is my marriage valid?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mrarbuckle
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

mrarbuckle

Guest
I have been going to mass with a friend, and have been really thinking about starting rcia. My question is this, I am a non catholic (never been baptized) and my wife is a baptized baptist. We were married in her baptist church. So can I still become catholic, even though I’ve never been baptized, but have been married in another church?
 
The short answer is “yes, you can become Catholic.”

How does your wife feel about this? Would she be going through RCIA as well?
 
I have been going to mass with a friend, and have been really thinking about starting rcia. My question is this, I am a non catholic (never been baptized) and my wife is a baptized baptist. We were married in her baptist church. So can I still become catholic, even though I’ve never been baptized, but have been married in another church?
My opinion:
I would start it all over again.
Though your wife’s baptims seems valid, I would start it again. There is a formula that the priest says: “If you were not baptized, I baptize you in the name of the Father, of the Son and of the Holy Spirit”.
I think the only marriage according to Jesus Christ is the Catholic Marriage. This is the opinion of the reputed theologian Karl Rahner.
Look, when we marry in another Church, we marry with the presupositions of the other Church, namely, about divorce. If the other Church grants easy divorces, you marry on that presuposition. BUT Catholic marriages have other presupositions, namely about the unity of marriage.
That is why I would say, for your peace of mind, I would start it all over again.
 
Ok, my wife is all for me to persue any religon I see fit, even if it is not hers. But when I asked her if she would be willing to kinda remarry in the catholic church. She replied that in her eyes/belief, there would b no need. Like in other words,HER belief is she is already and shouldn’t have to remarry to become part of a church. I told her she didn’t need to practice, just help me to enter the church. Now that being said, she is understanding with anything else I want to practice. So I guess a better way to say the question. Can a non-catholic adult, who is unbaptized, and is married to a baptized baptist. Still enter the holy catholic faith, even if he was married at another church of his spouses faith?
 
I’d need to go have a look, but I’m pretty certain that the Catholic Church would recognise your marriage. There might be some need to apply to have it recognised (once again, not sure), but you shouldn’t need to re-do the ceremony.

It’s only Catholics who marry outside the church whose marriages are not recognised by the CC.

What you did before you enter the Catholic Church should not prevent you from becoming a Catholic.
 
Now, does that mean since I married BEFORE I became a catholic, it still wouldn’t be recognized by the church? Or does that mean there is a paperwork process to validate it? My biggest fear, is to fall in love with the catholic faith. And find out, I couldn’t receive all my sacraments because I was married in another church. Even before comin to the catholic faith
 
Tricky one. As far as I know and I am not a expert,your marriage is valid. You must get baptized,that’s for sure,but the best you can do is to simply go to the nearest Catholic church and ask the priest,or call or e.mail,you need now to be sure,and that is step one. You are on the right track and don’t be afraid that some sacraments may not be allowed for you. If the marriage is OK in the legal word there,as far as I know,as I did point out earlier,nothing that will stop you from any of the sacraments in RCC. But first,and for your peace of mind,ask a Catholic priest. Then go one from that answer.
 
Ne Temere, a decree written by Pope Pius X in 1908 made it very clear that marriages of non-Catholics including those who had a valid baptism such as your wife, are not bound by Catholic Cannon law and thus the marriage could easily be valid. Note that if for some reason one of your was not of a sound state of mind or free to consent to the marriage of their own free will then the marriage may not be valid, but chances are the marriage is considered to be perfectly valid by the Church.
 
Is it the first marriage for both of you? If so, and barring any other impediment such as very close kinship, the Catholic Church presumes that your marriage is valid.

Though valid, your marriage is non-sacramental since you aren’t baptized. If your wife’s Baptist baptism was with water and ‘in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit’, your marriage will become sacramental when/if you are baptized.
 
I have been going to mass with a friend, and have been really thinking about starting rcia. My question is this, I am a non catholic (never been baptized) and my wife is a baptized baptist. We were married in her baptist church. So can I still become catholic, even though I’ve never been baptized, but have been married in another church?
Yes, you can join the Catholic Church without any trouble.

The Catholic Church already recognizes a marriage like yours as “a valid natural marriage.” In other words: your marriage is perfectly okay, it’s just not a Sacrament since one party is not baptized.

