Is Muhammad really a Prophet?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hlgomez
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

hlgomez

Guest
The gift of prophesying is one of the attributes of a prophet. Being regarded by muslims as the great prophet compared to Jesus, what are the things that Muhammad prophesied and are already fulfilled?

Pio
 
Anas bin Malik, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: Of the signs (or indications) of the Last Hour, knowledge would be taken away and ignorance would prevail (upon the world), the liquor would be drunk, and adultery would become rampant.

Abu Hurairah, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: The last Hour will not come unless there is much haraj. They said: What is haraj? Thereupon he said: Bloodshed, bloodshed.

Abu Hurairah, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
One day Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) appeared before the public. Then a man came to him and asked: …He (the inquirer) again asked: Messenger of Allah, when would there be the Hour of (Doom)? He (the Holy Prophet) replied: The one who is asked about it is no better informed than the inquirer. I, however, will narrate some of its signs (and these are): When the female-slave will give birth to her master, when the naked, barefooted would become the chiefs of the people; these are some of the signs of (Doom). (Moreover) when the shepherds of the black (camels) would exalt themselves in buildings, this is one of the signs of (Doom).

Hudhaifah bin Al-Yaman, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
People used to ask the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) about the good deeds, but I used to ask him about the bad deeds fearing lest they overtake me. I said: Messenger of Allah, we were in the midst of ignorance and evil, and then Allah brought us this good (time through Islam). Will there be any bad time after this good one? He said: Yes. I asked: Will there be a good time again after that bad time? He said: Yes, but therein will be a hidden evil. I asked: What will be the evil hidden therein? He said: (That time will witness the rise of) people who will adopt ways other than mine and seek guidance other than mine. You will know good points as well as bad points. I asked: Will there be a bad time after this good one? He said: Yes. (A time will come) when there will be people standing and inviting at the gates of Hell. Who so responds to their call they will throw into the fire. I said: Messenger of Allah, describe them for us. He said: All right. They will be a people having the same complexion as ours and speaking our language. I said: Messenger of Allah, what do you suggest if I happen to live in that time? He said: You should stick to the main body of the Muslims and their leader. I said: If they have no (such thing as the) main body and have no leader? He said: Separate yourself from all these factions, even if you have to eat the roots of trees (in a jungle) until death comes to you and you are in this state.
 
Anas bin Malik, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: Of the signs (or indications) of the Last Hour, knowledge would be taken away and ignorance would prevail (upon the world), the liquor would be drunk, and adultery would become rampant.

Abu Hurairah, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: The last Hour will not come unless there is much haraj. They said: What is haraj? Thereupon he said: Bloodshed, bloodshed.
This is just a different version of what Jesus and the apostles had already predicted. Muhammad is just copying and revising the words.

As to other so called “prophesy” of your prophet, there is no indication that it comes from a real prophet. Common sense just tells us that they are just pure guesses.

I also noticed that the writings were not actually coming from Muhammad but are “reported” by some other persons. How can you be so sure that what they are saying is true???

Abu Midjal, blah blah blah, reported… and you already believe them?
Who so responds to their call they will throw into the fire. I said: Messenger of Allah, describe them for us. He said: All right. They will be a people having the same complexion as ours and speaking our language.
Is he talking against Arabs?

Pio
 
You asked for some examples of the Prophecys of Muhammed (peace be upon him), yet after getting a reply u quickly conclude on your own that he just guessed such things. Ok, then why ask? Its ok if u believe he made the stuff up but then why are u asking for someone to give u examples?

Anyhow, all the statements of the Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him are narrated to us through a chain of trustworthy narrators, thus we can differentiate the authentic statements from the false and weak statements. As u might know already, the specialty of the arabs was language and they generally excelled in that. Thus the companions of Muhammed peace be upon him would narrate to the next generation all of his sayings, and that generation would narrate to the next, until those sayings were recorded in the books. There are authentic statements meaning they are completely free of weakness due to them having very reliable narrators originating from the Prophet peace be upon him, there are sound statements which are authentic but might have some sort of weakness but that weakness does not make it weak, there are weak statements either due to a narrator known for weak memory, or for doing major sins, or not reliable, or due to a cut in the chain, and other kinds of discepencies, and there is the fabricated statements where someone is known to have lied on the Prophet peace be upon him, or hes known to be a lier, or someone fabricated a chain of narrators.

Saheeh al Bukhari and Saheeh Muslim are the two most authentic books on the sayings of the Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him.
 
