Is non denominational a denomination?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Odell
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
O

Odell

Guest
I know that it is. In fact we are the only Church that is not a denomination; wish I thought of that the other day. I have a friend when talking about why there is so many denominations because of private interpretation. She states that she is non denominational.

How would you respond to this?
 
I know that it is. In fact we are the only Church that is not a denomination; wish I thought of that the other day. I have a friend when talking about why there is so many denominations because of private interpretation.
The problem is that “non-denominational” have nothing to connect them to one another, so if they are a denomination each one is it’s own denomination. They would form many different denominations, not one.
She states that she is non denominational.

How would you respond to this?
I would respond positively! Tell her as you noted above that the Catholic Church is non-denominational, and then ask why she is non-denominational herself. If she is beginning to see the inherent problems caused by private interpretation you offer the reasons why there needs to be one, institutional Church that interprets. Go as needed, not too fast and not too slow. Let the ideas grow in her head. Let her start to ask questions, then go where they lead. God be with you:)
 
“Non-denominational” Christians are ones that just read from the Bible at their services and let each person interprets scripture for himself/herself, which is in itself probablematic:

-Conflicting interpretations that are opposites of each other.

-Reading the passages out of context.

-Since their church is new, there is no Tradition to help them preserve the original meaning of what the author intended to say. Which leads to literalist interpretations that conflict with early church writings.
 
Hello all!

I like to tell our youth, when explaining the other church religions views as theirs being the “true church”, that the catholic church is the “nominated” church Christ initiated. All others are basically, denominated, so to speak. 😉
 
“Nominal” comes from the Latin root for name (nominee).

If you were “de-nominal”, I would guess you have no name.

If that way, perhaps you have no creed, no belief, no liturgy and (maybe) no G-d.

That would seem to mean you are both nameless and homeless, so, it would follow that you are meaningless.

Is that logical?
 
A church that is a member of a denomination usually accepts and teaches the statements of belief of that denomination.

A non-denominational church is based on the bible according to the way that particular pastor wants to interpret it. In a sense, the pastor of each such church acts as his own pope. If a group of people from that church don’t agree with him they break away and start their own based on what they think.
 
I know that it is. In fact we are the only Church that is not a denomination; wish I thought of that the other day. I have a friend when talking about why there is so many denominations because of private interpretation. She states that she is non denominational.

How would you respond to this?
haha, this is amusing! 👍 Yes it is. But as others have said, each non-denom. is its own denom.
 
The term really describes a philosophy about how the church is supposed to be. What is interesting is that in many ways it is close to the Catholic idea, and if you understand it it is much easier to talk to such people about the Catholic Church.

You know that the CC considers itself the True Church, and so not a “denomination” Although there are many congregations, they are all part of the True Church through their bishops and ultimately, the Pope.

Well non-denominationals also believe that the Church is not meant to have divisions. They don’t have a Pope or Bishops though. From their perspective every Christian congregation is part of the Church, and to try to separate Christians by holding to names or groupings against each other is putting a man-made label ahead of Christ.

You could say that they are denominations practically speaking, but then you would not have much ground to stand on when a non-Catholic says the CC is a denomination. The point is, both groups think there are no divisions of this kind in Christ’s Church.
 
I know that it is. In fact we are the only Church that is not a denomination; wish I thought of that the other day. I have a friend when talking about why there is so many denominations because of private interpretation. She states that she is non denominational.

How would you respond to this?
Technically speaking, the Catholic Church is a Christian denomination. Christianity itself is a denomination. A denomination is an identifiable religious body under a common name, structure, and doctrine. And, a Christian denomination is an identifiable religious body under a common name, structure, and doctrine within Christianity.

Of course, The Church was not originally a Christian denomination. It is only a denomination today because of schisms and heresies. Once these splits began, the label “denomination” became a necessary way to define the various bodies of our now tragically divided religion. So it is OK to concede that Catholicism is a denomination on the whole. But it should be followed up with the assertion that there should be NO denominations within Christianity. All should return to the fold of the Catholic Church.

Non-denominational is a nonsensical term to officially label or define any “church”. It is a lousy attempt to claim that your members are “just Christian”, suggesting they hold to authentic teachings. If it’s not a claim of that, it is more of an ecumenical term, which attempts to esteem itself as non-exclusive (all are welcome)…again a lousy attempt to suggest that other denominations are exclusive or private and unwelcoming to outsiders. This has been my experience with non-denoms. I’m not suggesting they’re deliberately using the label to this end. But one of these two themes is typically underlying it.
 
