Is Mormonism A Christian Religion?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jerry111
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Mormonism, or the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, is in fact Christian. We are not Catholic Christians, and we are not Protestant Christians, but we are Christians none the less.

To hear the arguments against Mormonism being Christian is a little like a dog and a cat trying to say a whale is not a mammal because the whale does not have 4 paws and whiskers.
 
Some members of the LDS church are Christians, some are not. Since Mormon beliefs and doctrines are so fluid and contradictory, people can pick and choose between Christian ones, and distinctively non-Christian ones.

When a Mormon bishop interviews people for eligibility for a temple recommend, he uses these questions mormondoctrine.net/misc/temple_recommend.htm, which can be creatively construed.

When the Catholic prepares for the Sacrament of Reconciliation, the rigorous examination of conscience is encouraged. Some get sloppy about it.

It is all in the mind of the beholder. Mormon “law” and theocracy, imitating that of the government, enforces adherence, because the BoM teaches that. Catholicism is voluntary-- people are allowed to practice it as closely or as sloppily as they want. Motivation comes from within. Mormonism is enforced.

So, I think the question is, for most purposes, irrelevant.
I would like to know what you mean by “enforced”. The sound of this post is way off the mark. Everything within the LDS religion is voluntary. Nothing is “enforced” as you seem to want to describe.

LDS can practice as closely or as sloppily as they want too, just as you describe Catholics.
Please explain what you mean by “enforced”, because it sounds like you want to make something that just is not there.
 
Please explain what you mean by “enforced”, because it sounds like you want to make something that just is not there.
So glad you chose to peek, or don’t have me on ignore. The LDS community knows who does not hold a recommend, and socially stigmatizes them, no matter why. The LDS church refuse the right for even parents of a bride or groom to attend a temple wedding, if they don’t have a recommend. Excommunication and disfellowshipment are an elaborate, formal procedure. LDS people often refuse to patronize the businesses of people who leave the church. That is just off the top of my head.
 
So glad you chose to peek, or don’t have me on ignore. The LDS community knows who does not hold a recommend, and socially stigmatizes them, no matter why.
The LDS community really does not know who has a recommend and who does not. The Bishop and his counselors know, as they are the ones that perform the temple recommend interviews. Records are kept as to who has one, but those records are not made public, so unless that individual without a recommend reveals it, the LDS community does not know.
The LDS church refuse the right for even parents of a bride or groom to attend a temple wedding, if they don’t have a recommend.
This is a non-issue. There are standards that must be kept for entrance into the temple. The bride and groom know what these are and they decide to be married in the temple. They know who in their family can attend and who cannot. The family of the bride and groom know what these standards are and it is up to them to adhere to the standards or not.
Excommunication and disfellowshipment are an elaborate, formal procedure.
And…? Is it an easy, informal procedure in your chruch?
LDS people often refuse to patronize the businesses of people who leave the church. That is just off the top of my head.
Though this may be true of a few people, it is not a common thing, and definately not condoned by the church or leadership.
I would find it hard to beleive that the same behavior is not exhibited within your own church, by at least a few.
 
The LDS community really does not know who has a recommend and who does not. The Bishop and his counselors know, as they are the ones that perform the temple recommend interviews. Records are kept as to who has one, but those records are not made public, so unless that individual without a recommend reveals it, the LDS community does not know.

Gossip mills run free in many LDS communities.

This is a non-issue. There are standards that must be kept for entrance into the temple. The bride and groom know what these are and they decide to be married in the temple. They know who in their family can attend and who cannot. The family of the bride and groom know what these standards are and it is up to them to adhere to the standards or not.

LOL. That is a splendid non-answer.

And…? Is it an easy, informal procedure in your chruch?

Rarely done, unless it is a matter of public scandal. The individual is seen as having excomunicated him/herself, in most cases.

Though this may be true of a few people, it is not a common thing, and definitely not condoned by the church or leadership.
I would find it hard to believe that the same behavior is not exhibited within your own church, by at least a few.
It is a deeply rooted tradition. The temple recommend interview (associating with Anites) enforces it.
 