Hashi,

I mean no offense here, but I think the author of this thread was asking about prophecies that were specific and clearly fulfilled. Christian examples of prophecies by Jesus might be helpful to understanding what I’m getting at. Jesus said that the temple in Jerusalem would be destroyed and that it would happen within the generation of the apostles. This did of course happen at the hands of the Romans.

Are there prophecies that would be similarly specific and fulfilled?
 
Yes there are many. Here is a good list i was able to find:
  1. In part of a long narration found in the two authoritative books of Hadith, the Prophet was sitting in a garden. 'Uthmaan ibn Afan walked in and the Prophet asked Abu Musa 'Ashari (the narrator) to inform him (ie. Uthmaan) of the good news of paradise, and also that the people would rebel against him. The Prophecy was fulfilled in that after Uthman become the leader of the Muslims, some of the people rose against him and eventually killed him.
  2. 'Ali ibn Abi Talib, the fourth Rightly Guided Caliph, had also been informed by the Prophet of his assassination in such detail that he knew the man who was going to kill him, and identified him and pointed him out to the people. They asked 'Ali why he did not kill the man and he replied: “Then who will kill me?” The night preceding his assassination 'Ali had come out, and gazed at the sky and said: “By Allah he never told a lie, nor was a lie ever told to him.” The next day the same man killed 'Ali, and his blood spilled down his beard, as the Prophet had described.
  3. Whilst the Muslims were fighting the Jews in Khyber, after some days of attempting to besiege the fortress, the Prophet said that the next morning he would entrust the flag to a man to whom Allah would give victory. He gave the flag to 'Ali, and the same day the fortress was conquered under Ali’s command.
  4. The Prophet saw 'Ali and Zubair one day laughing together, and he asked Ali if he loved Zubair. Ali replied: “How could I not love him since he is my nephew and brother in the religion.” The Prophet asked Zubair the same question, who gave a similar response. The Prophet then told Zubair that he would fight 'Ali, and that he would be the oppressor. So in the Battle of Jamal, when Ali and Zubair, in opposing camps came face to face. 'Ali reminded Zubair of the incident, and Zubair recalled, and said that he had forgotten, and he immediately left the battle field. So the battle took place as the Prophet had predicted, and Zubair was the oppressor, since Ali was the Rightful Caliph, and to oppose him with violence was wrong.
  5. The Prophet said: “The Caliphate will last for thirty years, then there will be a biting kingship.” So it happened. The rule of the Rightly Guided Caliphs was exactly thirty years: Abu Bakr from 632 to 634 C.E., 'Umar from 634 to 644 C.E., 'Uthman from 644 to 656 C.E., and 'Ali from 656 to 661 C.E. After that evil spread and kingship was established.
  6. The Prophet also predicted the capture of Egypt, and told his companions to treat the people well, and that they would seize the treasures of the Persian Choseros (Emperor), who lives in the white palace, all of which they accomplished, and that Suraqa bin Malik (one of the companions) would have the bracelets of Caesar put on his hands. So it happened that some such bracelets fell into the possession of 'Umar and he called Suraqa, and placed the bracelets on him, reminding him of the Prophet’s words.
  7. A narration in the most authoritative of the Hadith books, Saheeh al-Bukhari, told Auf bin Malik to look for six incidents before the last day: "The first,my death; the second the conquest of Jerusalem; third, an epidemic among them; fourth, the abundance of wealth so that a man would not gladly accept one hundred dinars even if given it; fifth, a trouble that would involve all Arab families without exception; sixth, a treaty with the Christians, which the Christians would violate, etc… (the hadeeth describes this last event, not yet fulfilled). Jerusalem was captured, and after this in 16 A.H. an epidemic broke out in Umwas and seventy thousand died. Wealth became plentiful, especially during the Caliphate of 'Uthman, and after that in the time of 'Umar ibn AbdulAzziz, when the collectors of zakat found no one poor enough to receive it. Also the rebellious war arose in the time of 'Uthman and became worse after his murder, so none of the Arabs families were not involved in some respect.
  8. The Prophet mentioned that the Muslims would conquer both Rome and Constantinople. He was asked which would fall first, and the Prophet said: “The city of Heraclius”, i.e. Constantinople. Constantinople was taken by the Muslims in the fifteenth century. Rome still remains to be conquered, as it will be. So the order is correct, and rest still to be fulfilled.
continued…
 
