Is Positive Thinking Another New Age Snare?

  • Thread starter Thread starter gigi_mvn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gigi_mvn

Guest
Is “Positive Thinking” anyway in line with Catholic teachings? Personally, it seems to be another New Age energy type channeling practice. “Think positive, don’t be negative”. ok? uhmm, are we to reduce our thought process to a mere Energizer Battery? get out our thin foil caps?

I did find something on it, labeling it as the Positive Thinking cult, but it was written by SSPX. If anyone can recommended any writings by a Roman Catholic, especially by a priest, would be helpful.
 
I’ve read a Bible based book on positive thinking. Dr Henry Cloud: The Secret Things of God. The author is not a catholic, but a christian and this book seems to be the christian alternative to the new age book: the secret. I hope this helps.
 
Is Positive Thinking Another New Age Snare? Not necessarily.

Is positive thinking necessary for salvation? No.

Could positive thinking be helpful in some situations? Yes.

Is positive thinking healthy and desirable in all situations? No.
 
Part of being Catholic is to be grounded in Christ. If you are then you do not need externals to be happy.

The Beautitudes can be used as an example-as we are to have trust in God in alll things.

Positive thinking is a testament of faith.As for channelling etc-not good.

Why not give Glory to God in prayer instead.
 
I agree with the other posters. Being a positive person–seeing the glass as half full instead of half empty will make you happier and an easier person to be around. Nobody wants to spend time with an Eyore-type. If you can smile and be pleasant when life isn’t working well for you–and offer up the bad things you are experiencing silently as a sacrifice–even better yet! It is not however a Catholic teaching–just good common sense I’d say! 😃
 
Yes, it is new age garbage. Not positive thinking in the most general sense, which could be interpreted to mean “trust in God”, but positive thinking as in The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale, the “Laws” of power and attraction, and the “name it and claim it” sub-Christian theology which is their spawn. I recommend Catholics and the New Age (Mitch Pacwa SJ), and, more relevantly, although written by a non-Catholic Christian, the section on the New Age worldview in the latest edition (4th?) of The Universe Next Door: A Basic Worldview Catalogue, which deals with the issue quite directly.
 
Yes, it is new age garbage. Not positive thinking in the most general sense, which could be interpreted to mean “trust in God”, but positive thinking as in The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale, the “Laws” of power and attraction, and the “name it and claim it” sub-Christian theology which is their spawn. I recommend Catholics and the New Age (Mitch Pacwa SJ), and, more relevantly, although written by a non-Catholic Christian, the section on the New Age worldview in the latest edition (4th?) of The Universe Next Door: A Basic Worldview Catalogue, which deals with the issue quite directly.
Well… Parts of that “garbage” are true. Some things only turn out horrible because we expect them to be. For instance, getting shots at the doctor’s office really isn’t bad at all. We just think it is and blow things out of proportion.
 
Positive thinking is beneficial. It is akin to being thankful to God in all circumstances, and having the joy of the Lord in all circumstances. This is heavily supported by Scripture. If Paul and Silas in prison had been negative thinkers they would have been caught up in the perceived misery of their situation. Instead they sang praises to God.

There is also science which tells us that the elevated mood from positive thinking changes brain and body chemistry for the good. Are we more capable of making good decisions when we feel good and unstressed, or when we are down in the dumps? Which person will do best in the given situation?

Jane has to give a speech for the first time. She is nervous and sure she will do poorly. She thinks the practice she did in the mirror will not help, because she will freeze on the stage. She frets about her hair, and clothes and what the audience will think.

June has to give a speech for the first time. She thinks it will be an exciting challenge. She know she practiced and has the speech memorized. She has consulted people to find out the appropriate clothes for the speech, and feels comfortable with her appearance.

*Mike, a pilot is shot down behind enemy lines. If caught he will most likely be tortured and beheaded. He is frightened the enemy will find him right away. His panicky first instinct is to call on the radio for help even though the radio signal could be traced by the enemy. He decides to stay near his smoking, smoldering plane as it will be the easiest plane for help to find him, but he puts his odds of survival at 50/50. *

**Mark, a pilot is shot down behind enemy lines. His first impression of the rugged terrain is the striking beauty of it, and what a great place it would be to camp if it were not enemy territory. He makes a mental list of what he will need to meet the challenge of survival. He recalls all his training in just this situation, and while he is hyped up, he is confident and unafraid. He gets far from the plane wreckage first. Then he seeks a source of water. After that he seeks shelter, and then a source of food. Only then does he think about contacting rescue help. One by one he takes the seemingly insurmountable task of survival and breaks it down into multiple achievable components. **

The negative thinker tends to not think clearly and tend more to inaction, afraid they may make things worse.
 