Gossip mills run free in many LDS communities.
Of course the Catholic community is immune from gossip…is that what you are stating?
LOL. That is a splendid non-answer.
I am sure there is nothing you would accept as an answer.
Rarely done, unless it is a matter of public scandal. The individual is seen as having excomunicated him/herself, in most cases.
And excommunication is a rare event in my church. Are you implying that if a heinous sin is commited by a Catholic, as long as the public does not find out about it, then that person remains in good standing as a Catholic? That is interesting.
It is a deeply rooted tradition. The temple recommend interview (associating with Anites) enforces it.
I’m not sure what you mean by “Anites” so will not respond.
 
Mormonism, or the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, is in fact Christian. We are not Catholic Christians, and we are not Protestant Christians, but we are Christians none the less.
The OP question was not if individuals believe Mormons to be Christian but what does the Catholic Church believe. It seems to me that the Catholic Church believes Mormons are not Christians.
To hear the arguments against Mormonism being Christian is a little like a dog and a cat trying to say a whale is not a mammal because the whale does not have 4 paws and whiskers.
No it is like a dog and a cat trying to say a salmon is not a mammal because the salmon does not nurse its young. Nothing wrong with being a salmon they are just not mammals.
 
The Church defines a religion that does not believe in the Trinity is non Christian.
And, for those interested, as well as the mormons, the jws also do not accept or believe in The Triune God.

That said. I have known some really wonderful people who were mormons and lived good lives in their own faith tradition. Their “theology” is skewed, for sure, but they make great neighbors and co-workers!
 
Right here at CAF www.catholic.com/projects/mormonism.asp -
The answers can be found here is an exerpt

Confronting the
New Mormon Threat
Why Catholics are easy targets
for Mormon evangelists—

and what we can do to keep Catholics Catholic.

What Mormons Really Believe

There are many problems with the Mormon religion. In fact, the problems are so numerous, we had to write a special report just to explain and refute them all.

Also as I mentioned before

“Mormons: from a Catholic Perspective” by Jimmy Akin

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints now claims over 12 million members world wide. This booklet describes Mormon-ism’s core beliefs and whether they can truly claim to be Christian. Fundamental differences between the Catholic Faith and that held by Mormons are explored and advice given on how to engage in sincere and respectful dialogue with missionaries one can meet in many places across the world.

It’s this powerful, eye-opening report that we need to get into the hands of as many Catholics as possible—as quickly as possible—before the Mormon juggernaut picks up more speed and takes in tens of thousands of our fellow Catholics.

This report was written by our director of apologetics, Jimmy Akin, who has done a masterful job of clearly explaining Mormon beliefs … making sense of them … and then charitably refuting them, one by one.

Let me give you a glimpse of what you’ll learn when you read this breakthrough report—and you’ll see why it’s “must reading” for every Catholic in America today …

• Do Mormons really believe they can become the “god” of their own planet?

• Why Mormons claim the Catholic Church is a “church of Satan”—teaching a false gospel.

• Why Mormons believe God the Father was once a human—and became the “god” of planet Earth.

• Do Mormons believe there is more than one “God”?

• How the Book of Mormon itself contradicts core Mormon beliefs and practices.

• What Mormons believe about the Eucharist—it’s not what Catholics believe.

• What goes on inside their mysterious, no-visitors-allowed temples.

• Does the Mormon church approve of divorce and abortion? (The answer will disappoint pro-lifers!)

• Who are the leaders of the Mormon church?

• Do Mormons believe black people are “cursed”?

• Is Mormon baptism valid? What Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, said.

Who are the leaders of the Mormon church?

• Do Mormons believe black people are “cursed”?

• Is Mormon baptism valid? What Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, said.

• How Mormons try to convert Catholics to Mormonism—successfully.

• How did Joseph Smith translate the “golden plates”—and why did no one else ever get to see them?

• Mormon doctrines have changed—often.

