Is my belief in flat earth heretical?

  • Thread starter Thread starter HouseUponRock
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Go to creation account. There are only Sun, Moon, and Stars. There is no such thing as “planets”. Mars, Mercury, etc. are Stars. Comets and Meteors are fallen Stars. And it is debatable whether Sun, Moon, and Stars are spherical, there is a theory that they are disc shaped, although I lean toward spherical theory.
How about metorids, comets, and other ‘space junk’ ? Are you a backer of the ‘Moon Hoax’ thoery? Because we have landed on both on the Moon, Mars, and Venus and at least one metoroid. :D:thumbsup:
 
OP, ever do any land navigation with a map and compass? Try it sometime without accounting for the G-M angle and let us know how it works out.
 
OP, ever do any land navigation with a map and compass? Try it sometime without accounting for the G-M angle and let us know how it works out.
you call it land navigation,i call it moral relativism .
 
I don’t believe it would be considered heretical, but saying that science is Satan’s work is, in my opinion, absolutely absurd. The earth is not flat, and that is a fact. Science does not undermine Christianity in the least; in fact, it often strengthens it. See Dr. William Lane Craig’s works on that subject.
Amen! Science will ultimately show the glory of God’s wonderful, magnificent creation:) God will use all disciplines of this life to reveal Himself. Remember, the Bible is a book of faith, not science, however our Great God can work through all things as He is beyond our intellects or understanding. It really is a poor witness to those who are in science but lack faith when people of faith say things like the earth is flat…it really makes Christians look ignorant and we aren’t! The wonderful thing about the Catholic faith is that they have such a open view of science and as long as you let God be the Creator, how he created is to be observed and appreciated…Praise our Wonderful Lord! (do not fear ‘science’…God is the Lord of all disciplines of study:) Alleluia!)

mlz
 
Whether or not your beliefs are right or wrong I think your wrong on this. It is not us individuals who interpret scripture but the Church.

I won’t “annoy” you with the science. (It does exist though - ask the guys who went to the Moon.) I have several questions you might want to answer and which I think you should consider:


  1. *]Why do you think science is the work of the Evil One?
    *]If you think science is the work of the Evil One why does the Vatican have a science academy and priests who are scientists?
    *]Why do you think that science and the Church are two irreconcilable things?

    I hope these questions can, at least, give you another perspective to think about.🙂

  1. I don’t believe humans have gotten to the Second Heaven, nor will they ever. Closest we got was Tower of Babel, and look what happened. That is why I firmly believe “space exploration” is a fraud. Moon landing is a proven fraud by people who are even heliocentrists.
    1. I don’t believe science is work of Satan. I believe science can be used to strengthen the faith. One of the reasons I came to Jesus is because of creation science. However, most “science” today is biased and purposely twisted. Instead of using science to compliment the Scriptures, most scientists are atheistic or pharisaic and try to undermine not just Scriptures, but Christianity in general. Modern 15 billion year Big Bang model actually has Kabbalistic origins, or Synagogue of Satan spoken of in Revelation.
    2. The Church is prone to errors, and it can be clearly seen throughout history. It does not diminish its infallibility one bit, though.
    3. Like I said before, creation science is what led me to take my faith seriously. Science is one of the best tools for evangelization. Unfortunately, many try to use anti-Christian science, but it only hurts the faith in the long run. People will not take Christianity seriously if they believe we live in one of the billions of rocks orbiting one of the trillions of stars in one of the billions of galaxies. It is simply unreconcillible with our faith and there is no reason to defend it. Instead, we should defend geocentrism (or flat earth, in my case) and creation ex-nihilo like the Church did for past 2000 years.
 
Hmm, I wonder how satellite orbits can be explained using the flat earth model.
 
Hmm, I wonder how satellite orbits can be explained using the flat earth model.
Many satellites are fraud, although many are legit. That’s how we get weather predictions (many times they are inaccurate because science is not the only determining factor). My answer to that is instead of going around the Earth, it goes across it, just like Sun, Moon, and Stars do, although staying within the range of First Heaven, or sky.
 
“It is written, ‘And the intelligent shall shine like the brightness of the firmament, and they that turn many to righteousness like the stars for ever and ever (Daniel 12:3).’ There was indeed a ‘brightness’ (Zohar). The Most Mysterious struck its void, and caused this point to shine. This ‘beginning’ then extended, and made for itself a palace for its honor and glory. There it sowed a sacred seed which was to generate for the benefit of the universe, and to which may be applied the Scriptural words ‘the holy seed is the stock thereof’ (Isaiah 6:13). Again there was Zohar, in that it sowed a seed for its glory, just as the silkworm encloses itself, as it were, in a palace of its own production which is both useful and beautiful. Thus by means of this ‘beginning’ the Mysterious Unknown made this palace. This palace is called Elohim, and this doctrine is contained in the words, ‘By means of a beginning IT created Elohim.’” (Zohar I:15a)*

This is a quote from Zohar written centuries before Copernicus, let alone Big Bang. As we can see, Synagogue of Satan is doing its job in advancing lies. “Satan is the father of all lies” as Jesus said, and Synagogue of Satan is spreading just that. People like Einstein were Kabbalists, and even Isaac Newton dwelt into that area, he was a nontrinitarian.
 
