Solomon and David were king. They ruled their states with fair. They expanded state through conquests. So were they not also prophets? Why did God allow them to rule a state?
Muhammad was a prophet and also president of Islamic state. Muslims established a state so a state can expand through coquests. Muslims did not persecute or being cruel. Muhammad coquered Mecca but never persecuted. Muslims made wars in most peaceful ways. Muslims did not commit possession. Few people died in all wars of Muhammad(for about 300). Do you know any state which never made war?
Tribes were used to be ally of Muslims or Pagans. When Pagans assembled troops they were used to get from tribes who were not Muslim yet. So Muslims fought against that tribes.
You should understand that there is no any problem with being both prophet and president or king. But prophets were not used to live prosperity. Muhammad never did such thing. he always was in trouble to promote faith. Muhammad was not reach when He died. he did not use facilities of state for His comfort. And the help of state was that Muslims could defend faith with that power. You think Jesus did not establish a state so why Muhammad did! Jesus could not have so much believer to establish a state. He preached only for about 3 years and believers were weak. Muslims were weak too for about 10 years.
What would Jesus do if He would live more long and have ten thousands of believer? Would not believers treat Jesus also as a president?
In Mecca the verses are about faith generally and short. But in Medina verses came about the details of worships. So in Medina Muhammad was more prophet coversely you claim He gave up prophethood and start to rule Medina.
And all asserts or statements you said do not refute Islam and prophet Muhammad. But those statements are to make doubts about Islam. You may sway people who do not know Islam and prophet Muhammad.
King David and Solomon were Kings, not presidents of a state.
Catechism of the Catholic Church 2579
“David is par excellence the king “after God’s own heart,” the shepherd who prays for his people and prays in their name. His submission to the will of God, his praise, and his repentance, will be a model for the prayer of the people. His prayer, the prayer of God’s Anointed, is a faithful adherence to the divine promise and expresses a loving and joyful trust in God, the only King and Lord.In the Psalms David, inspired by the Holy Spirit, is the first prophet of Jewish and Christian prayer. The prayer of Christ, the true Messiah and Son of David, will reveal and fulfill the meaning of this prayer.”
As for Solomon in 1Kings 9-11
9 Give your servant, therefore, a listening heart to judge your people and to distinguish between good and evil. For who is able to give judgment for this vast people of yours?”
10 The Lord was pleased by Solomon’s request.
11 So God said to him: Because you asked for this—you did not ask for a long life for yourself, nor for riches, nor for the life of your enemies—but you asked for discernment to know what is right
I’m assuming this is why God a Kingdom to King David and Solomon …not a “state” .This is a very far cry from we know of muhammad.
The muslim conquest conquering lands sounds anything but peaceful. When muslims mention verses in the quran about killing is for “self-defence”. Is it self-defence when muslims are invading other lands?
There is no peace in wars…as you stated “muslims made wars in most peaceful ways”
You asked “Do you know any state which never made war?”
My answer to this is Yes. That would be Vatican City
I think its impossible to think about Jesus living any longer because he a destiny to fulfill. He is the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world by his death on the cross and his Resurrection. But what seen throughout history and to this very day is Jesus appearing to people or in dreams. Like the Conversion of Paul the Apostle, Constantine-
"Maxentius organized his forces—still twice the size of Constantine’s—in long lines facing the battle plain. Constantine’s army arrived at the field bearing unfamiliar symbols on either its standards or its soldiers’ shields.According to Lactantius, Constantine was visited by Jesus in a dream the night before the battle, wherein he was advised “to mark the heavenly sign of God on the shields of his soldiers … by means of a slanted letter X with the top of its head bent round (Chi Rho). He marked Christ on their shields.” Eusebius describes another version, where, while marching at midday, "he saw with his own eyes in the heavens a trophy of the cross arising from the light of the sun, carrying the message, In Hoc Signo Vinces or “with this sign, you will conquer”
Imagine converting an empire that prosecuted you.
We even hear in the present time Jesus appearing to extremist in dreams changing their hearts and minds.
Has muhammad done such a thing?
In many respects, Joseph Smith was an “American Mohammed” and Brigham Young tried to continue it in Utah. He was successful for a time, but fortunately the US Army put a stop to it.
All I can say is, wow, yeah. No comparison.