S
Sneaux
Guest
If someone is gay and decides to live chaste, are they still sinning because they’re sexually attracted to the same gender?
Short answer: No.If someone is gay and decides to live chaste, are they still sinning because they’re sexually attracted to the same gender?
Lol.Short answer: No.
Long answer: Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.
I think this is what then Cardinal Ratzinger is referring to in his Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on the Pastoral Care of Homosexual Persons…So it is important to maintain one’s chastity in both deed and thought. If one willfully entertains lustful thoughts (of any kind, the sexual attraction does not matter) then one can be committing sin, even if he has not touched or been near a man at all.
An Objective Disorder
This then would be the same for a heterosexual to look at pornography but not act upon those thoughts? Just looking at pornography would be sinful or lead to sin?“Although the particular inclination of the homosexual person is not a sin, it is a more or less strong tendency ordered toward an intrinsic moral evil; and thus the inclination itself must be seen as an objective disorder.”
In order for a person to commit a sin, 1) the act must be wrong; 2) he must know it is wrong; and 3) it must be an act of the will. In other words, you have to choose to do it. Being sexually attracted to a member of the same gender is not sinful since it is not willful. Deliberate homosexual acts (fantasizing, homosexual acts, etc.) are sinful, because they are a willful act against God’s plan for our sexuality.I thought that those were the teachings, that it was not a sin as long as you didn’t act on it, but I’ve struggled with same sex attraction for a long time now, and used to date a girl, but when we broke up, I promised myself I was going to be chaste from now on.
She’s recently contacted me, not to get back together or anything, but I’ve discovered I still have a lot of feelings for her, well, last night I was talking to a friend about it, and she started lecturing me “That’s a mortal sin! You need to stop thinking about her in that way.” And she got upset with me because I hadn’t told her I used to be with another girl(we broke up last August, and I became friends with this girl in April, I honestly didn’t think it was that big of a deal, since I’ve decided to be chaste.) I just wanted to make sure.
No, not at all the same.This then would be the same for a heterosexual to look at pornography but not act upon those thoughts? Just looking at pornography would be sinful or lead to sin?
Sinful and lead to more sins such as thoughts.This then would be the same for a heterosexual to look at pornography but not act upon those thoughts? Just looking at pornography would be sinful or lead to sin?
A clarification.Similarly, if a man has sexual desire for a woman, he is not sinning. What matters is his response to his desire for her, will he act according to God’s plan, or his own.
Oh, I’m not interested in the new girl at all, we’re just friends, she just got mad that I didn’t tell her this about myself before now.In order for a person to commit a sin, 1) the act must be wrong; 2) he must know it is wrong; and 3) it must be an act of the will. In other words, you have to choose to do it. Being sexually attracted to a member of the same gender is not sinful since it is not willful. Deliberate homosexual acts (fantasizing, homosexual acts, etc.) are sinful, because they are a willful act against God’s plan for our sexuality.
While you may have sexual or romantic feelings for members of the same gender, what matters is your response to it. Similarly, if a man has sexual desire for a woman, he is not sinning. What matters is his response to his desire for her, will he act according to God’s plan, or his own.
Being friends with this new girl is fine if you are keeping the relationship one of friendship and not a romantic one.
Hope this helps and I will pray for you.
God bless
you should pray. I’ve never been in a SS relation but I went through the same temptation. The person still contacts me until now, but I resist her because of chastity and obedience to God.I do really want to be friends with her, but I dont want to provoke this inclination–the person wont just give up. Pray–it’s just everything.I thought that those were the teachings, that it was not a sin as long as you didn’t act on it, but I’ve struggled with same sex attraction for a long time now, and used to date a girl, but when we broke up, I promised myself I was going to be chaste from now on.
She’s recently contacted me, not to get back together or anything, but I’ve discovered I still have a lot of feelings for her, well, last night I was talking to a friend about it, and she started lecturing me “That’s a mortal sin! You need to stop thinking about her in that way.” And she got upset with me because I hadn’t told her I used to be with another girl(we broke up last August, and I became friends with this girl in April, I honestly didn’t think it was that big of a deal, since I’ve decided to be chaste.) I just wanted to make sure.