  1. The Prophet also predicted the dividing of the Muslims into many sects and mentioned some of their characteristics. The Prophet mentioned that some people would do to 'Ali what the Christians did to Jesus. This clearly refers to the Shi’a, who exaggerate in love and praise of 'Ali. One of the Shi’a sects, the Nusaria, actually worship him as the manifestation of Allah. The Prophet also mentioned that a group would arise who will deny Allah’s Qadr (Divine Decree) and he called them the “Magians of the Ummah”, and so it happened, and they were called the Qadaria. He also mentioned the appearance of those who would claim the Qur’an is created, and of those who would tell people to take only from the Qur’an and ignore the Sunnah (Prophetic Tradition), and these things have all come to pass. The Prophet also predicted that from the tribe of a certain individual a group would arise who would used the verses of Qur’an pertaining to unbelievers on the believers, and that they should be fought and killed. So it happened that the first of the deviant sects to arise was the Khawarij, who said that 'Ali and Muwawia were unbelievers, and whoever did not believe this, then they also were unbelievers, and they would slaughter the Muslims, and they arose from the tribe of Tamim, as the Prophet had said.
  2. The Prophet mentioned that there would be signs forewarning the approach of the last day. Among those that have clearly come to pass are:
a. The barefooted bedouins competing in building tall buildings. Today we find in the Arabian Peninsula, the Arabs who used to be impoverished herders of camels and sheep, are competing in building the tallest tower blocks.

b. The Mosques would be like palaces. This is clearly the case, even though the Prophet ordered simplicity in the houses of Allah, the mosques have become more and more fantastic, with golden domes, marbled floors, lavish carpets and chandeliers.

c. Disappearance of trustworthiness, so much so that one would only be able to say: “I know a trustworthy person in such-and-such town.”

d. The increase in killing, so that the one who kills does not know why he killed, and the one killed does not know why he was killed. I was recently sent an article from the Washington Post about the rise of gang warfare. Part of the initiation ceremony was for a new gang member(some times as young as eleven) to shoot someone. The second highest cause of death from fifteen to thirty five in the US are gun related. The massacre of civilians in the Vietnam War by American troops who had little idea why they were there, and the increase of such conflicts, is further illustration of the fulfillment of this prophecy. As are the rise of insane mass murders, of children killing children, such as Jamie Bulger.

e. The increase of the use of riba (usury/interest) so that no one will able to escape being tainted by it. This clearly the state of the world economy today.

f. The enemies of the Muslims dividing the Muslim’s wealth and lands between them and concerning themselves only with the worldly matters. We have already mentioned this.

g. The increase of literacy.

h. The decrease of religious knowledge due to the disappearance of scholars.

i. The increase of musical instruments, and the Muslims making it lawful even though the Prophet has forbidden them.

j. The increase of sexual promiscuity, and new diseases that people had not herd of before spreading amongst them as a consequence of that. This is clear, with the arrival of AIDS, and other previously unheard of viruses.

k. Appearance of Dajjals (liars), each claiming to be a Messenger of Allah, while Muhammad is the last messenger. There are numerous examples of this, starting with Musailima, who arose in the time of the Prophet, just before his death, to more modern liars such as Elija Muhammad, founder of the Black American racist movement “The Nation of Islam”, and India’s pretender Gulam Ahmed of Qadian.

l. Nakedness of women while still being dressed.

m. The drinking of wine becoming common, and the Muslims making it lawful by calling it another name.

n. Shouting in the mosques.

o. The worst and most ignorant will become leaders and they will be oppressors.

p. A man will obey his wife and disobey his mother, and treat his friends kindly and shun his father.

q. Men will wear silk and gold, and the making of it lawful by the Muslims even though the Prophet had forbidden it for the men of his 'Ummah (nation).

r. People will abandon the religion for a small worldly gain, and keeping to the religion will be like holding two hot coals.

So these are just some of the numerous prophecies of Muhammad, that have clearly come true, and some have been fulfilled in this age in which we live, all adding weight to the evidence in favour of his claim.
 
Hashi Al-Eritre,

Peace!

In Islam. what do you mean by the “last days?”

Pio
 
ashab al-yameen:
Anas bin Malik, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: Of the signs (or indications) of the Last Hour, knowledge would be taken away and ignorance would prevail (upon the world), the liquor would be drunk, and adultery would become rampant.

Abu Hurairah, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said: The last Hour will not come unless there is much haraj. They said: What is haraj? Thereupon he said: Bloodshed, bloodshed.

Abu Hurairah, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
One day Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) appeared before the public. Then a man came to him and asked: …He (the inquirer) again asked: Messenger of Allah, when would there be the Hour of (Doom)? He (the Holy Prophet) replied: The one who is asked about it is no better informed than the inquirer. I, however, will narrate some of its signs (and these are): When the female-slave will give birth to her master, when the naked, barefooted would become the chiefs of the people; these are some of the signs of (Doom). (Moreover) when the shepherds of the black (camels) would exalt themselves in buildings, this is one of the signs of (Doom).

