Is Sacred tradition a bad argument?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CalvinandHobbs
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

CalvinandHobbs

Guest
Ok
so the church holds the the magasterium and church fathers selected and inspected the whole of the canon
Then, they said they were the inspired word of god

SO it follows that at that time, the sacred tradition and scriptures were in perfect harmony or such would have never been deemed the very word of god.

SO if the above premise is true, I ask;

If we find in the modern church a disagreement between the written (archeologically verifiable text and plain level content) scriptures and sacred tradition which is not able to be empirically verified or confirmed, then:
If a conflict were to emerge, would not the magasteriums preservation of the sacred tradition be suspect? and then subject to correction by the sensor of the verifiable sacred tradition? in as much as, it must also fully and plainly confirm the canon with no disharmony, lest the charge be levied that the early fathers from which the apostolic succession came were in any form of error (which would mean all their “descendants” are too, and would make every Christian sect inherently wrong)

SO, from a theoretical viewpoint;
IF a defense against protestant or any other varying interpretation of a text (barring full erroneous readings, and within the context of a logical exegesis) is to refer to sacred tradition, does that referral point out a flaw in the understanding of sacred tradition which could not contradict the scriptures lest it contradict it’s self?

So if I say “sacred tradition explains it” have I already conceded and used a logical fallacy? And how then does anybody know what is true sacred tradition if it can conflict with what we know it affirmed entirely?

I guess the question is, do we call what sacred tradition it’s self affirms to be the word of, and thus God himself a lie… or do we condemn the teachings of the tradition. Paul went so far as to condemn apostles even Peter when or if they wavered.

Make sense?, I am very very very very tiered.:confused:
 
so the church holds the the magasterium and church fathers selected and inspected the whole of the canon
Then, they said they were the inspired word of god
SO it follows that at that time, the sacred tradition and scriptures were in perfect harmony or such would have never been deemed the very word of god.
SO if the above premise is true, I ask;
The problem you raise is a side-product of attempting to impose a very modern understanding of Scripture upon the ancient texts. It’s not like the ECF didn’t notice the “contradictions” in the text. They simply weren’t imposing a modern “literalist” requirement on texts that weren’t written with a modern “historical” intent.

So no, your premise is not true if that’s what you mean by “inspected” and “perfect harmony.”

Also keep in mind that part of the reason there cannot be a conflict between Scripture and Tradition because Scripture is part of Sacred Tradition.
 
Ok
so the church holds the the magasterium and church fathers selected and inspected the whole of the canon
Then, they said they were the inspired word of god
That’s not exactly how the canon of Scripture we hold today was arrived at, you know that though, right?
SO it follows that at that time, the sacred tradition and scriptures were in perfect harmony or such would have never been deemed the very word of god.
This is where you lose me to be honest. Because Tradition verifies Scripture is the word of God, Tradition is the same as Scripture??
:confused:
If we find in the modern church a disagreement between the written (archeologically verifiable text and plain level content) scriptures and sacred tradition which is not able to be empirically verified or confirmed, then:
If a conflict were to emerge, would not the magasteriums preservation of the sacred tradition be suspect? and then subject to correction by the sensor of the verifiable sacred tradition? in as much as, it must also fully and plainly confirm the canon with no disharmony, lest the charge be levied that the early fathers from which the apostolic succession came were in any form of error (which would mean all their “descendants” are too, and would make every Christian sect inherently wrong)
No, I think you’re talking about understanding Sacred Scripture here. The Bible contains a vast array of literary genres and you can’t interpret one as the other. There are rules if you want to understand what exactly was being said and why, it’s not always as clear as it might seem.
 
Sorry I said i was tired, and I appologize now for spelling, etc. This PC only speaks German. And sorry if I get a bit direct, but I really wanna keep this logical, and it’s already it’s sliping

“they said they were the inspired word of god”
  • I was actually giving a bit of leadway here, leaving room for false info, etc, unlike saying infallible.
    “sorry but this strikes a bit ya’ll are bible thumpers”
So your rejection of my premises on this grounds is a “Straw man.”

Yet, the church stated that the Canon’s position is scripture, which has in itself a meaning regarding the weight with which they lauded them.

next:
…cannot be a conflict between Scripture and Tradition because Scripture is part of Sacred Tradition

Yet, there can be a conflict it what is taught and propogated as sacred tradition, and what actually is.

So I am more saying that when scripture and a tradition are not congruent, you cannot be sure you are right by “Sacred Tradition”

There’s even risk you are using a, heaven forbid, false Tradition.

Yet, as scriptures are a verifiable aspect of Sacred Tradition, to use the argument of “well sacred tradition teaches in regards to scripture…”
THAT seperates the two to use as an argument!

I’m more saying I think the argument is self-defeating,
not addressing the viewpoint that there is Sacred Tradition

“That’s not exactly how the canon of Scripture we hold today was arrived at, you know that though, right?”
True

The Jews after the destruction of the temple, were actually the ones who set the septuigant —no clue how to spell that
Save Daniel, they didn’t like that book
and the Sudopigrapha–" "
Which they questioned the validity of

Now, the church fathers, and I believe it’s Irenaeus who says four gospels…ad naseum untill The African Synod of Hippo, in 393, approved the New Testament, and repeated by Councils of Carthage in 397 and 419.

SO both Jews (old testament) and catholic (when it was the big unsplit one) fathers said scripture, defined within the works as the word of God.

“Ok
so the church holds the the magasterium and church fathers selected and inspected the whole of the canon
Then, they said they were the {inspired} word of god”
{} - established earlier. see above. Now we could debate if they said infallible, literal, or whatever

Statement is pretty much a true simplification.

“No, I think you’re talking about understanding Sacred Scripture here. The Bible contains a vast array of literary genres and you can’t interpret one as the other. There are rules if you want to understand what exactly was being said and why, it’s not always as clear as it might seem.”

OK, my only spiritual argument is gonna be here, for now.

SO can’t confess, understand, come to, or profess God, or understand the scriptures without the Holy Spirit, (Council of Orange and TRENT)

SO if you think that if you heart is open, you bother to educate yourself, and you use sound literary theory
or
“a logical exegesis”

Personally I hold that the Holy spirit gives us the ability to misinterpret and then fix it, if we don’t fix it it’s our fault for not perservering.
(christ is a stumbling block)

Sound fair?
 
I confess that I am having trouble following what you are getting at here.

What is your issue?

Are you trying to say that sacred tradition is not valid if it can’t be verified with scripture?
  • if so you should know that everything in scripture is true but not every truth is in scripture.
If on the other hand you are trying to say that a particular tradition is untrue because it is contradicted by scripture, bring up your specific example and we can discuss it.
 
Sorry but you are a bit hard to follow… Can you give an example of Sacred Scripture that is not supported by Sacred Tradition. Unless of course you mean to say that “there are Sacred Traditions that are not supported by Sacred Sripture”. This order of the question doesn’t make sense, but you know that right?

Peace!👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top