurricane and famine, and who killed the Corinthians (I Corinthians 10, 11) for what these fools think is minor, but which is why these souls were destroyed by God, the Destroyer of men.
**
To say I don’t aggree is an understatement! 🙂 My God, is a fair God, Whe expects us to worship Hima dn only Him. Not false, madeup gods!**
 
I never said God wasn’t fair- I said he was harsh, yet this is within what is fair- but it is hard to explain to you- you keep misreading me.

Simply put- God is kind, yet he can be harsh- “He is not a tame Lion” C.S. Lewis.

As such- we know- the gospel, and sacraments aid our eternal soul- they are quite literally ointments to cure the broken- and our only salvation- in action or in that we would have acted on them given a chance!

In any case- you do confuse me, but that is perfect with me 🙂

You seem to enjoy arguing, (I prefer debate- on the facts)

so I don’t mind debate!😃

Do of course read my words, try to see why I write them- so that you don’t keep misunderstanding them- this is also what many neglect to do with scripture- they do not see the goal of the Author, and authors!
 
Whomper, I enjoyed your post- personally- I think we either go to purgatory or heaven- because some are cured here on earth- yet it is right to say all who live are punished- that we may share in God’s suffering, and comprehend it- as intimates with God- sharing pain.

Thank you, p.s. what do you mean by we all go to hell- is this literal or figurative- are there church documents on it- do you perhaps mean we all expirience pain, or some pain in death- and most suffer before heaven, or expirience darkness, or do you mean it literally- could you give me more of what the church teaches on this, Brother in seeking truth, Marc
 
… Even Christ+ descended into hell. I think you mean the Final Judgement’s gehenna.

He decended into purgatory! Hell is “without God”, Jesus is God oxymorinic for him to descend into hell! That is one way we know there is a purgatory!

But isn’t it possible that souls in hell can be judged more favorably than Man would have judged them, or that Man does judge them, or that Man has decided that they should be judged? And doesn’t that judgement belong to God alone?**Yes, God’s alone. As far as being judged more favorably, I don’t think so because people in Hell will already be judged. Eternally damned. **

Man’s judgement here on earth can implement great torment and pain, but it is not necessarily what God will pronounce on each of us at our Final Judgement. Indeed, Man’s interpretation of what God would do has led to many instances of ungodly acts during Man’s lifetime. It is akin to the Islamic tradition of thinking that it’s okay to murder someone because they don’t believe as Man does - or says to believe.**Interesting point of view. **

These wrong types of judgement are more dangerous to our souls than is misunderstanding of the Word. The actions speak louder than words.**Who judges that they are wrong? **

Food for thought, or food for anger?
“For God so loved the world, that He gave His only-begotten Son…”
Love. God gives it. Man apparently is not so inclined.**It is more loving to ameliorate our brother’s condition than to let him be damned forever is my thinking. **
 
Whomper, I enjoyed your post- personally- I think we either go to purgatory or heaven- because some are cured here on earth- yet it is right to say all who live are punished- that we may share in God’s suffering, and comprehend it- as intimates with God- sharing pain.

Thank you, p.s.** what do you mean by we all go to hell**- is this literal or figurative- are there church documents on it- do you perhaps mean we all expirience pain, or some pain in death- and most suffer before heaven, or expirience darkness, or do you mean it literally- could you give me more of what the church teaches on this, Brother in seeking truth, Marc
**I think he was referring to Protestans that never realize that the way to Heaven is only through the grace of RCC. Hey! Don’t yell, It is just my opinion! :rotfl:

GOD BLESS
**
 
I never said God wasn’t fair- I said he was harsh, yet this is within what is fair- but it is hard to explain to you- you keep misreading me.