Hudhaifah bin Al-Yaman, may Allah be pleased with him, reported:
People used to ask the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) about the good deeds, but I used to ask him about the bad deeds fearing lest they overtake me. I said: Messenger of Allah, we were in the midst of ignorance and evil, and then Allah brought us this good (time through Islam). Will there be any bad time after this good one? He said: Yes. I asked: Will there be a good time again after that bad time? He said: Yes, but therein will be a hidden evil. I asked: What will be the evil hidden therein? He said: (That time will witness the rise of) people who will adopt ways other than mine and seek guidance other than mine. You will know good points as well as bad points. I asked: Will there be a bad time after this good one? He said: Yes. (A time will come) when there will be people standing and inviting at the gates of Hell. Who so responds to their call they will throw into the fire. I said: Messenger of Allah, describe them for us. He said: All right. They will be a people having the same complexion as ours and speaking our language. I said: Messenger of Allah, what do you suggest if I happen to live in that time? He said: You should stick to the main body of the Muslims and their leader. I said: If they have no (such thing as the) main body and have no leader? He said: Separate yourself from all these factions, even if you have to eat the roots of trees (in a jungle) until death comes to you and you are in this state.
A collection of generalizations just as found in the horoscope of a daily newspaper.

Mohammed was just some uneducated, totally illiterate, camel merchant who may have been slightly insane (he was “subject to epileptic fits”.).
Please read:
newadvent.org/cathen/10424a.htm
 
Bobby A. Greene:
A collection of generalizations just as found in the horoscope of a daily newspaper.
I was thinking the same thing as I read many of them. I could easily claim to be a prophet with such generalizations. Lets see,

Before the year 2015 the united states will be attacked by evil terrorist who will call America the devil.

Before the year 2020 we will have miraculous inventions in technology and medicine that will change the world.

Evil will become worse and worse by 2020 and crime will increase. We will have rated R television and children will watch abominous things that parents will allow.

If these happen am I a prophet? If I had a huge army and conquered half the Earth and called myself one I’m sure some religion could start. Especialy if I manipulate people into thinking it’s all from God.

-D
 
If these happen am I a prophet? If I had a huge army and conquered half the Earth and called myself one I’m sure some religion could start. Especialy if I manipulate people into thinking it’s all from God.

-D
As found in the Old Testament, a self-fulfilling prophecy was when a Jewish prophet made a prophecy, and the army fulfilled it. This is another means to claim the gift of prophecy or to excuse your actions by claiming the fulfillment of a previous made prophecy.
 
Muhammad peace be upon him said that if any society practices sexual acts in public Allah will send upom them diseases which they didn’t find in their forefathers.

Divorces will be a daily occurrence.('Allamah Safarini, Ahwal Yaum al-Qiyamah)

There will be an abundance of illegitimate children.(Al-Muttaqi Al-Hindi, Muntakhab Kanzul Ummaal)

In the Last Days, there will be such people, who, when they meet, curse and abuse each other instead of greeting (with salaam). (Allama Jalaluddin Suyuti, Durre-Mansoor) Today this is very common today.

There will be no Judgment-until very tall buildings are constructed.(Reported by Abu Hurairah

The Hour will not be established-till the people compete with one another in constructing high buildings.(Bukhari)

Great distances will be traversed in short spans of time. (Ahmad, Musnad)

And horses, mules and donkeys both to ride and for adornment. And He creates other things you do not know. (Surat an-Nahl: 8)

The Last Hour will not come before the end of a man’s whip speak to him.(Tirmidhi) Seems like a phone is closest to a whip

There will be no Judgment … until a person’s own voice speaks to him. (Mukhtasar Tazkirah Qurtubi) Radios and recorders

Undoubtedly, a period will come upon people wherein not a single person will be saved from indulging in interest. If anyone avoids direct indulgence in interest, yet he will not escape from the smoke (effects) thereof… Its effects will somehow reach him. (Narrated by Abu Hurairah)

In the End Times, people will be carrying out their trade but hardly will there be a trustworthy person.(Bukhari and Muslim)

When the power or authority comes in the hands of unfit persons, then wait for the Hour (Doomsday). (Bukhari)
 
The Last Hour will not come before the end of a man’s whip speak to him.(Tirmidhi) Seems like a phone is closest to a whip.
This one is just out of hand … I mean cmon man. This can mean a million things. Nostrodamus did better than this using astrology. Talk to a few people who believe in pshychics they have all kinds of ‘incredible’ coincidences. These are all general statements you can get from some psychic friends network. Did he have anything for cell phones? Maybe a whip with the cord severed? I mean you no disrespect but any general statement like this 800 years later will produce some similarity in historical fact. If you fish long enough your gonna real something in. Which end of the whip is he talking about?
When the power or authority comes in the hands of unfit persons, then wait for the Hour (Doomsday). (Bukhari)
There have been unfit people in power and authority throughout all of human history.

