Is Mass 3 places at once?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JosephDColeman
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JosephDColeman

Guest
I was watching a YouTube video and a priest said that at Mass we are 3 places at once: the Mass in the present, the heavenly banquet, and the last supper. Is this true? Ever since I heard that I’ve been at Mass and my mind has been blown thinking, “I’m at the last supper right now with Christ and his Apostles…I’m in heaven with the angels and they are praising God with thunderous voices all around me!”
 
I was watching a YouTube video and a priest said that at Mass we are 3 places at once: the Mass in the present, the heavenly banquet, and the last supper. Is this true? Ever since I heard that I’ve been at Mass and my mind has been blown thinking, “I’m at the last supper right now with Christ and his Apostles…I’m in heaven with the angels and they are praising God with thunderous voices all around me!”
IMHO, it’s best to remain in one place at one time… such as in the Present…

That said, we can recall the Past and look forward to the Future…
 
However … as someone introduced… the Heavenly Banquet has not yet occurred.
 
Yes but more like the heavenly liturgy and Calvary. And the Resurrection at the tomb. And his Ascension. The Last Supper, as the first Mass was already the re-presentation of the Paschal Mystery even though it had not yet taken place in time so it’s more proper to think that the key events made present at Mass is the act of Redemption started on Calvary and forever present to God in the heavenly liturgy.
 
I’d assume because in Heaven, we can fully contemplate the events at mass.
 
The Veil Removed is a short film that reveals the coming together of heaven and earth at Mass, as seen by saints and mystics, revealed by scripture and in the catechism of the Catholic Church.

 
To think I nearly didn’t go today. I’m so glad I did. Sorry I take you for granted, Lord.
 
3 places at once
Maybe more. A while back, I was reading a lecture (or homily?) by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, from before he became Pope Benedict XVI, about the Real Presence of Christ. As I recall, he said that Christ’s presence unites every Mass with the Last Supper so closely, it’s like there is only one Mass which takes place concurrently (if that’s the right word) in all places and all times. I’m having a hard time grasping that!
 
Something told me to read the Book of Revelation while going through RCIA…Mass suddenly made a lot more sense to me
 
That’s sort of how it was explained to me because a common objection Protestants will throw out is ‘the sacrifice was once for all 2020 years ago’ and can’t be repeated every day at Mass. but in reality the sacrifice at Mass is taking place outside of space and time so we are taking part spiritually at the same time it happened in real time as well as now. My head hurts now!
 
If you ever get chance, read a short novel called ‘Flatland’. It’s science fiction and is basically about how if you were a triangle, a pyramid would be outside of anything you can grasp. You physically don’t exist within the plane required to see it. That’s the best thing I can do to explain how God is in relation to our human understanding
 
This is so true. Have you ever read The Lamb’s Supper by Scott Hahn. I highly recommend.

The Lamb’s Supper reveals a long-lost secret of the Church: The early Christians’ key to understanding the mysteries of the Mass was the New Testament Book of Revelation. With its bizarre imagery, its mystic visions of heaven, and its end-of-time prophecies, Revelation mirrors the sacrifice and celebration of the Eucharist.

https://www.amazon.com/Lambs-Supper...=2025&creative=165953&creativeASIN=0385496591
 
I was watching a YouTube video and a priest said that at Mass we are 3 places at once: the Mass in the present, the heavenly banquet, and the last supper. Is this true?
In a devotional sense, perhaps. Literally, no.
 
The Hahn book is good. But he talks more about the Mass pointing toward the heavenly banquet. I was thinking about the fact that we are in heaven at the time of Mass. Which, sense heaven isn’t in time, could be true.
 
I guess that depends on the perception of the reader. I always thought his books were easier reads for the average lay person. Of course, I read a lot of his earlier works like the one recommended. He may have gotten more “difficult” in his more recent books. I can’t vouch for them though.
 
I did and it was excellent! He also has a video on Youtube where he describes his experience. Less detail than the book, but an awesome presentation.
 
😮🙂 I was just discussing this same thing elsewhere on Sunday! Replying to something about how Protestants are largely against “ritual”. I wrote this:
Here’s another passage, starting at Heb. 9:1: Even (kai) the first tabernacle and covenant had ordinances of divine service and an earthly sanctuary.

Beware, some translations leave out the “even”. Others translate it as “also”, which makes it completely clear that we have them too, but obscures the fact that ours are better. Then the ch. goes on to summarize the 1st ordinances & describe the Tabernacle & its repeated sacrifices. Then it discusses how Christ made the greater sacrifice. This means we have greater ordinances (& a greater sanctuary).

I think Protestants like to gloss over that pt quickly to get to the pt about how Christ made only 1 sacrifice forever b/c they think we “sacrifice Christ over & over” (which is extra-nonsensical when they deny the Real Presence). I think that’s a big reason they think they hate rituals. But my priest said in the Theophany homily [we’re Byzantines] just today, “Our Lord is the Lord of time. For Him all time is the present.” I like to think of that principle like how we can look at a map & see the whole world (well, metaphorically) at once, even though to look at the actual globe is to see only pt. Something 3D can be looked at in 2D. Like in Flatland. God is beyond 4D, beyond xD (cf. Rm 16:26, aioniou Theou, eternal God), so He can see/exp. everything that ever happened, is happening, & ever will happen, in however many dimensions exist in the universe, all at once, as if the sum of the exp. of the universe is sitting in front of Him like a map. And it’s like how an icon is (Biblically—tell the Protestants this!) “like a ‘high-definition’ projection [that] exactly reflects its source…‘(eikṓn) assumes a prototype, of which it not merely resembles, but from which it is drawn’…(eikṓn) then is more than a ‘shadow’; rather it is a replication”. And so, “the honour rendered to the image passes over to the prototype” (St John of Damascus). To venerate the icon is to venerate who is in it. And to see the icon of an event is to exp. the event. (Icons of heaven are beyond time.) Icon veneration is another big reason [Protestants hate ritual].

So the 1 Sacrifice happens in every Liturgy, by amamnesis/zikaron, (cf. Lk 22:19, & azkarah—from the same root as zikaron—in Lv 2 about memorial grain offerings) “making present”. Most precisely, “replicate” (from the def. of eikṓn) is not actually “to make again”, but “to fold back” “Late Latin replicātus past participle of replicāre to fold back”. So when we witness an icon or participate in the Liturgy, time is folded back. (Folding something 2D, a plane, makes something 3D, a solid. So folding a solid, a cube, makes something 4D, a hypercube. So folding something 4D, time, makes something 5D, hypertime.) A true ritual is not empty but unites us w/ the moment in time that it’s about. 🤯
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top