Is purgatory in the same place as hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter fakename
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is purgatory in the same place as hell?

Are they distinct as to their punishments only or also as to their location?
I guess the first thing to understand is that purgatory (and hell for that matter) are not “places”. They are states of being. Hell is the self approved condition of being eternally separated from God. It is a punishment imposed on ones self in order to remain away from God for all eternity.

Purgatory is not a punishment. It is the theologically necessary state of being for someone in friendship with God to complete the removal of sin and it’s effect from the soul prior to entry into eternal life with God, (paradise/heaven), since we may not enter into our eternal reward with any blemish. A soul in the transitional state of purgation WILL enter into a state of eternal life in the presence of God. You can not fail to be with God if you are in this state. It’s more a cleansing than a punishment. Does this help at all?

Peace,

Steven
 
I guess the first thing to understand is that purgatory (and hell for that matter) are not “places”. They are states of being. Hell is the self approved condition of being eternally separated from God. It is a punishment imposed on ones self in order to remain away from God for all eternity.

Purgatory is not a punishment. It is the theologically necessary state of being for someone in friendship with God to complete the removal of sin and it’s effect from the soul prior to entry into eternal life with God, (paradise/heaven), since we may not enter into our eternal reward with any blemish. A soul in the transitional state of purgation WILL enter into a state of eternal life in the presence of God. You can not fail to be with God if you are in this state. It’s more a cleansing than a punishment. Does this help at all?

Peace,

Steven
I do not know if you can say for sure that hell is not a place. I think Heaven and Hell may both have some sort of temporal plane, because people will be there after the resurrection of the dead.

I would agree with you about purgatory.
 
user "hazcompat":
Purgatory is the path to perfection for some. In purgatory some are further along than others. All are part of the Church (community). Good comes out from evil (2 Cor 6:17) not out of evil. There is no partnership between the Truth and the lie.

peace
so all purgatory is simply the abode of the soon to be beatified and vice versa? Because it is the path to perfection?
 
user "StevenFrancis":
I guess the first thing to understand is that purgatory (and hell for that matter) are not “places”. They are states of being. Hell is the self approved condition of being eternally separated from God. It is a punishment imposed on ones self in order to remain away from God for all eternity.

Purgatory is not a punishment. It is the theologically necessary state of being for someone in friendship with God to complete the removal of sin and it’s effect from the soul prior to entry into eternal life with God, (paradise/heaven), since we may not enter into our eternal reward with any blemish. A soul in the transitional state of purgation WILL enter into a state of eternal life in the presence of God. You can not fail to be with God if you are in this state. It’s more a cleansing than a punishment. Does this help at all?

Peace,

Steven
Purgatory is also a punishment; if I die with a venial sin then I must be punished for good’s sake.
 
so all purgatory is simply the abode of the soon to be beatified and vice versa? Because it is the path to perfection?
if you take out vice versa, i believe the answer is yes!

peace

p.s. are there angels in purgatory?
 
I have never considered whether or not the devil is allowed “in” purgatory. I do believe that he can have no effect in purgatory. The fate of a person’s soul is sealed during the particular judgment right after death. What could Satan possibly accomplish in purgatory?
Code:
   I believe, Mtndwellar to be correct and in line with the Teachings of the Catholic Church.  Holy Souls work out their sanctification in Peace & Confidence that they have won Heaven.  God does not allow the devil to torment Holy Souls.
BP
 
user "hazcompat":
if you take out vice versa, i believe the answer is yes!

peace

p.s. are there angels in purgatory?
You say no vice versa because some beatified people don’t go to purgatory right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top