Because your wife is already a baptized Christian (Baptists have a valid baptism), if you were to join the Catholic Church, your marriage would become a Sacrament the moment you are baptized . 🙂
Ok, my wife is all for me to persue any religon I see fit, even if it is not hers. But when I asked her if she would be willing to kinda remarry in the catholic church. She replied that in her eyes/belief, there would b no need. Like in other words,HER belief is she is already and shouldn’t have to remarry to become part of a church.
Assure your wife that there will be no need for you to “remarry.” You are married already. Furthermore, your marriage will automatically become Sacramental when you are baptized.
Now, does that mean since I married BEFORE I became a catholic, it still wouldn’t be recognized by the church? Or does that mean there is a paperwork process to validate it?
To recap: the Catholic Church at the moment almost certainly considers your marriage to be valid as a natural marriage. I don’t know what paperwork would be required, but there’s probably either no requirement, or if there is, it most likely won’t be anything more than, “Show us proof/documentation of your marriage.”

No extra ceremony would be required to make it a Sacrament: that would happen automatically at your baptism.
My biggest fear, is to fall in love with the catholic faith. And find out, I couldn’t receive all my sacraments because I was married in another church. Even before comin to the catholic faith
Don’t worry, friend, that won’t happen. 🙂

All those stringent laws about proper canonical form for marriage apply only to Catholics.

If two validly baptized non-Catholics are getting married, the Church recognizes their marriage as a Sacrament by default.

If one or both of the spouses is unbaptized (as in your case), the Church recognizes that marriage as a valid natural marriage by default.

As I said above, in your case, from what you’ve told us your marriage is valid, and it will simply automatically become a Sacrament when you’re baptized.
 
Brother mrarbuckle, have no fear. My wife and I went through a similar thing 8 years ago. I was baptized in the Presbyterian church and we married in the same church when my wife was not baptized. About 10 years after we were married my wife went through RCIA and on the Easter Vigil she was baptized (took me another 3 years to find my way to the Church).

The biggest hurdle some people run into is RCIA teams that might want you to get your marriage “blessed” (code word for convalidation). Assuming that you met all the requirements for Catholic marriage (i.e. first marriage for both, intended as life long union, openness to children, etc.) then according to Canon Law (canon 1060) “… in a case of doubt, the validity of a marriage must be upheld until the contrary is proven.” I was concerned enough that I contacted a canon lawyer and he confirmed that the Church most certainly considered our marriage valid so I had nothing to worry about.
 
Ok, cool lots of good answers making me feel better lol. Here is a few more I’ve been trying to research with no luck.
  1. I have 3 kids, 2 r my wifes out of wedlock (I’m her only husband, she has never been married). But the 2 out of wedlock I’ve adoptted. Will they beable to persue the catholic faith?
  2. My youngest is 4, can he still b a “cradle baptism”?
  3. I heard rcia candidates have to have a exorcism?
    And the last one is something I saw in mass.
    Another guy I meet one day said he was non-catholic, and I know we r not to take communion. But, he got up n went forward with his arms crossed? What’s that mean and why?
    Thank all of u
 
Ok, cool lots of good answers making me feel better lol. Here is a few more I’ve been trying to research with no luck.
  1. I have 3 kids, 2 r my wifes out of wedlock (I’m her only husband, she has never been married). But the 2 out of wedlock I’ve adoptted. Will they beable to persue the catholic faith?
  2. My youngest is 4, can he still b a “cradle baptism”?
  3. I heard rcia candidates have to have a exorcism?
    And the last one is something I saw in mass.
    Another guy I meet one day said he was non-catholic, and I know we r not to take communion. But, he got up n went forward with his arms crossed? What’s that mean and why?
    Thank all of u
  1. Yes, your children and her children can become Catholic if they so choose.
  2. Yes, those children under the age of reason can be brought into full communion by their Catholic parent. If your child is not baptized, you can have them baptized in the Catholic Church.
  3. The unbaptized in RCIA go through a rite during Lent called the Scrutinies. Perhaps that is what you are thinking of. This is not an exorcism. There are some rites in RCIA that have to do with minor excorcisms, but this is a prayer and blessing not the type of exorcism you see in Hollywood movies.
Regarding communion, you are correct that non-Catholics do not receive communion. Some have been told to cross their arms and come forward for a blessing. BUT that is a practice specifically forbidden and is an illicit practice. I’m sure those doing it are following directions they receive from some misguided individual. So you should not follow that example, but simply remain seated.
 