• Did Joseph Smith develop his teaching on polygamy only after betraying his wife?

• Joseph Smith: the “martyr” who died in a gunfight, shooting at people.

• Mormons dropped some of their unpopular teachings in order to clean up their public image and appeal to more Americans.

• Joseph Smith’s background before he started the Mormon church—and how this affect his credibility

• The psychological and emotional elements that attract people to Mormonism.

All this—and much more—is covered in Jimmy Akin’s new special report. We will send it to you with our compliments when you help us with our project to distribute it nationwide.

You see, the new Mormon threat is more serious than ever before.

With all the talk in the media about Mormonism, more and more people are curious about Mormonism and are visiting Mormon web sites.

But these web sites are deceptive. They do not explain the true beliefs of Mormonism. They try to convince readers that Mormonism is a Christian faith—in fact, the true Christian faith!

As one Mormon web site put it, “Mormonism is the religion most consistent with biblical Christianity. We do not apologize for our beliefs. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints is the only true Christian church on the face of the earth.”

The problem is … people fall for it—especially Catholics.

In fact, Mormons count Catholics as their main target.

Over half of the current converts to Mormonism are Catholics.

Mormons target Catholics who don’t know their faith.

Sadly, that’s the majority of our fellow Catholics. They’ve been nearly defenseless against Mormon propaganda.

Until now.

With our new special report on Mormonism, we can “inoculate” Catholics from the half-truths and skewed history presented by Mormon missionaries.

By getting this report into the hands of Catholics all across America, we can bolster the faith of Catholics and keep them from leaving the Church.

But an ambitious project like this requires significant funds from generous supporters like you.

We are dependent on you for financial support.

That’s why I’m hoping you’ll support Catholic Answers’ new project to expose the errors of Mormonism.

We want to give parish priests the materials they need so they can educate their parishioners—and can keep their Catholics Catholic.
 
I see Mormonism as a mirror pointed directly to the Catholic Church as the standard for moderation and educator in how to be a church.

I believe in a certain way Mormons do indeed draw on Christ, but the theology of God, Christ, etc., is again like looking at a mirror…a separate mirror that talks about Christ, priesthood, good deeds, scripture studies…

But Mormonism, in spite of an undefined draw on the same Christ we all draw on…is a separate entity.
 
Mormonism has a Gnostic character.

I agree, Mormonism, with all its evasiveness (redefining words, for example) is a distorted imitation of Catholicism. Almost a parody, or a realization of the fictional image of the Catholic Church held by Protestants in the 19th century.
 
The question came up on Mitt Romney during the 2008 primaries and now concerning Glenn Beck- is Mormonism a Christian religion?

The question (or attacks) seemed to be raised primarily by Evangelicals. I am far from an expert on LDS, but I am familiar with the differences on the scriptures, the different levels of heaven and the rather bizarre “revelations” given to Joseph Smith while looking inside his hat. None of this relates even remotely to Catholicism or Protestantism. On the other hand, the only Mormons I know anything about, Romney and Beck, devoutly believe in Jesus and recognize that salvation comes from Jesus’ death on the cross.

In short, does the Catholic Church consider Mormonism to be a Christian religion?

Thanks in advance for any replies

Jerry
To my understanding the doctrinal differences between Catholics and Mormons are so antethetical to each other that accepting the two belief systems as remotely equall or valid or in correspondence to reality would be an exercise in cognitive dissonance IMO.
 
In the sense of being baptized into the Body of Christ? No.

In the sense that they try to follow Christ? Yes.

If I were asked to compile a list of religions and their relationships, I would say that Mormonism was a different religion that has it’s roots in Christianity. Maybe “Christianity is to Judaism as Mormonism is to Christianity”.

But I would never tell a person who was honestly trying to follow what he thought Christ said that he was not a Christian. I would perhaps discuss what the correct way to do that is, but I am not going to try to distance someone from Christ - I want them to get closer to him!

