C
CalvinandHobbs
Guest
Ok
so the church holds the the magasterium and church fathers selected and inspected the whole of the canon
Then, they said they were the inspired word of god
SO it follows that at that time, the sacred tradition and scriptures were in perfect harmony or such would have never been deemed the very word of god.
SO if the above premise is true, I ask;
If we find in the modern church a disagreement between the written (archeologically verifiable text and plain level content) scriptures and sacred tradition which is not able to be empirically verified or confirmed, then:
If a conflict were to emerge, would not the magasteriums preservation of the sacred tradition be suspect? and then subject to correction by the sensor of the verifiable sacred tradition? in as much as, it must also fully and plainly confirm the canon with no disharmony, lest the charge be levied that the early fathers from which the apostolic succession came were in any form of error (which would mean all their “descendants” are too, and would make every Christian sect inherently wrong)
SO, from a theoretical viewpoint;
IF a defense against protestant or any other varying interpretation of a text (barring full erroneous readings, and within the context of a logical exegesis) is to refer to sacred tradition, does that referral point out a flaw in the understanding of sacred tradition which could not contradict the scriptures lest it contradict it’s self?
So if I say “sacred tradition explains it” have I already conceded and used a logical fallacy? And how then does anybody know what is true sacred tradition if it can conflict with what we know it affirmed entirely?
I guess the question is, do we call what sacred tradition it’s self affirms to be the word of, and thus God himself a lie… or do we condemn the teachings of the tradition. Paul went so far as to condemn apostles even Peter when or if they wavered.
Make sense?, I am very very very very tiered.
so the church holds the the magasterium and church fathers selected and inspected the whole of the canon
Then, they said they were the inspired word of god
SO it follows that at that time, the sacred tradition and scriptures were in perfect harmony or such would have never been deemed the very word of god.
SO if the above premise is true, I ask;
If we find in the modern church a disagreement between the written (archeologically verifiable text and plain level content) scriptures and sacred tradition which is not able to be empirically verified or confirmed, then:
If a conflict were to emerge, would not the magasteriums preservation of the sacred tradition be suspect? and then subject to correction by the sensor of the verifiable sacred tradition? in as much as, it must also fully and plainly confirm the canon with no disharmony, lest the charge be levied that the early fathers from which the apostolic succession came were in any form of error (which would mean all their “descendants” are too, and would make every Christian sect inherently wrong)
SO, from a theoretical viewpoint;
IF a defense against protestant or any other varying interpretation of a text (barring full erroneous readings, and within the context of a logical exegesis) is to refer to sacred tradition, does that referral point out a flaw in the understanding of sacred tradition which could not contradict the scriptures lest it contradict it’s self?
So if I say “sacred tradition explains it” have I already conceded and used a logical fallacy? And how then does anybody know what is true sacred tradition if it can conflict with what we know it affirmed entirely?
I guess the question is, do we call what sacred tradition it’s self affirms to be the word of, and thus God himself a lie… or do we condemn the teachings of the tradition. Paul went so far as to condemn apostles even Peter when or if they wavered.
Make sense?, I am very very very very tiered.