Ok, cool lots of good answers making me feel better lol. Here is a few more I’ve been trying to research with no luck.
  1. I have 3 kids, 2 r my wifes out of wedlock (I’m her only husband, she has never been married). But the 2 out of wedlock I’ve adoptted. Will they beable to persue the catholic faith?
  2. My youngest is 4, can he still b a “cradle baptism”?
  3. I heard rcia candidates have to have a exorcism?
    And the last one is something I saw in mass.
    Another guy I meet one day said he was non-catholic, and I know we r not to take communion. But, he got up n went forward with his arms crossed? What’s that mean and why?
    Thank all of u
#1 - yes, no problem

#2 - assuming he isn’t baptized, I guess – but being a “cradle Catholic” is not important, being Catholic is

#3 - now that is weird, no you don’t need an exorcism (and note, it is extremely rare except in the movies)

In some areas, those not able to receive (non-Catholics and Catholics not in a state of grace) may approach for a blessing. Crossing your arms (hands on opposite shoulders) indicates that (although the gesture might not universally be interpreted that way).

FWIW - before I joined I never went for a blessing and still do not. There are issues in doing so and in 2008 the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments said it is not permitted from an EMHC.
 
#3 - now that is weird, no you don’t need an exorcism (and note, it is extremely rare except in the movies)
It’s not weird. The rites of minor exorcism are part of the RCIA for the Elect, usually during the Scrutinies. Not all parishes do them during Mass. Some do them during the RCIA catechetical sessions. They are blessings and prayers.

This is not the same thing as an exorcism for demonic possession.
 
I have been going to mass with a friend, and have been really thinking about starting rcia. My question is this, I am a non catholic (never been baptized) and my wife is a baptized baptist. We were married in her baptist church. So can I still become catholic, even though I’ve never been baptized, but have been married in another church?
Absolutely yes.

People in other churches or in no church at all can enter into valid marriages. Assuming this is the first marriage for both of you you’re good. And there’s something wonderful that will come. A marriage that includes a non-baptized person is considered a natural marriage. A marriage between two baptized people is also a sacrament. When you are baptized your marriage will become a sacramental marriage.
Ok, cool lots of good answers making me feel better lol. Here is a few more I’ve been trying to research with no luck.
  1. I have 3 kids, 2 r my wifes out of wedlock (I’m her only husband, she has never been married). But the 2 out of wedlock I’ve adoptted. Will they beable to persue the catholic faith?
  2. My youngest is 4, can he still b a “cradle baptism”?
  3. I heard rcia candidates have to have a exorcism?
    And the last one is something I saw in mass.
    Another guy I meet one day said he was non-catholic, and I know we r not to take communion. But, he got up n went forward with his arms crossed? What’s that mean and why?
    Thank all of u
  1. Yes the children will be able to become Catholic. The exact procedure will depend on their ages. Under the age of about 7, children are considered infants and can be baptized by their parents’ request. Over about 7 (the age of reason) they will go through RCIA adapted for children and prepare for baptism, confirmation, and First Eucharist.
  2. The 4-year-old is an infant for baptismal purposes.
  3. The exorcism is part of the rites leading up to baptism. The rites are called the scrutinies and are prayers for strength and healing for those who will receive their sacraments at the Easter Vigil. Don’t expect anything dramatic! The priest will lay his hands on your head and pray for you.
  4. Some parishes – but not all – invite people to come up in the communion line for a blessing. If your parish does this then you can participate if you wish. The other option is to stay in your pew and pray. My parish offers blessings so I tell the RCIA people they can go up if they wish. Most choose to remain in their pews.
 
Ok, cool lots of good answers making me feel better lol.
I’m glad. 🙂 Between this thread and Fr. Serpa’s answer, I hope you’re confident now that the Catholic Church accepts your marriage as valid.
Here is a few more I’ve been trying to research with no luck.
  1. I have 3 kids, 2 r my wifes out of wedlock (I’m her only husband, she has never been married). But the 2 out of wedlock I’ve adoptted. Will they beable to persue the catholic faith?
They certainly will be able to!
  1. My youngest is 4, can he still b a “cradle baptism”?
Yes, I’m pretty sure (s)he can.
  1. I heard rcia candidates have to have a exorcism?
It’s not a full-blown exorcism. As **1ke **said above: “The rites of minor exorcism are part of the RCIA for the Elect, usually during the Scrutinies. Not all parishes do them during Mass. Some do them during the RCIA catechetical sessions. They are blessings and prayers. This is not the same thing as an exorcism for demonic possession.”
And the last one is something I saw in mass.
Another guy I meet one day said he was non-catholic, and I know we r not to take communion. But, he got up n went forward with his arms crossed? What’s that mean and why?
Some Catholic churches offer a priestly “blessing” to those unable to receive Holy Communion (whether Catholics who are not properly disposed or non-Catholic Christians). I’ve heard that they’re not really supposed to do this, though, since everyone actually receives a blessing at the end of Mass anyway (right before the dismissal).
 