But as far as an analysis of the beliefs go, I think Christianity and Judaism and Islam are much more similar to each other than Mormonism is to any of them.
There’s a wonderful quote from either Chesterton or Lewis regarding what it means to be a Christian, and it goes something like:

If we included everyone who decided they liked what Christ had to say as a Christian, we’d include everyone outside of a strange few in the asylums.

That’s very much not verbatim, but it’ll do. Just so, I think Mormons are about as Christian as the hopeful deist who believes in only the humanity of Christ, or the Muslim who considers Christ a great moral teacher.
I see Mormonism as a mirror pointed directly to the Catholic Church as the standard for moderation and educator in how to be a church.

I believe in a certain way Mormons do indeed draw on Christ, but the theology of God, Christ, etc., is again like looking at a mirror…a separate mirror that talks about Christ, priesthood, good deeds, scripture studies…

But Mormonism, in spite of an undefined draw on the same Christ we all draw on…is a separate entity.
A dark, dusty mirror, I’d add, and more a scrap of glass than a mirror — but we cannot fault them for looking so devoutly at what they do have.
I agree, Mormonism, with all its evasiveness (redefining words, for example) is a distorted imitation of Catholicism. Almost a parody, or a realization of the fictional image of the Catholic Church held by Protestants in the 19th century.
That’s an interesting take on it. Mormons live better, more Catholic lives than way too many Catholics. Mormons would feel right at home in the Catholic Church, I think, if Catholics as a whole started bearing witness to their faith; I have every reason to believe, optimistically, that we’ve hit the bottom and are on our way to a revival.
 
There’s a wonderful quote from either Chesterton or Lewis regarding what it means to be a Christian, and it goes something like:

If we included everyone who decided they liked what Christ had to say as a Christian but who did not believe in his divinity, everyone on the planet would be Christian outside of a strange few in the asylums.

That’s very much not verbatim, but it’ll do. Just so, I think Mormons are about as Christian as the hopeful deist who believes in only the humanity of Christ, or the Muslim who considers Christ a great moral teacher.
You are thinking of Lewis, in Mere Christianity. He was however talking about something slightly different - whether we should call any good person a Christian, That would make the word Christian useless, in the same way the word 'gentleman" is now useless to describe a particular class of society.

I’m not sure he would say we would wrong to call anyone who explicitly calls himself a follower of Christ a Christian (aside I suppose from someone who was lying.)
 
I seriously investigated Mormonism before becoming a Catholic. I had two missionaries over at my house on a weekly basis, and this went on for a couple of months. I went to some of the Sunday services, but of course was NEVER allowed into the (Toronto) “Temple”. At first, I liked some of their answers to basic questions…but as my questions ran deeper and deeper, the answers got more and more BIZARRE.

I think what finally made me give it all up was my discovery of Joseph Smith’s false interpretation of an ancient Egyptian tablet. A picture of this tablet can be found in their book “Doctrines and Covenants”. Smith acquired this tablet in the mid-1800’s, when ancient Egyptian heiroglyphs were still unreadable. The words on the tablet were accompanied by a picture of a man lying on a table, with another man holding a knife over his body. Beside the table were stone jars with the heads of various Egyptian gods on them for lids. Joseph Smith claimed that the Holy Spirit revealed to him that the tablet described Abraham’s journey into Egypt in the Old Testament, and that the illustration showed the attempt by the Egyptians to kill Abraham. A few decades later, the Rosetta Stone was discovered and the key to understanding Egyptian heiroglyphs was finally unlocked. Later, Egyptian scholars looked at Smith’s tablet and translated it with ease. It was actually a set of instructions on how to properly mummify a corpse! Fact: Joseph Smith was a shameless LIAR. :eek:
 
Mormons would feel right at home in the Catholic Church, I think, if Catholics as a whole started bearing witness to their faith; I have every reason to believe, optimistically, that we’ve hit the bottom and are on our way to a revival.
I think that many Mormons, freed from the enforced orthodoxy of Mormonism, would flourish in the self-disciplined orthodoxy of Catholicism. (Once they learn our language. ;))
 
I think that many Mormons, freed from the enforced orthodoxy of Mormonism, would flourish in the self-disciplined orthodoxy of Catholicism. (Once they learn our language. ;))
Agreed! I think that is the hugest advantage in practice of Catholicism over Mormonism — getting over the wonky theology and articles of faith, of course.