“It is written, ‘And the intelligent shall shine like the brightness of the firmament, and they that turn many to righteousness like the stars for ever and ever (Daniel 12:3).’ There was indeed a ‘brightness’ (Zohar). The Most Mysterious struck its void, and caused this point to shine. This ‘beginning’ then extended, and made for itself a palace for its honor and glory. There it sowed a sacred seed which was to generate for the benefit of the universe, and to which may be applied the Scriptural words ‘the holy seed is the stock thereof’ (Isaiah 6:13). Again there was Zohar, in that it sowed a seed for its glory, just as the silkworm encloses itself, as it were, in a palace of its own production which is both useful and beautiful. Thus by means of this ‘beginning’ the Mysterious Unknown made this palace. This palace is called Elohim, and this doctrine is contained in the words, ‘By means of a beginning IT created Elohim.’” (Zohar I:15a)*

This is a quote from Zohar written centuries before Copernicus, let alone Big Bang. As we can see, Synagogue of Satan is doing its job in advancing lies. “Satan is the father of all lies” as Jesus said, and Synagogue of Satan is spreading just that. People like Einstein were Kabbalists, and even Isaac Newton dwelt into that area, he was a nontrinitarian.
The more I read your comments the more I get the impression that you choose to reject some of the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit. That is not a good Catholic behavior.
 
The more I read your comments the more I get the impression that you choose to reject some of the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit. That is not a good Catholic behavior.
Unfortunately, I am a very sinful person. 😦
 
HouseUponRock,

Have you ever played around with Google Earth? I suggest you do. Here is the link:
google.com/earth/index.html
Click the blue button that says “Download Google Earth.”
With Google Earth, you can type in your address. Your house will be shown as if you were looking down from above it. Then you can zoom out, slowly, and see your neighborhood, your city, your state, your country, come into view. Zoom out some more and you can see the whole globe. Fool around with it, try zooming in and out.

If that doesn’t convince you, you are hopeless.
 
Unfortunately, I am a very sinful person. 😦
Gently, I say: That’s no excuse. Jesus told the woman who was to be stoned to “Go and sin no more.” Do your best, don’t expect overnight change, but realize that you must work towards that change and that it takes effort every day.
 
Gently, I say: That’s no excuse. Jesus told the woman who was to be stoned to “Go and sin no more.” Do your best, don’t expect overnight change, but realize that you must work towards that change and that it takes effort every day.
I tell that myself every day. Maybe it’s because I rarely confess and take Eucharist that I have so much trouble overcoming.
 
40.png
HouseUponRock:
People will not take Christianity seriously if they believe we live in one of the billions of rocks orbiting one of the trillions of stars in one of the billions of galaxies.
(If you are indeed a legit poster, and not merely a troll):

The above fear is obviously ill-grounded, since most of the posters here are serious Christians who also believe in the model of the universe you criticize. We recognize that while a universe according to your model might emphasize all the more the truths which you believe modern science has undermined, there is in fact no dichotomy between those truths and the model of the universe put forth by modern science.

I think people are more likely not to take Christianity seriously if they believe that Christianity teaches flat-earth, heliocentrism and the like.

By the way, a number of objections to your position have been put forth which you have not responded to nor, at the very least, taken note of.
 
I tell that myself every day. Maybe it’s because I rarely confess and take Eucharist that I have so much trouble overcoming.
So go to Mass more often! Just remember to go to Confession first, so you’ll be able to receive after having missed Mass so often
(If you are indeed a legit poster, and not merely a troll):

Your claim is obviously not true, since most of the posters here are serious Christians who also believe in the model of the universe you criticize. We recognize that while a universe according to your model might emphasize all the more the truths which you believe modern science has undermined, there is in fact no dichotomy between those truths and the model of the universe put forth by modern science.

I think people are more likely not to take Christianity seriously if they believe that Christianity teaches flat-earth, geocentrism and the like.

By the way, a number of objections to your position have been put forth which you have not responded to nor, at the very least, taken note of.
Heliocentrism is what the OP doesn’t believe. That the Sun is the center of the solar system. You meant geocentrism
 
Flat Earth is my personal interpretation of Scriptures, and also supported by Tradition (John Chrysostom, who wrote Liturgy I attend on Sundays), and also Church (Pope Zachary declared belief in antipodes heretical). Paul said Satan is “the god of this world”, and Jesus said Satan is “the father of all lies”. Put those together, and massive conspiracy is more than plausible to pull off the lie of globe, heliocentrism, etc.

It is my knowledge that globularists and heliocentrists are not heretics according to Church, so I respect your beliefs and am in no power to dictate doctrines as I have no authority. For this reason, I seek to find out if my belief is orthodox. If some Popes or Church Fathers condemned flat earth, please, I need to see the citations and I am willing to change.

Please don’t show me pictures of NASA or “scientific evidence”, I believe modern “science” is Satan’s modern tool to undermine Christianity, since Islam failed.
Do you believe the Bedford Level Experiments proved something? Do you believe that there is no curvature of light near the surface of water due to refraction?

Note that lenses work through refraction.
 
For whatever reason we have this belief that the world was thought to be flat before Columbus realized it wasn’t. As others had said, humans had known for a long time that the earth was round, based on sunsets, how ships would disappear on the horizon, etc.

To answer your question: it may not be heretical, but that does not mean that it’s educated. I’m not saying you’re not smart for thinking the earth is flat; I’m saying you should educate yourself better on the Church’s position on science.
 
Heliocentrism is what the OP doesn’t believe. That the Sun is the center of the solar system. You meant geocentrism
Thanks for catching that! I understood what his position was - it was just a typo on my part. I meant to say geocentrism.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top