Simply put- God is kind, yet he can be harsh- “He is not a tame Lion” C.S. Lewis.B]Oh yes that great" Catholic" Theologian. “Jack” knew what he was talking about alright.:whistle: ** **

As such- we know- the gospel, and sacraments aid our eternal soul- they are quite literally ointments to cure the broken- and our only salvation- in action or in that we would have acted on them given a chance!
**Sacraments are quire literally Outward signs instituted by Christ to bring grace. **
In any case- you do confuse me, but that is perfect with me 🙂

You seem to enjoy arguing, (I prefer debate- on the facts)

so I don’t mind debate!😃

Do of course read my words, try to see why I write them- so that you don’t keep misunderstanding them- this is also what many neglect to do with scripture- they do not see the goal of the Author, and authors! **I agree totally with that statement:thumbsup: They make their own goals (Looks over sholder to see if Solo_scriptura is around!)

GOD BLESS**
 
You certainly have spunk- and you are Catholic- I quoted The Anglican Theologian because many of us enjoy some of his works.

God himself admits to killing many people in our own religion- He is fair though.

Enjoyed this conversation- even though we are arguing while not arguing, which is profound in itself!

Enjoy your day, and God bless,

p.s. what was the thread about again ? (smiling, knowing the answer, and laughing how none of us kept to it this one)!

For the mods- I did answer the question originally-

we just love to talk in this forum 🙂
 
You certainly have spunk- and you are Catholic- I quoted The Anglican Theologian because many of us enjoy some of his works.Marc, I was joking! 🙂 I have read his work plus the Book of Moron, eeerrrr 😃 I meant …Morman, the Quran and many versions of The Bible!

God himself admits to killing many people in our own religion- He is fair though.That is so nice of you to say about our GOD!

Enjoyed this conversation- even though we are arguing while not arguing, which is profound in itself!

Enjoy your day, and God bless,

p.s. what was the thread about again ? (smiling, knowing the answer, and laughing how none of us kept to it this one)!
**When this thread started. My first post was:

YES, JESUS IS GOD!** Boy this thread was easy!" Then the disagreements started! 😛
For the mods- I did answer the question originally-

we just love to talk in this forum 🙂

**That is called Christian fellowship or protestants might say a church service! :rotfl: **
 
🙂 that was not very politically correct now was it?🙂

mind you, I am laughing- out for now- Marc
 
🙂 that was not very politically correct now was it?🙂

mind you, I am laughing- out for now- Marc
**:rotfl: Yea Marc, you made me laugh out loud also! :rotfl:
Me politically correct. Yea Right!! 😃 That attitude comes from what I think is the biggest problem in the USA and other parts of the world right now.It is attempting to destroy all religion, not just the Catholic church, and many people fall into its trap! It is what is commonly known as Secular Humanism. Or as I like to call it a “GOD LESS RELIGION”. **
greatcom.org/resources/ha…03/default.htmect?
 
As long as they don’t call it God Bless religion, then we know they at least aren’t defrauding us- I agree- we should be more specific, and open- the heresies that people think they can get away with, or the actions- are ridiculous- I wish we taught out of Baltimore again- so yes- it is dangerous- mind you- sometimes being political aids me- but it’s like our doctor saying “Dear chap- you would be quite well off if you take this medication- but I shall not put my ideas on you!”

instead of,

“Dear chap- you may well die by an hour or so, if you don’t take this wondrous, horrid tasting medicine!”

(Church still can be gentleman-like- even if we aren’t politically correct)

I still love how Protestantism is a Material Heresy and Material Schism, according to the official documents- and if we leave for them- these documents say we go to hell- unless we are dumb, or unwilling, and how the church says- well- I really prefer it if you remain- but become the best whatever you want you can be- now be good with you.

Of course I love it how they sometimes are like that about utterly anti-catholic groups-

We really are English Gentlemen in our religion, aren’t we-

None of that hell and brimstone- just- well- this is my dear and humble opinion old chap- but I’d never try to make it law.

Mind you- many of our bishops are great men- and it’s not our priests fault they went to seminary- but we do have issues to solve!

Marc:D 😃 😃 😃 😃 :cool: :cool: 🙂
 
Awesome words, to be remembered when we think of the need for the Second Coming and what Christ+ has promised for that Coming.

Indeed, we all are going to hell, as we wait after death for that Second Coming and the Final Judgement. Even Christ+ descended into hell. I think you mean the Final Judgement’s gehenna.

