Is masturbation without lust a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Timi_Celcer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
As I said: Yes it is intrinsically gravely disordered. Such would be grave matter for mortal sin. It cannot be done.

I cannot be done for any reason.
 
iintrinsically grave matter is a necessary requisite for a mortal sin but it is not sufficient.

consider what the Catechism of the Catholic Church says

1735 Imputability and responsibility for an action can be diminished or even nullified by ignorance, inadvertence, duress, fear, habit, inordinate attachments, and other psychological or social factors.

So… masturbation is not necessarily a mortal sin, when modified by any of these conditions.

When these conditions may apply, (as I have said many times in these forums) I don’t think you even have to confess it as a sin, as venial sins do not have to be confessed before receiving Holy Communion.

There are different circumstances of masturbation (I’ll leave it at that) and those might affect which category of exception may apply.

I have read a good share of Jewish commentaries and books on spirituality. In the pursuit of earthly perfection, we should be oriented towards resisting all urges of the flesh. We should be guided by our intellect and free will to choose not to sin. The Rabbis prescribe that a prayer be said before performing a (positive or negative) mitzvah [command], so this practice of prayer – in this case, prayer over the sacrifice of self-will to masturbate-- should be said sincerely and perhaps repeated until the urge to sinful action has passed. We should concentrate on the positive commands to love and serve God.

Jews and Christians have developed theological and philosophical castles in the air to distinguish themselves from each other. don’t kid yourself. Read what Jesus says at the end of Mt’s gospel, about teaching all nations to observe (obey) what he has commanded.

We should be people who are experts on knowing and doing what Christ has commanded us to do.
You must always confess masturbation. If a penitent masturbates it is certainly not up to the penitent to decide if they had mitigating circumstances that reduced culpability from mortal sin. ONLY the priest can decide that.
When it comes to masturbation (which in all the years I have been a member here seems to be the dominant sin) people are looking for every excuse they can to be able to continue doing it.
I honestly believe that if there are mitigating factors they are the rare exception.
 
I am so sorry for those who are struggling in this way.

If you can, I would recommend going to Adoration before the Blessed Sacrament.

It has really helped me when I have been going through difficulties in my life. You don’t have to “do” anything during your time there. Meaning that you can just sit quietly before the Lord, and you can just bring your intentions to Him.

Please don’t feel unworthy or feel like a failure, those who are feeling like you do. God loves you just as you are, and He already knows your struggles.
 
As far as “do I entertain them or go to God for relief”? I used to be more of a soldier but recently do to despair, I’ve been more lukewarm. Im actually going through a major trial of my faith. Possibly the worst since my conversion. Say a Hail Mary and the Lord’s prayer for me.
You should know that despair is an even worse sin. Its a sin of pride. You’re basically telling the Lord of the Universe that because your sinfulness is so “great” that there is no possible way that He could love you, much less forgive your sins.

Your sinfulness, as great as you think it is, is a mere pittance when compared to the infinite ocean of God’s mercy and love. By imprisoning yourself in despair you blind yourself to the reality of God’s love for you in Christ and the realization that Christ is there, present with you, and wanting to drench you in love so as to free you, even in the midst of all your sinfulness.
 
As far as “do I entertain them or go to God for relief”? I used to be more of a soldier but recently do to despair, I’ve been more lukewarm. Im actually going through a major trial of my faith. Possibly the worst since my conversion. Say a Hail Mary and the Lord’s prayer for me.
I will pray for you tonight.

We all have this fight, trust me, whether male or female. I have experienced that we CAN overcome temptation with God’s grace by praying and asking for it.
Go to Our Lady, she is a GREAT help. Find a saint that is dear to your heart and talk to them. Perhaps a saint that has lived similar trials.

You are not alone. May Our Lady bless you and your guardian angel guide you.
Your sister in Christ.
 
=Timi Celcer;11538438]I wonder, since i do not masturbate, why would masturbation without lust be so bad. I do not masturbate so every two months or so i have wet dreams followed by ejaculation. It seems like God planned for me to ejaculate every months or so. But since lusting is obviously a sin, don’t you think that it is better to mastrurbate without lust every 3 weeks than have lustfull wet dreams and a lust problems day before wet dreams?
Masturbation is always a sin and I SUSPECT seldom /if ever without lusting]

It is a misuse and a selfish use of the creative powers God LOANS to us.

“Lusting is ONLY sinful” when we cooperate and desire it to happen. Lustful probes by Satan are common and can and need to be rejected.

So, NO:eek: I don’t agree with you.

God Bless you,
Patrick
 
I wonder, since i do not masturbate, why would masturbation without lust be so bad. I do not masturbate so every two months or so i have wet dreams followed by ejaculation. It seems like God planned for me to ejaculate every months or so. But since lusting is obviously a sin, don’t you think that it is better to mastrurbate without lust every 3 weeks than have lustfull wet dreams and a lust problems day before wet dreams?
wet dreams are not sinful (unless you are looking for them), if they happen they just happen. masturbation is. so the choice is pretty much simple.
 
Masturbation is addictive though and kills any kind of spiritual development in my opinion, it grounds you, it’s self-love and I believe Rastafari say something along the lines of it’s pleasing to your physical self and not your spiritual self, you know. It makes a lot of sense that does.
 
You should know that despair is an even worse sin. Its a sin of pride. You’re basically telling the Lord of the Universe that because your sinfulness is so “great” that there is no possible way that He could love you, much less forgive your sins.

Your sinfulness, as great as you think it is, is a mere pittance when compared to the infinite ocean of God’s mercy and love. By imprisoning yourself in despair you blind yourself to the reality of God’s love for you in Christ and the realization that Christ is there, present with you, and wanting to drench you in love so as to free you, even in the midst of all your sinfulness.
I dont see how despair is a sin of pride. Obviously God has dealt with all the evil that has ever or will ever be.

I know he loves me and forgives me.

Im just sick of being miserable and wasting time and talent and being a coward and living in a world that disgusts and depresses me.

I wish my mother would have aborted me so I could go to limbo, a place of bliss and no worries, labor, or responsibility.
 
I dont see how despair is a sin of pride. Obviously God has dealt with all the evil that has ever or will ever be.

I know he loves me and forgives me.

Im just sick of being miserable and wasting time and talent and being a coward and living in a world that disgusts and depresses me.

I wish my mother would have aborted me so I could go to limbo, a place of bliss and no worries, labor, or responsibility.
Dear brother,

The thougt that God loves you comes from God.
Do you love God?
 
Is masturbation without lust a sin?
Sin is whatever we do that produces or reproduces division and alienation between people. So it depends on what effect masturbation has on your relation to other people.

Any way, sin is pretty much everywhere, and in our struggle against sin we should focus on abolishing those structures and mentalities that causes the most division and alienation.

Sinful masturbation does indeed seem like an almost trivial problem in comparison to things that hypocritical and corrupt priests care far less about.
 
Life is not easy. So many temptations.

Thing is, God is always with you. He wants you to beat those temptations. Think of them as crosses to bear. Jesus suffered for you and me. God is all forgiving. All loving.

We are only human and trials are there to strengthen us. Nobody is perfect.

Being holy in easy times is just that ‘easy’. It’s when times are tough, when temptations come to us, when all the world is against us that we have to show God our love for him will never be beaten!

Pray to God for guidance. I would also see a priest that you know and ask for his guidance too as God works through his disciples.
 
Dear brother,

The thougt that God loves you comes from God.
Do you love God?
I want to love God and It seems that most of the time I do but maybe im fooling myself when I apparently choose to spit in his face with sin and blasphemy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top