Yes, it is new age garbage. Not positive thinking in the most general sense, which could be interpreted to mean “trust in God”, but positive thinking as in The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale, the “Laws” of power and attraction, and the “name it and claim it” sub-Christian theology which is their spawn. I recommend Catholics and the New Age (Mitch Pacwa SJ), and, more relevantly, although written by a non-Catholic Christian, the section on the New Age worldview in the latest edition (4th?) of The Universe Next Door: A Basic Worldview Catalogue, which deals with the issue quite directly.
A million thank yous for these two recommendations. In the book “Catholics and New Age”, Father Pacwa even discusses Carl Jung’s psychology, which I have strong reservations on, but was not able to find an authoritative refute against it.
Also, read the synopsis on the Universe Next Door, and it is another informative read.
 
It is hard to try to figure this out on my own, so thank you my Brothers and Sisters for taking the time to respond. These posts were really helpful. Am guilty at times for quickly shunning concepts and ideas (all together) harshly as New Age/Occult.
 
It is hard to try to figure this out on my own, so thank you my Brothers and Sisters for taking the time to respond. These posts were really helpful. Am guilty at times for quickly shunning concepts and ideas (all together) harshly as New Age/Occult.
Positive thinking is common sense. It is not “new age”.
 
“Positive thinking” can be defined in multiple ways, which I attempted to point out in my post. One common definition, which is used by members of the New Age, and is a cornerstone of certain New Age philosophies, is such that “positive thinking” has the power to redefine and even recreate the world around you (e.g. solipsism). Think Shirley MacLaine. This was the original definition of “positive thinking”, which phrase in its modern associations was coined by Norman Vincent Peale, an anti-Catholic pastor (best remembered for crusading against John F Kennedy because he was a Catholic) in his book, The Power of Positive Thinking. This kind of “positive thinking” contradicts the omnipotence (because it says we can re-create or alter the preordained flow of God’s providence) and omnibenevolence (because evil men can think positively as well) of God, and more, is incompatible with Christianity, as it is plainly Pelagian. This sort of “power of positive thinking” was refined in to the “Laws” of power and attraction (well known, if you don’t know, Google them) in the secular/plainly New Age sphere, and in to “Word-Faith” (name it and claim it, i.e. think or speak positively and with absolute faith and you can control the course of God’s providence) theology in the pseudo-Christian sphere.

General “positive thinking”, as some others in this thread have defined it, is a watered-down offshoot of the original concept, which nevertheless takes its valid insight (mental conditioning affects how we experience the world) and strips it of its original heresy.

The two should not be confused, the concepts of “positive thinking” as in “trust in God” (which kind of positivity is defined in the Bible and epitomized by Jesus Christ) and as in “positive thinking will get you what you want by yourself” (which kind of positivity is epitomized by the “Laws” of power and attraction).
 
Positive thinking in the sense of being joyful and thankful and filled with the Spirit is very much in line with Catholic teaching.
 
Thinking positively about a situation is more likely to result in your taking confident, positive steps to make the most of the situation. Thinking negatively is more likely to have you wallowing in hopelessness and despair.

Christianity is a positive, joyful religion of hope. We wait in joyful hope for our Saviour, rather than wallowing in despair. Positive thinking is most definitely compatible with Christianity. Positive thinking is core to our faith.
 
Yes, it is new age garbage. Not positive thinking in the most general sense, which could be interpreted to mean “trust in God”, but positive thinking as in The Power of Positive Thinking by Norman Vincent Peale, the “Laws” of power and attraction, and the “name it and claim it” sub-Christian theology which is their spawn. I recommend Catholics and the New Age (Mitch Pacwa SJ), and, more relevantly, although written by a non-Catholic Christian, the section on the New Age worldview in the latest edition (4th?) of The Universe Next Door: A Basic Worldview Catalogue, which deals with the issue quite directly.
“The Universe Next Door” is a good read and was one of the books used in my formation when I worked as a Protestant campus minister (before I became a Catholic some 18 years ago!).
 
Jesus himself taught positive thinking.
“Therefore I tell you, do not worry about your life, what you will eat [or drink], or about your body, what you will wear. Is not life more than food and the body more than clothing?
Look at the birds in the sky; they do not sow or reap, they gather nothing into barns, yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are not you more important than they?
Can any of you by worrying add a single moment to your life-span?
Why are you anxious about clothes? Learn from the way the wild flowers grow. They do not work or spin.
But I tell you that not even Solomon in all his splendor was clothed like one of them.
If God so clothes the grass of the field, which grows today and is thrown into the oven tomorrow, will he not much more provide for you, O you of little faith?
So do not worry and say, ‘What are we to eat?’ or ‘What are we to drink?’ or ‘What are we to wear?’
All these things the pagans seek. Your heavenly Father knows that you need them all.
Matthew 6: 25-32
Jim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top