But isn’t it possible that souls in hell can be judged more favorably than Man would have judged them, or that Man does judge them, or that Man has decided that they should be judged? And doesn’t that judgement belong to God alone?

Man’s judgement here on earth can implement great torment and pain, but it is not necessarily what God will pronounce on each of us at our Final Judgement. Indeed, Man’s interpretation of what God would do has led to many instances of ungodly acts during Man’s lifetime. It is akin to the Islamic tradition of thinking that it’s okay to murder someone because they don’t believe as Man does - or says to believe.

These wrong types of judgement are more dangerous to our souls than is misunderstanding of the Word. The actions speak louder than words.

Food for thought, or food for anger?
“For God so loved the world, that He gave His only-begotten Son…”
Love. God gives it. Man apparently is not so inclined.
Whomper Yes Jesus did go to hell, but that was only to take away death. If we go to hell now thats it, its over. Hell is total seperation from Christ. Once you get there now, its over. You dont get judged in hell. At least thats where your religion and mine differ anyway.
 
Whomper Yes Jesus did go to hell, but that was only to take away death. If we go to hell now thats it, its over. Hell is total seperation from Christ. Once you get there now, its over. You dont get judged in hell. At least thats where your religion and mine differ anyway.
**
**‘HE DESCENDED INTO HELL’
Pope John Paul II – General Audience given on January 11, 1989

The abode of the dead**
  1. To these final words of the article on the passion and death of Christ is linked in a certain way the following article which says: “<He descended into hell”>. This article reflects some texts of the New Testament which we shall see shortly. It is well to mention, however, that, although in the time of the Arian controversies the same formula was found in the writings of those heretics, it was nevertheless introduced also into the so-called , one of the professions of the Catholic faith then in use, which was drawn up at the end of the fourth century (cf. 16). It entered definitively into the teaching of the Councils with the Fourth Lateran (1215) and the Second Council of Lyons in the profession of faith of Michael Paleologus (1274).
It should also be mentioned straight-away that the word “hell” does not mean the hell of eternal damnation, but the abode of the dead which is in Hebrew and in Greek (cf. Acts 2:311.
3. There are numerous New Testament texts from which the formula is derived. The first is found in the Apostle Peter’s discourse of Pentecost. Referring to Psalm 16 to confirm the announcement of Christ’s resurrection contained in it, he states that the prophet David “foresaw and spoke of the resurrection of the Christ, that , nor did his flesh see corruption” (Acts 2:31). The Apostle Paul’s question in the Letter to the Romans has a similar meaning; “‘Who will descend <into the abyss?’> (that is, )” (Rom 10:7).

Also in the Letter to the Ephesians there is a text which, in reference to a verse of Psalm 68: “When he ascended on high he led a host of captives, and he gave gifts to men” (Ps 68:18), asks a significant question: “In saying, ‘he ascended’, ? He who descended is he who also ascended far above all the heavens, so that he might fill all things” (Eph 4:8-10). In this way Paul seems to link Christ’s “descent” (among the dead), of which he speaks in the Letter to the Romans, with his ascension to the Father, which begins the eschatological “fulfilment” of all things in God.

In line with this are the words placed in Christ’s mouth: "I am the First and the Last, and the Living One. <I died, and behold I am alive forevermore>, and I have the keys of " (Rev 1:17-18).
  1. As is evident from the texts quoted, the article of the Apostles’ Creed, “he descended into hell”, is based on the New Testament statements , after his death on the Cross, into the “region of death”, into the a abode of the dead", which in Old Testament language was called the “abyss”. If the Letter to the Ephesians speaks of “the lower parts of the earth”, it is because the earth receives the human body after death, and so it received also the body of Christ who expired on Calvary, as described by the Evangelists (cf. Mt 27:59 f, and parallel passages; In 19:40-42). a real , including the final moment which is generally a part of the whole process:
It is a confirmation that this was a real, and not merely an apparent, death. His soul, separated from the body, was glorified in God, but his body lay in the tomb as a <corpse.>