Ok, my wife is all for me to persue any religon I see fit, even if it is not hers. But when I asked her if she would be willing to kinda remarry in the catholic church. She replied that in her eyes/belief, there would b no need. Like in other words,HER belief is she is already and shouldn’t have to remarry to become part of a church. I told her she didn’t need to practice, just help me to enter the church. Now that being said, she is understanding with anything else I want to practice. So I guess a better way to say the question. Can a non-catholic adult, who is unbaptized, and is married to a baptized baptist. Still enter the holy catholic faith, even if he was married at another church of his spouses faith?
Let’s exagerate: if you marry as a muslim and have got 4 wives, can you consider your marriages valid in the Catholic Church?

I mean, when you marry, you marry with the presupositions of the Institution you are in. One thing is a Las Vegas marriage another a Catholic Marriage.

Baptist church has not got the same philosophy and theology and the Catholic Church. I mean, can the priest examine if, when you married, you married witht the same intention of the Catholic Church? It is har, if not impossible, to find out.

I think that your wife will understand it easily. The Catholic church cannot accpet the Civil Mariiage like Her Own…

Meanwhile, I see many opinions different from mine.

So, mine is mine…
 
Let’s exagerate: if you marry as a muslim and have got 4 wives, can you consider your marriages valid in the Catholic Church?
Yes. The first marriage is valid. The others are not. The man, if he seeks to enter the Church, can retain one wife. If they are unbaptized, he can dissolve the marriage with the first and retain one of the other three:

Can.* 1148 §1. When he receives baptism in the Catholic Church, a non-baptized man who has several non-baptized wives at the same time can retain one of them after the others have been dismissed, if it is hard for him to remain with the first one. The same is valid for a non-baptized woman who has several non-baptized husbands at the same time.
I mean, when you marry, you marry with the presupositions of the Institution you are in. One thing is a Las Vegas marriage another a Catholic Marriage.
This is NOT Church teaching. Those not bound by Catholic form marry validly when they marry civilly. A Catholic who has received a dispensation from form also marries validly when they marry civilly, including in Las Vegas.
Baptist church has not got the same philosophy and theology and the Catholic Church. I mean, can the priest examine if, when you married, you married witht the same intention of the Catholic Church? It is har, if not impossible, to find out.
No the priest does not do so.

Can.* 1060 Marriage possesses the favor of law; therefore, in a case of doubt, the validity of a marriage must be upheld until the contrary is proven.

Can.* 1099 Error concerning the unity or indissolubility or sacramental dignity of marriage does not vitiate matrimonial consent provided that it does not determine the will.
I think that your wife will understand it easily. The Catholic church cannot accpet the Civil Mariiage like Her Own…
You are incorrect and have been corrected more than once. Do not attempt to place a burden on a person that the Church does not.

If you accept the authority of the Church then you must accept that you are wrong on this topic and stop posting inaccurate information.
Meanwhile, I see many opinions different from mine.

So, mine is mine…
They are not opinions. They are factual statements of Church teaching.

This is not a matter of opinion. Please stop saying that it is.
 
Baptist church has not got the same philosophy and theology and the Catholic Church.
Concerning marriage, they do.
I mean, can the priest examine if, when you married, you married witht the same intention of the Catholic Church?
Why do you think the Church should make this unnecessarily difficult for him and his wife?

The Church recognizes marriages between non-Catholics as valid. If both parties are baptized, then that marriage is also a Sacrament, even if neither spouse is Catholic.

The OP’s marriage is valid. End of story. To assert otherwise is not being super-Catholic; it is actually defiance of the Church’s beliefs and standards.
I think that your wife will understand it easily. The Catholic church cannot accpet the Civil Mariiage like Her Own…
Actually, the Catholic Church does. According to Catholic teaching they have a valid natural marriage, and if the OP joins the Church, then when he is baptized their marriage will automatically become a Sacrament, too.
Meanwhile, I see many opinions different from mine.

So, mine is mine…
The Catholic Church’s opinion on such cases is one of those that is different from yours.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top