I know that it is. In fact we are the only Church that is not a denomination; wish I thought of that the other day. I have a friend when talking about why there is so many denominations because of private interpretation. She states that she is non denominational.

How would you respond to this?
A denomination can be defined as a group of churches that operate under a common name, tradition, and identity.

This Protestant denomination first appeared in the 1960’s. They were started by a group of Protestants under the name of “nondenominational” in the reformed evangelical tradition with the identity of “just plain Christian”.

There is no doubt that it is every bit a denomination as any other Protestant denomination.
 
Good points to build on. First they believe all denominations are all in the one Church. This reminds me of what she said that she don’t disagree with the church. This also reminds me of something Mark Bonicore said is that the true church is not only spiritual but physical as well. A light on a hill can not be invisible.

Also I like that we had no need for denomination in the begining because we where all one. If I could just convince her that this is how it should still be.

By the way she is a old friend who used to be catholic. Pray for her
 
The Non-denominational communities pretty much sprung up in the 1960s (Calvary Chapel is a good example, though realistically, they are now their own denomination) largely from those people who rejected “the establishment” (a hippie influence…) and along with it “the establishment church”.

Their thinking was that no one has it right and so they struck out to find their own version of Christian truth. Much like the reformers, they latched onto the Bible and went from there, but ultimately, (with the exception of the occasional cult) they are pretty much just like the folks they departed from…only with much less authority and oversight.

That’s just how it is… 🤷
 
Yes a non denominational is a denomination. It is denomination unto thy self.
 
I would have told her then she really does not belong to a church. Yep nondenomintional is still denominational.

Wow private interpretation gives rise to all these things outside the Church. Yikes!!! And still more of these denominations are being formed every day. :eek:

Little One0307
 
Quote scripture for her:

(Rheims) 1 Peter 1 19-21
[19] And we have the more firm prophetical word: whereunto you do well to attend, as to a light that shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the day star arise in your hearts: [20] Understanding this first, that no prophecy of scripture is made by private interpretation. [21] For prophecy came not by the will of man at any time: but the holy men of God spoke, inspired by the Holy Ghost.

Rheims commentary verus 20 - “No prophecy of scripture is made by private interpretation”… This shews plainly that the scriptures are not to be expounded by any one’s private judgment or private spirit, because every part of the holy scriptures were written by men inspired by the Holy Ghost, and declared as such by the Church; therefore they are not to be interpreted but by the Spirit of God, which he hath left, and promised to remain with his Church to guide her in all truth to the end of the world. Some may tell us, that many of our divines interpret the scriptures: they may do so, but they do it always with a submission to the judgment of the Church, and not otherwise.

Not a matter of private interpretation? Who interprets it then? Ues the above and lead the conversation from there.

Throw logic in the conversation like ask her is God of order or confusion? Is the Holy Sprit with all demoninations? Does that not imply God is confusing with all these beliefs contradicting each other? That’s counter logic, we understand God implies order. If God implies order, where does that leave these relativist christians that think truth is not dogmatic and is just up to everyone’s understanding and that “we’re all right and everybody’s a winner!”? “Relative truth” is an oxymoron, the sooner you can convience a non-demoninationalist that the sooner you can connect Sacred Scripture to Catholicism for her. I’ll quote G.K. Chesterton (and this is from the latest episode on EWTN) “People want to avoid dogma because the want to avoid Hell” because if there is a dogma of truth and your not following truth, we have to face the consequences of our actions at the end of our journey. I’d be careful though in this route because there is a reason why a person does not accept a dogmatic way or an absolute standard to live by everyday (Catholicism) and usually is rooted deep in their psyche of a past experience or current lifestyle.
 
I know that it is. In fact we are the only Church that is not a denomination; wish I thought of that the other day. I have a friend when talking about why there is so many denominations because of private interpretation. She states that she is non denominational.
It’s just a matter of semantics. I was a member of the “non-denominational” Christian Church when I was a teenager and into Bible College. They claimed not to accept any creeds because “creeds” divided Christians. But they still had their core beliefs like any denomination. And these beliefs were “core” enough to separate the “Christian Church” from the “Disciples of Christ” and both from the “Churches of Christ” – and the many, many splinter groups between these three main divisions. The non-denominational “Disciples” movement started in the mid to later 1800s – one of the many denominations that traces its origin (at least partially) to the “Cane Ridge Revival.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top