It is a great thing to tithe, says Rome, but give what you can. God will know.

It is a great thing to tithe, says Salt Lake City, so pony up.

I have hope that Catholicism will find a renewed popularity in the next century to rival the newfound popularity of the Mormon church, that in the next few generations Catholics will have such a deep revival of faith that people will flock to the Church.

The Catholic Church has always best witnessed to Christ in thought, but people will only see that when the laity begins to witness to Christ in deed.
 
In short, does the Catholic Church consider Mormonism to be a Christian religion?
185 Whoever says “I believe” says “I pledge myself to what *we *believe.” Communion in faith needs a common language of faith, normative for all and uniting all in the same confession of faith.

189 The first “profession of faith” is made during Baptism. The symbol of faith is first and foremost the baptismal creed. Since Baptism is given “in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit”, ** the truths of faith professed during Baptism are articulated in terms of their reference to the three persons of the Holy Trinity.

**843 ** The Catholic Church recognizes in other religions that search, among shadows and images, for the God who is unknown yet near since he gives life and breath and all things and wants all men to be saved. Thus, the Church considers all goodness and truth found in these religions as “a preparation for the Gospel and given by him who enlightens all men that they may at length have life.”

**844 ** In their religious behavior, however, men also display the limits and errors that disfigure the image of God in them:
Very often, deceived by the Evil One, men have become vain in their reasonings, and have exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and served the creature rather than the Creator. Or else, living and dying in this world without God, they are exposed to ultimate despair. **845 ** To reunite all his children, scattered and led astray by sin, the Father willed to call the whole of humanity together into his Son’s Church. The Church is the place where humanity must rediscover its unity and salvation. The Church is “the world reconciled.” She is that bark which “in the full sail of the Lord’s cross, by the breath of the Holy Spirit, navigates safely in this world.” According to another image dear to the Church Fathers, she is prefigured by Noah’s ark, which alone saves from the flood.
 
I think that many Mormons, freed from the enforced orthodoxy of Mormonism, would flourish in the self-disciplined orthodoxy of Catholicism. (Once they learn our language. ;))
This has been my experiance here in utah. One who was baptised about 5 years ago is one whom goes to confession often. He really gets it. I know two other ex Mormons who are helping with the RCIA. Lectures, Deacons etc… I have been hear for 12 years and all I can say is the more LDS that convert to Chritsinaity the better for all of us.
www.utahmission.com
 
This has been my experiance here in utah. One who was baptised about 5 years ago is one whom goes to confession often. He really gets it. I know two other ex Mormons who are helping with the RCIA. Lectures, Deacons etc… I have been hear for 12 years and all I can say is the more LDS that convert to Chritsinaity the better for all of us.
www.utahmission.com
I work with our RCIA, and it is always amazing to me the many ways that God leads people to Him. Infinite in His love and mercy, people come to Him in infinite ways. There are no Catholics going door to door, but the door for all is open. The Holy Spirit searches the hearts of all people, and they just show up. They walk through our door, freely, seeking the Infinite who is Jesus Christ.

Baptism is our response to the profound Truth who is a Person, Jesus Christ. His Church, through the Holy Spirit, unites all to Himself. Extreme gratitude, a constant amazement of what God does for us, and a desire to serve Him wherever He wills it. A recognized juxtaposition of lie against truth, and we are all the more grateful for being led out of darkness and made children of the Light.

This is what is offered to all. The willful denial by Mormons of the One True God is an obstacle to them, a stumbling block. A blindfold that is super glued in place.

God never ceases calling to us all, searching our hearts, and healing the blind.

Peace to all this Advent season.

Rebecca
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top