-D
 
General reminder:

Please keep the tone charitable or the thread will have to be closed. Thanks!
 
Muhammad peace be upon him said that if any society practices sexual acts in public Allah will send upom them diseases which they didn’t find in their forefathers.
This has been a daily occurence at Sodom and Gommorah, it was even worse.
Divorces will be a daily occurrence.('Allamah Safarini, Ahwal Yaum al-Qiyamah)
This happened in Israel before Jesus’ time.
There will be an abundance of illegitimate children.(Al-Muttaqi Al-Hindi, Muntakhab Kanzul Ummaal)
As a result of divorce and remarry, there will be a lot of illegitimate children. BTW, Ishmael was an illegitimate child of Abraham.
There will be no Judgment-until very tall buildings are constructed.(Reported by Abu Hurairah
There had been tall buildings constructed in ancient times like the Ziggurat, the Pyramids in Egypt, the Tower of Babel, the pyramids of the Aztecs, etc.
And horses, mules and donkeys both to ride and for adornment. And He creates other things you do not know. (Surat an-Nahl: 8)
The Last Hour will not come before the end of a man’s whip speak to him.(Tirmidhi) Seems like a phone is closest to a whip
There will be no Judgment … until a person’s own voice speaks to him. (Mukhtasar Tazkirah Qurtubi) Radios and recorders
More like a horoscope, just like the rest of those prophecies.

Pio
 
40.png
hlgomez:
BTW, Ishmael was an illegitimate child of Abraham.
wow :bigyikes: look at the disrespect and slander here! directed at a prophet of God, no less!! :bigyikes:

illegitimate children are children born out of wedlock. they are the result of fornication/adultery. you’ve just accused the intimate friend of Allah, ibraaheem of committing this heinous crime, and accused his son, ismaa’eel - another noble prophet - of being his bastard son! a’oodhu billah!
 
40.png
hlgomez:
This has been a daily occurence at Sodom and Gommorah, it was even worse.

This happened in Israel before Jesus’ time.

As a result of divorce and remarry, there will be a lot of illegitimate children. BTW, Ishmael was an illegitimate child of Abraham.

There had been tall buildings constructed in ancient times like the Ziggurat, the Pyramids in Egypt, the Tower of Babel, the pyramids of the Aztecs, etc.

More like a horoscope, just like the rest of those prophecies.

Pio
Yep, all he needed was a crystal ball!😃
 
I never heared God reprimend Abraham for having an Illigitimate child .

Can any body face the sky and talk to God and tell him in the face that Your prophet Abraham had an Illigitimate child?

There is somthing that makes me wonder …

There is this easiness of insulting people who God mentioned in Hi Holy books . I mean i feel some people here have no problem about saying anything about any one nearly except Jesus PBUH.

I mean i am sure many of us wouldnt even think we should have an illigitimate child so i guess we are better than Abraham?!

I Really Dont knwo anymore

Peace
 
40.png
meedo:
I never heared God reprimend Abraham for having an Illigitimate child .

Can any body face the sky and talk to God and tell him in the face that Your prophet Abraham had an Illigitimate child?

There is somthing that makes me wonder …

There is this easiness of insulting people who God mentioned in Hi Holy books . I mean i feel some people here have no problem about saying anything about any one nearly except Jesus PBUH.

I mean i am sure many of us wouldnt even think we should have an illigitimate child so i guess we are better than Abraham?!

I Really Dont knwo anymore

Peace
I can tell your a good person meedo. I think everyone is just doing apologetics on both sides of our fences. I may not agree with Islam as a whole but people are not Islam. This is nothing personal against you. I give you alot of credit for speaking up about your faith in a Catholic forum.

-D
 
According to Luke, John The Baptist was the last prophet, so no Christians don’t believe Muhammad was a prophet.
Luke 16:16
"The law and the prophets lasted until John; but from then on the kingdom of God is proclaimed, and everyone who enters does so with violence.

Likewise none of the founders of LDS could be prophets either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top