During the three (incomplete) days between the moment when he “expired” (cf. Mk 15:37) and the resurrection, Jesus experienced the a state of death", that is, the , as in the case of all people. This is the primary meaning of the words “he descended into hell”; they are linked to what Jesus himself had foretold when, in reference to the story of Jonah. he had said: "For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the whale, so " (Mt 12:40).**
 
So did Jesus descend into prison or not- I believed he did from the part about preaching in prison?

it sounds allot like inbetween pergatory and Limbo to me (limbo being the C.S. Lewis- not Augustine version! Neither of which I believe exists- perhaps as a state)
 
Whomper Yes Jesus did go to hell, but that was only to take away death. If we go to hell now thats it, its over. Hell is total seperation from Christ. Once you get there now, its over. You dont get judged in hell. At least thats where your religion and mine differ anyway.
The resurrection and the descent into hell

From 1st Peter Chapter 3:18 - 20, says, “Christ himself died once and for all for sins, the upright for the sake of the guilty, to lead us to God. In the body he was put to death, in the spirit he was raised to life and, in the spirit, he went to preach to the spirits in prison. They refused to believe long ago, while God patiently waited to receive them, in Noah’s time when the ark was being built. In it only a few, that is eight souls were saved through water.” Given this scripture, I don’t think we can deny the " dwelling place of the dead". ’ Prison’ therefore,in this verse means Hell.
 
So did Jesus descend into prison or not- I believed he did from the part about preaching in prison?

it sounds allot like inbetween pergatory and Limbo to me (limbo being the C.S. Lewis- not Augustine version! Neither of which I believe exists- perhaps as a state)
**
Marc, you confuse me? You are a Catholic and you say don’t believe in purgatory? Where (Edited) did you learn about Our Religion? (Edited) You better read the CCC! It is part of our creed. Even my friend Solo_scripture and other Protestants believes in purgatory! You can call it the Abyss, Limbo, Hades Sheol, Hell, whatever , it is a “holding area” until the second coming!

Apostles’ Creed

  1. I believe in God the Father, Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth:
  2. And in Jesus Christ, his only begotten Son, our Lord:
  3. Who was conceived by the Holy Ghost, born of the Virgin Mary:
  4. Suffered under Pontius Pilate; was crucified, dead and buried: He descended into hell:
  5. The third day he rose again from the dead:
  6. He ascended into heaven, and sits at the right hand of God the Father Almighty:
  7. From thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead:
  8. I believe in the Holy Ghost:
  9. I believe in the holy catholic church: the communion of saints:
  10. The forgiveness of sins:
    1l. The resurrection of the body:
  11. And the life everlasting. Amen.
Where did you ever read prison? How did you ever get to where you can say " Neither of which I believe exists- perhaps as a state".

**(Edited)

:highprayer: :blessyou: :highprayer:
 
I believe in purgatory- I don’t believe in limbo-

I believe verry much in pergatory-

I don’t believe in Augustine’s limbo for babies,
Nor C.S. Lewis’ Limbo for people going to hell!😃

Mind you, in johannesburg- you might confuse me with a diocesan official- if I say something like that purgatory doesn’t exist, or that we shouldn’t worship formally:)

(or that the saints were insane idiots, who shouldn’t have self mortified- in fact that self mortification is itself to be avoided by all sane people (Diocese not caring in the least at that one)- which is why I’ve just gotten in contact with Opus Dei- perhaps they can help me truly begin to grow in my faith)
 
I believe in purgatory- I don’t believe in limbo-

I believe verry much in pergatory-

I don’t believe in Augustine’s limbo for babies,
Nor C.S. Lewis’ Limbo for people going to hell!😃

Mind you, in johannesburg- you might confuse me with a diocesan official- if I say something like that purgatory doesn’t exist, or that we shouldn’t worship formally:)

(or that the saints were insane idiots, who shouldn’t have self mortified- in fact that self mortification is itself to be avoided by all sane people (Diocese not caring in the least at that one)- which is why I’ve just gotten in contact with Opus Dei- perhaps they can help me truly begin to grow in my faith)
** I am glad you explained yourself. You had me wondering! 😃

You also are in South Africa?

Small world isn’t it!

If you really want o grow in your faith. Pray the Rosary!
**
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top